Lockridge Medical Clinic

Lockridge Medical Clinic was a historic building notable for its Prairie School-style design by Frank Lloyd Wright, located in Whitefish, Montana, United States.[2] Originally built as a medical clinic in 1963, the building served a variety of other commercial purposes before it was demolished by its owners in 2018.[3]

Lockridge Medical Clinic
U.S. National Register of Historic Places
Show map of Montana Show map of the United States
Location	341 Central Ave., Whitefish, Montana
Coordinates	48°24′33″N 114°20′10″W
Area	less than one acre
Built	1960
Built by	Frank Lloyd Wright
Architectural style	Modern, Prairie School
NRHP reference No.	12000789[1]
Added to NRHP	August 14, 2012

Before its demolition, it was one of three Wright-designed structures in the state of Montana. He had previously designed the Bitter Root Inn in Stevensville, which burned down in 1924, and the Como Orchards Summer Colony complex in Darby, of which only two small cottages survive.[3][4] When the clinic building was demolished in 2018, it became the first of Wright's intact non-residential buildings to be intentionally destroyed since the Francisco Terrace apartment complex in Chicago was torn down in 1974,[5] and the first of any kind since the W.S. Carr House in Grand Beach, Michigan was demolished in 2004.[6]

History

Thaddeus Leon Lockridge, a practicing physician in Whitefish, Montana, approached Frank Lloyd Wright to commission him for the design of a new medical clinic building in 1958. Reportedly, Lockridge and his wife chose Wright, by then one of the most famous architects in America, after a Montana architectural firm quoted them a price so "exorbitantly high" that they decided they "may as well have Frank Lloyd Wright design it".[7] Wright drew up plans for the building with his close assistant, John H. "Jack" Howe.[2] The design was among Wright's last works, as he died the following year. Construction began in the summer of 1959, after Wright's death, with the carpenter visiting Taliesin to study Wright's methods.[8] Taliesin Associated Architects (Wright's successor firm) was not involved with the construction process.[9] John T. Whalen, a Whitefish doctor, and Bruce C. McIntyre, who had just closed his blood bank in St. John, Washington to move to Whitefish,[10] joined Lockridge's practice in anticipation of the building's completion, although they protested the Wright design.

At 5,000 square feet (460 m²), the clinic was one of the town's largest buildings, and was compared to "half of Montana". Its layout was based around a grid with units of four feet.[11] The design of the building was based on Wright's Usonian houses. Its most noticeable design element, a ceiling-high plastic sphere embedded in the front facade and surrounded by a planter, was removed later after a "vehicular mishap",[3] to provide a more direct entrance to the lobby.[12] The sphere, which was well-lit and resembled a full moon, was used as a terrarium, and later owners of the building attempted to restore it to the facade but could not find any remaining pieces.[7] The building's prominent rooftop gardens remained, but the flowers were removed to make way for HVAC equipment.[5]

The clinic opened for business in 1960. Dr. Lockridge died in 1963,[13] and the other doctors moved out the following year. First State Bank occupied the building from 1964 to 1980, and after that it was divided into three professional offices, which held a variety of tenants including the administrative offices for Iron Horse, an upscale subdivision and golf course in Whitefish. In 2002, the building was purchased again and became the law offices of Sharon and Frank Morrison and Sean and Diana Frampton.[9] The Morrisons, inspired by Wright's Harvey P. Sutton House in their hometown of McCook, Nebraska, decided to restore the building.[7] It was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 2012.[1]

After the law partnership between the Morrisons and Framptons ended in 2016, the building, locally known as the Frank Lloyd Wright Building, was sold to Mick Ruis, a developer from Columbia Falls, Montana who presented his plans to demolish the building and replace it with a three-story mixed-use development late that year.[14] He was apparently unaware when he submitted the plans that the building was protected and considered historic, but after being made aware of this he nevertheless continued with his plans to raze it,[5] which was originally slated for late 2018.[15] Local residents and members of the Montana Preservation Alliance led a movement to save the building.[14]

On January 3, 2018, the owner began preparing for demolition, leading the Frank Lloyd Wright Building Conservancy to reach out with an offer to purchase the building. The conservancy and its allies were willing to pay the full asking price, but sparred with the developers over whether the deposit could be refundable. According to the conservancy, the time frame of one week was not enough for them to raise funds to pay the non-refundable deposit. Ruis had set a January 10 deadline for the negotiations, which ended without a deal on the afternoon of the 10th. Hours later, before preservationists could make any effort to start a second round of negotiations, the building was demolished overnight.[3][5][15]

The demolition outraged preservationists and scholars of Wright and modern architecture, both locally and across the country. A billboard appeared in Whitefish two months after the clinic building was razed, calling for residents to boycott Ruis and the development that would replace the building.[16]

References

1. "National Register Information System". National Register of Historic Places. National Park Service. July 9, 2010.
2. Lockridge Medical Clinic, National Register Information System, National Park Service.
3. Inbody, Kristen. "Developer demolishes Frank Lloyd Wright building in Montana", Great Falls Tribune, January 11, 2018.
4. LeCocq, Randall. Frank Lloyd Wright in Montana: Darby, Stevensville, and Whitefish, Drumlummon Institute, 2013.
5. Gibson, Eleanor. "Bulldozer demolishes Frank Lloyd Wright medical centre in Montana", Dezeen, January 12, 2018.
6. "Even a Wright can be a teardown", Chicago Tribune, November 13, 2004.
7. Hintze, Lynnette. "Historic Whitefish building listed on National Register", Daily Inter Lake, September 15, 2012.
8. "New Clinic Will Be Built In Whitefish This Summer", Kalispell Daily Inter Lake, April 14, 1959.
9. Steiner, Douglas. "Wright Studies: Lockridge Medical Clinic, Whitefish, Montana", The Wright Library, 2008. Retrieved March 31, 2018.
10. Barbra Winogene N. McIntyre obituary, Daily Inter Lake, April 30, 2013.
11. Storrer, William Allin. The Architecture of Frank Lloyd Wright, Fourth Edition: A Complete Catalog, University of Chicago Press, 2017.
12. Sanderson, Arlene. A Guide to Frank Lloyd Wright Public Places: Wright Sites, Princeton Architectural Press, 2001.
13. "Dr. Lockridge, Whitefish, Dies", Kalispell Daily Inter Lake, August 2, 1963.
14. Hintze, Lynnette. "Whitefish historic landmark headed for wrecking ball", Daily Inter Lake, November 15, 2016.
15. McGrath, Katherine. "Update: Spiteful Developer Tore Down Frank Lloyd Wright Building Overnight, Eclipsing Negotiations to Save It", Architectural Digest, January 9, 2018.
16. McGrath, Katherine. "New Billboard Protests the Demolition of a Frank Lloyd Wright Building", Architectural Digest, March 26, 2018.

• Storrer, William Allin. The Frank Lloyd Wright Companion. University Of Chicago Press, 2006, ISBN 0-226-77621-2 (S.425)