Jewish atheism

Jewish atheism refers to the atheism of people who are ethnically and (at least to some extent) culturally Jewish. Because Jewish identity is ethnoreligious (i.e., it encompasses ethnic as well as religious components), the term "Jewish atheism" does not inherently entail a contradiction.

Based on Jewish law's emphasis on matrilineal descent, even religiously conservative Orthodox Jewish authorities would accept an atheist born to a Jewish mother as fully Jewish.[1] A 2011 study found that half of all American Jews have doubts about the existence of God, compared to 10–15% of other American religious groups.[2]

Organized Jewish life

There has been a phenomenon of atheistic and secular Jewish organizations, mostly in the past century, from the Jewish socialist Bund in early twentieth-century Poland to the modern Congress of Secular Jewish Organizations and the Society for Humanistic Judaism in the United States. Many Jewish atheists feel comfortable within any of the three major non-Orthodox Jewish denominations (Reform, Conservative, and Reconstructionist). This presents less of a contradiction than might first seem apparent, given Judaism's emphasis on practice over belief, with even mainstream guides to Judaism suggesting that belief in God is not a necessary prerequisite to Jewish observance.[3] However, Orthodox Judaism regards the acceptance of the "Yoke of Heaven" (the sovereignty of the God of Israel in the world and the divine origin of the Torah) as a fundamental obligation for Jews, and the Reform movement has rejected efforts at affiliation by atheistic temples despite many Reformed Jews being atheist/agnostic.[4] Although, as mentioned, the presence of atheists in many denominations of modern Judaism from Secular Humanistic Judaism to Conservative Judaism has been noted.[5]

Jewish theology

Nineteenth-century and early twentieth-century Reform Judaism in the US, which had become the dominant form of Judaism there by the 1880s, was profoundly shaped by its engagement with high profile skeptics and atheists such as Robert Ingersoll and Felix Adler. These included the writings of rabbis such as Isaac Mayer Wise, Kaufmann Kohler, Emil G. Hirsch, Joseph Krauskopf, Aaron Hahn, and J. Leonard Levy, with the result that a distinctly panentheistic character of US Reform Jewish theology was observable, which many would have viewed as atheistic or espousing atheistic tendencies.[6]

Liberal Jewish theology makes few metaphysical claims, and is thus compatible with atheism on an ontological level. The founder of Reconstructionist Judaism, Mordecai Kaplan, espoused a naturalistic definition of God, while some post-Holocaust theology has also eschewed a personal god.[7][8] The Jewish philosopher Howard Wettstein has advanced a non-metaphysical approach to religious commitment, according to which metaphysical theism-atheism is not the issue.[9] Harold Schulweis, a Conservative rabbi trained in the Reconstructionist tradition, has argued that Jewish theology should move from a focus on God to an emphasis on "godliness." This "predicate theology", while continuing to use theistic language, again makes few metaphysical claims that non-believers would find objectionable.[10][11]

However, some Jewish atheists remain deeply uncomfortable with the use of any kind of theistic language. For such Jews, traditional practice and symbolism can still retain powerful meaning. They may continue to engage in Jewish rituals such as the lighting of Shabbat candles and find meaning in many aspects of Jewish culture and religion. For example, to an atheist Jew, the Menorah might represent the power of the Jewish spirit or stand as a symbol of the fight against assimilation or simply as a celebration of a historical event, which is a debate even in theistic Jewish circles. No mention of a divine force in Jewish history would be accepted literally; the Torah may be viewed as a common mythology of the Jewish people, not a faith document or correct history.

Secular Jewish culture

See also: Jewish secularism

Many Jewish atheists would reject even this level of ritualized and symbolic identification, instead embracing a thoroughgoing secularism and basing their Jewishness entirely in ethnicity and secular Jewish culture. Possibilities for secular Jewishness include an identification with Jewish history and peoplehood, immersion in Jewish literature (including such non-religious Jewish authors as Philip Roth and Amos Oz), the consumption of Jewish food, the use of Jewish humor, and an attachment to Jewish languages such as Yiddish, Hebrew or Ladino. A high percentage of Israeli Jews identify themselves as secular, rejecting some religious practices (see Religion in Israel). While some non-believers of Jewish ancestry do not consider themselves Jews, preferring to define themselves solely as atheists, some would argue that Judaism is arguably a culture and tradition that can be embraced without religious faith, despite Jewish culture revolving around Abrahamic conceptions of God.[12]

Notable people

See also: List of Jewish atheists and agnostics

Historically, many well-known Jews have rejected a belief in deities. Some have denied the existence of a traditional deity while continuing to use religious language. In 1656, the seventeenth-century Jewish philosopher Baruch Spinoza was excommunicated by Amsterdam's Sephardic synagogue after advancing a pantheist notion of God that, according to some observers, is both compatible with and paved the way for modern atheism.[13] Deeply influenced by Spinoza, Albert Einstein used theistic language and identified strongly as a Jew, while rejecting the notion of a personal god.[14] The astrophysicist Carl Sagan was born into a Jewish family and was a non-theist.[15]

Karl Marx was born into an ethnically Jewish family but raised as a Lutheran, and is among the most notable and influential atheist thinkers of modern history; he developed dialectical and historical materialism which became the basis for his critique of capitalism and his theories of scientific socialism. Marx became a major influence among other prominent Jewish intellectuals including Moses Hess. In one of his most cited comments on religion he stated: "Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people."

Some other famous Jews have wholeheartedly embraced atheism, rejecting religiosity altogether. Sigmund Freud penned The Future of an Illusion, in which he both eschewed religious belief and outlined its origins and prospects. At the same time he urged a Jewish colleague to raise his son within the Jewish religion, arguing that "If you do not let your son grow up as a Jew, you will deprive him of those sources of energy which cannot be replaced by anything else."[16] The anarchist Emma Goldman was born to an Orthodox Jewish family and rejected belief in God,[17] while the Israeli prime minister Golda Meir, when asked if she believed in God, answered "I believe in the Jewish people, and the Jewish people believe in God."[18] More recently, the French Jewish philosopher Jacques Derrida stated somewhat cryptically, "I rightly pass for an atheist".[19] In the world of entertainment, Woody Allen has made a career out of the tension between his Jewishness and religious doubt ("Not only is there no God, but try getting a plumber on weekends").[20] David Silverman, president of the American Atheists since 2010, swore after his bar mitzvah that he would never again lie about not being an atheist.[21]

See also

• Apostasy in Judaism
• Conversion to Judaism
• Cultural Judaism
• Haskalah
• Jewish schisms
• Jewish secularism
• Off the derech
• Who is a Jew?

Notes

1. "What Makes a Jew "Jewish"?". Chabad.org. Retrieved December 22, 2018.
2. Winston, Kimberly (September 26, 2011). "Judaism without God? Yes, say American atheists". USA Today. Retrieved December 22, 2018.
3. Septimus, Daniel (January 10, 2003). "Must a Jew Believe in God?". MyJewishLearning.com. Retrieved December 22, 2018.
4. "Reform Jews Reject a Temple Without God". The New York Times. June 13, 1994. Retrieved December 22, 2018.
5. Berlinerblau, Jacques (November 6, 2007). "In Praise of Jewish Atheism". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on December 23, 2018. Retrieved December 22, 2018.
6. Langton, Daniel R. "Discourses of Doubt: The Place of Atheism, Scepticism and Infidelity in Nineteenth-Century North American Reform Jewish Thought" in Hebrew Union College Annual (2018) Vol.88. pp. 203-253.
7. Kaplan, Mordecai (1937). The Meaning of God in Modern Jewish Religion. New York: Behrman's Jewish book house.
8. Rubenstein, Richard (1966). After Auschwitz: Radical Theology and Contemporary Judaism. Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill. p. 87. Retrieved December 22, 2018.
9. Wettstein, Howard (2012). The Significance of Religious Experience. Oxford University Press. pp. 27, 212–213. ISBN 9780199841363.
10. Schulweis, Harold M. (1984). Evil and the Morality of God. Cincinnati: Hebrew Union College Press. p. 87. ISBN 9780878201563.
11. Schulweis, Harold M. (1995). For Those Who Can't Believe: Overcoming the Obstacles to Faith. Harper Perennial. p. 133. ISBN 9780060926519.
12. An example of an atheist rejecting Jewish identification is cited here: Blowdryer, Jennifer; Orloff, Alvin (January 2005). "Hipster Antisemitism". Zeek.com. Retrieved December 22, 2018.
13. Hitchens, Christopher, ed. (2007). The Portable Atheist. Philadelphia: Da Capo Press. p. 21. ISBN 9780306816086.
14. "Einstein and his God". Moment. April 2007. Retrieved December 22, 2018.
15. Sagan, Carl (February 12, 1986). "23". Broca's Brain: Reflections on the Romance of Science. Ballantine Book. p. 335. ISBN 0-345-33689-5.
16. Ariel, David S. (1995). What Do Jews Believe?. New York: Shocken Books. p. 248. ISBN 9780805210590.
17. Hitchens, Christopher, ed. (2007). "The Philosophy of Atheism". The Portable Atheist. Philadelphia: Da Capo Press. pp. 129–133. ISBN 9780306816086.
18. Rosen, Jonathan (December 14, 2003). "So Was It Odd of God?". The New York Times. Retrieved December 22, 2018. He seems to subscribe to Golda Meir's observation: 'I believe in the Jewish people, and the Jewish people believe in God.' 
19. McLemee, Scott (October 11, 2004). "Jacques Derrida, Thinker Who Influenced and Infuriated a Range of Humanistic Fields, Dies at 74". The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved December 22, 2018.
20. "Woody Allen Quotes". Retrieved December 22, 2018.
21. Freethought Arizona (December 12, 2013). "Dave Silverman "I'm an Atheist (And So Are You); Why I've Changed My Mind on Jewish Atheism"". Retrieved December 22, 2018.