Achaeans (Homer)

The Achaeans (/əˈkiːənz/; Ancient Greek: Ἀχαιοί Akhaioí, "the Achaeans" or "of Achaea") constitute one of the collective names for the Greeks in Homer's Iliad (used 598 times) and Odyssey. The other common names are Danaans (/ˈdæneɪ.ənz/; Δαναοί Danaoi; used 138 times in the Iliad) and Argives (/ˈɑːrɡaɪvz/; Ἀργεῖοι Argeioi; used 182 times in the Iliad) while Panhellenes (Πανέλληνες Panhellenes, "All of the Greeks") and Hellenes (/ˈhɛliːnz/;[1] Ἕλληνες Hellenes) both appear only once;[2] all of the aforementioned terms were used synonymously to denote a common Greek civilizational identity.[3][4] In the historical period, the Achaeans were the inhabitants of the region of Achaea, a region in the north-central part of the Peloponnese. The city-states of this region later formed a confederation known as the Achaean League, which was influential during the 3rd and 2nd centuries BC.

This article is about the Homeric use of the term 'Achaeans'. For other uses in antiquity, see Achaea (disambiguation).

Homeric versus later use

The Homeric "long-haired Achaeans" would have been a part of the Mycenaean civilization that dominated Greece from circa 1600 BC until 1100 BC. Later, by the Archaic and Classical periods, the term "Achaeans" referred to inhabitants of the much smaller region of Achaea. Herodotus identified the Achaeans of the northern Peloponnese as descendants of the earlier, Homeric Achaeans. According to Pausanias, writing in the 2nd century CE, the term "Achaean" was originally given to those Greeks inhabiting the Argolis and Laconia.[5]

Pausanias and Herodotus both recount the legend that the Achaeans were forced from their homelands by the Dorians, during the legendary Dorian invasion of the Peloponnese. They then moved into the region later called Achaea.

A scholarly consensus has not yet been reached on the origin of the historic Achaeans relative to the Homeric Achaeans and is still hotly debated. Former emphasis on presumed race, such as John A. Scott's article about the blond locks of the Achaeans as compared to the dark locks of "Mediterranean" Poseidon,[6] on the basis of hints in Homer, has been rejected by some. The contrasting belief that "Achaeans", as understood through Homer, is "a name without a country", an ethnos created in the Epic tradition,[7] has modern supporters among those who conclude that "Achaeans" were redefined in the 5th century BC, as contemporary speakers of Aeolic Greek.

Karl Beloch suggested there was no Dorian invasion, but rather that the Peloponnesian Dorians were the Achaeans.[8] Eduard Meyer, disagreeing with Beloch, instead put forth the suggestion that the real-life Achaeans were mainland pre-Dorian Greeks.[9] His conclusion is based on his research on the similarity between the languages of the Achaeans and pre-historic Arcadians. William Prentice disagreed with both, noting archeological evidence suggests the Achaeans instead migrated from "southern Asia Minor to Greece, probably settling first in lower Thessaly" probably prior to 2000 BC.[10]

Hittite documents

Emil Forrer, a Swiss Hittitologist who worked on the Boghazköy tablets in Berlin, said the Achaeans of pre-Homeric Greece were directly associated with the term "Land of Ahhiyawa" mentioned in the Hittite texts.[11] His conclusions at the time were challenged by other Hittitologists (i.e. Johannes Friedrich in 1927 and Albrecht Götze in 1930), as well as by Ferdinand Sommer, who published his Die Ahhijava-Urkunden ("The Ahhiyawa Documents") in 1932.[11]

Map showing the Hittite Empire, Ahhiyawa (Achaeans) and Wilusa (Troy) in c. 1300 BC.

Some Hittite texts mention a nation lying to the west called Ahhiyawa.[12] In the earliest reference to this land, a letter outlining the treaty violations of the Hittite vassal Madduwatta,[13] it is called Ahhiya. Another important example is the Tawagalawa Letter written by an unnamed Hittite king (most probably Hattusili III) of the empire period (14th–13th century BC) to the king of Ahhiyawa, treating him as an equal and implying Miletus (Millawanda) was under his control.[14] It also refers to an earlier "Wilusa episode" involving hostility on the part of Ahhiyawa. Ahhiya(wa) has been identified with the Achaeans of the Trojan War and the city of Wilusa with the legendary city of Troy (note the similarity with early Greek Ϝίλιον Wilion, later Ἴλιον Ilion, the name of the acropolis of Troy). The exact relationship of the term Ahhiyawa to the Achaeans beyond a similarity in pronunciation was hotly debated by scholars, even following the discovery that Mycenaean Linear B is an early form of Greek; the earlier debate was summed up in 1984 by Hans G. Güterbock of the Oriental Institute.[15] More recent research based on new readings and interpretations of the Hittite texts, as well as of the material evidence for Mycenaean contacts with the Anatolian mainland, came to the conclusion that Ahhiyawa referred to the Mycenaean world, or at least to a part of it.[16]

Egyptian sources

Map of Mycenaean cultural areas, 1400-1100 BC (unearthed sites in red dots).

It has been proposed that Ekwesh of the Egyptian records may relate to Achaea (compared to Hittite Ahhiyawa), whereas Denyen and Tanaju may relate to Classical Greek Danaoi.[17] The earliest textual reference to the Mycenaean world is in the Annals of Thutmosis III (ca. 1479–1425 BC), which refers to messengers from the king of the Tanaju, circa 1437 BC, offering greeting gifts to the Egyptian king, in order to initiate diplomatic relations, when the latter campaigned in Syria.[17] Tanaju is also listed in an inscription at the Mortuary Temple of Amenhotep III. The latter ruled Egypt in circa 1382–1344 BC. Moreover, a list of the cities and regions of the Tanaju is also mentioned in this inscription; among the cities listed are Mycenae, Nauplion, Kythera, Messenia and the Thebaid (region of Thebes).[17]

During the 5th year of Pharaoh Merneptah, a confederation of Libyan and northern peoples is supposed to have attacked the western delta. Included amongst the ethnic names of the repulsed invaders is the Ekwesh or Eqwesh, whom some have seen as Achaeans, although Egyptian texts specifically mention these Ekwesh to be circumcised (which does not seem to have been a general practice in the Aegean at the time). Homer mentions an Achaean attack upon the delta, and Menelaus speaks of the same in Book IV of the Odyssey to Telemachus when he recounts his own return home from the Trojan War. Later Greek myths also say Helen had spent the time of the Trojan War in Egypt, and not at Troy, and that after Troy the Greeks went there to recover her.

Greek mythology

In Greek mythology, the perceived cultural divisions among the Hellenes were represented as legendary lines of descent that identified kinship groups, with each line being derived from an eponymous ancestor. Each of the Greek ethne were said to be named in honor of their respective ancestors: Achaeus of the Achaeans, Danaus of the Danaans, Cadmus of the Cadmeans (the Thebans), Hellen of the Hellenes (not to be confused with Helen of Troy), Aeolus of the Aeolians, Ion of the Ionians, and Dorus of the Dorians.

Cadmus from Phoenicia, Danaus from Egypt, and Pelops from Anatolia each gained a foothold in mainland Greece and were assimilated and Hellenized. Hellen, Graikos, Magnes, and Macedon were sons of Deucalion and Pyrrha, the only people who survived the Great Flood;[18] the ethne were said to have originally been named Graikoi after the elder son but later renamed Hellenes after Hellen who was proved to be the strongest.[19] Sons of Hellen and the nymph Orseis were Dorus, Xuthos, and Aeolus.[20] Sons of Xuthos and Kreousa, daughter of Erechthea, were Ion and Achaeus.[20]

According to Hyginus, 22 Achaeans killed 362 Trojans during their ten years at Troy.[21][22]

Genealogy of the Argives

Argive genealogy in Greek mythology

Inachus Melia Zeus Io Phoroneus Epaphus Memphis Libya Poseidon Belus Achiroë Agenor Telephassa Danaus Pieria Aegyptus Cadmus Cilix Europa Phoenix Mantineus Hypermnestra Lynceus Harmonia Zeus Polydorus Sparta Lacedaemon Ocalea Abas Agave Sarpedon Rhadamanthus Autonoë Eurydice Acrisius Ino Minos Zeus Danaë Semele Zeus Perseus Dionysus

Colour key:      Male      Female      Deity

Etymology

According to Margalit Finkelberg, the name Ἀχαιοί/Ἀχαιϝοί is derived from Hittite Aḫḫiyawā.[23] However, Robert S. P. Beekes doubted the validity of this derivation and suggested a Pre-Greek proto-form *Akay^wa-.[24] The etymology of Danaoi is uncertain; according to Beekes, "the name is certainly Pre-Greek".[25]

See also

• Achaea (modern province)
• Achaea (Roman province)
• Achaean League
• Achaean Federation
• Aegean civilization
• Denyen
• Historicity of the Iliad
• Homer
• Mycenaean Greece
• Mycenaean language
• Military of Mycenaean Greece
• Troy

References

Citations

1. "Hellene" entry in Collins English Dictionary.
2. See Iliad, II.2.530 for "Panhellenes" and Iliad II.2.653 for "Hellenes".
3. Cartledge 2011, Chapter 4: Argos, p. 23: "The Late Bronze Age in Greece is also called conventionally 'Mycenaean', as we saw in the last chapter. But it might in principle have been called 'Argive', 'Achaean', or 'Danaan', since the three names that Homer does apply to Greeks collectively were 'Argives', 'Achaeans', and 'Danaans'."
4. Nagy 2014, Texts and Commentaries – Introduction #2: "Panhellenism is the least common denominator of ancient Greek civilization...The impulse of Panhellenism is already at work in Homeric and Hesiodic poetry. In the Iliad, the names "Achaeans" and "Danaans" and "Argives" are used synonymously in the sense of Panhellenes = "all Hellenes" = "all Greeks.""
5. Pausanias. Description of Greece, VII.1.
6. Scott 1925, pp. 366–367.
7. As William K. Prentice expressed this long-standing skepticism of a genuine Achaean ethnicity in the distant past, at the outset of his article "The Achaeans" (see Prentice 1929, p. 206).
8. Beloch 1893, Volume I, pp. 88 (Note #1) and 92.
9. Meyer 1884–1902, Volume II, Part 1: Die Zeit der ägyptischen Großmacht – V. Das griechische Festland und die mykenische Kultur.
10. Prentice 1929, pp. 206–218.
11. Güterbock 1984, p. 114.
12. Huxley 1960, p. 22; Güterbock 1983, pp. 133–138; Mellink 1983, pp. 138–141.
13. Translation of the Sins of Madduwatta Archived February 28, 2007, at the Wayback Machine
14. Translation of the Tawagalawa Letter Archived 2013-10-21 at the Wayback Machine
15. Güterbock 1984, pp. 114–122.
16. Latacz 2004, pp. 121–122 harvnb error: no target: CITEREFLatacz2004 (help); Bryce 1999, p. 60.
17. Kelder 2010, pp. 125–126.
18. Hesiod. Catalogue of Women, Fragments.
19. Aristotle. Meteorologica, I.14.
20. Pseudo-Apollodorus. Bibliotheca, I.7.3.
21. Hyginus. Fabulae, 114.
22. In particular: Achilles 72, Antilochus 2, Protesilaus 4, Peneleos 2, Eurypylus 1, Ajax 14, Thoas 2, Leitus 20, Thrasymedes 2, Agamemnon 16, Diomedes 18, Menelaus 8, Philoctetes 3, Meriones 7, Odysseus 12, Idomeneus 13, Leonteus 5, Ajax 28, Patroclus 54, Polypoetes 1, Teucer 30, Neoptolemus 6; a total of 362 Trojans.
23. Finkelberg 1988, pp. 127–134.
24. Beekes 2010, p. 181.
25. Beekes 2010, p. 302.

Sources

• Beekes, Roberts Stephen Paul (2010). Etymological Dictionary of Greek: The Pre-Greek Loanwords in Greek. Leiden: Brill. ISBN 9789004174184.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Beloch, Karl Julius (1893). Griechische Geschichte (Volume I). Strassburg and Berlin.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Bryce, Trevor (1999). The Kingdom of the Hittites. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-924010-4.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Cartledge, Paul (2011). Ancient Greece: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-960134-9.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Finkelberg, Margalit (1988). "From Ahhiyawa to Ἀχαιοί". Glotta. 66: 127–134.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Güterbock, Hans G. (April 1983). "The Hittites and the Aegean World: Part 1. The Ahhiyawa Problem Reconsidered". American Journal of Archaeology. Archaeological Institute of America. 87 (2): 133–138. doi:10.2307/504928. JSTOR 504928.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Güterbock, Hans G. (June 1984). "Hittites and Akhaeans: A New Look". Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society. American Philosophical Society. 128 (2): 114–122. JSTOR 986225.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Huxley, George Leonard (1960). Achaeans and Hittites. Oxford: Vincent Baxter Press.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Kelder, Jorrit M. (2010). "The Egyptian Interest in Mycenaean Greece". 42. Jaarbericht "Ex Oriente Lux" (JEOL): 125–140. Cite journal requires |journal= (help)CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Mellink, Machteld J. (April 1983). "The Hittites and the Aegean World: Part 2. Archaeological Comments on Ahhiyawa-Achaians in Western Anatolia". American Journal of Archaeology. Archaeological Institute of America. 87 (2): 138–141. doi:10.2307/504929. JSTOR 504929.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Meyer, Eduard (1884–1902). Geschichte des Altertums (Volume 1–5). Stuttgart-Berlin.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Nagy, Gregory (2014). "The Heroic and the Anti-Heroic in Classical Greek Civilization". Cambridge, MA: President and Fellows of Harvard College. Archived from the original on 2016-05-20. Retrieved 2014-02-07.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Prentice, William K. (April–June 1929). "The Achaeans". American Journal of Archaeology. Archaeological Institute of America. 33 (2): 206–218. doi:10.2307/497808. JSTOR 497808.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Scott, John A. (March 1925). "The Complexion of the Achaeans". The Classical Journal. The Classical Association of the Middle West and South. 20 (6): 366–367. JSTOR 3288466.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Windle, Joachim Latacz (2004). Troy and Homer: Towards a Solution of an Old Mystery. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-926308-0.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)

External links

• Jordan, Herbert (2009–2012). "The Iliad of Homer (Translated by Herbert Jordan): The Achaeans, Argives, Danaans, or Greeks?".
• Salimbetti, Andrea (30 September 2013). "The Greek Age of Bronze".