John Davis (Massachusetts governor)

John Davis (January 13, 1787 – April 19, 1854) was an American lawyer, businessman and politician from Massachusetts. He spent 25 years in public service, serving in both houses of the United States Congress and for three non-consecutive years as Governor of Massachusetts. Because of his reputation for personal integrity he was known as "Honest John" Davis.

John Davis
Daguerreotype by Mathew Brady, March 1849
United States senator from Massachusetts
In office March 4, 1835 – January 5, 1841
Preceded by	Nathaniel Silsbee
Succeeded by	Isaac C. Bates
In office March 24, 1845 – March 3, 1853
Preceded by	Isaac C. Bates
Succeeded by	Edward Everett
14th & 17th Governor of Massachusetts
In office January 9, 1834 – March 1, 1835
Lieutenant	Samuel Turell Armstrong
Preceded by	Levi Lincoln Jr.
Succeeded by	Samuel Turell Armstrong (acting)
In office January 7, 1841 – January 17, 1843
Lieutenant	George Hull
Preceded by	Marcus Morton
Succeeded by	Marcus Morton
Member of the U.S. House of Representatives from Massachusetts's 5th district
In office March 4, 1825 – January 14, 1834
Preceded by	Jonas Sibley
Succeeded by	Levi Lincoln Jr.
Personal details
Born	(1787-01-13)January 13, 1787 Northborough, Massachusetts
Died	April 19, 1854(1854-04-19) (aged 67) Worcester, Massachusetts
Resting place	Worcester Rural Cemetery
Nationality	American
Political party	Whig Anti-Jackson
Spouse(s)	Eliza Bancroft Davis
Relations	Henry Cabot Lodge, Jr. (great-great grandson)
Children	John Chandler Bancroft Davis, Horace Davis
Alma mater	Yale College
Occupation	lawyer, politician
Signature

Born in Northborough, Massachusetts, Davis attended Yale College before studying law in Worcester, Massachusetts, where he established a successful law practice. He spent 10 years (1824–34) in the United States House of Representatives as a National Republican (later Whig), where he supported protectionist tariff legislation. He won election as Governor of Massachusetts in a three-way race in 1833 that was decided by the state legislature. After two terms he was elected to the United States Senate, where he served most of one term, resigning early in 1841 after he was once again elected governor.

His second term as governor was undistinguished, but he split with fellow Whig Daniel Webster over a variety of issues, and lost the 1843 election to Democrat Marcus Morton. He was reelected to the Senate in 1845, where he served until 1851. He opposed the Mexican–American War, and worked to prevent the extension of slavery to the territories, although he did not take a hard line on the matter, voting for most of the provisions of the Compromise of 1850. He retired from public service in 1853, and died the next year.

Early life

John Davis was born in Northborough, Massachusetts to Deacon Isaac Davis and Anna (Brigham) Davis.[1] He attended local schools and then Leicester Academy before attending Yale College. He graduated in 1812, and then studied law with Worcester lawyer Francis Blake, gaining admission to the bar three years later.[2]

He was elected a member of the American Antiquarian Society in 1821.[3]

Lawyer and Congressman

Davis first practiced law in Spencer, Massachusetts, but soon returned to Worcester, where he eventually took over Blake's practice.[2] He was briefly in partnership with Levi Lincoln, Jr. before the latter was appointed to the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court in 1824.[4] Davis also entered politics in 1824, winning election to the United States Congress. He represented Massachusetts from 1825 to 1833 in the House of Representatives in the 19th, 20th, 21st, 22nd and 23rd Congresses. He supported John Quincy Adams in his successful bid for the presidency, and favored conservative fiscal policies. In keeping with the state's (and Worcester's) increasingly industrial character, he favored protectionist tariff legislation; his speeches in support of the Tariff of 1828 were widely reprinted. He opposed the policies of President Andrew Jackson, and was politically aligned with Henry Clay, although he was against Clay's proposed compromise tariff of 1833.[5]

Governor and Senator

In 1833 Davis was encouraged by National Republican Party leaders to run for Governor of Massachusetts, against former President John Quincy Adams, who was running on the Anti-Masonic ticket, and Democrat Marcus Morton. His political support came from textile interests and a faction of the National Republicans (later Whigs) led by Abbott Lawrence, as well as outgoing Governor Levi Lincoln, Jr.[6] In the election Davis gained a plurality of votes, but not the majority that was then required. As a result, the state legislature decided the election, choosing Davis when Adams withdrew, preferring him over Morton.[7] The Whig-controlled legislature did nothing to reward the Anti-Masons for Adams's move, breaking up any chance that the two parties would form a working relationship. Davis was reelected in 1834, aided by a general dislike in Massachusetts for President Jackson's attacks on the Second Bank of the United States. During these two terms, Davis made no particular initiatives of his own, continuing Lincoln's business-friendly fiscal and economic policies. The state continued to grow economically, expanding its transportation infrastructure and industry.[6]

Senator Nathaniel Silsbee, whose term ended in 1835, decided not to run for reelection.[8] Davis was approached by Whig leader Daniel Webster about running for the seat in December 1834, as part of a bid to oppose Adams, who had announced his interest in the seat. The idea was that Davis, a strong candidate, would be positioned against Adams (a long-standing rival of Webster who was again running as an Anti-Mason) in the vote, which would be made by the state legislature, while Edward Everett would have the opportunity to run for governor when Davis vacated that seat.[9] The state house and senate deadlocked on the two choices until a speech by Adams in Congress arguing in favor of Jackson's foreign policies alarmed enough senators to change their votes in favor of Davis.[10] The deadlock was not resolved until February 1835; Davis, who had been reelected governor, resigned that post to assume the Senate seat.[11] Everett went on to win the governor's seat in the next election. (Adams's son Charles Francis believed that Webster and Everett conspired to achieve this end, but there is no evidentiary support for the idea.)[9] Webster, in exchange for his advocacy on behalf of Davis, expected Davis's faction in the Whig Party to support him in a future bid for the presidency.[6]

Map depicting the northeast boundary dispute; the British claim is marked in red, the American in blue, and the final negotiated line in yellow.

Davis's term in the Senate was unexceptional, except for the notably hard line he took on the question of the nation's northeastern boundary. This dispute with the United Kingdom concerned the boundary between Maine and the British (now Canadian) province of New Brunswick, and had only been partially resolved after the 1794 Jay Treaty. In the 1830s both sides pushed development into the disputed area, leading to petty conflicts (and by 1839 the possibility of war). Massachusetts, which Maine had been a part of prior to 1820, maintained a property interest in some of the disputed land;[12] Davis took a hard line on the matter, insisting that the United States should not surrender any of the territory it claimed.[6]

In 1836 Davis sat on a special committee formed to consider legislative responses to a flood of allegedly inflammatory abolitionist materials being sent into southern slave states from northern anti-slavery organizations. Davis, the only northerner on the committee, opposed any sort of legislation, and the committee was unable to reach a consensus. When John C. Calhoun introduced legislation criminalizing the mailing of such materials, Davis spoke out against it, pointing out that it would effectively act as an unconstitutional gag on people seeking to speak out against slavery. The bill was rendered moot by administrative actions in the United States Post Office.[13]

While serving in the Senate, Davis appeared before the United States Supreme Court in 1837, representing the defendants in Charles River Bridge v. Warren Bridge. The plaintiffs were proprietors of the Charles River Bridge, a toll bridge constructed between Boston and Charlestown in 1786, and the defendants were proprietors of a competing bridge to which the state had issued a charter in 1828. The plaintiffs argued that the defendant's charter infringed on their charter, in which they claimed the state granted them an exclusive right to control the crossing. Davis and cocounsel Simon Greenleaf argued that the rights granted to the Charles River proprietors had to be interpreted narrowly, and that the state had not granted them an exclusive right. The court found for the defendants, with Chief Justice Roger B. Taney's decision echoing the defendant's reasoning.[14] The Charles River Bridge charter would be acquired by the state in 1841, during Davis's next term as governor.[15]

During the early years of his political career Davis was on good terms with Daniel Webster, who was highly influential in party politics both at the state and national levels, and to whom he looked up.[16] However, in the late 1830s Davis and other Massachusetts Whigs (notably Abbott Lawrence) came to believe that Webster lacked broad-based national support to successfully contend with Henry Clay and William Henry Harrison after his weak showing in the 1836 Whig convention.[17] This introduced a rift between Webster and Davis that deepened in 1838 when the two split on western land policies.[18] The split between Davis and Webster became permanent after Webster harshly criticized Lawrence in an 1842 speech celebrating his successful negotiation of the Webster-Ashburton Treaty with Great Britain, which resolved (among other matters) the northeast boundary.[19][20]

Governor and Senator, again

Marcus Morton, Davis's opponent in his gubernatorial races

Not long after Marcus Morton won the 1839 gubernatorial election, Whig leadership prevailed on Davis to run again for governor. In the 1840 election Davis rode the coattails of Harrison's landslide presidential victory into office.[21] Harrison's death in April 1841 reenergized the Democrats, who attacked Davis in that year's election. They charged that protectionist tariffs he supported taxed the poor, and that his opposition to western land policies was hypocritical because he also speculated in those lands.[22] Davis won a narrow majority over Morton,[23] and was reelected in 1841. This period in office, like his first term as governor, also did not contain any new programs or initiatives, but was overshadowed by the ongoing negotiations between Daniel Webster (now Secretary of State) and Lord Ashburton over the boundary issue. Davis and Webster had contentious disagreements over the negotiations, although Webster was finally able to convince Davis to accept the final agreement. The matter deepened the division between the two men, who stopped speaking to each other.[6]

In 1842 the anti-slavery Liberty Party had risen to sufficient prominence in the state that neither Morton nor Davis was able to secure a majority. The state senate, which had a Democratic majority, elected Morton.[23] Davis's showing in the election was undoubtedly harmed by his ongoing feud with Webster, who refused to campaign on his behalf.[6]

Daniel Webster (1897 portrait print), with whom Davis feuded

Davis was considered as a potential vice presidential nominee in the 1844 Whig Party convention. He was nominated by the state Whig convention over Webster's opposition,[6] but Webster worked to ensure he was not chosen at the national convention.[24] Webster forces successfully got Webster elected to the Senate in early 1845, despite opposition from the Lawrence-Davis faction. Davis was himself elected to the Senate again later in 1845 to fill the vacancy caused by the death of Isaac C. Bates,[6][25] and was elected to a full term in 1847. He opposed the annexation of Texas on the grounds that it would expand slaveholding territory, but was not willing to split the party over the issue of slavery.[26] Davis was one of only two senators who voted against the Mexican–American War.[27]

Davis was opposed to slavery and its extension into the territories, but he voted for most of the provisions of the Compromise of 1850,[28] including the bill on Texas borders, shocking some anti-compromise Whigs.[29] He regularly voted in favor of the Wilmot Proviso, a measure to ban slavery from territories won in the Mexican war which was frequently attached to legislation in the late 1840s but was never adopted. In one notable debate, Davis used procedural measures to delay vote on an amendment to remove it from a military appropriations bill, hoping to force a vote without time to conference on differences between the House and Senate versions before Congress adjourned. However, due to a difference in the clocks in the respective chambers, the House adjourned before he finished speaking, scuttling the bill. Salmon P. Chase wrote of the episode, "Ten political lives of ten John Davises, spent in the best direction, could not compensate for this half-hour's mischief", and Polk noted that if the loss of the bill delayed the end of the Mexican war, Davis would "deserve the execrations of the country."[30] Scholarship is divided on whether Davis's claimed strategy would really have worked.[31]

Davis's weak stance on slavery began to cause a decrease in his popularity as abolitionist sentiment in the state gained ground during the 1840s. He also refused to support Webster in his 1852 presidential bid, campaigning on behalf of Winfield Scott.[6] He declined renomination for election in 1852,[32] and retired from public life.[33]

Davis's son Horace, late in life

Davis's son Hasbrouck Davis.

In his later years Davis was associated with the American Antiquarian Society, where he served as president for many years.[31] He died in Worcester on April 19, 1854,[4] and was interred in the Worcester Rural Cemetery.[34] He was known as "Honest John" Davis, because of an impeccable reputation for personal integrity.[31]

Personal life and business

In 1844, Davis and his nephew Isaac were among the founders of the State Mutual Life Assurance Company of Worcester, one of only five life insurance companies in the country.[35] Davis served as its president until his death, after which his nephew took over.[36][37]

Davis married Eliza Bancroft in 1822. She was the daughter of Worcester minister Aaron Bancroft and sister to historian and statesman George Bancroft.[38] They had five children, including diplomat John Chandler Bancroft Davis, general Hasbrouck Davis, and Congressman Horace Davis;[39] their descendants include Assemblyman Gherardi Davis (1858–1941), Henry Cabot Lodge, Jr.[35] John Davis Long, the grandson of a cousin, and who was named in his honor, also served as Governor of Massachusetts.[40]

See also

• Davis political family

Notes

1. H. Davis, pp. 24–25
2. W. Davis, p. 146
3. American Antiquarian Society Members Directory
4. W. Davis, p. 147
5. Brauer, p. 206
6. Brauer, p. 207
7. Darling, pp. 110–118
8. Remini, p. 435
9. Varg, p. 64
10. Peterson, p. 247
11. Roe, p. 542
12. Hart, pp. 4:302–303
13. Peterson, pp. 258–259
14. Johnson, pp. 344–348
15. Warren, p. 354
16. Handlin, p. 109
17. Dalzell, pp. 61–69
18. Parish, p. 542
19. Dalzell, pp. 74–76
20. Remini, p. 572
21. Hart, pp. 4:88–89
22. Handlin, p. 181
23. Hart, pp. 4:90–92
24. Dalzell, pp. 89–90
25. Dalzell, p. 100
26. Holt, pp. 226–227
27. Hart, p. 4:297
28. Dalzell, p. 215
29. Holt, p. 536
30. Merry, pp. 290–292
31. Brauer, p. 208
32. Dalzell, p. 77
33. Kinnicutt, p. 7
34. Roe, p. 543
35. Tucker, p. 191
36. Nutt, p. 93
37. Knowlton, p. 21
38. H. Davis, pp. 55–56
39. H. Davis, pp. 25–26
40. Johnson and Brown

References

• Brauer, Kinley (1999). "Davis, John". Dictionary of American National Biography. 6. New York: Oxford University Press. pp. 206–208. ISBN 9780195206357. OCLC 39182280.
• Dalzell, Robert (1973). Daniel Webster and the Trial of American Nationalism. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. ISBN 9780395139981. OCLC 571952.
• Darling, Arthur (1925). Political Changes in Massachusetts, 1824–1848. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press. OCLC 1593840.
• Davis, Horace (1897). Ancestry of John Davis and Eliza Bancroft. San Francisco, CA: self-published. OCLC 8023109.
• Davis, William Thomas (1895). Bench and Bar of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Volume 2. Boston: Boston History Co. OCLC 15711603.
• Handlin, Lilian (1984). George Bancroft: The Intellectual as Democrat. New York: Harper & Row. ISBN 0060390336. OCLC 10183133.
• Hart, Albert Bushnell (ed) (1927). Commonwealth History of Massachusetts. New York: The States History Company. OCLC 1543273.CS1 maint: extra text: authors list (link) (five volume history of Massachusetts until the early 20th century)
• Holt, Michael (1999). The Rise and Fall of the American Whig Party: Jacksonian Politics and the Onset of the Civil War. New York: Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780195055443. OCLC 231788473.
• Johnson, Rossiter; Brown, John Howard (eds) (1904). The Twentieth Century Biographical Dictionary of Notable Americans, Volume 7. Boston, MA: Biographical Society. OCLC 6182270.CS1 maint: extra text: authors list (link) No page numbers.
• Johnson, John (ed) (2001). Historic US Court Cases, Volume 1. New York: Taylor and Francis. ISBN 9780415937559. OCLC 24847153.CS1 maint: extra text: authors list (link)
• Kinnicutt, Thomas (1854). Notice of the Life and Character of Hon. John Davis. Boston: J. Wilson. p. 5. OCLC 13297703.
• Knowlton, Elliott (1984). Worcester's Best: A Guide to the City's Architectural Heritage. Worcester, MA: Worcester Heritage Preservation Society. ISBN 9780914274124. OCLC 11655281.
• Merry, Robert (2009). A Country of Vast Designs: James K. Polk, the Mexican War and the Conquest of the American Continent. New York: Simon and Schuster. ISBN 9780743297431. OCLC 310397742.
• Parish, Peter (December 1967). "Daniel Webster, New England, and the West". The Journal of American History (Volume 54, No. 3). JSTOR 2937405.
• Peterson, Merrill (1987). The Great Triumvirate: Webster, Clay, and Calhoun. New York: Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780195038774. OCLC 15016375.
• Remini, Robert (1997). Daniel Webster: The Man and his Time. New York: Norton. ISBN 9780393045529. OCLC 231718657.
• Roe, Alfred (January 1902). "The Governors of Massachusetts". The New England Magazine. No. Volume 25, No. 5. OCLC 1644447.
• Tucker, Stanley (ed) (2013). The Encyclopedia of the Mexican-American War. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO. ISBN 9781851098538. OCLC 773022366.CS1 maint: extra text: authors list (link)
• Varg, Paul (1992). Edward Everett: The Intellectual in the Turmoil of Politics. Selinsgrove, PA: Susquehanna University Press. ISBN 9780945636250. OCLC 24319483.
• Warren, Charles (July 1908). "The Charles River Bridge Case". The Green Bag (Volume 20, No. 7): 346–354.

External links

• United States Congress. "John Davis (id: D000117)". Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.

Party political offices
Preceded by Levi Lincoln Jr.	National Republican nominee for Governor of Massachusetts 1833	Succeeded by None
First	Whig nominee for Governor of Massachusetts 1834	Succeeded by Edward Everett
Preceded by Edward Everett	Whig nominee for Governor of Massachusetts 1840, 1841, 1842	Succeeded by George N. Briggs
U.S. House of Representatives
Preceded by Jonas Sibley	Member of the U.S. House of Representatives from Massachusetts's 5th congressional district March 4, 1825 – January 14, 1834	Succeeded by Levi Lincoln, Jr.
U.S. Senate
Preceded by Nathaniel Silsbee	U.S. senator from Massachusetts March 4, 1835 – January 5, 1841	Succeeded by Isaac C. Bates
Preceded by Isaac C. Bates	U.S. senator from Massachusetts March 24, 1845 – March 3, 1853	Succeeded by Edward Everett
Political offices
Preceded by Levi Lincoln, Jr.	Governor of Massachusetts 1834–1835	Succeeded by Samuel T. Armstrong (acting)
Preceded by Marcus Morton	Governor of Massachusetts 1841–1843	Succeeded by Marcus Morton