Fur trade in Montana

The fur trade in Montana was a major period in the area's economic history from about 1800 to the 1850s. It also represents the initial meeting of cultures between indigenous peoples and those of European ancestry. British and Canadian traders approached the area from the north and northeast focusing on trading with the indigenous people, who often did the trapping of beavers and other animals themselves. American traders moved gradually up the Missouri River seeking to beat British and Canadian traders to the profitable Upper Missouri River region.

The Capture of the Beavers, Egerton R. Young's Winter Adventures of Three Boys in the Great Lone Land (1899)[1]

Indigenous peoples reacted to fur traders in a variety of ways, usually seeking to further their own interests in these economic dealings.[2] Many times, various tribal groups worked well with traders, but sometimes, especially when indigenous interests were threatened, conflicts developed. The best example of conflict on the Upper Missouri was between American fur traders and trappers and the Blackfeet, particularly the Blood. Misunderstanding of indigenous peoples' interests by American traders inevitably led to violence and conflict.[3]

Ultimately, the fur trade brought increased interactions between indigenous peoples and people of American and European ancestry. A capitalistic economic system was introduced to indigenous peoples impacting their cultures, along with deadly diseases that took a heavy toll in lives. The beaver population, and later the bison, were significantly diminished in the area that became the territory of, and subsequently, the state of Montana.

Fur trade and indigenous people in Montana

At the start of the 19th century, the North American fur trade was expanding toward present-day Montana from two directions. Representatives of British and Canadian fur trade companies, primarily the Hudson's Bay Company and the North West Company, pushed west and south from their stronghold on the Saskatchewan River, while American trappers and traders followed the trail of the Lewis and Clark Expedition up the Missouri River from their base in St. Louis.[4]

These traders competed not only in trapping fur-bearing animals, particularly the American beaver, but also in arranging trade relations with the many indigenous groups in the region, hoping to corner the market on these rich resources. For their part, the region's indigenous groups – particularly the Piegan (often called "Blackfeet" in the USA), the Crow, and the Salish and Kootenai – struggled to maintain control of their own lands and resources which supported their people and way of life. Each group interacted in the fur trade in different ways and to differing extents, yet all were changed by the important trading relations that developed from about 1805 through the 1860s.[5][6][2]

Indigenous Women in the Fur Trade

Indigenous women across Montana played a vital and complex role in the development of the fur trade, acting as economic mediators, cultural brokers, and producers/consumers of trade goods and foodstuffs. Over time, as a distinct fur trade society evolved around company-operated outposts, cross-cultural sexual relationships and marriages became commonplace between Euro-American men and women from various tribal communities.[7] These unions and the resultant family networks consolidated and cemented the political and economic ties at the heart of the emerging economy.[8] Many native women occupied central positions of agency and influence, but also proved vulnerable to violence and disease.[9]

Notable individuals include Natawista[10] (also known as Natoapxíxina, Na-ta-wis-ta-cha and Natoyist-Siksina[11]), who in 1840 married Major Alexander Culbertson, then the head of Fort Union, and Wambdi Autepewin, a Lakota woman widely known for her skills as a mediator.[7] Countless others, however, produced necessary articles of clothing and food; prepared skins and tanned hides for market; offered their knowledge of local ecologies and geographies; and became inextricably involved in the multicultural exchange of the trade.[12]

British and Canadian traders

Cartographer and fur trader David Thompson

Even while Lewis and Clark struggled to make their way up and over the Rocky Mountains in the summer of 1805, a French Canadian trapper working for the North West Company, François Antoine Larocque explored part of the Yellowstone River drainage in what became southeastern Montana looking to arrange trading relations with Native Americans in the area, especially the Crow.[13] Though his expedition succeeded, Larocque's long-term plans ultimately failed due to the difficulties of competing with the Hudson's Bay Company and aggressive American fur traders.

The North West Company's efforts to establish themselves west of the Continental Divide proved far more successful. Largely avoiding lands known to be within the Louisiana Purchase, the Nor'Westers, led by the Welsh-born geographer, David Thompson, worked their way to the headwaters of the Saskatchewan River and then turned southwestward into the headwaters of the Columbia River, the western boundary of the Columbia District of the British fur trade.

Thompson's men came into present-day northwestern Montana in 1808 and founded a post on the Kootenai River (near present-day Libby, Montana) to trade with the Native Americans of the same name. In November 1809, Thompson himself established the most important post in the area, Saleesh House, on the Clark Fork River near present-day Thompson Falls, Montana, named for the explorer.[14] After many travels and amazingly accurate map-making in the area of the Clark Fork, Kootenai and Flathead rivers, Thompson left the region for good in 1812.[15][16] Through Thompson's efforts and the continuing work of North West Company, and the later efforts of Hudson's Bay Company men like Alexander Ross and Peter Skene Ogden, this region came to be dominated by the British and Canadian fur trade for decades to come.[17]

American traders and trappers

Manuel Lisa

Main article: Manuel Lisa

American fur traders quickly moved up the Missouri River following the Louisiana Purchase and Lewis and Clark's exploration. The first American fur post established in the region now known as Montana was completed in November 1807, and located at the confluence of the Yellowstone and Big Horn rivers by Manuel Lisa and his party of traders.[18] Lisa called it Fort Remon for his son,[19] but it was variously known as Lisa's Fort, or Fort Manuel.

From this post Lisa hoped to build a small empire for his fledgling Missouri Fur Company. His dream did not last, as he and his men were the first of many American fur traders to be attacked by groups of Piegan, Blood, and Gros Ventre.[20] The post at the mouth of the Big Horn was abandoned by 1811 and Lisa's efforts ended in failure.[21]

Trapper James Beckwourth

Andrew Henry, William H. Ashley, and Jedediah Smith

Main articles: Andrew Henry (fur trader), William H. Ashley, and Jedediah Smith

Taking game in Indian country by non-indigenous parties was against Federal law, but Federal officials were willing to turn a blind eye to the practice in order to encourage American occupation of the frontier and drive out the British.[22] In 1822, Andrew Henry, formerly of the Missouri Fur Company, and William H. Ashley formed a partnership to enter the fur trade,[23] and obtained a license "to carry on trade with the Indians up the Missouri," but their strategy was to rely predominantly on non-indigenous contract trappers and depend less on direct, formal trade with Native Americans.[22] Henry and Ashley's trappers included Jim Bridger, Jedediah Strong Smith, and David Edward Jackson, and eventually William Sublette[24] and James Beckwourth.[25]

Henry and Ashley established operations on the upper Missouri River at Fort Henry, and most of the men stayed there through the winter of 1822-23.[23] Smith and some other men had continued up the Missouri to the mouth of the Musselshell River in central Montana where they camped and trapped through the winter and spring, without any notable encounters with indigenous groups.[26] However, in the spring of 1823, Henry took a party further up the Missouri to the Great Falls to try to establish a trading post, but an attack by the Piegans pushed him back. They retreated to Fort Henry[27] but soon abandoned it and established a post two miles up the Yellowstone from the old Fort Remon near present-day Custer, Montana[23] to trade with the more amicable Crow.[27] The rest of the Ashley-Henry men were focusing their trapping in the Snake River country of present-day Idaho and ranged along rivers and streams in present-day Wyoming and Utah, so Henry arranged for a rendezvous in the spring of 1824 along the Sweetwater River in Wyoming. He picked up the winter's harvest of furs and made it back to St. Louis with half of them, then retired from the fur business.

Upon Henry's retirement, Ashley abandoned the idea of trading posts and initiated the free trapping and rendezvous system in 1825, taking on Smith as a partner.[24] The new partnership avoided the more dangerous territories to the north, but the next year, in 1826, Smith, Sublette, and Jackson took over the company,[28] and while Smith was engaged in his southwest expeditions, Jackson, Sublette and Robert Campbell made forays into Montana.[29] In 1829, Smith led a trapping expedition into Piegan country.[26] The next year, Smith and his partners sold out to Thomas Fitzpatrick, Baptiste Gervais, Jim Bridger, Milton Sublette and Henry Fraeb, who took the name Rocky Mountain Fur Company and set out with 200 men into the Great Falls area. The hunt was successful, but another attempt the next year was foiled by the Crows running off their horses.[30]

American Fur Company

Main articles: American Fur Company, John Jacob Astor, and Kenneth McKenzie (fur trader)

The steamboat Yellowstone (1833)

John Jacob Astor's American Fur Company (AFC) set up operations in St. Louis in 1822. By 1828 they arrived in the upper Missouri River region. Scotsman Kenneth McKenzie, intent on breaking into the Upper Missouri—the elusive prize of the Western fur trade—established what became Fort Union near the confluence of the Missouri and Yellowstone rivers. The Piegan were surprisingly ready to trade with the AFC. In 1830 McKenzie negotiated an agreement with a Piegan band, and sent James Kipp to the mouth of the Marias River in 1831 to organize a trading post on Piegan lands.

The AFC soon established a similar post to trade with the Crow on the Yellowstone. In 1832, the paddle steamer Yellowstone was the first to reach Fort Union. Steamboats, being able to haul larger loads, provided a decided transportation advantage to the AFC thereafter.[31]

Astor's company dominated the trade in the entire Missouri River region, wresting the lucrative Upper Missouri trade from the Hudson's Bay Company traders to the north who had traded with the Piegan for decades.[6] Unable to match the resources of the AFC, their main American rival, the Rocky Mountain Fur Company sold out in 1834.[32][31]

Consequences of the fur trade in Montana

Fur Trade Review (1887). "Extinction of the Buffalo"

The coming of the fur trade to Montana brought several substantial results. First of all, the land and its resources became better known, maps were filled in and became more accurate.[33] As Montana historian K. Ross Toole put it, "Before the emigrant's wagon ever rolled a mile, before the miner found his first color, before the government authorized a single road or trail, this inhospitable land had been traversed and mapped."[34]

A negative consequence of the trade was its impact on fur-bearing animals, initially the beaver and later the American bison or buffalo, whose populations were pushed to the brink. The worst consequence physically was the ravages of European diseases such as smallpox being increasingly spread to Native Americans by traders and trappers.[35]

Finally, for those indigenous peoples who survived, the fur trade intensified the introduction of Western European ideals of commerce and religion, since the beaver trade was an extension of global capitalism and also indirectly led to the spread of Roman Catholic Christianity to some of the tribes.[36] These changes greatly impacted the Native Americans of the region, challenging their already distressed way of life and changing their world forever.[35][37]

Notes

1. Young 1899, p. 228.
2. Binnema 2006, pp. 327–349.
3. Binnema & Dobak 2009, pp. 411–440.
4. Toole 1959, pp. 41–43.
5. Malone, Roeder & Lang 1991, pp. 41–59.
6. Smyth 1984, pp. 2–15.
7. Lansing, Michael (Winter 2000). "Plains Indian Women and Interracial Marriage in the Upper Missouri Trade, 1804-1868". Western Historical Quarterly. 31 (4): 413–433.
8. Graybill, Andrew (2013). The Red and the White: A Family Saga of the American West. New York: W.W. Norton.
9. Brown, Jennifer S.H. (1980). Strangers in the Blood: Fur Trade Company Families in Indian Country. Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press.
10. Schemm, Mildred Walker (January 1952). "The Major's Lady: Natawista". The Montana Magazine of History. 2 (1): 4–15.
11. Wischmann, Lesley (2004). Frontier Diplomats: Alexander Culbertson and Natoyist-Siksina among the Blackfeet. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press.
12. Van Kirk, Sylvia (1980). Many Tender Ties: Women in Fur Trade Society, 1670-1870. Winnipeg: Watson & Dwyer.
13. Holmes 2008, pp. 73–74.
14. White 1942, pp. 251–263.
15. Holmes 2008, pp. 74–75.
16. Malone, Roeder & Lang 1991, pp. 42–45.
17. Malone, Roeder & Lang 1991, pp. 45–47.
18. Toole 1959, p. 43.
19. "Fort Raymond (1)". fortwiki.com. Retrieved October 24, 2015.
20. Binnema 2006, pp. 327–330.
21. Malone, Roeder & Lang 1991, pp. 47–49.
22. Barbour, Barton H. (2011). Jedediah Smith: No Ordinary Mountain Man. Norman: U of Oklahoma Press. pp. 26–7. ISBN 978-0-8061-4196-1.
23. "Andrew Henry". National Park Service. Retrieved October 10, 2015.
24. Eddins, O. N. (ed.). "William Ashley Mountain Man Rendezvous System". Mountain Man - Indian - Canadian Fur Trade. Archived from the original on May 6, 2015. Retrieved October 18, 2015.
25. "Jim Beckwourth". National Park Service. Retrieved October 18, 2015.
26. Eddins, O. N. (ed.). "Jedediah Smith and America's Western Expansion". Mountain Man - Indian - Canadian Fur Trade. Archived from the original on October 23, 2015. Retrieved October 18, 2015.
27. Malone, Roeder & Lang 1991, p. 50.
28. Crutchfield, Moutlon & Del Bene 2015, p. 439.
29. Carter, Harvey L. (1983) [1971]. "Robert Campbell". In Leroy R. Hafen (ed.). Trappers of the Far West: Sixteen Biographical Sketches. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press. pp. 298–99. ISBN 0-8032-7218-9.
30. Malone, Roeder & Lang 1991, p. 51.
31. Malone, Roeder & Lang 1991, pp. 54–56.
32. Toole 1959, pp. 53–54.
33. Malone, Roeder & Lang 1991, p. 57.
34. Toole 1959, p. 55.
35. Malone, Roeder & Lang 1991, p. 59.
36. Malone, Roeder & Lang 1991, pp. 61–62.
37. Holmes 2008, pp. 92–96.

References

• Binnema, Theodore (Ted) (Autumn 2006). "Allegiances and interests : Niitsitapi (Blackfoot) trade, diplomacy, and warfare, 1806–1831". Western Historical Quarterly. 37 (3): 327–349. doi:10.2307/25443373. JSTOR 25443373.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Binnema, Ted; Dobak, William A. (Fall 2009). ""Like the greedy wolf" : the Blackfeet, the St. Louis fur trade, and war fever, 1807–1831". Journal of the Early Republic. 29 (3): 411–440. doi:10.1353/jer.0.0089. JSTOR 40541856.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Crutchfield, James A.; Moutlon, Candy; Del Bene, Terry (2015). The Settlement of America: An Encyclopedia of Westward Expansion from Jamestown to the Closing of the Frontier. Routledge.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Holmes, Krys (2008). Montana : stories of the land. Helena, MT: Montana Historical Society Press. Retrieved 14 November 2014.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link) Chap. 4 and Chap. 5
• Malone, Michael P.; Roeder, Richard B.; Lang, William L. (1991). Montana : a history of two centuries (Revised ed.). Seattle, WA: University of Washington Press.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Smyth, David (Spring 1984). "The struggle for the Piegan trade : the Saskatchewan vs. the Missouri". Montana The Magazine of Western History. 34 (2): 2–15. JSTOR 4518817.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Toole, K. Ross (1959). Montana : an uncommon land. Norman, OK: University of Oklahoma Press.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• White, M. Catherine (July 1942). "Saleesh House : the first trading post among the Flathead". Pacific Northwest Quarterly. 33 (3): 251–263. JSTOR 41441196.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Young, Edgerton R. (1899). Winter Adventures of Three Boys in the Great Lone North. London: Charles H. Kelly.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)

Further reading

• Chittenden, Hiram M. (1986). The American fur trade of the far West. Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska Press. Two volumes, reprint of work first published in 1902, considered a seminal work on the American fur trade.
• Graves, F. (1994). Montana's Fur Trade Era. Helena, Montana: Montana Magazine and American & World Geographic Pub. ISBN 1560370548.
• Hamilton, James McClellan; Burlingame, Merrill G.; Ryan, Betty G. (1957). "Part II-The Period of Fur Trade". From Wilderness to Statehood: A History of Montana, 1805–1900. Portland, OR: Binfords & Mort. pp. 56–92.
• Exploration and development (Video cassette). Montana State University. 1984. Describes the relationship between native peoples of Montana and the buffalo. The Lewis and Clark expedition and explorations by David Thompson led to the development of the fur trade in the state. Increased contact with whites introduced the Indians to disease, alcohol, and a new economy based on the fur trade.
• Sister, Frances Therese Shea (1944). Typical aspects of the fur trade in the Montana Rockies (Thesis (MA)). Marquette University.
• Wishart, David J. (1992). The Fur Trade of the American West 1807–1840, A Geographical Synthesis. Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska Press. ISBN 0-8032-4705-2.
• David Thompson Sesquicentennial Symposium, 1809–1959, Sandpoint, Idaho, August 29, 1959. Sandpoint, ID: Bonner County Museum. 1960.
• "Trails of the Past:Historical Overview of the Flathead National Forest, Montana, 1800–1960, The Fur Trade". U.S. Forest Service. January 18, 2010. Retrieved 2014-11-15.