Gerald B. and Beverley Tonkens House

The Gerald B. and Beverley Tonkens House, also known as the Tonkens House, is a single story private residence, designed by American architect Frank Lloyd Wright in 1954. The house was commissioned by Gerald B. Tonkens (an automobile dealer) and his first wife Rosalie. It is located in Amberley Village, a village in Hamilton County, Ohio.

Gerald B. and Beverley Tonkens House
U.S. National Register of Historic Places
As viewed from the street
Location	Cincinnati, Ohio
Coordinates	39°11′44.47″N 84°24′53.45″W
Built	1954[1]
Architect	Frank Lloyd Wright [2]
Architectural style	Modern Movement and Other[2]
NRHP reference No.	91001414[2]
Added to NRHP	October 3, 1991[2]

Wright designed the home in the Usonian Automatic style. It is considered to be one of the finest and most intact examples of Usonian Automatic architecture ever produced and was designated a National Historic Landmark and listed in the National Register of Historic Places on October 3, 1991.

Description

The Tonkens House is a single story, three bedroom, two bathroom private residence, designed in the Usonian Automatic style. The house is situated on a partially developed 3.54-acre property in Amberley Village, Ohio and measures some 2,100 square feet. An early 20th-century guest cottage also occupies the property, a remnant of its earlier use as a farm.

The Usonian Automatic style was Frank Lloyd Wright's final architectural period and is based on a modular design system that employed interlocking, precast concrete blocks. It was first conceived by Wright in the wake of the Depression in 1936 and later developed as a response to a lack of low-cost housing and rising construction costs following World War Two.

Like many of Wright's Usonian style buildings, the floor plan of the Tonkens House mimics the shape of a polliwog. The tail of the polliwog is represented by the bedroom wing, with each bedroom opening off into a long, narrow hallway. The hallway leads into 'the body' of the house, which consists of a bright and expansive living room or Great Room, alongside a kitchen and foyer. The configuration allowed for additional rooms to be added to the bedroom wing in the future. The Great Room was designed as a large, warm and welcoming space, a room in which the family and their guests could gather throughout the day and night.

The master bedroom contains an en-suite and private study, which opens off to a private patio. Ceilings in the bedroom wing are low (7.5 feet) and gilded in 18 karat gold leaf. On the other hand, those in the Great Room, kitchen and foyer are high (10.5 feet and 13.5 feet respectively) and unembellished. The Great Room contains a cantilevered fireplace and east-facing wall of floor-to-ceiling windows and French doors that open onto a lanai at the rear of the house. Philippine mahogany was used for interior paneling and furniture. Piano hinges (hinges extending from the top to the bottom of a door) were used for all doors in the house, including closet doors.[3]

The house is constructed using eleven styles of precast concrete blocks, reinforced by steel rods. It has a total of 492 windows, which consist of glass contained within the precast concrete blocks. Instead of gutters, copper flashing and downspouts allow for water to run off the roof, which is protected by insulation, a rubber membrane and pea gravel.[4]

Two Wright designed gates guard a Cherokee red concrete driveway leading towards the house. The dwelling has no garage or basement, keeping with Wright's well known dislike of such spaces. Instead, two carports—divided by concrete and glass pillars—and two storage sheds occupy the property.

History

Interior of the Tonkens House showing the Great Room. The cantilevered fireplace can be seen to the right.

Gerald B. Tonkens was born in Milwaukee, Wisconsin in 1919 where he was exposed to many examples of Frank Lloyd Wright’s architecture from a young age. This had a lasting effect on Tonkens, who later stated “I always admired Mr Wright’s work. I always knew that I would never build a house on my own unless it was designed by Frank Lloyd Wright”.[5]

After graduating from the University of Wisconsin in the early 1940s, Tonkens joined the U.S military, fighting with the Eighth Air Force during World War Two.[6] Tonkens met and married his first wife, Red Cross nurse, Rosalie Robbins, while stationed with the military in Europe.[7]

By 1953 the couple had two daughters and decided to move to Hamilton County, where Gerald established the 'Tonkens Oldsmobile-Cadillac' dealership in Hamilton, Ohio. In 1954 Gerald and Rosalie purchased a 2.75 acre block in Amberley Village, Ohio for $6,000. The land was cheap in comparison to surrounding lots, many of which sold for an average price of $25,000 per acre. When Rosalie queried the price, she was told that the property was considered a “problem lot” as no architect had been able to engineer a driveway up the steep incline from the road to the house.[8] When this was mentioned to Wright, he replied "They built the Suez Canal, didn't they? We'll go right up the middle with a big shovel".[3]

Once the purchase was finalized, the couple who were on a tight budget, yet still wanted a Frank Lloyd Wright-esque home, approached a local architect who had studied under Wright in the 1930s. Although early meetings were successful, Gerald and Rosalie were ultimately unhappy with the architect's design and cancelled their agreement in early 1954. After some discussion, they decided to contact Wright himself with a proposal for the house and a budget of $25,000.[7] Shortly afterwards, Wright invited them to Taliesin in Spring Green, Wisconsin to discuss the design.[9] Their meeting was a success and the first half of 1954 was spent discussing designs via letter and telegram between the Tonkens and Wright's personal assistant Eugene Beyer "Gene" Masselink. In mid-1954 Wright asked if the couple would be interested in being his ‘guinea pigs’ stating his desire to design their home as “an experiment in Usonian Automatic architecture”.[10] They agreed, and Wright's preliminary designs for the home were completed in October of the same year.

Drawings for the Tonkens House were completed by Frank Lloyd Wright, his grandson and apprentice, Eric Lloyd Wright, and John H. "Jack" Howe. John deKoven Hill and Cornelia Brierly were landscape designers on the project. Engineering drawings were completed by William Wesley Peters, Edmond Thomas "Tom" Casey and Mendel Glickman. Glickman was also solely responsible for the ceiling block engineering. Furniture, upholstery and fabric selections for the house were supervised by John deKoven Hill.[11] Final drawings and specifications were presented to Gerald and Rosalie on February 25, 1955 and approved soon after. The 'Tonkens House' would be assigned project number 5510 by the Taliesin Foundation.[12]

The final design featured three bedrooms, one study, two bathrooms, Philippine mahogany paneling throughout, a grand living room (the Great Room) with a cantilevered fireplace, two carports and two storage sheds. A comprehensive furniture plan included built in pieces as well as Frank Lloyd Wright designed furniture from his collection for Henredon Furniture, and Wright designed upholstery.

The house remained in the Tonkens family for over six decades, until it was sold to a private buyer in 2015.

Construction

The Tonkens hired local contractor, Horace Wersel, to be the project lead and Cincinnati firm Harvard Construction Co. to build the house.[13] The construction of the Tonkens House was overseen by the Taliesin Fellowship, which was represented by Eric Lloyd Wright. Wright spent over a year living in Cincinnati while overseeing the construction of the home. Such close supervision was unusual, and the Tonkens House was the first Usonian Automatic structure to be solely directed by a Taliesin fellow.

The home incorporated Wright's iconic precast concrete blocks. These were made using metal molds into which concrete was poured and then set. The Tonkens house is built using eleven block variations, which allowed for infinite modifications to the design.[14] Masonry subcontractors were used to lay the foundation, while carpentry subcontractors were used to lay the blocks. Blocks were two feet wide by one foot high for walls, and two feet high by two feet wide for ceilings. Blocks were adhered to a reinforced concrete slab, unlike Wright's Californian homes, in which ceiling blocks were adhered to wooden slabs. Concrete blocks for the Tonkens House were made as a lightweight cinder block. Because cinder blocks are porous, a sand based sealer was applied to the exterior of the building to waterproof the house.[15]

Example of precast concrete blocks in the Tonkens House. Photo courtesy of Toby Oliver.

By mid-1955 the total cost of construction, including Wright's 10 percent fee and additional costs for interior furnishings, was up to $59,000. The increase was due in part to rising values of materials such as steel, concrete and wood. Complications associated with casting concrete blocks also raised construction costs. Expenditure continued to increase throughout the duration of the construction and Cindy Damschroder estimates that the final cost of construction was likely to have been around $118,000.

The Tonkens House was completed in late-July 1956. Frank Lloyd Wright died in 1959. Prior to his death he was in the midst of designing the Beth Sholom Congregation in Elkins Park, Pennsylvania, the Guggenheim Museum in New York City, as well as a number of residential homes. Therefore, he would never see the completed Tonkens House. He did however meet with the Tonkens soon after it was completed, presenting them with a hand signed, Cherokee red glazed tile to attest his approval of the home. The tile was permanently placed on the exterior wall, just outside the front entrance.

Variations in design

Over the eighteen month construction period, a number of minor changes were made to the original design. These included modifying the driveway, installing additional electrical outlets to the exterior of the house and increasing the size of the master bedroom.[16] A pool was included in initial designs and registered by Taliesin. In late 1955, Eric Lloyd Wright proposed that the pool be relocated as it was positioned above solid ground, with only earth fill below.[17] Although the pool was relocated and re-sized, it was never built. A cabana and covered porch were also envisioned for the home, but these did not make it onto the final designs.

Repair and restoration

Example of windows set into precast blocks in the Tonkens House. Photo courtesy of Toby Oliver.

In July 2001, renovations were undertaken to restore and upgrade the home's aging roof, original plumbing, wiring and kitchen. During this time, a heavy rainstorm hit the Greater Cincinnati area. In addition to flooding more than 70 homes and killing three people,[18] strong winds blew protective tarp off the roof, exposing it to the heavy downpour. The Philippine mahogany walls and cabinetry in the living room, dining room and kitchen all suffered significant water damage, as did the home's precast concrete block ceiling.[18] These elements required replacement, a project that took almost a year to complete. Care was taken to ensure the renovations were sympathetic to the original design and character of the home and it continues to be the only largely unaltered Frank Lloyd Wright house in the Greater Cincinnati area.[3]

In mid-2015, the new roof was found to have failed. Additional repairs are currently underway, a complex task due to the unique design of the structure.[19]

Notes

1. Donald Langmead (2003). Frank Lloyd Wright: A Bio-Bibliography. Greenwood Publishing. p. 34. ISBN 0313319936.
2. "National Register Information System". National Register of Historic Places. National Park Service. June 30, 2007.
3. Johnston Haas, Ann (1 June 1996). "Wright in Style". The Cincinnati Enquirer – via Newspapers.com.
4. Coleman, Brent (9 February 2013). "Seeking a New Caretaker". The Cincinnati Enquirer – via newspapers.com.
5. Findsen, O. “Residing in Wright Work of Art Different Way to Live”, Cincinnati Enquirer, 8 August 1982, sec H, p. 4.
6. Damschroder, Cindy B., 1996. "The Gerald B Tonkens House: A Study of Usonian Automatic Architecture of Frank Lloyd Wright". Master of Art Thesis in the Department of Art History, University of Cincinnati, p. 16.
7. Tonkens, R. Letter to Frank Lloyd Wright dated May 20, 1954.
8. Tonkens, Rosalie R., “Having a Home Built By Frank Lloyd Wright Changed Couples Life”, New York Times, 6 February 1972, sec 8, p. 1.
9. Greenspan, S. “Keepers of the Flame”, Art and Auction, April 1990, p. 172.
10. Findsen. Residing in Wright Work of Art “Different Way to I’ve”, sec. H, p. 4.
11. Damschroder, Cindy B. 1996, p. 24.
12. Damschroder, Cindy B.. 1996. "The Gerald B. Tonkens House: A Study of Usonian Automatic Architecture of Frank Lloyd Wright". Master of Art Thesis in the Department of Art History, University of Cincinnati, p. 24.
13. Tonkens, G. Letter to Eugene Masselink, November 15, 1954.
14. Damschroder, Cindy B., 1996. "The Gerald B Tonkens House: A Study of Usonian Automatic Architecture of Frank Lloyd Wright". Master of Art Thesis in the Department of Art History, University of Cincinnati, p. 13.
15. Damschroder, Cindy B., 1996. "The Gerald B Tonkens House: A Study of Usonian Automatic Architecture of Frank Lloyd Wright". Master of Art Thesis in the Department of Art History, University of Cincinnati, p. 30.
16. Tonkens R. Letter to Jack Howe, April 7, 1955.
17. Damschroder, Cindy B. 1996, p. 28.
18. Coleman, Brent (February 8, 2013). "For owner, Wright house was like a family member".
19. https://ssrg.com/2019/10/18/tonkens-house-renovations/

• Storrer, William Allin. The Frank Lloyd Wright Companion. University Of Chicago Press, 2006, ISBN 0-226-77621-2 (S.386)

External links

• Documentation from the University of Cincinnati
• Detailed photographs