Arthur Henderson

Arthur Henderson (13 September 1863 – 20 October 1935) was a British iron moulder and Labour politician. He was the first Labour cabinet minister, won the Nobel Peace Prize in 1934 and, uniquely, served three separate terms as Leader of the Labour Party in three different decades. He was popular among his colleagues, who called him "Uncle Arthur" in acknowledgement of his integrity, his devotion to the cause and his imperturbability. He was a transitional figure whose policies were, at first, close to those of the Liberal Party. The trades unions rejected his emphasis on arbitration and conciliation, and thwarted his goal of unifying the Labour Party and the trade unions.

For the 1940s government minister, see Arthur Henderson, Baron Rowley. For other people, see Arthur Henderson (disambiguation).

The Right Honourable Arthur Henderson
Henderson circa 1910-15
Leader of the Opposition
In office 1 September 1931 – 25 October 1932
Prime Minister	Ramsay MacDonald
Preceded by	Stanley Baldwin
Succeeded by	George Lansbury
Leader of the Labour Party
In office 28 August 1931 – 25 October 1932
Deputy	John Robert Clynes
Preceded by	Ramsay MacDonald
Succeeded by	George Lansbury
In office 5 August 1914 – 24 October 1917
Chief Whip	Frank Goldstone George Henry Roberts
Preceded by	Ramsay MacDonald
Succeeded by	William Adamson
In office 22 January 1908 – 14 February 1910
Chief Whip	George Henry Roberts
Preceded by	Keir Hardie
Succeeded by	George Barnes
Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs
In office 7 June 1929 – 24 August 1931
Prime Minister	Ramsay MacDonald
Preceded by	Austen Chamberlain
Succeeded by	1st Marquess of Reading
Chief Whip of the Labour Party
In office 1925–1927
Leader	Ramsay MacDonald
Preceded by	Ben Spoor
Succeeded by	Tom Kennedy
In office 1920–1924
Leader	John Robert Clynes Ramsay MacDonald
Preceded by	William Tyson Wilson
Succeeded by	Ben Spoor
In office 1914–1914
Leader	Ramsay MacDonald
Preceded by	George Henry Roberts
Succeeded by	Frank Walter Goldstone
In office 8 February 1906 – 1907
Preceded by	David Shackleton
Succeeded by	George Henry Roberts
Home Secretary
In office 23 January 1924 – 4 November 1924
Prime Minister	Ramsay MacDonald
Preceded by	William Bridgeman
Succeeded by	Sir William Joynson-Hicks
Minister without Portfolio
In office 10 December 1916 – 12 August 1917
Prime Minister	David Lloyd George
Preceded by	Henry Petty-Fitzmaurice
Succeeded by	George Nicoll Barnes
Paymaster-General
In office 18 August 1916 – 10 December 1916
Prime Minister	H. H. Asquith
Preceded by	Thomas Legh
Succeeded by	Joseph Compton-Rickett
President of the Board of Education
In office 25 May 1915 – 18 August 1916
Prime Minister	H. H. Asquith
Preceded by	Jack Pease
Succeeded by	Robert Crewe-Milnes
Member of Parliament for Clay Cross
In office 1 September 1933 – 20 October 1935
Preceded by	Charles Duncan
Succeeded by	Alfred Holland
Member of Parliament for Burnley
In office 28 February 1924 – 27 October 1931
Preceded by	Dan Irving
Succeeded by	Gordon Campbell
Member of Parliament for Newcastle-upon-Tyne East
In office 17 January 1923 – 6 December 1923
Preceded by	Joseph Nicholas Bell
Succeeded by	Sir Robert Aske
Member of Parliament for Widnes
In office 30 August 1919 – 15 November 1922
Preceded by	William Hall Walker
Succeeded by	George Christopher Clayton
Personal details
Born	13 September 1863 Glasgow, Scotland
Died	20 October 1935(1935-10-20) (aged 72) London, England
Nationality	British
Political party	Labour

Early life

Arthur Henderson was born at 10 Paterson Street, Anderston, Glasgow, Scotland, in 1863, the son of Agnes, a domestic servant, and David Henderson, a textile worker who died when Arthur was ten years old. After his father's death, the Hendersons moved to Newcastle upon Tyne in the North-East of England, where Agnes later married Robert Heath.

Henderson worked at Robert Stephenson and Sons' General Foundry Works from the age of twelve. After finishing his apprenticeship there aged seventeen, he moved to Southampton for a year and then returned to work as an iron moulder (a type of foundryman) in Newcastle-upon-Tyne.

Henderson became a Methodist in 1879 (having previously been a Congregationalist) and became a Local Preacher. After he lost his job in 1884, he concentrated on preaching.

Union leader

In 1892, Henderson entered the complex world of trade union politics when he was elected as a paid organiser for the Friendly Society of Iron Founders. He also became a representative on the North East Conciliation Board. Henderson believed that strikes caused more harm than they were worth and tried to avoid them whenever he could. For this reason, he opposed the formation of the General Federation of Trade Unions, as he was convinced that it would lead to more strikes.

The Labour Party

Henderson (on left) in 1906, with other leading figures in the party

In 1900 Henderson was one of the 129 trade union and socialist delegates who passed Keir Hardie's motion to create the Labour Representation Committee (LRC). In 1903, Henderson was elected Treasurer of the LRC and was also elected as Member of Parliament (MP) for Barnard Castle at a by-election. From 1903 to 1904, Henderson also served as mayor of Darlington, County Durham.[1]

In 1906, the LRC changed its name to the Labour Party and won 29 seats at the general election. In 1908, when Hardie resigned as Leader of the Labour Party, Henderson was elected to replace him. He remained Leader until his own resignation two years later, in 1910.

Cabinet Minister

In 1914 the First World War broke out and Ramsay MacDonald resigned from the Leadership of the Labour Party in protest. Henderson was elected to replace him.

In 1915, following Prime Minister H. H. Asquith's decision to create a coalition government, Henderson became the first member of the Labour Party to become a member of the Cabinet, as President of the Board of Education.

In 1916, David Lloyd George forced Asquith to resign and replaced him as Prime Minister. Henderson became a member of the small War Cabinet with the post of Minister without Portfolio on December 9, 1916. (The other Labour representatives who joined Henderson in Lloyd George's coalition government were John Hodge, who became Minister of Labour, and George Barnes, who became Minister of Pensions.) Henderson resigned on August 11, 1917 after his proposal for an international conference on the war was rejected by the rest of the Cabinet.[2]

Henderson turned his attention to building a strong constituency-based support network for the Labour Party. Previously, it had little national organisation, based largely on branches of unions and socialist societies. Working with Ramsay MacDonald and Sidney Webb, Henderson in 1918 established a national network of constituency organisations. They operated separately from trade unions and the National Executive Committee and were open to everyone sympathetic to the party's policies. Secondly, Henderson secured the adoption of a comprehensive statement of party policies, as drafted by Sidney Webb. Entitled "Labour and the New Social Order," it remained the basic Labour platform until 1950. It proclaimed a socialist party whose principles included a guaranteed minimum standard of living for everyone, nationalisation of industry, and heavy taxation of large incomes and of wealth.[3]

The "Coupon Election" and the 1920s

Henderson lost his seat in the "Coupon Election" of 14 December 1918, which had been announced within twenty-four hours of the end of hostilities and which resulted in a landslide victory for a coalition formed by Lloyd George.[4] However, Henderson returned to Parliament in 1919 after winning a by-election in Widnes. He then became Labour's Chief Whip, only to lose his seat again, at the general election of 1922.

Vladimir Lenin held Henderson in very low regard. In a letter to the Soviet Commissar for Foreign Affairs, Georgy Chicherin, written on 10 February 1922 and referring to the Genoa Conference, Lenin wrote: "Henderson is as stupid as Kerensky, and for this reason he is helping us."[5]

Henderson returned to Parliament via another by-election, this time representing Newcastle East, but again, he was unseated at the general election of 1923. He returned to Parliament just two months later after winning another by-election in Burnley.

In 1924, Henderson was appointed as Home Secretary in the first-ever Labour government, led by MacDonald. This government was defeated later the same year and lost the general election that followed.

Having been re-elected in 1924, Henderson refused to challenge MacDonald for the party leadership. Worried about factionalism in the Labour Party, he published a pamphlet, Labour and the Nation, in which he attempted to clarify the party's goals.

Foreign Secretary

In 1929, Labour formed another minority government and MacDonald appointed Henderson as Foreign Secretary, a position Henderson used to try to reduce the tensions that had been building up in Europe since the end of the First World War. Diplomatic relations were re-established with the USSR and Henderson guaranteed Britain's full support to the League of Nations.[6]

The MacDonald "betrayal"

The Great Depression plunged the government into a terminal crisis. The Cabinet agreed that it was essential to maintain the Gold Standard and that the Budget needed to be balanced, but were divided over reducing unemployment benefits by 10%. At first, Henderson gave strong support to Prime Minister MacDonald throughout the financial and political crisis of August. The financial crisis across Europe was worsening and Britain's gold reserves were at high risk. New York banks provided an emergency loan; but additional money was needed and to get it, the budget had to be balanced. MacDonald and Chancellor of the Exchequer Philip Snowden proposed cuts in unemployment benefits. Henderson rejected that solution and became the leader of nearly half the Cabinet. The Labour Cabinet decided to resign. The King implored MacDonald to remain and form an all-party National government that would make the budget cuts. MacDonald agreed on 24 August 1931 and formed an emergency National Government, with members from all parties. The new cabinet had four Labourites (now called "National Labour Party") who stood with Macdonald, plus four Conservatives and two Liberals. Labour unions were strongly opposed and the Labour Party officially repudiated the new National government. It expelled MacDonald and his supporters from the party. Henderson cast the only vote against the expulsions. Against his inclinations, Henderson accepted the leadership of the main Labour Party and led it into the general election on 27 October against the cross-party National coalition. It was a disastrous result for Labour, which was reduced to a small minority of 52. MacDonald won the largest landslide in British electoral history. Yet again Henderson lost his seat, at Burnley. The following year, he relinquished the party leadership.[7]

Later career

Henderson returned to Parliament after winning a by-election at Clay Cross, achieving the unique feat of being elected a total of five times at by-elections in constituencies where he had not previously been the MP. He holds the record for the greatest number of comebacks from losing a previous seat.

Henderson spent the rest of his life trying to halt the gathering storm of war. He worked with the World League of Peace and chaired the Geneva Disarmament Conference, and in 1934 he was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize. (On 3 April 2013 his Nobel medal was stolen from the official residence of the Lord Mayor of Newcastle.)[8]

Henderson died in 1935, aged 72. All three of Henderson's sons saw military service during the Great War, the eldest, David, being killed in action in 1916 whilst serving as a Captain with the Middlesex Regiment (Duke of Cambridge's Own). His surviving sons also became Labour politicians: second son William was granted the title of Baron Henderson in 1945, while his third son, Arthur, was created Baron Rowley in 1966.

The Labour History Archive and Study Centre at the People's History Museum in Manchester holds the papers of Arthur Henderson in their collection, spanning from 1915 to 1935.[9]

References

1. <https://www.thenorthernecho.co.uk/news/10330798.arthur-henderson-a-labour-pioneer/>
2. Eric Hopkins, 'A Social History of the English Working Classes, 1815–1945 (Hodder & Stoughton, 1979) p. 219. ISBN 0713103167.
3. Bentley B. Gilbert, Britain since 1918 (1980) p 49.
4. Katz, Liane (4 April 2005) "Women and the Welsh Wizard". Politics.guardian.co.uk. Retrieved on 12 September 2015.
5. Handwritten note at the Russian Center for the Preservation and Study of Documents of Recent History, fond 2, opis 2, delo 1,1119, published as Document 88 in The Unknown Lenin, ed. Richard Pipes, Yale University Press, 1996. ISBN 0300076622.
6. David Carlton (1970). MacDonald versus Henderson: The Foreign Policy of the Second Labour Government. Palgrave Macmillan. ISBN 9781349006755.
7. Andrew Thorpe, "Arthur Henderson and the British political crisis of 1931." Historical Journal 31#1 (1988): 117-139. in JSTOR
8. "Nobel Peace Prize Medal Stolen in Newcastle". BBC News. 3 April 2013.
9. Collection Catalogues and Descriptions, Labour History Archive and Study Centre, archived from the original on 13 January 2015, retrieved 20 January 2015

Further reading

•  Buckle, George Earle (1922). "Henderson, Arthur" . In Chisholm, Hugh (ed.). Encyclopædia Britannica (12th ed.). London & New York.
• Carlton, David (1970). MacDonald versus Henderson: The Foreign Policy of the Second Labour Government. Palgrave Macmillan. ISBN 9781349006755.
• Hamilton, Mary Agnes. Arthur Henderson: A Biography (1938), a detailed and favourable account by a former colleague
• McKibbin, Ross. "Arthur Henderson as Labour Leader," International Review of Social History (1978) pp. 79–101
• Riddell, Neil. "Arthur Henderson, 1931–1932," in Leading Labour: From Keir Hardie to Tony Blair, ed. Kevin Jefferys (1999)
• Thorpe, Andrew. "Arthur Henderson and the British Political Crisis of 1931," Historical Journal (1988) pp. 117–139 in JSTOR
• Winkler, Henry H. "Arthur Henderson," in The Diplomats, 1919–1939, ed. Gordon A. Craig and Felix Gilbert (1953)
• Winter, J M. "Arthur Henderson, the Russian Revolution and the Reconstruction of the Labour Party," Historical Journal (1972) pp. 753–73. in JSTOR
• Wrigley, Chris. Arthur Henderson (1990), a scholarly biography

External links

• Hansard 1803–2005: contributions in Parliament by Arthur Henderson
• Arthur Henderson on Nobelprize.org including the Nobel Lecture, December 11, 1934 Essential Elements of a Universal and Enduring Peace
• J. Keir Hardie and Arthur Henderson, Manifesto to the British People (1 August 1914)
• Newspaper clippings about Arthur Henderson in the 20th Century Press Archives of the ZBW

Parliament of the United Kingdom
Preceded by Joseph Pease	Member of Parliament for Barnard Castle 1903–1918	Succeeded by John Edmund Swan
Preceded by William Hall Walker	Member of Parliament for Widnes 1919–1922	Succeeded by Christopher Clayton
Preceded by Joseph Nicholas Bell	Member of Parliament for Newcastle-upon-Tyne East 1923–1923	Succeeded by Sir Robert Aske
Preceded by Dan Irving	Member of Parliament for Burnley 1924–1931	Succeeded by Gordon Campbell
Preceded by Charles Duncan	Member of Parliament for Clay Cross 1933–1935	Succeeded by Alfred Holland
Political offices
Preceded by Jack Pease	President of the Board of Education 1915–1916	Succeeded by The Marquess of Crewe
Preceded by The Lord Newton	Paymaster-General 1916	Succeeded by Sir Joseph Compton-Rickett
Preceded by William Bridgeman	Home Secretary 1924	Succeeded by Sir William Joynson-Hicks
Preceded by Sir Austen Chamberlain	Foreign Secretary 1929–1931	Succeeded by The Marquess of Reading
Preceded by Stanley Baldwin	Leader of the Opposition 1931–1932	Succeeded by George Lansbury
Party political offices
Preceded by New position	Treasurer of the Labour Party 1904–1912	Succeeded by Ramsay MacDonald
Preceded by John Hodge	Chairman of the Annual Conference of the Labour Party 1905–1906	Succeeded by J. J. Stephenson
Preceded by Keir Hardie	Chairman of the Labour Party 1908–1910	Succeeded by George Nicoll Barnes
Preceded by Ramsay MacDonald	General Secretary of the Labour Party 1912–1934	Succeeded by James Middleton
Preceded by Ramsay MacDonald	Chairman of the Labour Party 1914–1917	Succeeded by William Adamson
Preceded by New position	President of the Labour and Socialist International 1923–1924	Succeeded by Charlie Cramp
Preceded by Charlie Cramp	President of the Labour and Socialist International 1925–1929	Succeeded by Emile Vandervelde
Preceded by Ramsay MacDonald	Treasurer of the Labour Party 1929–1936	Succeeded by Arthur Greenwood
Preceded by Ramsay MacDonald	Leader of the Labour Party 1931–1932	Succeeded by George Lansbury