Leader of the Opposition (New Zealand)

In New Zealand, the leader of the Opposition (or Opposition leader) is a senior politician who commands the support of the Official Opposition. The leader of the Opposition by convention heads the largest party not supporting the government: usually this is the parliamentary leader of the second-largest caucus in the House of Representatives.[2] When in the debating chamber the Opposition leader sits on the left-hand side of the centre table, in front of the Opposition and opposite the prime minister.[3]

Leader of the Opposition of New Zealand
Coat of Arms
Incumbent Judith Collins since 14 July 2020
Official Opposition of New Zealand
Reports to	Parliament
Term length	While leader of the largest political party not in government
Inaugural holder	John Ballance^[a]
Formation	2 July 1889^[b]
Salary	$288,900 (As at 2016)[1]
^ a. As the first parliamentary leader of an Opposition party. ^ b. The date Ballance was officially named Leader of the Opposition.

The role of the leader of the Opposition dates to the late 19th century, with the first political parties, and the office was formally recognised by statute in 1933. Although currently mentioned in a number of statutes, the office is not established by any Act (nor is that of the prime minister); it is simply a product of the conventions of the Westminster-style parliamentary system. The leader of the Opposition is paid a special salary by virtue of the office.

Typically the leader of the Opposition is elected by his or her party according to its rules. A new leader may be elected when the incumbent dies, resigns, or is challenged for the leadership. Judith Collins of the National Party has served as leader since 14 July 2020,[4] following the resignation of Todd Muller.[5]

Role

Further information: Official Opposition (New Zealand)

The term "opposition" has a specific meaning in the parliamentary sense; it is an important component of the Westminster system, with the Official Opposition directing criticism at the Government. The leader of the Opposition leads a Shadow Cabinet, which scrutinises the policies and actions of the Cabinet led by the prime minister, as well as offer alternative policies.[6] The Opposition leader may be viewed as an alternative prime minister.[7] He or she is expected to be ready to form a new government if the incumbent government is unable to continue in office.

There are several ways in which the leader of the Opposition participates directly in affairs of state. Often, these relate to national security matters, which are supposed to transcend party politics – the New Zealand Security Intelligence Service, for example, is required to brief the leader of the Opposition as well as the prime minister on certain matters of national security.[8]

Salary

The leader of the Opposition receives a higher salary than other members of the Opposition, being paid the same amount as a Cabinet Minister.[9] As at 2016 the Leader of the Opposition's salary is NZ$288,900.[10][1] In addition, like all other members of parliament, the leader of the Opposition receives annual allowances for travel and lodging.

History

For much of the country's early history, the role was not a formal one. For most of the 19th century, there was rarely any one person who could be identified as the leader of the Opposition. Prominent members were sometimes informally dubbed as "Leader of the Opposition" – often facetiously by rival politicians.[11] It was only when the Liberal Party was formed that any unified leadership appeared in Parliament, and the role of Opposition leader is generally traced from this point. John Ballance, leader of the Liberals (and later premier) is usually considered the first leader of the Opposition in the modern sense.[11]

When Ballance led the Liberals into government in 1891, they faced no formal opposition in a party sense, though certain MPs were styled leader of the Opposition. Their opponents gradually coalesced around a leader, William Massey, who became Opposition leader in 1903, and in 1909 became the first parliamentary leader of the new Reform Party.[12] For the first time, an Opposition party came forward as an alternative government.[12] After this, the leader of the Opposition would always be the parliamentary leader of the largest party in the House of Representatives that had not undertaken to support the government of the day.

One notable exception to this was during World War I, when the opposition Liberal Party accepted the governing Reform Party's offer to form a wartime coalition. Prime Minister Massey also extended the offer to the new Labour Party who rejected it. This made Labour the largest party not in government, however their leader Alfred Hindmarsh was not officially recognised as the leader of the Opposition. Joseph Ward, who became deputy prime minister in the wartime cabinet, still retained the title, albeit in name only.[13]

During the 1910s and 1920s, the role of Opposition alternated between the Liberal and Reform parties. However, the rise of the Labour Party in the 1920s, together with a gradual weakening in support for the Liberals, led to a three-party situation by the mid-1920s, with the Labour and Liberal parties having a similar number of seats. After the 1925 election there was no official leader of the Opposition until Rex Mason of Labour won the seat of Eden in the by-election held on 15 April 1926. Labour superseded the Liberals as the official opposition and their leader Harry Holland became Opposition leader.[14]

The 1928 general election put the United Party (a remnant of the Liberals) in government for the last time. Reform then became the Opposition, however in 1931 Reform entered into coalition with the Liberals, and Labour then became the Official Opposition, despite being the third party. The unity of the coalition, culminating in the formation of the National Party in 1936, created a stable two-party system, with National and Labour alternating between Government and Opposition for much of the remainder of the century.

Modern office

The office was first officially recognised by an Act of Parliament in 1933, when a special allowance was conferred on the holder.[11]

With the introduction of the mixed-member proportional (MMP) voting system, first used in the 1996 general election, the nature of parliamentary opposition has changed. Now, though the leader of the largest non-Government party still becomes the leader of the Opposition, there will usually be several parties who are "in opposition". An example of this arose after the 2002 general election, when the National Party gained only 27 seats – less than half the 58 seats held by opposition parties. This prompted calls from a number of parties, notably New Zealand First and the Greens, for the abolition or reform of the post. It was argued by these parties that the position had become an "anachronism" in the modern multi-party environment, and that the days of a united opposition bloc were gone. However, with the revival of the National Party in the 2005 general election, a more traditional relationship between Government and Opposition has been restored. According to Parliamentary Services, the leader of the Opposition formally represents and speaks for all parties that are outside Government.[15]

List of leaders of the Opposition

A table of leaders is below. Those who also served as prime minister, either before or after being leader of the Opposition, are indicated.

Key

  Liberal   Conservative   Reform   Labour   United   National

No.		Leader (Birth–Death) Constituency	Portrait	Term of office		Party	Prime Minister
	1	John Ballance (1839–1893) MP for Wanganui		2 July 1889	23 January 1891	Liberal		Atkinson 1887–91
	2	John Bryce (1833–1913) MP for Waikato		23 January 1891	31 August 1891	Conservative		Ballance 1891–93
	3	William Rolleston (1831–1903) MP for Halswell		31 August 1891	8 November 1893	Conservative
								Seddon 1893–1906
	4	William Russell (1838–1913) MP for Hawkes Bay		26 June 1894	3 July 1901	Conservative
	5	William Massey (1856–1925) MP for Franklin		11 September 1903	February 1909	Conservative
								Hall-Jones 1906
								Ward 1906–12
				February 1909	10 July 1912	Reform
								Mackenzie 1912
	6	Joseph Ward (1856–1930) MP for Awarua^[1]		11 September 1913	27 November 1919	Liberal		Massey 1912–25
	7	William MacDonald (1862–1920) MP for Bay of Plenty		21 January 1920	31 August 1920†	Liberal
	8	Thomas Wilford (1870–1939) MP for Hutt		8 September 1920	13 August 1925	Liberal
								Bell 1925
								Coates 1925–28
	9	George Forbes (1869–1947) MP for Hurunui		13 August 1925	4 November 1925	Liberal
Position vacant from 1925 general election until after 1926 Eden by-election				4 November 1925	16 June 1926	—
	10	Harry Holland (1868–1933) MP for Buller		16 June 1926	18 October 1928	Labour
	(6)	Joseph Ward (1856–1930) MP for Invercargill		4 December 1928	10 December 1928	United
	11	Gordon Coates (1878–1943) MP for Kaipara		10 December 1928	22 September 1931	Reform		Ward 1928–30
								Forbes 1930–35
	(10)	Harry Holland (1868–1933) MP for Buller		22 September 1931	8 October 1933†	Labour
	12	Michael Joseph Savage (1872–1940) MP for Auckland West		12 October 1933	6 December 1935	Labour
	(9)	George Forbes (1869–1947) MP for Hurunui		6 December 1935	May 1936	United		Savage 1935–40
				May 1936	2 November 1936	National
	13	Adam Hamilton (1880–1952) MP for Wallace		2 November 1936	26 November 1940	National
	14	Sidney Holland (1893–1961) MP for Christchurch North until 1946 MP for Fendalton from 1946		26 November 1940	13 December 1949	National		Fraser 1940–49
	15	Peter Fraser (1884–1950) MP for Brooklyn		13 December 1949	12 December 1950†	Labour		Holland 1949–57
	16	Walter Nash (1882–1968) MP for Hutt		17 January 1951	12 December 1957	Labour
								Holyoake 1957
	17	Keith Holyoake (1904–1983) MP for Pahiatua		12 December 1957	12 December 1960	National		Nash 1957–60
	(16)	Walter Nash (1882–1968) MP for Hutt		12 December 1960	31 March 1963	Labour		Holyoake 1960–72
	18	Arnold Nordmeyer (1901–1989) MP for Island Bay		1 April 1963	16 December 1965	Labour
	19	Norman Kirk (1923–1974) MP for Lyttelton until 1969 MP for Sydenham from 1969		16 December 1965	8 December 1972	Labour
								Marshall 1972
	20	Jack Marshall (1912–1988) MP for Karori		8 December 1972	4 July 1974	National		Kirk 1972–74
	21	Robert Muldoon (1921–1992) MP for Tāmaki		4 July 1974	12 December 1975	National
								Rowling 1974–75
	22	Bill Rowling (1927–1995) MP for Tasman		12 December 1975	3 February 1983	Labour		Muldoon 1975–84
	23	David Lange (1942–2005) MP for Māngere		3 February 1983	26 July 1984	Labour
	(21)	Robert Muldoon (1921–1992) MP for Tāmaki		26 July 1984	29 November 1984	National		Lange 1984–89
	24	Jim McLay (born 1945) MP for Birkenhead		29 November 1984	26 March 1986	National
	25	Jim Bolger (born 1935) MP for King Country		26 March 1986	2 November 1990	National
								Palmer 1989–90
								Moore 1990
	26	Mike Moore (1949–2020) MP for Christchurch North		2 November 1990	1 December 1993	Labour		Bolger 1990–97
	27	Helen Clark (born 1950) MP for Mount Albert		1 December 1993	5 December 1999	Labour
								Shipley 1997–99
	28	Jenny Shipley (born 1952) MP for Rakaia		5 December 1999	8 October 2001	National		Clark 1999–2008
	29	Bill English (born 1961) MP for Clutha-Southland		8 October 2001	28 October 2003	National
	30	Don Brash (born 1940) List MP		28 October 2003	27 November 2006	National
	31	John Key (born 1961) MP for Helensville		27 November 2006	19 November 2008	National
	32	Phil Goff (born 1953) MP for Mount Roskill		19 November 2008	13 December 2011	Labour		Key 2008–16
	33	David Shearer (born 1957) MP for Mount Albert		13 December 2011	15 September 2013	Labour
	34	David Cunliffe (born 1963) MP for New Lynn		15 September 2013	27 September 2014	Labour
	35	Andrew Little (born 1965) List MP		18 November 2014	1 August 2017	Labour
								English 2016–17
	36	Jacinda Ardern (born 1980) MP for Mount Albert		1 August 2017	26 October 2017	Labour
	(29)	Bill English (born 1961) List MP		26 October 2017	27 February 2018	National		Ardern 2017–present
	37	Simon Bridges (born 1976) MP for Tauranga		27 February 2018	22 May 2020	National
	38	Todd Muller (born 1968) MP for Bay of Plenty		22 May 2020	14 July 2020	National
	39	Judith Collins (born 1959) MP for Papakura		14 July 2020	Incumbent	National

¹ From 4 August 1915 to 21 August 1919, the Reform Party and the Liberal Party formed a joint wartime coalition. Joseph Ward of the Liberals officially remained "Leader of the Opposition", even though he was actually part of the government.

See also

• Leader of the Opposition (United Kingdom)
• List of Australian Leaders of the Opposition
• List of Prime Ministers of New Zealand

References

1. "MPs given 2.5 percent pay rise". Radio NZ. 8 November 2016. Retrieved 8 November 2016.
2. "Glossary". New Zealand Parliament. Retrieved 12 October 2018.
3. "People in Parliament". New Zealand Parliament. Retrieved 21 January 2009.
4. Sadler, Rachel (14 July 2020). "Judith Collins announced as new National Party leader". Newshub. Retrieved 14 July 2020.
5. "Todd Muller resigns as National Party leader". RNZ. 14 July 2020. Retrieved 14 July 2020.
6. "The Relationship between the Government and the Opposition or Minority Parties in Selected Places" (PDF). 13 November 2002. Retrieved 28 May 2018.
7. "The Leader of the Opposition" (PDF). Retrieved 28 May 2018.
8. "Overview". NZSIS. Archived from the original on 4 January 2009. Retrieved 21 January 2009.
9. "Bill English admits pay rise 'a bit embarrassing'". New Zealand Herald. 21 November 2008. Retrieved 21 January 2009.
10. "Parliamentary Salaries and Allowances Determination 2016" (PDF). New Zealand Parliament. 2016. Retrieved 28 May 2018.
11. "Chapter 8 Parties and Government". www.parliament.nz. New Zealand Parliament. Retrieved 18 April 2020.
12. Gardner, William James (1966). McLintock, Alexander Hare (ed.). "MASSEY, William Ferguson". An Encyclopaedia of New Zealand. Retrieved 18 April 2020.
13. Bassett, Michael. "Ward, Joseph George". Dictionary of New Zealand Biography. Ministry for Culture and Heritage. Retrieved 2 February 2016.
14. O'Farrell, Patrick. "Holland, Henry Edmund - Biography". Dictionary of New Zealand Biography. Ministry for Culture and Heritage. Retrieved 2 February 2016.
15. "Who's who in Parliament?". Retrieved 9 February 2018.

External links

• People of Parliament – New Zealand Parliament