Graduation (album)

Graduation is the third studio album by American rapper and producer Kanye West, released on September 11, 2007, through Def Jam Recordings and Roc-A-Fella Records. Recording sessions took place between 2005 and 2007 at several studios in New York and Los Angeles. It was primarily produced by West himself, with contributions from various other producers. The album also features guest appearances from recording artists such as Dwele, T-Pain, Lil Wayne, DJ Premier, and Chris Martin of Coldplay. The cover art and its interior artwork were designed by Japanese contemporary artist Takashi Murakami.

Graduation
Studio album by Kanye West
Released	September 11, 2007 (2007-09-11)
Recorded	2005–2007
Studio	Chung King and Sony Music Studios, New York City Chalice Recording Studios and Record Plant, Los Angeles
Genre	Hip hop pop rap alternative hip hop
Length	51:12
Label	Def Jam Roc-A-Fella
Producer	Shawn Carter (exec.) Kanye West (also exec.) Gee Roberson (also exec.) Kyambo "Hip Hop" Joshua (exec.) Brian "All Day" Miller DJ Toomp Eric Hudson Jon Brion Mike Dean Nottz Patrick "Plain Pat" Reynolds Warryn "Baby Dubb" Campbell
Kanye West chronology
Can't Tell Me Nothing (2007) Graduation (2007) 808s & Heartbreak (2008)
Singles from Graduation
"Can't Tell Me Nothing" Released: May 15, 2007 "Stronger" Released: July 31, 2007 "Good Life" Released: October 2, 2007 "Flashing Lights" Released: November 12, 2007 "Homecoming" Released: February 18, 2008

Inspired by stadium tours, house-music and indie rock, Graduation marked a departure from the ornate, soul-based sound of West's previous releases as he musically progressed to more anthemic compositions. West incorporated layered synthesizers and dabbled with electronics while sampling from various music genres and altering his approach to rapping. He conveys an ambivalent outlook on his newfound fame and media scrutiny alongside providing inspirational messages of triumph directed at listeners. Graduation concludes the education theme of West's first two albums The College Dropout (2004) and Late Registration (2005).

Graduation debuted at number one on the US Billboard 200, selling over 957,000 copies in the first week of sales. It has since sold over 2.7 million copies in the United States and been certified double platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA). Five accompanying singles were released, including the international hits "Stronger", "Good Life" and "Homecoming", the former of which topped the Billboard Hot 100. The album received widely positive reviews from music critics, with several of them praising the production, and earned West his third Grammy Award for Best Rap Album, as well as his third nomination for Album of the Year. It was named as one the best albums of 2007 by multiple publications, including Rolling Stone and USA Today, while also listed among numerous decade-end lists.

The coinciding release dates between Graduation and rapper 50 Cent's Curtis generated much publicity over the idea of a sales competition, resulting in record-breaking sales performances by both albums. The success of the former and the outcome of its competition with the latter marked the end of the dominance of gangsta rap in mainstream hip-hop. This is credited with paving the way for other hip-hop artists who did not conform to gangster conventions to find commercial acceptance.

Background

Graduation is the third installment of West's planned tetralogy of education-themed studio albums, which West subsequently later deviated from due to the events surrounding the conception of his fourth studio album, 808s & Heartbreak (2008).[1] The album demonstrates yet another distinctive progression in West's musical style and approach to production. After spending the previous year touring the world with Irish rock band U2 on their Vertigo Tour, West became inspired by watching Bono open the stadium tours every night to incredible ovations and sought out to compose anthemic rap songs that could operate more efficiently in large stadiums and arenas.[2] In West's attempt to accomplish this "stadium-status" endeavor, West incorporated layered electronic synthesizers into his hip-hop production, which also finds him utilizing slower tempos, being influenced by the music of the 1980s, and experimenting with electronic music.[3][4][5] West was particularly influenced by house music, a subgenre of electronic dance music that first originated in his hometown of Chicago, Illinois in the early 1980s.[6] West has stated that growing up, he would listen to hip-hop music at home or in his car, but when he felt like dancing, he would attend a house club. While he rarely listened to house at home, he still felt it was an important part of his culture and background.[7]

West further broadened his musical palette on Graduation by not limiting himself to his customary use of samples and interpolation from classic soul records and instead drew influences from a far more eclectic range of music genres.[8] Along with house music, Graduation contains samples and music elements of euro-disco, hard rock, electronica, lounge, progressive rock, synth-pop, electro, krautrock, dub, reggae, and dancehall.[9][10][11][12][13] Also, for much of the third studio album, West modified his style of rapping and adopted a dilatory, exuberant flow in emulation of Bono's operatic singing.[2] West altered his vocabulary, he utilised less percussive consonants for his vocal delivery in favor of smoother vowel harmonies.[14] In addition to U2, West drew inspiration from other arena rock bands such as The Rolling Stones and Led Zeppelin for the melodies and chord progressions of his songs.[4][15] In terms of lyricism, he simplifies some of his rhymes after touring with The Rolling Stones on their A Bigger Bang concert tour and discovering he could not captivate the audiences as well with his most complex lyrical themes.[2][16]

West made a conscious decision to abstain from the widespread recording practice of excessive rap albums saturated with skits and filler and instead comprised Graduation with significantly fewer tracks.[17][18] He also chose to scale back on the guest appearances, limiting himself to just one single guest rap verse on the entire studio album.[19] West cites the rock bands The Killers, Keane, Modest Mouse, and indie-pop singer-songwriter Feist for being among his favorite musicians and having considerably profound influence on the sound of Graduation.[17] Due largely to these factors and the inclusion of layered electronic synthesizers, West believed that his record took hip-hop in a different direction. He also acknowledged that the differences did not in and of themselves make Graduation a good album; however, he felt it was an accurate representation of the music he was listening to and inspired by at that time.[17]

Recording

West's experiences on arena rock tours such as U2's Vertigo Tour (pictured) inspired his direction for the album.

West began working on Graduation immediately after releasing his second studio album Late Registration.[20] By late September 2005, West had already completed three songs for the album, which he intended to contain a total of twelve tracks.[20] Around the time of the recording of the third studio album, West would often listen to songs written by folk and country singer-songwriters Bob Dylan and Johnny Cash in hopes of developing methods to augment his word play and storytelling abilities. The former musician had been recommended to West by multiple of his friends, including English disc jockey Samantha Ronson, all of whom claimed his music and the way he dealt with the press reminded them of Dylan. West also listened to his most favorite alternative rock bands, including The Killers, Radiohead, Modest Mouse, and Keane, in order to gain new ideas on how to make his hip-hop production style more stadium-friendly.[21] Additionally, West would often test his new songs on his iPod, in his office, in dance clubs and just about anywhere people might listen to his music. He would then make adjustments to the tracks based on feedback he received, repeating the process as many times as necessary.[17]

In comparison to previous albums, Graduation features fewer guest appearances from other recording artists. West elaborated that it was a fully conscious decision to keep his guest vocalists at a minimum, saying that, "When I hear the records of my favorite bands – The Killers or Coldplay – you only hear one voice from start to finish".[22] R&B singers T-Pain and Dwele, New York rappers Mos Def and ALBe. Back, and famed hip-hop record producer DJ Premier are featured in individual tracks primarily to deliver melodic hooks and refrains.[23] However, though he originally intended for Graduation to be completely devoid of guest rap verses, West decided to invite New Orleans rapper Lil Wayne on the track "Barry Bonds".[24] At the time, the two MCs had been working together, with West contributing to the production of Lil Wayne's sixth studio album Tha Carter III.[25] As for the absence of skits, West explained, "There's just serious songs, hooks, chords, and ideas. No special effects or antics ... and no fake Bernie Mac!"[18] West instead decided to record two earthy musical interludes in place of the hip-hop skits. He incorporated African sounds and polyrhythmic percussion into both.[18] However, for unknown reasons, the two musical interludes were omitted from the studio album.[26]

Many songs on Graduation contain background vocals provided by Connie Mitchell of the Australian dance music group Sneaky Sound System.[26] The collaboration came about when West met her bandmates Angus McDonald and Daimon Downey at a diner in Sydney while touring the country with U2 around November 2006.[27][28] Seeking musical inspiration, West asked McDonald for ideas, who in turn suggested that he be introduced to Mitchell.[28] Upon meeting Mitchell after she arrived at Studios 301 where he was recording music during the tour, West had her sing over a vocal track and quickly took a liking to her voice.[27][28] U2 singer Bono and guitarist The Edge also complimented Mitchell's singing while visiting the studio.[28] Some time later, Mitchell received a call from West who asked if she could travel to The Record Plant in Los Angeles to begin recording tracks for his third studio album.[28] Mitchell later admitted that while she previously didn't know who West was and never really cared for hip-hop music, the collaboration has changed her views.[27]

Connie Mitchell contributed vocals to several songs on the album.[26]

During an interview with Billboard, West revealed that he had worked with Chris Martin, the lead singer of the British alternative rock band Coldplay, on a song entitled "Homecoming", and that it could possibly be released as the lead single for Graduation.[29] The collaboration occurred the year before when West and Martin met one another during an impromptu jam session at the Abbey Road Studios in London, England.[30] West had just finished performing at a show that had been held at Abbey Road and the band just so happened to be recording their music in the recording studio at exactly the same time.[6] The song in itself is actually a re-vamping for "Home (Windy)", a track that originated from a demo tape dating back to the year 2001.[31] It was made available two years later under the new title "Home" on West's 2003 mixtape Get Well Soon... and also on the advance copy of West's debut studio album The College Dropout, which due to a leak was never released.[9][32][33] This original version possesses West's once trademark classic soul vocal sample production style, with singer John Legend on the chorus, which contains lyrics that are different than Martin's.[32] This is due to the fact that Martin asked West to change the song's lyrical content.[34]

Widely considered by music critics and listeners alike to be the most radio-friendly track on Graduation, West defines the studio album's third single "Good Life" as the song with the most "blatant hit-recordness".[35] The track features vocals from R&B singer T-Pain, who utilizes the voice audio processor technology of Auto-Tune. The Song is sampled from Michael Jackson's song P.Y.T. (Pretty Young Thing). West had previously experimented with the technology on his debut album The College Dropout for the background vocals on the songs "Jesus Walks" and "Never Let Me Down". During his brief stay in Sweden, West sent through sixteen different mixes of "Good Life" over to their recording studio for the audio mastering process.[36] West admitted that he actually did not really care for the single, but he was pressured into releasing it by his record label Def Jam Recordings. However, West has since clarified that he doesn't retain any lingering animosity whatsoever towards his record label in regards to this.[18]

Graduation started taking definite form around the time of the filming of the music video for its second single "Stronger", whereas prior West had been "aimlessly making songs".[37] The music video was directed by famed music video director, film director, and screenwriter Hype Williams. The sci-fi imagery of music video inspired West to take his album in a more futuristic direction.[37] After the filming of the music video, which began before West had even written the song's second verse, he returned to the studio to redo parts of "Stronger" and various other tracks he recorded for the album, watching films such as Total Recall for more ideas.[37] West mixed the track seventy-five times, as he could not seem to get the kick drum to sound precisely the way that he wanted it to, amongst other issues.[36] He worked on "Stronger" with eight different audio engineers and eleven different mix engineers around the globe and recorded over fifty versions of the track.[38][39] Still feeling dissatisfied after hearing the number-one hit single inside a club compared alongside Timbaland's 2007 single "The Way I Are", which was his favorite hip-hop beat at the time, West enlisted the record producer to assist him in redoing the drum programming.[18][40]

The third studio album also sees the return of composer and multi-instrumentalist Jon Brion – who had played an integral role as the co-executive producer on West's previous studio album Late Registration – for the track "Drunk and Hot Girls".[29] West claimed that one day, while listening to "Sing Swan Song" by the German experimental-rock band Can, he heard the words "drunk and hot girls" rather than the actual "drunky hot bowls" lyrics.[41] Rather than rap, West instead slowly sings along to the sinister song's dreary original melody with warbled vocals.[42] West features vocal harmony during the chorus with guest artist Mos Def, who just after his voice experiences a four-second audio delay, also delivers the song's reverb-filled bridge.[43]

More than any other song on the entire studio album, the epic stadium-rap power ballad "I Wonder" was the most influenced by U2.[2] West cites it as one of this top three most favorite songs from Graduation.[4] West imparted that he had sought out to make the hip-hop variation of the rock band's "City of Blinding Lights".[2] West reportedly heard the snare drum which was used for the track while shopping for furniture at Moss and spent many weeks working on it.[38][44] West has also said that he wrote the song while thinking of performing it onstage in front of an audience of over 50,000 people. With this in mind, he placed a significant amount of concentration on speaking at high volumes with fewer wording and initially delivers his defiant lyrics in an intense staccato vocal style.[2][45] West raps the song's three verses using single and double-time rhyme schemes. He stresses each syllable in each word in the minimalist first verse.[46] West then transitions to a faster, more fluid flow for the more intricate second and third verses. West considered the release of "I Wonder" as the album's fourth single. But he instead chose "Flashing Lights", which he refers to as the "coolest" track from the studio album.[4][47]

The track "Everything I Am" features turntable scratches by famed record producer DJ Premier

The hip-hop beat for "The Glory" was originally made for West's GOOD Music associate, close friend, and fellow Chicago hip-hop artist Common, whose seventh album Finding Forever was being produced and recorded by West simultaneously with Graduation.[48][49] As was the case with both their previous albums, certain tracks that West originally crafted for Finding Forever that Common declined eventually ended up on his own studio album.[50] "Everything I Am" was yet another song intended for Common but was passed on, a fact which West addresses within the opening lines.[51] The record features turntable scratches contributed by famed hip-hop record producer DJ Premier.[45] After West had played the demo for "Everything I Am" over the phone for DJ Premier and asked him what he thought of it, DJ Premier then replied that he enjoyed the lyrics and the innovative beat and offered to scratch over it.[52] When working on the track, and while following the numerous instructions that were supplied by West, DJ Premier took seven different styles of scratches, including drum breaks, then cut all of them up into different rhythms, and scattered them all throughout the track, providing West with many different ideas to choose from.[52]

While written by West, who envisioned its concept and chorus while riding an elevator, the soul-baring Jay-Z dedication "Big Brother" stands as the only song on Graduation that he didn't produce.[26][53] The production of the track was instead handled solely by Atlanta record producer DJ Toomp.[26] According to West's cousin, soul singer Tony Williams, Jay-Z became quite emotional after West played a part of "Big Brother" for him in the studio for the very first time.[54] During an interview with Rolling Stone, West himself recalled that it was "a very serious moment".[21] When asked for his opinion, Jay-Z replied that he considered "Big Brother" a fair portrayal from a little brother's perspective. Jay-Z went on to say that he also thought that the song was "brilliantly written" and voice the belief of it being West's best song since "Jesus Walks" as far as structure and emotion.[36][55]

Although "Bittersweet Poetry" appears as a Japanese bonus track on Graduation, it was actually one of the very first songs crafted for Late Registration.[56] After seeing the 2004 biographical film Ray together, West and blues-rock musician John Mayer decided to collaborate on a record and immediately went back to a recording studio to compose the song "Bittersweet".[57] This wasn't the first time West and Mayer collaborated with one another. The two previously worked together to make "Go!", the third single from Common's sixth studio album Be, which came about when Mayer went to visit West at The Record Plant in Los Angeles.[58] In the end, because West felt that their song did not coincide well into the overall soundscape of his second studio album, it was subsequently unincluded.[32]

Musical style

With Graduation, West made a departure from the warm soul samples of The College Dropout and the lush baroque-pop orchestration of Late Registration.[9] Motivated by stadium impulses, West ventured towards a more atmospheric soundscape imbued with arena rock elements that explores electronic music.[59][60][61] The musical progression arose from West touring the world in 2006 with the rock bands U2 and The Rolling Stones.[59] The change also came about from listening to music that encompass genres such as alternative rock, indie-rock, and especially house music.[62] House music is a subgenre of electronic dance music whose origins can be traced back to West's hometown of Chicago, Illinois.[6] The productions of the tracks on Graduation are also unique in that they brandish European musical influences.[63] According to Jayson Green of Stylus Magazine, West had developed a fascination with Euro-disco, a European form of electronic dance music that branched off from American disco in the 1970s.[9] Going further, a columnist for Slant Magazine claims that the album's hip-hop beats would be "European-club-worthy" were they stripped of the vocals.[19] Most importantly, Green perceives that West had developed an affinity with electronic synthesizers.[9] Chicago Tribune music critic Greg Kot comments on the incorporation of synthesizer sounds. From a musical standpoint, he views Graduation as "an album steeped in keyboard tones, in all their richness and variety".[64] Mark Pytlik of Pitchfork surmises that the album exhibits a new electronic production style, especially modulated electronic noises.[63] By contrast, AllMusic's Andy Kellman argues, "Though the synthesizer use marks a clear, conscious diversion from Kanye's past productions, highlights ... are deeply rooted in the Kanye of old, using nostalgia-inducing samples, elegant pianos and strings, and gospel choirs".[65] Graduation has been regarded as a work of pop-rap by music journalists Brad Callas,[66] Joshua Botte of NPR,[67] AbsolutePunk,[68] Vice magazine's Eric Sundermann,[69] Jay Willis of GQ,[70] and The Atlantic's Spencer Korhaber.[71]

West retracted much of the rich live instrumentation that had characterized his previous studio album Late Registration. He had them replaced with heavy, layered electronic synthesizers with Gothic tendencies at loud volumes throughout Graduation.[19][72] West injected distorted synth-chords, house beats, electro-disco rhythms, and a wide array of audio-effects into his articulate hip-hop production.[63][73][74] All the while, West buried his signature kicks and snares deep beneath the decomposing layers of synths into the bottom of the mix.[6][8] Graduation contains an eclectic variety of vaguely familiar samples that were artfully manipulated by West.[75] Though he continues to use vocal samples, West now gleans them before also pushing them underneath the synths, causing them to "sound like voices trapped in a huge machine, not like organic, subliminal connections to a mythical black-music past".[3] As always is the case with his productions, West neither relies nor settles simply on samples alone. Instead, there lies a discernible sense of multi-layered grandeur evident within each track.[76] Even in new, unfamiliar musical surroundings, West retains both his self-assurance as well as his close attention to sonic detail.[9] Hence, the album contains a plethora of random, semi-audible sounds that are challenging to notice during the first few listens.[42] The sounds range from keyboard arpeggios to crowd cheers to hard rock guitars and act as a supplement for the atypical samples and the layered electronic synths.[76] West filled the corners of Graduation with enough subtle instrumental flourishes and studio embellishments to warrant a repeated, close, and careful listening experience.[9][77] According to Ann Powers from the Los Angeles Times, the album's subtly dark tone was a byproduct of the inevitable toll placed on West as an artist, "an innovator in a genre that he must at least partially destroy to renew", torn between his devotion to hip-hop tradition and his "restless artistic drive":

Graduation's intricate musical environments take a while to comprehend, and at times they seem at odds with West's confrontational lyrics. But this contradictory music makes sense when heard as an attempt to express an internal struggle – between the Kanye West hip-hop made and the West who can't be contained by it or any other genre. It's hard to stop running with the crowd, even for a trendsetter. But West is on the verge, and moving forward.[45]

Despite the predominant synthetic attributes and the overall electronic aesthetic, the emphasis placed on organic string arrangements that had accentuated Late Registration remained a significant factor on Graduation.[21] Similar to its predecessor, Graduation wasn't restricted to the confines of conventional looping techniques typical of traditional hip-hop production. Instead, West continues to implement sudden musical shifts within the multi-layered song structures and express meticulously composed introductions, bridges, and codas.[9][78] For his third album, West produced songs that combine hip-hop beats with anthemic refrains and continues to employ his skill in layering keys, strings, and vocals to coax the melodies out of samples.[79] Through acting as his own producer, West manages to maintain quality control over the album's music to ensure that "his productions build momentum even when they revolve around a handful of repeated samples [and] nearly every song on Graduation is memorable for both its hooks and its overall sound".[80] And as the album progresses, its textures and the glossy sheen of its polished, synthesizer-driven productions become harder and denser with every track.[64] Under the belief that his sophomore effort had been far too indulgent, poorly arranged, and oversaturated with unnecessary sonic accoutrements, West took measures to streamline his third release.[21] West fashioned Graduation to contain less ornate production, made the studio album completely devoid of hip-hop skits, and sequenced the record in such a way that it produced a tighter, more cohesive package.[81]

Songs

Graduation opens on a sparse note with "Good Morning", beginning with an echoed, metronomic cowbell beat and a thumping bassline melded with a simple, arpeggiating synthesizer drone.[64][82] The drone is drowned by the music that arrives at the chorus, which is a conflation of ambient synths and an astral backing choir crafted from a non-verbal vocal sample of "Someone Saved My Life Tonight" by Elton John.[38] "Good Morning" eventually concludes with the voice of Jay-Z reiterating lyrics from "The Ruler's Back", the rapper's own opening track of his sixth studio album The Blueprint.[81] The production for "Champion" features intermittent drops and 808-handclaps and expresses a slight jazz-rock influence, eschewing guitars and trumpets in favor of breezy synths.[82][83] During the verses, West raps over a constant loop of the words "their eyes" while the chopped-up hook is formed from the question, "Did you realize, that you were a champion?"[2] Both phrases are recontextualized from "Kid Charlemagne" by Steely Dan.[84] The song also sports a reggae-inspired bridge delivered by Connie Mitchell in a distinct toasting vocal style.[43] The soul-fired track "I Wonder" starts off with its piano-based refrain, which contains samples of "My Song" by Labi Siffre.[64] It then proceeds to morph into a myriad of interlaced synths that are impacted by distorted snare drum strokes (taken from "Ambitionz Az a Ridah" by 2Pac, which samples the drums from "Pee-Wee's Dance by Joeski Love) and ethereal electric keyboards.[63] During the bridge, the chord progression changes and the song adopts a heavy string section that emulates the melody of its synths. The composition then enters an instrumental passage and finishes off with a sweeping string arrangement.[63]

"Good Life" utilizes multi-tracked, interlocking vocals that harmonize with guest singer T-Pain's Auto-Tuned voice. The song's melody is based on sampled keyboards from "P.Y.T. (Pretty Young Thing)" by pop star Michael Jackson , with the tempo slightly decreased and the pitch raised to the point its sound resembles squealing shrieks.[9] "Barry Bonds" (named after the baseball player) is built on a moaning bass line and Gothic organ, while punctuated by wailing sampled from "Long Red" by Mountain.[42][81] "Drunk and Hot Girls" exhibits a sluggish waltz pitched with the rhythm of an Eastern European drinking song.[30] It contains a mix of dark orchestration and detuned electronics with elements of "Sing Swan Song" by German progressive rock band Can.[63] West claimed that while listening to their song, he heard the words "drunk and hot girls" rather than the actual "drunky hot bowls" lyrics.[41] Rather than rap, West and guest artist Mos Def sing along to the song's melody.[42] Opening with a gradual, rising crescendo of symphonic strings, "Flashing Lights" emits synth twinklings before transforming into a moderately-paced, synth-driven beat. After the introduction, in which Mitchell's processed vocals repeat the titular hook four times, West raps the two verses, each one followed by the chorus sung by Dwele coupled with the hook. Following a break, the song enters a passage where its heavily manipulated hook echoes in and out before the coda draws the composition to a close.[26] "Stronger" is built around a sample of "Harder, Better, Faster, Stronger" by Daft Punk, while its echoing deep, hallow drums affect the electronic sound.[26]

By being composed using nothing more than a Rhodes piano, a vocal sample, and turntable scratches, "Everything I Am" stands as the third studio album's most minimalistic production.[19] West marries a down-tempo beat to gentle piano chords which are accentuated by soulful cooing sampled from "If We Can't Be Lovers" by Prince Phillip Mitchell.[26] The low-key track has a scratched hook by DJ Premier formed with the vocal sample which says "Here we go again" taken from "Bring the Noise" by Public Enemy from their 1988 album It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back.[64] With its thick, heavy bass-line pattern, "The Glory" is an up-tempo number which revisits the "chipmunk-soul" that once defined the early production style of West.[15][18] It displays a sped-up and high-pitched vocal sample of "Save the Country" by Laura Nyro accompanied by uplifting strings, keys, and an all-male gospel choir with drums from "Long Red" by Mountain.[65] Chris Martin sings the chorus and supplies a gospel-style piano motif while West raps over heavy yet buoyant drums on "Homecoming".[32][41] The chatter of a noisy, cheering crowd can inexplicably be heard lurking in the background throughout the track.[42] The Jay-Z ode "Big Brother" begins with West uttering the words, "Stadium status...", backed by a string orchestra, pounding drums, a distorted guitar riff and plinking piano keys.[26] Around mid-verse, the track adopts synths that mimic the melodies of the string section. Before the second verse, additional instrumentation enters; including a heavy bass-line, metallic percussion, and 808-handclaps. The studio album's final track "Good Night" exhibits the production characteristics of West's next musical evolution. West juxtaposes the glitchy, mechanical sound of an 8-bit beat with the more elegant, traditional sound of a classical piano.[30]

Lyrics and themes

West wrote lyrics expressing an ambivalence towards his newfound wealth and fame.

In comparison to previous albums, which were largely driven by observational commentary on matters pertaining to social welfare, Graduation is more introspective in nature and addresses personal themes.[79][85] West stated that he wanted to make inspirational music and placed more focus on individual perspective and experience that listeners could connect with in an attempt to create "people's theme songs".[2] Dismayed that the messages behind his complex lyricism were frequently lost on listeners and didn't carry well during live performances, West made an attempt to simplify his lyrics and use more skeletal rhyme schemes for more straightforward verses while concentrating on speaking volumes with sparser wording on Graduation.[2] Having committed a significant amount of time towards elevating his storytelling abilities by listening to folk musicians, West manages to form a lyrical narrative within nearly every song on the album.[21] West dedicated a majority of the album towards conducting an analysis himself and conveying his ambivalent outlook on his newfound wealth and fame. As such, West's subversive songwriting fluctuates between playful self-aggrandizement and critical self-doubt.[8] While confident, extroverted and celebratory at face value, many songs contained on Graduation were thematically distanced and retained melancholic subtext.[65] Some music critics remarked that compounded with West's urgent, emotive rapping style, the record sounded as if he were experiencing an existential crisis.[86]

The free-associative "Champion" is primarily composed of motivational lyrics, but West also briefly touches on the strained relationship he had with his father–who divorced from his mother when he was just three-years-old–eventually reaching the conclusion that even with their ups and downs, in the end, his father was a champion in his eyes.[87] West described "Stronger" as an "emancipation", as he uses the song to vent his frustration over mistakes he has made in the past.[37] He describes his tribulation's with music critics and media causing his return as a "Stronger" rapper, as the song title implies.[88] "I Wonder" carries an introspective tone, retaining a chorus about finding one's dreams, while West uses the verses to describe the struggle a person experiences in determining the meaning behind their life and achieving those dreams.[42] Inspired by watching Bono open stadium tours, West concentrated on speaking volumes without using too many words on the song and delivers his raps in an exuberant, staccato manner.[2] Using the same vocal styling, "Flashing Lights" tells the operatic narrative of man contemplating the complexities of a tragic relationship. "Can't Tell Me Nothing" serves as West's reflection on his fame and is characterized by bitter remorse and defiant self-awareness. West begins the song by expounding his conflicted feelings regarding wealth and desire, describing a compulsion to spend that overwhelms any and all other objectives in life.[42] He ties this into his perceived overall inability to keep himself together even as he grows into an increasingly prominent figure in the public eye.[64]

West regains his lyrical dexterity on "Barry Bonds", a competitive, though friendly battle with Lil Wayne in which the two MC exchange braggadocios rhymes.[24] The song uses Major League Baseball player Barry Bonds as a metaphor for West's ability to create music hits.[89] "Drunk and Hot Girls" is a first-person narrative that illustrates a man courting an attractive intoxicated woman in a club but gets more than what he bargained for.[2] "Everything I Am" is a song of self-examination, in which West attempts to confront his fallacies by surveying the consequences of his outspokenness ruminating over various ways people expect him to conduct himself. In the track, West addresses his indifference towards constructing a gangster persona, his refusal to dress and act like every other rapper, his inclination towards social commentary, and his lack of self-restraint.[9] West comes to the conclusion that while he will never be able to live up to people's expectations and will always be disadvantageously flawed; it's all these imperfections and more that serve to make up who he is.[42] When writing the song, West thought of a young girl in high school dealing with people coming down on her.[21]

"Homecoming" serves as a heartfelt tribute to West's hometown of Chicago, Illinois. Using an extended metaphor that personifies the city as a childhood sweetheart named 'Windy' (a reference to Chicago's nickname of the 'Windy City'), West rhymes about his love for Chicago and his guilt over leaving "her" to pursue his musical dream.[9] The song's opening lines lyrically paraphrase "I Used to Love H.E.R.", a similarly metaphoric hip-hop song made by West's close friend and label mate Common, who later appeared in the single's music video.[30] West dedicated "Big Brother" to Jay Z, whom he feels so close to that he sees him as a brother. Within the song, West dually details his love and admiration as well as his envy and antagonism towards Jay Z, metaphorically equating their relationship to that of a sibling rivalry.[21] West also uses the song's chorus as a subsidiary dedication to his mentor No I.D., who first taught him how to produce music.[90] Similar to its musicality, the songwriting characteristics of the album-closing track, "Good Night" alludes to West's next musical progression. The majority of song is composed of repetitive recitations of its choruses and bridges by Mos Def and Al Be Back. West melodically raps only one single verse in which he nostalgically reminisces over taking trips to the museum with his grandparents. As his verse draws to a close, West chastises that a person can't dwell on the past, and charges himself with living his life like he has no tomorrow. In retrospect, with the death of his mother Donda West less than two months after the album was released in addition to the dissolution of his engagement with fiancée Alexis Phifer, the trace amounts of melancholy found scattered throughout Graduation would all but envelop West's next studio album, 808s & Heartbreak.[91][92][93]

Artwork

Dropout Bear being pursued by a monstrous cloud within the interior artwork of Graduation.

West collaborated with Japanese contemporary artist Takashi Murakami to oversee the art direction of Graduation as well as design the cover art for the album's accompanying singles.[94] Often called "the Warhol of Japan", Murakami's surrealistic visual art is characterized by cartoonish creatures that appear friendly and cheerful at first glance, but possess dark, twisted undertones.[95][96] The collaboration between the two came about when West visited Murakami's Kaikai Kiki studio during a brief trip to Asaka, Japan.[97] The album's artwork expresses colorful, pastel imagery influenced by Murakami's affiliation with superflat, a post-modern art movement influenced by manga and anime.[98] Its production process took place over the course of several weeks, with West constantly visualizing new images and emailing the ideas to Murakami and his team.[99] Bringing the educational theme expressed by West's previous albums to a close, the visual plotline of the images contained within the liner notes lead up to a graduation ceremony that takes places within a fictional college institution situated within a futuristic metropolis called Universe City.[48] Murakami explained the metaphor behind the artwork saying:

The cover is based on Kanye's theme of student life. School. It's a place of dreams, of righteousness, a place to have fun. It's also occasionally a place where you experience the rigid dogma of the human race. Kanye's music scrapes sentimentality and aggressiveness together like sandpaper, and he uses his grooves to unleash this tornado that spins with the zeitgeist of the times. I too wanted to be swept up and spun around in that tornado.[100]

The artwork's storyline centers around "Dropout Bear", West's anthropomorphic teddy bear mascot.[101] The story begins on a rainy day with Dropout being awoken by his alarm clock and running out of his apartment to his car, modeled after a DeLorean. When the car's engine dies, he is forced to find an alternative means of transportation.[95] Dropout attempts to hail a cab but it speeds right past him, soaking him with puddle water. He then tries to get onto a metro rail but just misses it as it pulls away. Left with no other options, Dropout is reduced to pursuing his goal on foot. As he races down sidewalks, populated by multi-eyed, living mushrooms, Dropout is pursued by a monstrous rain cloud that attempts to swallow him whole.[102] Eventually, Dropout Bear arrives at the university and makes it to his ceremony just in time to stand before his colleagues, a wide variety of anthropomorphic creatures like himself. The visual story concludes with Dropout Bear being shot out of a cannon from the university into the sky into another stratosphere on the back cover.[26]

The cover art for Graduation was cited as the fifth best album cover of the year by Rolling Stone.[103] Murakami later reproduced the artwork designs through the use of cel-shaded animation within a three-minute animated music video for the opening track "Good Morning".[102] After collaborating with West on the artwork and video, Murakami later worked with him on the cover art for West and Kid Cudi's eponymous debut studio album, Kids See Ghosts (2018).[104]

Marketing

Publicity over the album's release date pitted West in a sales competition against rapper 50 Cent (pictured).

While hosting a listening session for his second studio album Late Registration on August 3, 2005 at Sony Music Studios, West revealed that he wanted to schedule the release of Graduation sometime around October 2006.[105] Several months later, on March 28, 2007, West appeared on the Los Angeles radio station Power 106. He said that he was working on his third album and Common's seventh album Finding Forever and rapped a few lyrics from one of his songs in a cappella.[106] On May 11, it was announced that the release date for Graduation was September 18.[48] West debuted the album's lead single "Can't Tell Me Nothing" on the New York radio station Hot 97 on May 15.[107] He then released a free mixtape under the same name onto the Internet on May 27.[108] The mixtape features preview clips of songs that would appear on Graduation and showcases various artists signed onto West's record label GOOD Music as well as collaborations with other unaffiliated musicians.[109] It also contains "Us Placers", the debut song of Child Rebel Soldier, a supergroup West formed with Lupe Fiasco and Pharrell.[108]

At the end of May, Island Def Jam pushed forward the release date for Graduation up from September to an unspecified late August date, a decision that West first announced on the introductory track of his Can't Tell Me Nothing mixtape.[110] On July 19, the album's release date was changed once more and moved to September 11, 2007, the same US release date as rapper 50 Cent's third studio album Curtis.[111] When first presented with the proposal of his label moving the release date of his album yet again as well as the idea of a sales competition between him and 50 Cent, West initially expressed his indifference towards the thought, saying, "When I heard that thing about the debate, I thought that was the stupidest thing. When my album drops and 50's album drops, everybody wins because you're gonna get a lot of good music at the same time".[112] However, then Def Jam president and CEO Jay Z welcomed competition, feeling that it would be prosperous for hip-hop and the date became permanent.[113]

The album's release generated much publicity over a sales competition with 50 Cent's Curtis.[114][115] Three months that were prior to the September 11 release date, West extended his gratitude towards 50 Cent for the enthusiasm and excitement the friendly competition had produced. Though confident that he would emerge victorious, West said that he would be perfectly fine with losing to 50 Cent, saying that he'd rather, "be #2 on that day rather than come out and be #1 on a day nobody cares about".[116] In an interview for USA Today, 50 Cent expressed his view on the idea of a sales competition, stating "It's great marketing – for Kanye West. But I sell way more records than Kanye West, and I generate way more interest than Kanye West. They think they can match us up, but they'll find out when that week goes by and the sales come back. This is no rivalry".[117] "Mine will sell and his will still be on the shelf," 50 Cent tells ROLLING STONE".[118] On August 10, 50 Cent confirmed during an interview with SOHH that he would end his career as a solo recording artist if Graduation were to sell more copies than Curtis in the United States.[119] However, 50 Cent later retracted his statement within an MTV interview due to his contract agreements with Aftermath Entertainment and Interscope Records.[120] But most retailers and radio programmers interviewed picked West, whose single, "Stronger", was Number Six on Billboard's Hot 100 -while none of 50's four singles climbed higher than the thirty-second spot.[118]

West performing before a crowd at V Festival on August 18, 2007 in Chelmsford, England.

West spent a significant amount of time promoting Graduation during his trip to the United Kingdom.[121] On August 17, West guest starred on the British comedy-variety show The Friday Night Project.[121] He played preview versions of the songs "Big Brother" and "Champion" from his forthcoming third album while making an appearance on DJ Tim Westwood's radio show on August 18.[122] Later that day, West performed at V Festival in Chelmsford, England before an audience of over 50,000 people and again played new material from Graduation as well as a tribute cover of Amy Winehouse's hit single "Rehab".[123][124] He then held a secret concert with Barbadian singer Rihanna for an audience of over five hundred fans and invited guests at Westminster Central Hall in London, England on August 20.[121][125] The guests were greeted by staff members wearing graduation robes and mortarboard caps in reference to the title of West's third studio album Graduation. At the end of the concert, a shower of silver confetti and ticker tape reading Touch the Sky fell from the ceiling onto the audience while the actual "Touch the Sky", which was the fourth single from Late Registration, was played on the speakers.[125][126]

After he returned to the United States, West joined 50 Cent onstage for a surprise performance before an audience of over 20,000 people at a show held on August 22 in Madison Square Garden during Ciara and T.I.'s Screamfest '07 tour.[127] West performed for a benefit concert raising funds for and promoting higher education sponsored by his charity foundation on August 24 at Chicago's House of Blues.[128] At the concert, he provided live renditions of songs from Graduation and gave the audience a sneak peek of the early production stages of his fall Glow in the Dark Tour.[128] On August 28, West hosted a studio album listening session for Graduation at New World Stages in New York City.[2] There, West explained his influences and aspirations for the album and played songs over video clips taken from a variety of futuristic sci-fi films, including Tron, Akira, 2046, and 2001: A Space Odyssey.[2] Two days later, on the morning of August 30, the clean version of the album leaked onto the Internet.[129] In a survey conducted by Billboard, results displayed that an estimated 44% of readers predicted that Graduation would sell more units over 50 Cent and Kenny Chesney.[130] Projections for first week scans based on early store sales reports indicated towards the 575,000–700,000 range for Graduation, while Curtis was projected in the 500,000–600,000 range.[131] West and 50 Cent appeared on a 106 & Park special titled: "Kanye West vs. 50 Cent: The Clash of the Titans", which aired on September, 11. They both performed, had solo interviews, and a joint interview.[132][133] The episode was the second-highest viewed music series telecast in BET history behind 106 & Park's tribute to Aaliyah in 2001.[134]

Sales

It's a great promotional tool. To me, it's the greatest thing ever. I think people should do it more often. I'm a fan of both albums. Hip-hop needs this right now.

Timbaland, on the sales competition between West's Graduation and 50 Cent's Curtis.[114]

On the first day of its release, Graduation sold over 437,000 copies.[135] The album debuted at number one on the US Billboard 200 chart, grossing a total of over 957,000 copies in its first week in the United States alone.[136] Graduation became West's second consecutive studio album to top the Billboard 200 and also debuted at number-one on the album charts in the United Kingdom and Canada.[137][138] It was within the very same week that "Stronger" topped the Billboard Hot 100, selling over 205,000 digital downloads and giving West his third number-one single.[139] The album registered the best first-week sales totals of any record released within the last two years, with the last being West's own Late Registration.[140]

Additionally, Graduation became ranked as the 15th highest sales week for an album since Nielsen SoundScan began tracking data in 1991, as well as the highest sales week at the time of its release for an album since 50 Cent's The Massacre (2005).[141] It also set the record for the largest week of an album digitally downloaded, registering over 133,000 paid downloads, beating Maroon 5's previous set record of 102,000 for It Won't Be Soon Before Long.[142] Graduation's first week sales of 957,000 and Curtis's first week sales of 691,000 marked only the second time ever since the inception of Nielsen SoundScan that two albums debuted within the same week with totals surpassing 623,000 copies in the United States. The first occurrence of such an event was in September 1991, when Guns N' Roses conjunctively released Use Your Illusion I, which sold 685,000 copies, and Use Your Illusion II, which sold 770,000 copies. The first week sales totals of Graduation and Curtis have outsold the first week sales totals of Guns N' Roses' two albums.[141] 50 Cent showed graciousness in regards to his defeat.[143] In a statement released to the Associated Press, he said, "I am very excited to have participated in one of the biggest album release weeks in the last two years. Collectively, we have sold hundreds of thousands of units in our debut week. This marks a great moment for hip-hop music, one that will go down in history".[143] After years of slumping sales, the album competition between the two releases and the resulting record breaking performances both albums demonstrated was considered to be a "fantastic day for hip-hop".[115]

West performing at the United Center in Chicago on the album's supporting tour.

In its second week on the Billboard 200, Graduation outsold Curtis, 226,000 copies to 143,000.[144] By the next week, on October 3, 2007, the former had sold a total of 1.3 million copies in the US.[145] By year's end, Graduation was the third most-downloaded and best-selling album of 2007 on iTunes Store.[146] Graduation became West's third consecutive studio album to sell over two million copies in the United States, and it was certified double platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) for shipping two million copies on October 18, 2007.[147] As of June 14, 2013, Nielsen Soundscan reported that the album has since grossed over 2.7 million copies in the US.[148] The 957,000 copies sold in the first week of Graduation's release stood as the sixth largest first week sales in hip hop history up to January 7, 2019.[149]

In the United Kingdom, Graduation debuted at number-one on the UK Albums Chart dated September 22, 2007.[150] As of February 8, 2008, the album has been certified Platinum by the British Phonographic Industry (BPI), with sales of 600,000 copies in the UK.[151] In 2018, Official Charts Company revealed that Graduation was the 25th highest-selling rap album in the UK in the 21st century.[152] For the issue date of September 20, 2007, Graduation debuted atop the Canadian Albums Chart.[138] On January 10, 2008, the album was certified double platinum by Music Canada for sales of 200,000 copies.[153] In the week of Jesus Is King being released in 2019, Graduation re-entered the Canadian Albums Chart at number 144, experiencing a 26% increase in consumption units.[154] Graduation is the most streamed album on Spotify to have been released in 2007.

Critical reception

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
Metacritic	79/100[155]
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[65]
The A.V. Club	B+[23]
Entertainment Weekly	B−[79]
The Guardian	[72]
Los Angeles Times	[45]
MSN Music (Consumer Guide)	A−[156]
NME	6/10[30]
Pitchfork	8.7/10[63]
Rolling Stone	[81]
Spin	[157]

Graduation was met with widely positive reviews. At Metacritic, which assigns a normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from professional critics, the album received an average score of 79, based on 32 reviews.[155]

Reviewing for Spin in November 2007, Charles Aaron hailed Graduation as "mesmerizing and alienating, like all the purest forms of pop culture", with music in the tradition of Puff Daddy's late 1990s pop-rap, but more skilled: "Its music is a rush of designer adrenaline, its personality insatiable self-justification. It's the paradigm ya love to hate".[157] Pitchfork critic Mark Pytlik complimented the accessibility of West's sonic experimentations, finding it impressive and innovative how he assembled seemingly disparate elements on the songs.[63] Greg Tate, writing in The Village Voice, dubbed him "the most genuinely confessional MC in hip-hop today" and said, "bouts of narcissism aside, Graduation contains killer pieces of production".[158] Stylus Magazine's Jayson Greene said it "serves as a document of West's maturation" and, "musically, at least, it's the most accomplished thing he's ever done".[9] In Rolling Stone, Nathan Brackett wrote of West's evolving and increasingly experimental, genre-bending production and said although he lacks Jay-Z's "formal mastery", West has "grown as a writer ... given the lousy year hip-hop has had, the music needs his spazzed-out, neurotic creativity more than ever".[81] Josh Tyrangiel from Time wrote, "West plunders the best [samples] and meticulously layers every track with enough surprises that there are thrills and discoveries a dozen listens in".[77]

Some reviewers were more qualified in their praise. For MSN Music, Robert Christgau deemed Graduation a "minor success" in which "every single track offers up its momentary pleasures—choruses that make you say yeah on songs you've already found wanting, confessional details and emotional aperçus on an album that still reduces to quality product when they're over". However, he felt West spent too much of the album rationalizing his obsession with his fame in sketchy fashion and occasionally awkward rhymes, "little stuff like his failure to convert 'this'-'crib'-'shit'-'live'-'serious' into a rhyme" on "Champion" or "'at bay at a distance' into an idiom" on "Big Brother".[156] Dorian Lynskey from The Guardian said West often "undercuts rap cliches with wit and ambivalence", but observed some disappointing lyrics such as on "Can't Tell Me Nothing", which he said revealed his limited perspective.[72] Slant Magazine critic Eric Henderson found West's lyrics "only transparently expressive", saying that the songs' hooks "grab your ear on the first listen (notably bypassing your brain), your balls on the second, and your soul from there on out", and described West's production as having "adopted a beefy, synth-glam sheen".[85] Dave Heaton from PopMatters felt that though the album is good, it lacks the epochal feel of Late Registration, with songs that "aren't as richly dressed" and he claimed that West "doesn't seem to be trying as hard".[42]

Rankings

Graduation appeared on best albums of the 2000s decade lists; Pitchfork listed Graduation at number 87,[159] and Complex listed it at number 2.[160] Rolling Stone listed it at number 45,[161] and it finished second its readers list.[162] The album also appeared at 470 on NME's The 500 Greatest Albums of All Time 2013 list.[163] Complex ranked it number one on their list of the 100 Best Albums of the Complex Decade (2002-2012).[164]

Year-end lists

Publication	Accolade	Rank	Ref.
Amazon	Top 10 Albums of 2007	3	[165]
Billboard	2007 Billboard Critics' Choice poll	8	[166]
Blender	Top 10 Albums of 2007	4	[165]
Cleveland Magazine	The Best Albums of 2007	6	[167]
Consequence of Sound	Top 50 Albums of 2007	8	[168]
Entertainment Weekly	2007 Readers Picks	1	[169]
Idolator	Idolator's 2007 Pop Critics Poll	8	[170]
LAS Magazine	Top 10 Albums of 2007	5	[165]
The Morning News	The Top 10 Albums of 2007	8	[171]
My List Pad	Top Music Albums of 2007	3	[172]
NPR	Best Hip-Hop of 2007	3	[173]
Paste	Top 100 Albums of 2007	15	[174]
Pazz & Jop	The 2007 Pazz & Jop Critics Poll	6	[175]
Pitchfork	The 50 Best Albums of 2007	18	[176]
PopMatters	The Albums of 2007	3	[177]
Prefix	Top 10 Albums of 2007	6	[165]
Rolling Stone	Top 50 Albums of 2007	5	[178]
Spin	The 40 Best Albums of 2007	4	[179]
Stylus Magazine	Top 10 Albums of 2007	6	[180]
Thought Catalog	Top 27 Rap Albums of 2007	2	[181]
Time	Top 10 Albums of 2007	10	[182]
Time Out	The Best Albums of 2007 (Mike Wolf's List)	7	[183]
Treblezine	Top 10 Hip-hop Albums of 2007	2	[184]
USA Today	USA TODAY's Music Staff Year Review	1	[185]

Industry awards

Graduation won the award of Favorite Rap/Hip-Hop Album at the American Music Awards of 2008, while also counting towards West earning the award for Favorite Rap/Hip-Hop Artist. With his two wins at the ceremony, West was the second biggest winner, behind Chris Brown with three awards to his name. West told the crowd during his acceptance speech that despite winning the Favorite Rap/Hip-Hop Album award, he wanted to give the award to Lil Wayne instead. Though this stands as one of the multiple times that West has given an award of his to someone else, West also has a frequent history of complaining when he does not win an award.[186]

At the 50th Annual Grammy Awards, Graduation won the award for Best Rap Album, becoming West's third consecutive album to do so.[187] The album was also nominated for Album of the Year at the ceremony, making West the only artist in Grammy history to receive a nomination for the award from all of their first three studio albums.[187][188] West claimed in an interview that he felt confident towards Graduation winning the award.[189] The album was considered the favorite to win Album of the Year[190][191][192][193][194], and its failure to win was considered by many publications to be a snub.[195][196][197][198][199] At the same ceremony, "Stronger" and "Good Life" were awarded Best Rap Solo Performance and Best Rap Song, respectively.[187] The latter also received a nomination for Best Rap/Sung Collaboration, while "Can't Tell Me Nothing" was nominated for Best Rap Song.[187] The six awards that the album led to West contending for at the 50th Annual Grammy Awards were among his total of eight nominations for the ceremony, making West the most nominated music artist of that show.[200] Graduation was a contender for numerous other industry awards.

Awards and nominations

Year	Organization	Award	Result	Ref.
2007	HipHopDX Awards	Album of the Year	Won	[201]
2008	American Music Awards	Favorite Rap/Hip-Hop Album	Won	[186]
	BET Hip Hop Awards	CD of the Year	Nominated	[202]
	ECHO Music Awards	Album of the Year Hip-Hop / R&B	Nominated	[203]
	Grammy Awards	Album of the Year	Nominated	[187]
		Best Rap Album	Won
	Fonogram Hungarian Music Awards	Best Foreign Rap or Hip-Hop Album of the Year	Won	[204]
	NAACP Image Awards	Outstanding Album	Nominated	[205]
	Swiss Music Awards	Best Album Urban International	Nominated	[206]

Legacy and influence

The sales battle [between Curtis and Graduation] serves as the final battle, the winner-take-all rumble between the present (thug rap) and the future (alternative rap) for rap supremacy. The fact that Graduation was both the bigger commercial and critical success was the death knell for thug rap, and correspondingly the Modernist movement of hip-hop. When it came down to it, an album with a track titled 'I'll Still Kill' couldn't compete with a song sampling a French dance duo's unknown hit. By choosing Kanye over 50 Cent in 2007, we were saying that we had gotten bored by gangsta rap and all of its cheap imitators; we were ready for something new, and Kanye thus became one of the pioneers of hip-hop's postmodern movement.

—Andrew Doscas, PopMatters (2014)[207]

The critical reception and commercial success of Graduation left a profound influence on both hip-hop culture and popular music.[208][209] West has earned praise for his ability to appeal to diverse music audiences such as indie-rock listeners and rave enthusiasts without alienating his core hip-hop audiences.[210] Collaborative tracks such as "Homecoming" signaled the diversification of mainstream hip-hop and its intertwining with the genres of alternative and indie-rock in subsequent years.[211][212] In addition, songs such as "Everything I Am" have been cited as "the best example of the soulful and introspective atmosphere that came to dominate the rap world, from Drake to The Weeknd".[213] Irish rock band U2 has imparted that touring with West on their Vertigo Tour in turn had a significant effect on their own music as well in regards to the band's twelfth studio album No Line on the Horizon (2009).[14] Lead singer Bono elaborated that West's rapping inspired him to utilize more percussive consonants for his songwriting and vocal performance.[14]

West's third studio album, particularly with its two hit singles "Stronger" and "Flashing Lights", has been attributed to not only encouraging other hip-hop artists to incorporate house and electronica elements into their music, but also for playing a role in the revival of disco and electro-infused club music in the late-2000s.[209][13] The number-one hit "Stronger" was leading part of a wave of synthesizer-driven music which combined danceable electro beats with an accessible pop format.[209] It was succeeded by the high chart placings and multi-platinum sales of singles by artists and bands ranging from "Just Dance" (2008) by singer Lady Gaga to "Right Round" (2009) by rapper Flo Rida.[214][13]

Graduation marked a musical progression towards synth-based production in regards to the art of crafting hip-hop beats.[212] The studio album demonstrated West's shift from sample-orientated hip-hop production and more towards digital synths and drum machines generated by Digital Audio Workstations (DAW).[212] While samples are present throughout the album, they were fewer in number and not nearly as prominent.[212] As hip hop producer Anthony Kilhoffer recalled to Billboard in 2017 for Graduation's 10th anniversary, "I think it was the first time having a heavy hand in the use of electronic music in hip-hop. Previous to that it was very R&B influenced, tracks like 'Stronger' and 'Flashing Lights' contained very electronic type of elements. This was way before EDM became mainstream, and marked the end of the jersey-wearing era in hip-hop".[215] Since Graduation's release, countless other record producers have followed suit in blurring the lines of conventional hip-hop with the incorporation of electronic production.[216] This synth-driven production approach has since been adopted by artists including Future, Young Chop, and Metro Boomin.[212]

Graduation has been credited with paving the way for rappers, such as Drake (left) and J. Cole (right), to find mainstream success without conforming to gangsta rap conventions.

The outcome of the highly publicized sales competition between 50 Cent's Curtis and West's Graduation has been accredited to the commercial decline of the gangsta rap that once dominated mainstream hip-hop.[208] Ben Detrick of XXL cites West defeat over 50 Cent in sales as being responsible for altering the direction of hip-hop and paving the way for new rappers who didn't follow the hardcore-gangster mold, writing, "If there was ever a watershed moment to indicate hip-hop's changing direction, it may have come when 50 Cent competed with Kanye in 2007 to see whose album would claim superior sales. Kanye led a wave of new artists—Kid Cudi, Wale, Lupe Fiasco, Kidz in the Hall, Drake—who lacked the interest or ability to create narratives about any past gunplay or drug-dealing".[217] The Michigan Daily columnist Adam Theisen asserts that West's win once and for all "prove[d] that rap music didn't have to conform to gangsta-rap conventions to be commercially successful".[218] Rolling Stone remarked that "While Kanye West's decisive triumph over 50 seems inevitable in retrospect, it's easy to forget how much of an underdog he was at the time. The College Dropout and Late Registration sold a combined 7 million copies in the U.S., but 50 Cent's own first two albums, Get Rich or Die Trying and The Massacre, sold nearly 14 million, almost exactly twice as much. West had the last laugh: Graduation sold nearly a million copies in one week, and rap became the playground of emotional heroes like Kid Cudi, Lupe Fiasco, Drake and J. Cole".[219]

Going further, Noah Callahan-Bever, chief content officer and editor-in-chief for Complex Media, marked September 11, 2007: "The Day Kanye West Killed Gangsta Rap".[220] In a retrospective, Lawrence Burney of Noisey expands on this notion by asserting that the event caused the more aggressive forms of rap music to undergo an evolution. He continued writing, "Gangsta rap, street music, and the like have yet to recover from that showdown, as only two albums of the sort have gone platinum in the 2010s—Kevin Gates' Islah and Meek Mill's Dreams Worth More Than Money—If anything, street music has also made a shift since Kanye began to peal back more layers of himself on Graduation; 50's whole get up was about being an indestructible, emotionless robot. Now, what connects fans to artists like Gates and Meek is that they aren't afraid to rhythmically cry about lost loves ones and the price of fame".[208] Likewise, Billboard wrote, "In 2007, Kanye West trumped 50 Cent in an epic sales battle, in which his opus Graduation trounced Curtis by several hundred thousand copies. Ye's emotive raps on Graduation, intertwined with his evolution on the production side, inspired a new wave of MCs to take notes. .. While gangsta rap still has a seat in the ever-expanding classroom of hip-hop, vulnerability and experimentation now serve as the leading candidates in creating your prototypical MC. Because of songs like 'I Wonder', 'Flashing Lights' and 'Stronger'", the hip-hop artists of today "cling on to Kanye's indomitable body of work like a go-to study guide".[221] The competition between 50 Cent and West, when the two released their studio albums on the same day, was penultimate in a series of articles that lists fifty key events in the history of R&B and hip-hop music, written by Rosie Swash of The Guardian. Swash wrote that it "highlighted the diverging facets of hip-hop in the last decade; the former was gangsta rap for the noughties, while West was the thinking man's alternative."[222]

Track listing

Credits adapted from liner notes.[26]

No.	Title	Writer(s)	Producer(s)	Length
1.	"Good Morning"	Kanye West Elton John Bernie Taupin	West	3:15
2.	"Champion"	West Walter Becker Donald Fagen	West Brian "All Day" Miller	2:47
3.	"Stronger"	West Thomas Bangalter Guy-Manuel de Homem-Christo Edwin Birdsong	West Mike Dean^[c]	5:12
4.	"I Wonder"	West Labi Siffre	West	4:03
5.	"Good Life" (featuring T-Pain)	West Faheem Najm Aldrin Davis Quincy Jones James Ingram	West Toomp Dean^[b]	3:27
6.	"Can't Tell Me Nothing"	West Davis	West Toomp	4:31
7.	"Barry Bonds" (featuring Lil Wayne)	West Dominick Lamb Dwayne Carter, Jr. Norman Landsberg John Ventura Leslie Weinstein Felix Pappalardi	Nottz West^[a]	3:24
8.	"Drunk and Hot Girls" (featuring Mos Def)	West Irmin Schmidt Michael Karoli Jaki Liebezeit Kenji Suzuki Holger Schuering	West Jon Brion^[b] Dean^[d]	5:13
9.	"Flashing Lights" (featuring Dwele)	West Eric Hudson	West Hudson	3:57
10.	"Everything I Am" (featuring scratches by DJ Premier)	West Christopher Martin Prince Phillip Mitchell George Clinton, Jr. Carlton Ridenhour Eric Sadler Hank Shocklee	West	3:47
11.	"The Glory"	West Dante Smith Laura Nyro Landsberg Pappalardi Ventura Weinstein	West Gee Roberson^[a] Patrick "Plain Pat" Reynolds^[a]	3:32
12.	"Homecoming" (featuring Chris Martin)	West Chris Martin Warryn Campbell	West Warryn "Baby Dubb" Campbell	3:23
13.	"Big Brother"	West Davis	Toomp	4:47

iTunes and Australia bonus track

No.	Title	Writer(s)	Producer(s)	Length
14.	"Good Night" (featuring Al Be Back and Mos Def)	West Albert Daniels Jason T. Miller Arthur Reid Ewart Beckford William Maragh	West Miller Al Be Back	3:07

Alternative Business Partners bonus track[223][224]

No.	Title	Writer(s)	Producer(s)	Length
14.	"Can't Tell Me Nothing" (remix featuring Young Jeezy)	West Davis	West Toomp	4:08

United Kingdom bonus tracks

No.	Title	Writer(s)	Producer(s)	Length
14.	"Good Night" (featuring Al Be Back and Mos Def)	West Daniels Miller Reid Beckford Maragh	West Miller Al Be Back	3:06
15.	"Stronger (A-Trak Remix)"	West Bangalter de Homem-Christo Birdsong	West	4:34

Japanese bonus tracks

No.	Title	Writer(s)	Producer(s)	Length
14.	"Good Night" (featuring Al Be Back and Mos Def)	West Daniels Miller Reid Beckford Maragh	West Miller Al Be Back	3:06
15.	"Bittersweet Poetry" (featuring John Mayer)	West John Mayer	West	4:01

France and Spotify bonus tracks[225][226]

No.	Title	Writer(s)	Producer(s)	Length
14.	"Stronger (A-Trak Remix)"	West Bangalter de Homem-Christo Birdsong	West	4:34
15.	"Stronger (AD Remix Main)"	West Bangalter de Homem-Christo Birdsong	West	4:48

Notes:[26]

• ^{^[a]} – co-production
• ^{^[b]} – additional production
• ^{^[c]} – extended outro co-production
• ^{^[d]} – bridge section

Sample credits:

• "Good Morning" contains samples from "Someone Saved My Life Tonight" performed by Elton John.
• "Champion" contains elements of "Kid Charlemagne" performed by Steely Dan.
• "Stronger" contains a sample of "Harder, Better, Faster, Stronger" performed by Daft Punk and master use of "Cola Bottle Baby" performed by Edwin Birdsong.
• "I Wonder" contains a sample from "My Song" performed by Labi Siffre.
• "Good Life" contains a sample of "P.Y.T. (Pretty Young Thing)" performed by Michael Jackson.
• "Barry Bonds" contains a sample of "Long Red" performed by Mountain.
• "Drunk and Hot Girls" contains elements of "Sing Swan Song" performed by Can.
• "Everything I Am" contains elements of "If We Can't Be Lovers" performed by Prince Phillip Mitchell and "Bring the Noise" performed by Public Enemy.
• "The Glory" contains elements of "Save the Country" performed by Laura Nyro and contains a sample of "Long Red" performed by Mountain.
• "Good Night" contains elements of "Nuff Man a Dead" performed by Super Cat and "Wake the Town" performed by U-Roy.
• "Bittersweet Poetry" interpolates "Bittersweet" performed by Chairmen of the Board.

Personnel

Credits are adapted from liner notes.[26]

• Kanye West – executive producer, primary artist (all tracks), producer (all tracks except 13)
• Lil Wayne – featured artist (track 7)
• Mos Def – featured artist (track 8), backing vocals (8, 11)
• T-Pain – featured artist (track 5)
• Dwele – featured artist (track 9)
• DJ Premier – featured artist, DJ scratching (track 10)
• Young Jeezy – rap vocals (track 6)
• Jay Z – additional rap vocals (track 1)
• Chris Martin – additional vocals (sung by) (track 12), piano (track 12)
• Connie Mitchell – additional vocals (tracks 1-2, 6, 9)
• Tanya Herron – additional vocals (track 8)
• John Legend – backing vocals (tracks 5, 11)
• Ne-Yo – backing vocals (track 5)
• Jalil Williams – additional backing vocals (track 11)
• Jehireh Williams – additional backing vocals (track 11)
• Daphne Chen – violin (tracks 5, 8)
• Eric Gorfain – violin (tracks 5, 8)
• Luigi Mazzocchi – violin (tracks 4, 9)
• Charles Parker – violin (tracks 4, 9)
• Igor Szwec – violin (tracks 4, 9)
• Emma Kummrow – violin (tracks 4, 9)
• Olga Konopelsky – violin (tracks 4, 9)
• Gloria Justen – violin (tracks 4, 9)
• Peter Nocella – viola (tracks 4, 9)
• Leah Katz – viola (tracks 5, 8)
• Alexandra Leem – viola (tracks 4, 9)
• Alma Fernandez – viola (track 5)
• Wired Strings – string section performed by (track 11)
• DJ Toomp - producer (tracks 5, 6, 13, 14)
• Mike Dean – keyboards (track 3, 7), music arranger (3), string arrangements (5, 8), recording engineer (3), guitar (3), mixing (5-8, 10, 12), producer (3, 5)
• Jon Brion – keyboards (track 4), percussion (12), record producer (8)
• Darryl Beaton – keyboards (track 6)
• Andy Chatterly – keyboards (tracks 1, 3, 8, 11)
• Chris Rob – keyboards (track 6)
• Richard Dodd – cello (tracks 5, 8)
• John Krovoza – cello (track 5)
• Jennie Lorenzo – cello (tracks 4, 9)
• Tim Resler – bass (tracks 4, 9)
• Vincent "Biggs" James – bass guitar (track 7)
• Omar Edwards – piano (tracks 4-5, 10), keyboards (3, 11) synthesizer (4-5, 8), synthesizer bass (8).
• Nottz Raw – producer (track 7), recording engineer (track 7)
• Tony Rey – recording engineer (track 6)
• Seiji Sekine – recording engineer (track 3)
• Greg Koller – recording engineer (tracks 4, 8, 12)
• Bruce Buechner – recording engineer (track 12)
• Andrew Dawson – recording engineer (all tracks), mixing (tracks 2, 4-6, 9, 12-13)
• Anthony Kilhoffer – recording engineer (tracks 1-6, 9-12), mixing (1, 11)
• Anthony Palazzole – assistant recording engineer (track 2, 5-10, 12)
• Andy Marcinkowski – assistant recording engineer (tracks 2, 5-10, 12-13)
• Richard Reitz – assistant recording engineer (tracks 3, 6)
• Jared Robbins – assistant recording engineer (track 3)
• Kengo Sakura – assistant recording engineer (track 3)
• Bram Tobey – assistant recording engineer (tracks 1-6, 8, 10-11)
• Matty Green – assistant recording engineer (tracks 1, 9, 11-12)
• Nate Hertweck – assistant recording engineer (tracks 1-6, 10-11)
• Jason Agel – assistant recording engineer (tracks 1-6, 8, 10-11)
• Keke Smith - production coordination for DJ Toomp (tracks 5, 6, 13, 14)
• Tracey Waples – marketing
• Al Brancch – marketing
• Takashi Murakami – artwork
• Carol Corless – package production
• Eric Hudson – all other instruments (track 9), producer (9)
• Warryn Campbell – producer (track 12)
• Larry Gold – string arrangements, string conductor (tracks 4, 9)
• Rosie Danvers – string arrangements (track 11)
• Sandra Campbell – project coordinator
• Sean Cooper – sound designer (track 12)
• Tommy D – string section producer (track 11)
• Vlado Meller – mastering
• Terese Joseph – A&R
• Kyambo Joshua – executive producer
• Manny Marroquin – mixing (track 3)
• Kazuhiro Mizuno – design
• Patrick "Plain Pat" Reynolds – A&R, producer (track 11)
• Timbaland – additional drum machine (track 5), additional music programming (3)

Charts

Weekly charts Chart (2007) Peak position Australian Albums (ARIA)[227] 2 Austrian Albums (Ö3 Austria)[227] 26 Belgian Albums (Ultratop Flanders)[227] 11 Belgian Albums (Ultratop Wallonia)[228] 49 Canadian Albums (Billboard)[229] 1 Danish Albums (Hitlisten)[227] 10 Dutch Albums (Album Top 100)[227] 11 European Albums (Billboard)[230] 3 Finnish Albums (Suomen virallinen lista)[227] 16 French Albums (SNEP)[227] 9 German Albums (Offizielle Top 100)[227] 10 Irish Albums (IRMA)[227] 2 Italian Albums (FIMI)[227] 33 Japanese Albums (Oricon)[231] 13 New Zealand Albums (RMNZ)[227] 2 Norwegian Albums (VG-lista)[227] 2 Portuguese Albums (AFP)[227] 30 Scottish Albums (OCC)[232] 3 Swedish Albums (Sverigetopplistan)[227] 6 Swiss Albums (Schweizer Hitparade)[227] 3 UK Albums (OCC)[227] 1 UK R&B Albums (OCC)[233] 1 US Billboard 200[234] 1 US Top R&B/Hip-Hop Albums (Billboard)[235] 1 Chart (2012) Peak position Hungarian Albums (MAHASZ)[236] 37 Chart (2017–19) Peak position Canadian Albums (Billboard)[154] 144 Lithuanian Albums (AGATA)[237] 94 US Billboard 200[238] 154 US Top Catalog Albums (Billboard)[239] 15

Year-end charts Chart (2007) Position Australian Albums (ARIA)[240] 88 European Albums (Billboard)[241] 75 Swiss Albums (Schweizer Hitparade)[242] 93 UK Albums (OCC)[243] 59 US Billboard 200[244] 12 US Top R&B/Hip-Hop Albums (Billboard)[245] 4 Worldwide Charts (IFPI)[246] 17 Chart (2008) Position Australian Urban Albums (ARIA)[247] 19 UK Albums (OCC)[248] 121 US Billboard 200[249] 79 US Top R&B/Hip-Hop Albums (Billboard)[250] 29 Chart (2016) Position US Billboard 200[251] 157 Chart (2017) Position Australian Urban Albums (ARIA)[252] 82 Chart (2018) Position Australian Urban Albums (ARIA)[253] 78 Chart (2019) Position Australian Urban Albums (ARIA)[254] 70

Certifications

[255][256][257][151]

Region	Certification	Certified units/sales
Australia (ARIA)[258]	Platinum	70,000^^
Canada (Music Canada)[153]	2× Platinum	160,000^^
Denmark (IFPI Denmark)[259]	Platinum	20,000
Ireland (IRMA)[260]	Platinum	15,000^^
Japan (RIAJ)[261]	Gold	100,000^^
New Zealand (RMNZ)[262]	Gold	7,500^^
Russia (NFPF)[263]	Gold	10,000^*
Switzerland (IFPI Switzerland)[264]	Gold	15,000^^
United Kingdom (BPI)[265]	Platinum	600,000^^
United States (RIAA)[266]	2× Platinum	2,700,000[148]
^*sales figures based on certification alone ^^shipments figures based on certification alone

See also

• 2007 in hip hop music
• Can't Tell Me Nothing (mixtape)
• The College Dropout
• Curtis (50 Cent album)
• Kanye West albums discography
• Kanye West production discography
• Late Registration
• List of best-selling albums in the United States of the Nielsen SoundScan era
• List of number-one albums of 2007 (Canada)
• List of UK Albums Chart number ones of the 2000s
• List of UK R&B Albums Chart number ones of 2007
• List of Billboard 200 number-one albums of 2007
• List of Billboard number-one rap albums of 2007
• List of Billboard number-one R&B albums of 2007

References

1. Patel, Joseph (2003-06-05). "Producer Kanye West's Debut LP Features Jay-Z, ODB, Mos Def". MTV Viacom. Archived from the original on 2009-05-04. Retrieved 2009-04-21.
2. Reid, Shaheem (August 29, 2007). "Kanye's Graduation: Inside The NYC Listening Party For West's So-Called 'Comeback'". MTV. Archived from the original on October 21, 2007. Retrieved May 27, 2019.
3. Breihan, Tom (2007-08-29). "Kanye West's Graduation: A Preview". The Village Voice. Village Voice, LLC. Archived from the original on 2012-10-23. Retrieved 2007-09-22.
4. Laws, Angel (2007-10-05). "Exclusive Interview W/ Kanye West". Concrete Loop. concreteloop.com. Archived from the original on 2007-10-06. Retrieved 2007-10-05.
5. Japie, Stoppelenburg (2007-09-30). "Music Reviews – Kanye West: Graduation". No Ripcord. No Ripcord. Archived from the original on 2009-01-30. Retrieved 2008-04-12.
6. Park, Adam (2007-01-07). "Kanye West "God Just Brings Collaborations Together"". Clash. Clashmusic.com. Archived from the original on 2009-01-18. Retrieved 2008-04-13.
7. "Kanye West Interviewed". Clash. Clashmusic.com. 2008-04-12. Archived from the original on 2009-01-08. Retrieved 2008-04-13.
8. Cowie, Del (October 2007). "Recently Reviewed". Exclaim!. Archived from the original on 2008-01-05. Retrieved 2008-10-13.
9. Greene, Jayson (2007-09-10). "Kanye West Graduation – Music Review". Stylus Magazine. stylusmagazine.com. Archived from the original on 2007-09-29. Retrieved 2007-09-10.
10. Powers, Ann. 2007-09-10. Hip-hop's Man of Two Minds Archived 2014-10-14 at the Wayback Machine. Los Angeles Times. Retrieved on 2009-10-06.
11. Power, Ed (2007-03-12). "Kanye Goes Where Other Rappers Dare Not Tread". Irish Independent. Independent News & Media. Archived from the original on 2015-01-09. Retrieved 2014-03-23.
12. Newsweek Staff (2007-09-02). "Fall Preview: Music". Newsweek. Newsweek LLC. Archived from the original on 2015-01-09. Retrieved 2007-09-06.
13. Dugan, John (2008-05-14). "New Mutants". Time Out Chicago. Time Out Chicago Partners. Archived from the original on 2013-10-22. Retrieved 2008-11-21.
14. Calloway, Sway; Vena, Jocelyn (2009-03-10). "U2 Take Cues From Kanye West, Jay-Z". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2009-03-12. Retrieved 2009-03-10.
15. Serwer, Jesse (2007-08-13). "Kanye West". Time Out New York. Time Out Group Limited. Archived from the original on 2013-10-19. Retrieved 2010-07-09.
16. Denslow, Michael (2010-11-15). "Album Review: Kanye West – My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy". Consequence of Sound. Consequence of Sound. Archived from the original on 2013-05-14. Retrieved 2013-06-02.
17. Danton, Eric (2007-08-11). "Man With a Message". The Sydney Morning Herald. Fairfax Media. Archived from the original on 2013-12-04. Retrieved 2012-05-20.
18. Kathwadia, Rajveer (2007-08-15). "Online Review: Kanye West – Graduation". RWD Magazine. RWD Magazine. Archived from the original on 2007-08-21. Retrieved 2007-08-15.
19. Rizov, Vadim (2007-11-01). ""Indie 500": Kanye West, Swizz Beatz, Joy Division and Pale Young Gentlemen". Slant Magazine. Slant Magazine. Archived from the original on 2013-10-04. Retrieved 2013-04-06.
20. MTV News Staff Report (2005-09-23). "For The Record: Quick News On Kanye West, R. Kelly, Britney Spears, Mariah Carey, Spoon, Elvis Costello & More". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2008-07-24. Retrieved 2007-05-02.
21. Scaggs, Austin (2007-09-20). "Kanye West: A Genius In Praise of Himself". Rolling Stone. Jann Wenner. Archived from the original on 2013-02-02. Retrieved 2007-09-26.
22. Crosley, Hillary (2007-08-06). "'Graduation' Day Nears for Kanye West". Reuters. Archived from the original on 2013-11-03. Retrieved 2013-02-23.
23. Rabin, Nathan (September 11, 2007). "Kanye West: Graduation". The A.V. Club. Chicago. Archived from the original on May 22, 2013. Retrieved April 8, 2013.
24. Reid, Shaheem (2007-08-14). "Kanye West And Lil Wayne Counting On 'Barry Bonds' For A Hit Single". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2007-12-29. Retrieved 2007-08-14.
25. Barshad, Amos (2010-12-10). "Photos: Kanye West's Career Highs — and Lows 19 of 24". Rolling Stone. Jann Wenner. Archived from the original on 2013-06-13. Retrieved 2013-03-04.
26. Graduation (Media notes). Kanye West. Roc-A-Fella Records. 2007.CS1 maint: others (link)
27. Nui Te Koha (2008-08-03). "Sneaky Sound System Sneaking Their Way to the Top". Herald Sun. Archived from the original on 2014-05-25. Retrieved 2008-11-13.
28. Confidential, Sydney (2007-03-10). "Connie Hits Hip-hop". The Daily Telegraph. London: Telegraph Media Group Limited. Archived from the original on 2011-08-11. Retrieved 2008-08-06.
29. Crosley, Hillary (2007-01-19). "Kanye Rolling With Chris Martin On New Album". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Archived from the original on 2013-06-28. Retrieved 2007-01-19.
30. Pattison, Louis (September 13, 2007). "Kanye West: Graduation". NME. Archived from the original on October 20, 2007. Retrieved September 13, 2007.
31. Lynch, Joe (2013-04-22). "10 Things We Learned From Kanye West's Pre-Fame Mixtape". Fuse. Fuse Networks, LLC. Archived from the original on 2013-04-25. Retrieved 2013-04-22.
32. Benbow, Julian (2007-09-11). "After the Hip-hop Hype". The Boston Globe. Globe Newspaper Company. Archived from the original on 2007-09-20. Retrieved 2007-09-11.
33. Ahmed, Insanul (September 21, 2011). "Kanye West × The Heavy Hitters, Get Well Soon (2003) – Clinton Sparks' 30 Favorite Mixtapes". Complex. Archived from the original on January 19, 2013. Retrieved December 9, 2012.
34. Dharmic X (2013-11-21). "Kanye West: "I Will Never Be on The Same Level Rap-Wise as Jay Z"". Complex. Complex Media, LLC. Archived from the original on 2015-10-04. Retrieved 2015-09-19.
35. Caramanica, Jon (2007-08-26). "The Education of Kanye West". The New York Times. The New York Times Company. Archived from the original on 2013-11-14. Retrieved 2007-09-17.
36. Vozick-Levinson, Simon (2007-09-20). "Jay-Z's Brotherly Love". Entertainment Weekly. Entertainment Weekly Inc. Archived from the original on 2007-10-12. Retrieved 2007-09-22.
37. Reid, Shaheem (2007-06-20). "Kanye West's 'Stronger' Video: Japanese Motorcycle Gangs, Mad Scientists — And Cassie". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2012-10-24. Retrieved 2007-08-27.
38. Luke, Bainbridge (2007-08-11). "It's Kanye's World". The Guardian. Guardian News and Media Limited. Archived from the original on 2013-10-05. Retrieved 2008-03-12.
39. Paul Tingen (December 2007). "Secrets of the Mix Engineers: Manny Marroquin". Sound on Sound. SOS Publications Group. Archived from the original on 2011-09-04. Retrieved 2010-07-20.
40. Reid, Shaheem (2007-08-21). "Kanye West Thanks 50 Cent for Much-Hyped Rivalry: 'We Push Each Other'". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2012-02-22. Retrieved 2013-02-06.
41. Scaggs, Austin (2007-09-20). "Kanye West: A Genius In Praise of Himself". Rolling Stone. Jann Wenner. Archived from the original on 2009-03-09. Retrieved 2007-09-26.
42. Heaton, Dave. Review: Graduation Archived 2008-12-16 at the Wayback Machine. PopMatters. Retrieved on 2009-10-06.
43. Breihan, Tom (2007-09-11). "Ten Favorite Moments on Kanye West's Graduation". The Village Voice. Village Voice, LLC. Archived from the original on 2013-10-04. Retrieved 2007-09-11.
44. Caramanica, Jon (2007-08-26). "The Education of Kanye West". The New York Times. The New York Times Company. Archived from the original on 2013-11-14. Retrieved 2007-09-17.
45. Powers, Ann (September 10, 2007). "Hip-hop's Man of Two Minds". Los Angeles Times. Archived from the original on October 17, 2012. Retrieved October 6, 2009.
46. Nishimoto, Dan (2008-01-08). "Best Albums of 2007: Picks 10 to 1". Prefixmag. Prefix. Archived from the original on 2013-10-31. Retrieved 2013-07-04.
47. Crosely, Hillary (2007-09-19). "Jay-Z, L.A. Reid Weigh in On Kanye/50 Sales Battle". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Archived from the original on 2013-07-04. Retrieved 2007-09-19.
48. Bland, Bridget; Reid, Shaheem; Richard, Yasmine (2007-05-11). "Kanye West Says He's 'Ready To Take Over The World Once Again'". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2007-06-01. Retrieved 2007-06-02.
49. Frehsee, Nicole (2007-06-08). "Common Preps New Album "Finding Forever" With Help From Kanye, Lily Allen". Rolling Stone. Jann Wenner. Archived from the original on 2013-11-15. Retrieved 2007-06-29.
50. Reid, Shaheem (2006-05-23). "Common, Kanye Going For 'Glory' On Raw, Soulful New Songs". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2007-04-16. Retrieved 2007-05-14.
51. Richards, Jason (2007-09-20). "How Not To Be Common". Now. Now Communications. Archived from the original on 2013-10-04. Retrieved 2013-06-26.
52. Crosley, Hillary (2010-11-30). "DJ Premier Talks Kanye West's 'Mama's Boyfriend'". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2013-10-04. Retrieved 2013-02-24.
53. Conan, Milne (2008-03-17). "A-Trak Links With Nike, Jay-Z". URB. NativeSon Media, Inc. Archived from the original on 2013-10-04. Retrieved 2009-05-03.
54. Ryon, Sean (2012-01-10). "Tony Williams Recalls Kanye West Showing Jay-Z "Big Brother"". HipHopDX. Cheri Media Group. Archived from the original on 2012-02-21. Retrieved 2012-02-23.
55. Crosley, Hillary (2007-09-12). "50 Cent, Kanye West Continue Rivalry On 106 & Park". Billboard. Nielsen Business Media, Inc. Archived from the original on 2013-06-28. Retrieved 2007-09-12.
56. Cohen, Jonathan (2005-04-22). "West Shows Off 'Diamonds' With Jay-Z". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Archived from the original on 2013-07-23. Retrieved 2006-06-17.
57. "Kanye West and John Mayer Recording Bittersweet". YouTube. 2006-04-09. Archived from the original on 2007-10-16. Retrieved 2008-02-05.
58. Moss, Cory (2004-11-18). "Kanye West And John Mayer Collaborate But Won't Elaborate". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2007-08-17. Retrieved 2007-08-25.
59. Mcalley, John (2007-12-20). "Entertainer of the Year: Kanye West". Spin. Spin Media, LLC. Archived from the original on 2008-03-10. Retrieved 2008-01-14.
60. S., Nathan (2015-02-18). "Is Kanye West's "Graduation" Album a Masterpiece?". DJBooth.net. The DJ Booth LLC. Archived from the original on 2015-05-16. Retrieved 2015-05-08.
61. Comer, Sean (2013-08-13). "Give Life Back To Music 08.19.13: Kanye West – Graduation". 411MANIA. 411mania.com, LLC. Archived from the original on 2016-08-17. Retrieved 2015-01-24.
62. S., Nathan (2015-02-18). "Is Kanye West's Graduation Album a Masterpiece?". DJBooth.net. The DJ Booth LLC. Archived from the original on 2015-05-16. Retrieved 2015-05-08.
63. Pytlik, Mark (2007-09-11). "Kanye West: Graduation". Pitchfork. Archived from the original on 2009-09-29. Retrieved 2009-10-06.
64. Greg Kot (2007-08-31). 'Graduation' day arrives: Kanye West exploits his growing pains Archived 2009-05-14 at the Wayback Machine. Chicago Tribune. Accessed 2007-10-01.
65. Kellman, Andy. "Graduation – Kanye West". AllMusic. Archived from the original on 2019-03-26. Retrieved 2009-10-16.
66. "Which Kanye is Apex Kanye?". Medium. August 24, 2016. Retrieved November 26, 2019.
67. Botte, Joshua (March 23, 2018). "Are Kanye West And Michael Scott From 'The Office' The Same Person? Yes". NPR. Archived from the original on November 20, 2019. Retrieved November 26, 2019.
68. "Critics Reviews for The Life of Pablo". Metacritic. Archived from the original on June 7, 2019. Retrieved November 26, 2019.
69. "The Definitive Kanye West Album Rankings: A Roundtable". Noisey. December 4, 2015. Retrieved November 25, 2019.
70. Willis, Jay (August 30, 2017). "Late Registration Was the Last Great Album by the Old Kanye". GQ. Archived from the original on April 10, 2019. Retrieved November 25, 2019.
71. Kornhaber, Spencer (February 18, 2016). "The Life of Pablo and the Terror of Monogamy". The Atlantic. Archived from the original on November 22, 2018. Retrieved November 26, 2019.
72. Lynskey, Dorian (September 7, 2007). "Kanye West, Graduation". The Guardian. London. Archived from the original on October 5, 2014. Retrieved September 10, 2007.
73. Jones, Kevin (December 2007). "Beats & Rhymes: Year in Review 2007". Exclaim!. Ian Danzig. Archived from the original on 2014-01-28. Retrieved 2013-09-06.
74. Johnson, Brett (2007-09-10). "Review: New CDs From 50 Cent, Kanye West". The Washington Post. The Washington Post Company. Archived from the original on 2012-11-10. Retrieved 2007-09-10.
75. "Graduation – Kanye West". The Village Voice. Pop Rock Nation. September 2007. Archived from the original on 2016-06-15. Retrieved 2014-06-04.
76. Manne, Jesse (2008-03-05). "Album Review Kanye West Graduation". Prefixmag. Prefix. Archived from the original on 2013-10-04. Retrieved 2013-07-04.
77. Tyrangiel, Josh (2007-12-06). "Top 10 Albums". Time. Time, Inc. Archived from the original on 2007-12-12. Retrieved 2007-12-09.
78. Kim, Serena (2005-09-12). "Kanye West – Late Registration (Roc-A-Fella)". Vibe. Vibe Media Group, LLC. Archived from the original on 2006-10-19. Retrieved 2007-04-12.
79. Drumming, Neil (September 7, 2007). "Graduation". Entertainment Weekly. Archived from the original on February 15, 2009. Retrieved October 6, 2009.
80. Pareles, Jon. Topics/People/L/Lil Wayne Review: Graduation Archived 2017-09-12 at the Wayback Machine. The New York Times. Retrieved on 2009-10-06.
81. Brackett, Nathan (September 4, 2007). "Graduation". Rolling Stone. Archived from the original on June 14, 2012. Retrieved October 6, 2009.
82. D., Spence (2007-09-12). "Kanye West - Graduation Review". IGN. IGN Entertainment, Inc. Archived from the original on 2013-10-08. Retrieved 2013-06-17.
83. Breihan, Tom (2007-06-20). "Kanye West Premiers the "Stronger" Video". The Village Voice. Village Voice, LLC. Archived from the original on 2013-10-04. Retrieved 2007-09-10.
84. Kot, Greg (2007-08-25). "The Many Moods of Kanye West Prevail as He Unveils New Songs at Charity Concert". The Chicago Tribune. The Chicago Tribune. Archived from the original on 2008-06-17. Retrieved 2008-08-14.
85. Henderson, Eric. Review: Graduation Archived 2010-06-06 at the Wayback Machine. Slant Magazine. Retrieved on 2010-06-13.
86. "Pop CDs of the Year: When the Bard of Wimbledon Triumphed". The Daily Telegraph. London: Telegraph Media Group Limited. 2007-12-22. Archived from the original on 2009-02-05. Retrieved 2008-08-06.
87. Mcalley, John (2007-12-20). "Entertainer of the Year: Kanye West". Spin. Spin Media, LLC. Archived from the original on 2008-03-05. Retrieved 2008-01-14.
88. Crosley, Hillary. Billboard - The International Newsweekly of Music, Video and Home Entertainment119.32(Aug 11, 2007): 22-24.
89. "Kanye features Lil' Wayne on new album track". Paste Magazine. Paste Media Group. 2007-08-15. Archived from the original on 2008-06-08. Retrieved 2008-04-19.
90. Brown, Jake (2006). Kanye West in the Studio: Beats Down! Money Up! (2000-2006). Colossus Books. p. 557. ISBN 0-9767735-6-2.
91. Glover, Scott (2008-11-20). "Doctor Talks About Donda West's Death". Los Angeles Times. Archived from the original on 2008-12-04. Retrieved 2008-11-23.
92. McGee, Tiffany. "Kanye West's Fiancée 'Sad' Over Breakup". People. Archived from the original on 2008-12-07. Retrieved 2008-11-23.
93. Dombal, Ryan (2009-08-19). "The Top 500 Tracks of the 2000s: 100-51". Pitchfork. Archived from the original on 2009-08-22. Retrieved 2009-08-19.
94. Martin, Francesca (2007-08-01). "Kanye West Mixes Manga and Music With the 'Warhol of Japan'". The Guardian. London: Guardian News and Media Limited. Archived from the original on 2013-12-04. Retrieved 2007-09-05.
95. Gopnik, Blakel (2008-05-04). "Toying With Catastrophe". The Washington Post. The Washington Post Company. Archived from the original on 2012-11-08. Retrieved 2008-05-04.
96. Vogel, Carol (2008-04-02). "Watch Out, Warhol, Here's Japanese Shock Pop". The New York Times. The New York Times Company. Archived from the original on 2015-01-10. Retrieved 2008-08-30.
97. Kato, Akiko; Wilson, Wayne. "カニエ・ウェストがカイカイキキにやってきた！Kanye West visits the studio!" (in Japanese). Kaikai Kiki. Archived from the original on 2009-04-09. Retrieved 2008-11-21.
98. Barthel, Mike (2010-10-15). "Understanding Kanye: Sweet, Sweet Robot Fantasy, Baby". The Awl. David Cho. Archived from the original on 2010-11-19. Retrieved 2010-10-15.
99. Lumpkin, Bernard; Stolz, Kim (2008-04-04). "Kanye West Album-Cover Artist Takashi Murakami Talks About Working With 'Ye, At His NYC Exhibit Opening". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2008-04-08. Retrieved 2008-04-04.
100. Vozick-Levinson, Simon (2007-09-28). "Kanye's Work of (CD) Art". Entertainment Weekly. Entertainment Weekly. Archived from the original on 2007-10-18. Retrieved 2007-09-30.
101. Heffernan, Virginia (2008-08-08). "Kanye on Keyboards". The New York Times. The New York Times Company. Archived from the original on 2014-03-06. Retrieved 2009-03-17.
102. Dukes, Rahman; Reid, Shaheem; Richard, Yasmine (2007-05-21). "Mixtape Monday: Kanye West Glows In The Dark; Pharrell Brings The B-More Beats". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2007-05-23. Retrieved 2007-05-22.
103. "Weekend Rock List: Best Album Covers of 2007". Rolling Stone. Jann Wenner. 2007-12-28. Archived from the original on 2014-04-09. Retrieved 2009-03-26.
104. Lu Stout, Kristie (2013-01-11). "Interview with Japanese Artist Takashi Murakam". CNN. Archived from the original on 2018-02-09. Retrieved 2019-09-29.
105. Reid, Shaheem (2005-08-05). "'Can He Do It Again?' – Kanye West Says New LP Backs Up His Bragging". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2009-10-02. Retrieved 2013-02-23.
106. "Kanye West Premiers Rap From New Album". NME. IPC Media. 2007-03-28. Archived from the original on 2013-12-19. Retrieved 2013-04-08.
107. MTV News staff (2007-05-15). "Kanye Releases 'Nothing,' Plus Mary J., Phil Spector, Bono, Lindsay, Christina, Rihanna & More". MTV. MTV Networks. Archived from the original on 2007-05-18. Retrieved 2007-05-15.
108. Reid, Shaheem; Richard, Yasmine (2007-05-30). "Kanye West Says MTV Movie Awards Snubbed Mel Gibson's Apocalypto". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2007-06-02. Retrieved 2007-05-31.
109. Reid, Shaheem; Rodriguez, Jayson (2007-06-04). "Mixtape Monday: 50 Didn't Bite Jim Jones; Kanye Keeps GOOD Music Intact". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2007-06-06. Retrieved 2007-06-04.
110. MTV News staff (2007-05-31). "Kanye West Changes Graduation Date; Plus 50 Cent, Jessica Alba, Nicole Richie, Lindsay Lohan & More, In For the Record". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2007-06-02. Retrieved 2007-06-02.
111. Reid, Shaheem (2007-07-19). "Kanye West And 50 Cent Set For Epic Battle: Both Releasing Albums On September 11". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2007-08-12. Retrieved 2007-07-20.
112. "Kanye West Declines Debate With 50 Cent, Calls It 'Stupid'". Baller Status. 2007-08-08. Archived from the original on 2008-04-09. Retrieved 2008-04-24.
113. Reid, Shaheem (2007-07-30). "Jay-Z Calls Kanye West And 50 Cent's LP Face-Off 'A Fantastic Thing For Hip-Hop'". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2007-08-20. Retrieved 2007-07-31.
114. Reid, Shaheem. 50 Cent Or Kanye West, Who Will Win? Nas, Timbaland, More Share Their Predictions Archived 2010-11-23 at the Wayback Machine. MTV. Viacom Retrieved on 2009-12-24.
115. Rodriguez, Jayson (2007-09-19). "Kanye West Pounds 50 Cent in First Week Of Album Showdown". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2007-10-02. Retrieved 2007-09-19.
116. Reid, Shaheem (2007-07-23). "Kanye West Says He's Ready To Pit His Album Against 50 Cent's: 'We Ain't Moving'". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2007-08-05. Retrieved 2007-07-23.
117. Jones, Steve. 2007-09-09. 50 Cent isn't worried: He's rich with confidence Archived 2009-02-09 at the Wayback Machine. USA Today. Retrieved on 2009-12-25.
118. Rock & Roll: Kanye vs. 50 Cent. Serpick, Evan. Rolling Stone (Sep 6, 2007): 26.
119. MTV News staff (2007-08-10). "50 Cent Says He'll Quit If Kanye West Outdoes Him; Plus Lily Allen, D'Angelo, Beastie Boys, Norah Jones & More, In for the Record". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2007-08-19. Retrieved 2007-08-11.
120. Jayson Rodriguez, with reporting by Tim Kash (2007-08-15). 50 Cent Explains Last Week's Blowup, Says 'I Will Be #1 on September 11' Archived 2007-08-19 at the Wayback Machine. MTV. Viacom Accessed 2007-09-15.
121. Reid, Shaheem (2007-08-21). "Kanye West Thanks 50 Cent for Much-Hyped Rivalry: 'We Push Each Other'". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2011-06-12. Retrieved 2007-09-20.
122. eskay (18 August 2007). "Video: Kanye Previews Champion & Big Brother". Nah Right. Archived from the original on 22 August 2007. Retrieved 18 August 2007.
123. Gittins, Ian (2007-08-20). "V Festival – Chelmsford and Stafford". The Guardian. Guardian News and Media Limited. Archived from the original on 2013-12-04. Retrieved 2013-04-08.
124. "Kanye West Plays Tribute to Amy Winehouse at V Festival". NME. IPC Media. 2007-08-18. Archived from the original on 2007-11-18. Retrieved 2007-08-18.
125. Los Angeles staff (2007-08-21). "Kanye West Gives Shout Out to Jay-Z During Intimate Gig". NME. IPC Media. Archived from the original on 2008-09-26. Retrieved 2007-08-21.
126. Urdang, Ben (2007-07-20). "Kanye West @ Westminster Central Hall, London". musicOMH. OMH. Archived from the original on 2013-07-03. Retrieved 2007-07-22.
127. Reid, Shaheem (2007-07-23). "Jay-Z, Kanye West, 50 Cent, Diddy, T.I., Ciara, Swizz Beatz Make Hip-Hop History at NYC Show". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2007-08-25. Retrieved 2007-07-23.
128. Cohen, Jonathan (2007-07-17). "Billboard Bits: Kanye West, John Legend, Starbucks". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Archived from the original on 2013-07-30. Retrieved 2013-02-27.
129. Crosley, Hillary (2007-08-30). "West's 'Graduation' Leaked". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Archived from the original on 2013-07-04. Retrieved 2013-02-05.
130. "Thoughts On Who Will Sell More Albums On September 11?". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. 2007-09-07. Archived from the original on 2014-07-09. Retrieved 2007-09-09.
131. Christman, Ed (2007-09-11). "Early Sales Projections Put Kanye Ahead Of 50, Chesney". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Archived from the original on 2013-07-04. Retrieved 2007-09-11.
132. "50 Cent & Kanye West Go Head To Head On Who Has The Best Album". YouTube. Retrieved 2 March 2020.
133. "BET 106 & Park with Kanye West And 50 Cent". Getty Images. Archived from the original on 2 March 2020. Retrieved 2 March 2020.
134. "BET's '106 & Park' Scores Impressive Ratings for Tuesday's 'Clash of the Titans' Featuring 50 Cent and Kanye West". BET Pressroom. 13 September 2007. Archived from the original on 2 March 2020. Retrieved 2 March 2020.
135. Mayfield, Geoff (2007-09-12). "Kanye Well Ahead Of 50 Cent in First-Day Sales Race". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Archived from the original on 2013-07-04. Retrieved 2007-09-12.
136. Adaso, Henry. Graduation Blows Curtis Out of the Water Archived 2011-08-07 at the Wayback Machine. About.com. Retrieved on 2009-12-25.
137. Sexton, Paul (2007-09-17). "Kanye Defeats 50 Cent On U.K. Album Chart". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Archived from the original on 2013-05-23. Retrieved 2007-09-18.
138. "Albums : Top 100 – 2007-08-16 (For the Week Ending 20 September 2007)". Canoe – Jam! Music. Canoe, Inc. 2007. Archived from the original on 2004-12-26. Retrieved 2007-09-21.
139. Cohen, Jonathan (2007-09-20). "Kanye Caps Banner Week With Hot 100 Chart-Topper". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Archived from the original on 2013-06-28. Retrieved 2007-09-28.
140. Harris, Chris (2007-09-19). "Kanye West, 50 Cent Leave Competition in the Dust On Albums Chart". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2007-10-14. Retrieved 2007-09-19.
141. Mayfield, Geoff (2007-09-18). "Kanye Crushes 50 Cent in Huge Album Sales Week". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Archived from the original on 2013-05-24. Retrieved 2007-09-19.
142. Rodriguez, Jayson (2007-09-21). "Kanye West's Sales Triumph, By The Numbers: He Thumped 50 Cent In Almost Every Market". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2007-10-02. Retrieved 2007-09-21.
143. Crosley, Hillary (2007-09-19). "Jay-Z, L.A. Reid Weigh in On Kanye/50 Sales Battle". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Archived from the original on 2013-07-04. Retrieved 2007-09-19.
144. Hasty, Katie (2007-09-26). "Reba Outmuscles Kanye, 50 To Score First No. 1". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Archived from the original on 2013-06-28. Retrieved 2007-09-28.
145. Hasty, Katie (2007-10-03). "Rascal Flatts Races To No. 1 In Debut-Heavy Week". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Archived from the original on 2013-07-23. Retrieved 2007-10-13.
146. Montgomery, James (2007-12-11). "Fergie, Maroon 5, Amy Winehouse Are iTunes' Most-Downloaded Artists Of 2007". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2010-04-26. Retrieved 2007-12-18.
147. "RIAA – Gold & Platinum". Recording Industry Association of America (Prometheus Global Media). 2008-12-12. Archived from the original on 2013-07-28. Retrieved 2008-12-12.
148. Cibola, Marco (2013-06-14). "Kanye West: How the Rapper Grew From 'Dropout' to 'Yeezus'". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Archived from the original on 2013-06-17. Retrieved 2013-06-14.
149. "Top 10 Rap Albums That Sold The Most in Their First Week". SA Hip Hop. 2019-01-07. Archived from the original on 2019-12-09. Retrieved 2019-12-09.
150. "Official Albums Chart Top 100". Official Charts Company. Archived from the original on February 20, 2018. Retrieved January 10, 2013.
151. "Certified Awards Search". British Recorded Music Industry. 2008-02-08. Archived from the original on 2011-07-04. Retrieved 2008-07-12.
152. White, Jack (2018-05-04). "The UK's Official Top 40 biggest rap albums of the Millennium revealed". Official Charts Company. Archived from the original on 2018-09-06. Retrieved 2019-11-30.
153. "Canadian album certifications – Kanye West – Graduation". Music Canada. Retrieved 2019-10-19.
154. "Jesus Is King On This Week's Albums Chart". FYIMusicNews. 2019-11-03. Archived from the original on 2019-11-04. Retrieved 2019-11-29.
155. "Reviews for Graduation by Kanye West". Metacritic. Archived from the original on July 17, 2012. Retrieved October 1, 2007.
156. Christgau, Robert (October 2007). "Consumer Guide". MSN Music. Archived from the original on November 4, 2008. Retrieved October 6, 2009.
157. Aaron, Charles (November 2007). "Doo Wah Diddy". Spin. 23 (11): 114. Archived from the original on May 27, 2016. Retrieved September 30, 2015.
158. Tate, Greg. Review: Graduation Archived 2009-05-16 at the Wayback Machine. The Village Voice. Retrieved on 2009-10-06.
159. Pitchfork staff (2009-08-30). "The Top 200 Albums of the 2000s: 100-51". Pitchfork. Archived from the original on 2009-10-06. Retrieved 2007-10-01.
160. "2. Kanye West Graduation". Complex. Complex Media, LLC. 2009-09-09. Archived from the original on 2009-09-12. Retrieved 2009-09-09.
161. "100 Best Albums of the 2000s". Rolling Stone. 2011-07-18. Archived from the original on 2018-11-15. Retrieved 2019-01-04.
162. "The Decade-End Readers' Poll". Rolling Stone. 8 December 2009. Archived from the original on 14 December 2019. Retrieved 29 December 2019.
163. "NME The 500 Greatest Albums of All Time : October 2013". Rocklistmusic. Archived from the original on 1 March 2017. Retrieved 1 November 2019.
164. "The 100 Best Albums of the Complex Decade". Complex. 2 April 2012. Archived from the original on 1 November 2019. Retrieved 1 November 2019.
165. "Best of 2007". Metacritic. Archived from the original on 2008-03-05. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
166. "Radiohead Wins Billboard Critics' Poll in Landslide". Billboard. 2007-12-17. Archived from the original on 2017-10-25. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
167. James Sweeney (2007-12-30). "From Amy Winehouse to The Shins: The best albums of 2007". Cleveland. Archived from the original on 2019-01-01. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
168. "Top 50 Albums of 2007". Consequence of Sound. 2017-01-23. Archived from the original on 2017-01-26. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
169. "Readers' Picks". EW. 2007-12-21. Archived from the original on 2009-01-23. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
170. "Idolator Pop 07: Albums". Idolator. 2008-03-07. Archived from the original on 2008-03-05. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
171. Andrew Womack (2007-12-19). "The Top 10 Albums of 2007". The Morning News. Archived from the original on 2018-09-01. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
172. "Top Music Albums of 2007". My List Pad. 2014-05-03. Archived from the original on 2019-01-01. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
173. Don Yates (2007-12-24). "Best Hip-Hop of 2007 Changes the Game". NPR. Archived from the original on 2018-12-29. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
174. "The 100 Best Albums of 2007". Paste Magazine. 2007-11-26. Archived from the original on 2018-07-23. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
175. "The 2007 Pazz & Jop Critics Poll". Robert Christgau. Archived from the original on 2018-07-23. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
176. "The 50 Best Albums of 2007". Pitchfork. 2007-12-18. Archived from the original on 2018-04-01. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
177. "The Best Albums of 2007". PopMatters. 2007-12-20. Archived from the original on 2020-05-11. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
178. "The Top 50 Albums of 2007". Rolling Stone. 2007-12-17. Archived from the original on 2007-12-21. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
179. "The 40 Best Albums of 2007". Spin. 31 December 2007. Archived from the original on 4 April 2017. Retrieved 1 March 2019.
180. "Stylus Magazine closes with some 2007 lists". Brooklyn Vegan. 2007-10-31. Archived from the original on 2018-07-13. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
181. Henry Adaso (2007-11-26). "Top 27 Rap Albums of 2007". Thought Co. Archived from the original on 2018-12-15. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
182. Josh Tyrangiel (2007-12-09). "Top 10 Albums of 2007". Time. Archived from the original on 2019-01-01. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
183. "The Best Albums of 2007". Time Out. 2007-12-27. Archived from the original on 2013-10-04. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
184. Jeff Terich (12 December 2007). "Top 10 Hip-hop Albums of 2007". Treblezine. Archived from the original on 20 March 2018. Retrieved 1 January 2019.
185. "The best, the worst, the weirdest". USA Today. 2003-12-23. Archived from the original on 2008-06-07. Retrieved 2019-01-01.
186. Daniel Kreps (2008-11-24). "Kanye West, Chris Brown Win Big at American Music Awards". Rolling Stone. Archived from the original on 2017-12-10. Retrieved 2017-12-10.
187. "Kanye West | Artist". Grammy. Archived from the original on 2018-12-08. Retrieved 2020-04-09.
188. Grein, Paul (2020-03-31). "Post Malone, The Weeknd & More Early Front-Runners for Album of the Year at the 2021 Grammys". Billboard. Archived from the original on 2020-04-03. Retrieved 2020-04-09.
189. Reid, Shaheem (2008-02-01). "Kanye West: Will The Grammys Reward His Confidence In Graduation?". MTV. Viacom. Archived from the original on 2016-01-20. Retrieved 2020-04-09.
190. Scott Tady (8 February 2008). "Grammy preview and predictions". Times Online. Archived from the original on 12 April 2020.
191. Keith Caulfield (14 December 2007). "Ask Billboard". Billboard. Archived from the original on 28 June 2008.
192. "2008 Grammy Awards: Winner Predictions". Slant Magazine. 26 January 2008. Archived from the original on 23 February 2020.
193. Erik Pedersen (6 February 2008). "Grammy Predix: Album of the Year". E Online. Archived from the original on 23 February 2020.
194. Brian Orloff (10 February 2008). "All Eyes on Kanye West, Amy Winehouse at Grammys". People. Archived from the original on 29 February 2020.
195. Maggie Panos (10 February 2015). "9 Grammys Upsets Heard Round the World". Pop Sugar. Archived from the original on 12 April 2020.
196. Steven Edelstone (14 February 2017). "10 Terrible Grammy Album of the Year Snubs". Paste Magazine. Archived from the original on 4 March 2018.
197. Gil Kaufman (10 February 2012). "Kanye West Isn't Only Grammy Album of the Year Snub". MTV. Archived from the original on 28 February 2020.
198. Callie Ahlgrim (27 January 2020). "The 21 best album of the year nominees that got robbed at the Grammys". Insider.
199. "Epic Album of the Year Snubs: The 2000s". BET. Archived from the original on 7 March 2016.
200. "Kanye and Amy lead Grammys field". BBC News. 2007-12-06. Archived from the original on 2009-01-11. Retrieved 2020-04-10.
201. "2007 HipHopDX Awards". HipHopDX. 2007-12-31. Archived from the original on 2015-11-18. Retrieved 2019-01-06.
202. "Lil Wayne Tops BET Hip-Hop Award Nominations With 12 Nods". XXL Mag. 15 September 2008. Archived from the original on 12 December 2017. Retrieved 12 December 2017.
203. "Echo Pop: Suche". Echo Pop. Archived from the original on 2012-02-17. Retrieved 2019-01-04.
204. "Winners 2008". Fonogram. Archived from the original on 2018-07-17. Retrieved 2018-07-17.
205. "2008 NAACP Image Awards Winners". NAACP. 2008-02-14. Archived from the original on 2017-04-13. Retrieved 2017-12-17.
206. "Swiss Music Awards 2008". Hitparade. 2008-01-28. Archived from the original on 2017-12-19. Retrieved 2017-12-19.
207. Doscas, Andrew (September 23, 2014). "The Future Is Now, and It Is Odd: A Retrospective on Hip-hop in the '00s". PopMatters. Archived from the original on June 19, 2019. Retrieved November 27, 2019.
208. Burney, Lawrence (2017-09-11). "Kanye West's 'Graduation' Gave Birth to Rap's First Real Rock Star". Noisey. Vice Media. Archived from the original on 2017-09-11. Retrieved 2017-09-12.
209. Frere-Jones, Sasha (2009-03-30). "Dance Revolution". The New Yorker. Condé Nast Digital. Archived from the original on 2009-03-26. Retrieved 2009-04-16.
210. Stylus Staff (2007-10-31). "Top 50 Albums of 2007". Stylus Magazine. stylusmagazine.com. Archived from the original on 2007-12-18. Retrieved 2007-12-16.
211. Respect Staff (2014-02-14). "Interview: Rockie Fresh, MMG's Next Heavyweight Champ". Respect. Harris Publications. Archived from the original on 2018-08-08. Retrieved 2018-07-08.
212. Peat, Mark (April 2016). "The Musical Journey of Kanye West". Neutral. Archived from the original on 2018-04-27. Retrieved 2018-05-09.
213. Boult, Adam (2011-12-16). "Poll: Which Is the Greatest Kanye West Album?". The Guardian. Guardian News and Media Limited. Archived from the original on 2013-10-04. Retrieved 2013-05-06.
214. Sullivan, Caroline (17 December 2008). "Slaves to synth". The Guardian. London. Archived from the original on 28 February 2014. Retrieved 20 June 2011.
215. Saponara, Michael (2007-09-19). "Grammy-Winning Engineer Anthony Kilhoffer Recalls Memorable Studio Sessions From Kanye's 'Graduation' Album". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Archived from the original on 2017-09-12. Retrieved 2007-09-19.
216. Newton, Matthew (December 2008). "Is Sampling Dying?". Spin. SPIN Media LLC. 24 (12): 32. Archived from the original on January 11, 2014. Retrieved March 25, 2012.
217. Detrick, Ben (2007-10-07). "Reality Check". XXL: 114.
218. Theisen, Adam (2015-02-18). "Rap's Latest Heavyweight Championship". The Michigan Daily. The Michigan Daily. Archived from the original on 2015-07-13. Retrieved 2015-05-08.
219. Shipley, Al. Kanye West's 'Graduation': 10 Things You Didn't Know Archived 2018-02-03 at the Wayback Machine. Rolling Stone. Retrieved on 2017-09-11.
220. Callahan-Bever, Noah (2015-09-11). "The Day Kanye West Killed Gangsta Rap". Complex. Archived from the original on 2016-02-19. Retrieved 2016-02-17.
221. Lamarre, Carl (2017-09-11). "Vic Mensa, KYLE, A Boogie Wit Da Hoodie & More Reflect on Their Fondest Memories of Kanye's 'Graduation' Album". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Archived from the original on 2018-06-15. Retrieved 2018-06-24.
222. Swash, Rosie (2011-06-13). Kanye v 50 Cent Archived 2016-08-26 at the Wayback Machine. The Guardian. Guardian News and Media Limited. Retrieved 2011-08-09.
223. "Graduation Kanye West − Album, singles et concerts" (in French). Virgin Mega. Archived from the original on 2014-10-18. Retrieved 2014-10-12.
224. https://play.spotify.com/album/0FnTw6TY6iB5AHATPzCYkd
225. "Graduation + 2 remixes Kanye West − Album, singles et concerts" (in French). Virgin Mega. Archived from the original on 2014-10-18. Retrieved 2014-10-12.
226. https://play.spotify.com/album/2EvIPfiWOIxIZ193E8sK8w
227. "Kanye West – Graduation". aCharts.us. 2007. Archived from the original on 2007-10-13. Retrieved 2007-09-29.
228. "Ultratop.be – Kanye West – Graduation" (in French). Hung Medien. Retrieved 2019-11-29.
229. "Kanye West Chart History (Canadian Albums)". Billboard. Retrieved 2019-11-29.
230. Sexton, Paul (2007-09-24). "Kingston, Blunt Rule On U.K. Charts". Billboard. Archived from the original on 2015-07-04. Retrieved 2020-01-10.
231. "Japanese Oricon Top 30 Albums". Oricon. Oricon, Inc. 2007. Archived from the original on 2009-03-03. Retrieved 2007-09-23. (in Japanese)
232. "Official Scottish Albums Chart Top 100: 16 September 2007 - 22 September 2007". Official Charts Company. Archived from the original on 24 September 2015. Retrieved 2015-06-29.
233. "Official R&B Albums Chart Top 40". Official Charts Company. Retrieved 2020-01-11.
234. "Kanye West Chart History (Billboard 200)". Billboard. Retrieved 2020-01-11.
235. "Kanye West Chart History (Top R&B/Hip-Hop Albums)". Billboard. Retrieved 2020-01-11.
236. "Top 40 album DVD és válogatáslemez-lista – 2012. 11. hét" (in Hungarian). MAHASZ. Retrieved December 9, 2019.
237. "2019 44-os savaitės klausomiausi (TOP 100)" (in Lithuanian). AGATA. 2019-11-04. Archived from the original on 2019-11-05. Retrieved 2019-11-29.
238. McIntyre, Hugh (2019-11-07). "BTS, Jackson Wang, Kanye West And Future: 5 Noteworthy Moves On This Week's Billboard 200". Forbes. Archived from the original on 2019-11-08. Retrieved 2019-11-29.
239. "Kanye West Chart History (Top Catalog Albums)". Billboard. Archived from the original on 2019-11-05. Retrieved 2019-12-09.
240. "Top 100 Albums 2007". ARIA. Archived from the original on 2010-07-28. Retrieved 2019-08-04.
241. "European Top 100 Albums (Year end) 2007". Billboard. 2008-01-13. Archived from the original on 2009-02-25. Retrieved 2020-01-11.
242. "Jahreshitparaden 2007". Swiss Music Charts. Hung Medien (in German). Archived from the original on 2011-07-07. Retrieved 2019-09-22.
243. "End of Year Album Chart Top 100 – 2007". Official Charts Company. Archived from the original on 2015-04-03. Retrieved 2019-08-04.
244. "Billboard 200 Albums (Year end) 2007". Billboard. 2008-01-13. Archived from the original on 2015-02-28. Retrieved 2019-09-22.
245. "R&B/Hip-Hop Albums (Year end)". Billboard. 2008-01-13. Archived from the original on 2013-11-19. Retrieved 2013-05-17.
246. "Top 50 Global Best Selling Albums for 2007" (PDF). IFPI. Archived from the original on April 10, 2011. Retrieved December 7, 2019.
247. "Top 50 Urban Albums 2008". ARIA. Archived from the original on 2013-05-28. Retrieved 2019-08-04.
248. "UK Albums Chart 2008" (PDF). ChartsPlus. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2009-03-27. Retrieved 2019-09-26.
249. "Billboard 200 Albums (Year end)". Billboard. 2009-01-13. Archived from the original on 2019-04-13. Retrieved 2019-08-04.
250. "R&B/Hip-Hop Albums (Year end)". Billboard. 2009-01-13. Archived from the original on 2019-04-01. Retrieved 2019-04-04.
251. "Billboard 200 Albums (Year end)". Billboard. 2016-12-09. Retrieved 2019-12-09.
252. "Top 100 Urban Albums 2017". ARIA Charts. Archived from the original on 2019-04-17. Retrieved 2019-09-22.
253. "Top 100 Urban Albums 2018". ARIA Charts. Archived from the original on 2019-03-28. Retrieved 2019-09-22.
254. "Top 100 Urban Albums 2019". ARIA Charts. Retrieved 2020-01-09.
255. ??????????? 2007?10? (in Japanese). Recording Industry Association of Japan (RIAJ). 2007-11-10. Archived from the original on 2012-11-09. Retrieved 2010-11-10.
256. "Chart #1591: Graduation Gold certification". Recording Industry Association of New Zealand. 2007-11-19. Archived from the original on 2008-12-04. Retrieved 2007-11-19.
257. "Swiss Certifications – Awards 2008". SwissCharts.com. Hung Medien. 2008. Archived from the original on 2011-05-15. Retrieved 2009-04-26.
258. "ARIA Charts – Accreditations – 2016 Albums". Australian Recording Industry Association. Retrieved 2019-08-04.
259. "Danish album certifications – Kanye West – Graduation". IFPI Denmark. Retrieved 2019-10-19. Scroll through the page-list below until year 2018 to obtain certification.
260. "2007 Certification Awards – Platinum". The Irish Charts. IRMA. Archived from the original on 2008-12-24. Retrieved 2008-12-12.
261. "Japanese album certifications – Kanye West – Graduation" (in Japanese). Recording Industry Association of Japan. Retrieved 2019-10-19.
262. "New Zealand album certifications – Kanye West – Graduation". Recorded Music NZ. Retrieved 2020-04-09.
263. "Russian album certifications – Kanye West – Graduation" (in Russian). National Federation of Phonogram Producers (NFPF). Retrieved 2019-09-10.
264. "The Official Swiss Charts and Music Community: Awards (Kanye West; 'Graduation')". IFPI Switzerland. Hung Medien. Retrieved 2019-10-19.
265. "British album certifications – Kanye West – Graduation". British Phonographic Industry. Retrieved 2019-10-19. Select albums in the Format field. Select Platinum in the Certification field. Type Graduation in the "Search BPI Awards" field and then press Enter.
266. "Gold & Platinum – Graduation". Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA). Archived from the original on 2016-08-06. Retrieved 2011-08-04.

External links

• Graduation at Discogs (list of releases)