Execution of the Romanov family

The Russian Imperial Romanov family (Emperor Nicholas II, his wife Empress Alexandra and their five children: Olga, Tatiana, Maria, Anastasia, and Alexei) were shot and bayoneted to death[1][2] by Communist revolutionaries under Yakov Yurovsky in Yekaterinburg on the night of 16–17 July 1918. Also killed that night were retainers who had accompanied them: notably Eugene Botkin, Anna Demidova, Alexei Trupp and Ivan Kharitonov.[3] The bodies were taken to the Koptyaki forest, where they were stripped and mutilated.[2][4]

Clockwise from top: The Romanov family, Ivan Kharitonov, Alexei Trupp, Anna Demidova, Eugene Botkin

In 1919 the White Army commissioned an investigation but were unable to find the unmarked gravesite. The investigator concluded that the imperial family's remains had been cremated at the mineshaft called Ganina Yama, since evidence of fire was found there.[5]

In 1979 and 2007, the remains of the bodies were found in two unmarked graves in a field called Porosenkov Log. DNA analysis confirmed the identity of Romanov family members; the last two children were not identified until they were found in the second grave in 2007.[6]

According to the official state version of the USSR, former Tsar Nicholas Romanov, along with members of his family and retinue, was executed by firing squad, by order of the Ural Regional Soviet, due to the threat of the city being occupied by Whites (Czechoslovak Legion).[7][8] Numerous researchers believe the execution was ordered by Vladimir Lenin, Yakov Sverdlov and Felix Dzerzhinsky.

Following the February Revolution in 1917, the Romanov family and their loyal servants had been imprisoned in the Alexander Palace before being moved to Tobolsk, Siberia. They were next moved to a house in Yekaterinburg, near the Ural Mountains. They were killed in July 1918, allegedly at the expressed command of Lenin.[9] The Bolsheviks initially announced only Nicholas's death,[10][11] although they were told that "the entire family suffered the same fate as its head."[12] The official press release said that "Nicholas Romanov's wife and son have been sent to a secure place."[12] For over eight years,[13] the Soviet leadership maintained a systematic web of disinformation as to the fate of the family,[14] from claiming in September 1919 that they were murdered by left-wing revolutionaries[15] to denying outright in April 1922 that they were dead.[14]

The Soviets finally acknowledged the murders in 1926, following the publication in France of a 1919 investigation by a White émigré, but said that the bodies were destroyed and that Lenin's Cabinet was not responsible.[16] The Soviet cover-up of the murders fuelled rumours of survivors.[17] Various Romanov impostors claimed to be one of the children, which drew media attention away from activities of Soviet Russia.[14] From 1938, Joseph Stalin suppressed any discussion regarding the fate of the family.[18]

The burial site was discovered in 1979 by Alexander Avdonin, an amateur sleuth.[19] The Soviet Union did not acknowledge the existence of these remains publicly until 1989, during the glasnost period.[20] The identity of the remains was later confirmed by forensic and DNA analysis and investigation, with the assistance of British experts.

In 1998, 80 years after the executions, the remains of the Romanov family were reinterred in a state funeral in the Peter and Paul Cathedral in Saint Petersburg.[21] The funeral was not attended by key members of the Russian Orthodox Church, who disputed the authenticity of the remains.[22]

In 2007, a second, smaller grave, containing the remains of two Romanov children missing from the larger grave, a boy and a girl, was discovered by amateur archaeologists.[19] However, their remains are kept in a state repository pending further DNA tests.[23] The remains of Alexei and a sister have been confirmed by DNA analysis, but the government was allowing the Church to hold Alexei's remains for additional testing. In 2008, after considerable and protracted legal wrangling, the Russian Prosecutor General's office rehabilitated the Romanov family as "victims of political repressions".[24] A criminal case was opened by the post-Soviet government in 1993, but nobody was prosecuted on the basis that the perpetrators were dead.[23]

Some historians attribute the execution order to the government in Moscow, specifically Sverdlov and Lenin, who wanted to prevent the rescue of the Imperial Family by the approaching Czechoslovak Legion during the ongoing Russian Civil War.[25][26] This is supported by a passage in Leon Trotsky's diary.[27]

An investigation led by Vladimir Solovyov concluded in 2011 that, despite the opening of state archives in the post-Soviet years, no written document has been found that indicates that either Lenin or Sverdlov instigated the orders; however, they did endorse the executions after they occurred.[28][29][30][31] Other sources argue that Lenin and the central Soviet government had wanted to conduct a trial of the Romanovs, with Trotsky serving as prosecutor, but that the local Ural Soviet, under pressure from Left S-Rs and anarchists, undertook the executions on their own initiative due to the approach of the Czechoslovaks.[32] Lenin had close control over the Romanovs, although he ensured his name was not associated with their fate in any official documents.[33]

In 1998 President Boris Yeltsin described the killings of the royal family as one of the most shameful chapters in Russian history.[34][35]

Background

Location of the main events in the last days of the Romanov family, who were held at Tobolsk, Siberia, before being transported to Yekaterinburg, where they were killed.

On 22 March 1917, Nicholas, deposed as a monarch and addressed by the sentries as "Nicholas Romanov", was reunited with his family at the Alexander Palace in Tsarskoe Selo. He was placed under house arrest with his family by the Provisional Government, and the family was surrounded by guards and confined to their quarters.[36]

In August 1917, Alexander Kerensky's provisional government, after a failed attempt to send the Romanovs to Britain, which was ruled by Nicholas and Alexandra's mutual first cousin, King George V, evacuated the Romanovs to Tobolsk, Siberia, allegedly to protect them from the rising tide of revolution. There they lived in the former governor's mansion in considerable comfort. After the Bolsheviks came to power in October 1917, the conditions of their imprisonment grew stricter. Talk in the government of putting Nicholas on trial grew more frequent. Nicholas was forbidden to wear epaulettes, and the sentries scrawled lewd drawings on the fence to offend his daughters. On 1 March 1918, the family was placed on soldiers' rations. Their 10 servants were dismissed, and they had to give up butter and coffee.[37]

As the Bolsheviks gathered strength, the government in April moved Nicholas, Alexandra, and their daughter Maria to Yekaterinburg under the direction of Vasily Yakovlev. Alexei, who had severe haemophilia, was too ill to accompany his parents and remained with his sisters Olga, Tatiana, and Anastasia, not leaving Tobolsk until May 1918. The family was imprisoned with a few remaining retainers in Yekaterinburg's Ipatiev House, which was designated The House of Special Purpose (Russian: Дом Особого Назначения).

Nicholas II, Tatiana and Anastasia Hendrikova working on a kitchen garden at Alexander Palace in May 1917. The family was allowed no such indulgences at the Ipatiev House.[38]

All those under arrest will be held as hostages, and the slightest attempt at counter-revolutionary action in the town will result in the summary execution of the hostages.

— Announcement in the local newspaper by Bolshevik War Commissar Filipp Goloshchyokin, in overall charge of the family's incarceration in Yekaterinburg.[39]

The House of Special Purpose

The imperial family was kept in strict isolation at the Ipatiev House.[40] They were strictly forbidden to speak any language other than Russian.[41] They were not permitted access to their luggage, which was stored in an outhouse in the interior courtyard.[40] Their brownie cameras and photographic equipment were confiscated.[38] The servants were ordered to address the Romanovs only by their names and patronymics.[42] The family was subjected to regular searches of their belongings, confiscation of their money for "safekeeping by the Ural Regional Soviet's treasurer",[43] and attempts to remove Alexandra's and her daughters' gold bracelets from their wrists.[44] The house was surrounded by a 4 metre (14 ft) high, double palisade that obscured the view of the streets from the house.[45] The initial fence enclosed the garden along Voznesensky Lane. On 5 June a second palisade was erected, higher and longer than the first, which completely enclosed the property.[46] The second palisade was constructed after it was learned that passersby could see Nicholas's legs when he used the double swing in the garden.[47]

Ipatiev House, with the palisade erected just before Nicholas, Alexandra and Maria arrived on 30 April 1918. On the top left of the house is a attic dormer window where a Maxim gun was positioned. Directly below it was the tsar and tsarina's bedroom.[48]

The Church of All Saints in 2016 (top left), where the Ipatiev House used to be. Voznesensky Cathedral is in the foreground, where a machine gun was mounted in the belfry aimed at the tsar and tsaritsa's bedroom on the southeastern corner of the house.[49]

The windows in all the family's rooms were sealed shut and covered with newspapers (later painted with whitewash on 15 May).[50] The family's only source of ventilation was a fortochka in the grand duchesses' bedroom, but peeking out of it was strictly forbidden; in May a sentry fired a shot at Anastasia when she looked out.[51] After Romanov made repeated requests, one of the two windows in the tsar and tsarina's corner bedroom was unsealed on 23 June 1918.[52] The guards were ordered to increase their surveillance accordingly, and the prisoners were warned not to look out the window or attempt to signal anyone outside, on pain of being shot.[53] From this window, they could see only the spire of the Voznesensky Cathedral located across the road from the house.[53] An iron grille was installed on 11 July, after Alexandra had ignored repeated warnings from the commandant, Yakov Yurovsky, not to stand too close to the open window.[54]

The guard commandant and his senior aides had complete access at any time to all rooms occupied by the family.[55] The prisoners were required to ring a bell each time they wished to leave their rooms to use the bathroom and lavatory on the landing.[56] Strict rationing of the water supply was enforced on the prisoners after the guards complained that it regularly ran out.[57] Recreation was allowed only twice daily in the garden, for half an hour morning and afternoon. The prisoners were ordered not to engage in conversation with any of the guards.[58] Rations were mostly tea and black bread for breakfast, and cutlets or soup with meat for lunch; the prisoners were informed that "they were no longer permitted to live like tsars".[59] In mid-June, nuns from the Novo-Tikhvinsky Monastery also brought the family food on a daily basis, most of which the captors took when it arrived.[59] The family was not allowed visitors or to receive and send letters.[38] Princess Helen of Serbia visited the house in June but was refused entry at gunpoint by the guards,[60] while Dr Vladimir Derevenko's regular visits to treat Alexei were curtailed when Yurovsky became commandant. No excursions to Divine Liturgy at the nearby church were permitted.[41] In early June, the family no longer received their daily newspapers.[38]

The Romanov entourage. From left to right: Catherine Schneider, Ilya Tatishchev, Pierre Gilliard, Anastasia Hendrikova and Vasily Dolgorukov. They voluntarily accompanied the Romanov family into imprisonment but were forcibly separated by the Bolsheviks at Ekaterinburg. All except Gilliard were later murdered by the Bolsheviks.[61]

To maintain a sense of normality, the Bolsheviks lied to the Romanovs on 13 July 1918 that two of their loyal servants, Klementy Nagorny (Alexei's sailor nanny)[62] and Ivan Sednev (OTMA's footman; Leonid Sednev's uncle),[63] "had been sent out of this government" (i.e. out of the jurisdiction of Yekaterinburg and Perm province). In fact, both men were already dead: after the Bolsheviks had removed them from the Ipatiev House in May, they had been shot by the Cheka with a group of other hostages on 6 July, in reprisal for the death of Ivan Malyshev, a local Bolshevik killed by the Whites.[64] On 14 July, a priest and deacon conducted a liturgy for the Romanovs.[65] The following morning, four housemaids were hired to wash the floors of the Popov House and Ipatiev House; they were the last civilians to see the family alive. On both occasions, they were under strict instructions not to engage in conversation with the family.[66] Yurovsky always kept watch during the liturgy and while the housemaids were cleaning the bedrooms with the family.[67]

The 16 men of the internal guard slept in the basement, hallway, and commandant's office during shifts. The external guard, led by Pavel Medvedev, numbered 56 and took over the Popov House opposite.[55] The guards were allowed to bring in women for sex and drinking sessions in the Popov House and basement rooms of the Ipatiev House.[67] There were four machine gun emplacements: one in the bell tower of the Voznesensky Cathedral aimed toward the house; a second in the basement window of the Ipatiev House facing the street; a third monitored the balcony overlooking the garden at the back of the house;[53] and a fourth in the attic overlooking the intersection, directly above the tsar and tsarina's bedroom.[48] Ten guard posts were located in and around the Ipatiev House, and the exterior was patrolled twice hourly day and night.[51] In early May, the guards moved the piano from the dining room, where the prisoners could play it, to the commandant's office next to the Romanovs' bedrooms. The guards would play the piano, while singing Russian revolutionary songs and drinking and smoking.[40] They also listened to the Romanovs' records on the confiscated phonograph.[40] The lavatory on the landing was also used by the guards, who scribbled political slogans and crude graffiti on the walls.[40] The number of Ipatiev House guards totaled 300 at the time the imperial family was killed.[68]

When Yurovsky replaced Aleksandr Avdeev on 4 July,[69] he moved the old internal guard members to the Popov House. The senior aides were retained but were designated to guard the hallway area and no longer had access to the Romanovs' rooms; only Yurovsky's men had it. The local Cheka chose replacements from the volunteer battalions of the Verkh-Isetsk factory at Yurovsky's request. He wanted dedicated Bolsheviks who could be relied on to do whatever was asked of them. They were hired on the understanding that they would be prepared, if necessary, to kill the tsar, about which they were sworn to secrecy. Nothing at that stage was said about killing the family or servants. To prevent a repetition of the fraternization that had occurred under Avdeev, Yurovsky chose mainly foreigners. Nicholas noted in his diary on 8 July that "new Latvians are standing guard", describing them as Letts – a term commonly used in Russia to classify someone as of European, non-Russian origin. The leader of the new guards was Adolf Lepa, a Lithuanian.[70]

The Romanovs were being held by the Red Army in Yekaterinburg, since the Bolsheviks initially wanted to put them on trial. As the civil war continued and the White Army (a loose alliance of anti-Communist forces) was threatening to capture the city, the fear was that the Romanovs would fall into White hands. This was unacceptable to the Bolsheviks for two reasons: first, the tsar or any of his family members could provide a beacon to rally support to the White cause; second, the tsar, or any of his family members if the tsar were dead, would be considered the legitimate ruler of Russia by the other European nations. This would have given the Whites some power to negotiate for greater foreign intervention on their behalf. Soon after the family was executed, Yekaterinburg fell to the White Army.

In mid-July 1918, forces of the Czechoslovak Legion were closing on Yekaterinburg, to protect the Trans-Siberian Railway, of which they had control. According to historian David Bullock, the Bolsheviks, falsely believing that the Czechoslovaks were on a mission to rescue the family, panicked and executed their wards. The Legions arrived less than a week later and on 25 July captured the city.[71]

During the imperial family's imprisonment in late June, Pyotr Voykov and Alexander Beloborodov, president of the Ural Regional Soviet,[72] directed the smuggling of letters written in French to the Ipatiev House. These claimed to be by a monarchist officer seeking to rescue the family, but were composed at the behest of the Cheka.[73] These fabricated letters, along with the Romanov responses to them (written on either blank spaces or the envelopes),[74] provided the Central Executive Committee (CEC) in Moscow with further justification to 'liquidate' the imperial family.[75] Yurovsky later observed that, by responding to the faked letters, Nicholas "had fallen into a hasty plan by us to trap him".[73] On 13 July, across the road from the Ipatiev House, a demonstration of Red Army soldiers, Socialist Revolutionaries, and anarchists was staged on Voznesensky Square, demanding the dismissal of the Yekaterinburg Soviet and the transfer of control of the city to them. This rebellion was violently suppressed by a detachment of Red Guards led by Peter Ermakov, which opened fire on the protesters, all within earshot of the tsar and tsarina's bedroom window. The authorities exploited the incident as a monarchist-led rebellion that threatened the security of the captives at the Ipatiev House.[76]

We like this man less and less.

— Diary entry of Tsar Nicholas II, referring to the constant tightening of restrictions on his family by Yurovsky.[54]

Planning for the execution

An M1911, similar to the ones used by Yurovsky and Kudrin. Kudrin was also armed with a FN Browning M1900.

A Mauser C96, similar to the ones used by Yurovsky and Ermakov

A FN Model M1906, similar to the one used by Grigory Nikulin

The Ural Regional Soviet agreed in a meeting on 29 June that the Romanov family should be executed. Filipp Goloshchyokin arrived in Moscow on 3 July with a message insisting on the Tsar's execution.[77] Only seven of the 23 members of the Central Executive Committee were in attendance, three of whom were Lenin, Sverdlov and Felix Dzerzhinsky.[72] They agreed that the presidium of the Ural Regional Soviet should organize the practical details for the family's execution and decide the precise day on which it would take place when the military situation dictated it, contacting Moscow for final approval.[78]

The killing of the Tsar's wife and children was also discussed, but it was kept a state secret to avoid any political repercussions; German ambassador Wilhelm von Mirbach made repeated enquiries to the Bolsheviks concerning the family's well-being.[79] Another diplomat, British consul Thomas Preston, who lived near the Ipatiev House, was often pressured by Pierre Gilliard, Sydney Gibbes and Prince Vasily Dolgorukov to help the Romanovs;[60] Dolgorukov smuggled notes from his prison cell before he was murdered by Grigory Nikulin, Yurovsky's assistant.[80] Preston's requests to be granted access to the family were consistently rejected.[81] As Trotsky later said, "The Tsar's family was a victim of the principle that forms the very axis of monarchy: dynastic inheritance", for which their deaths were a necessity.[82] Goloshchyokin reported back to Yekaterinburg on 12 July with a summary of his discussion about the Romanovs with Moscow,[72] along with instructions that nothing relating to their deaths should be directly communicated to Lenin.[83]

On 14 July, Yurovsky was finalizing the disposal site and how to destroy as much evidence as possible at the same time.[84] He was frequently in consultation with Peter Ermakov, who was in charge of the disposal squad and claimed to know the outlying countryside.[85] Yurovsky wanted to gather the family and servants in a small, confined space from which they could not escape. The basement room chosen for this purpose had a barred window which was nailed shut to muffle the sound of shooting and in case of any screaming.[86] Shooting and stabbing them at night while they slept or killing them in the forest and then dumping them into the Iset pond with lumps of metal weighted to their bodies were ruled out.[87] Yurovsky's plan was to perform an efficient execution of all 11 prisoners simultaneously, though he also took into account that he would have to prevent those involved from raping the women or searching the bodies for jewels.[87] Having previously seized some jewelry, he suspected more was hidden in their clothes;[43] the bodies were stripped naked in order to obtain the rest (this, along with the mutilations were aimed at preventing investigators from identifying them).[4]

On 16 July, Yurovsky was informed by the Ural Soviets that Red Army contingents were retreating in all directions and the executions could not be delayed any longer. A coded telegram seeking final approval was sent by Goloshchyokin and Georgy Safarov at around 6 pm to Lenin in Moscow.[88] There is no documentary record of an answer from Moscow, although Yurovsky insisted that an order from the CEC to go ahead had been passed on to him by Goloshchyokin at around 7 pm.[89] This claim was consistent with that of a former Kremlin guard, Aleksey Akimov, who in the late 1960s stated that Sverdlov instructed him to send a telegram confirming the CEC's approval of the 'trial' (code for execution) but required that both the written form and ticker tape be returned to him immediately after the message was sent.[89] At 8 pm, Yurovsky sent his chauffeur to acquire a truck for transporting the bodies, along with rolls of canvas to wrap them in. The intention was to park it close to the basement entrance, with its engine running, to mask the noise of gunshots.[90] Yurovsky and Pavel Medvedev collected 14 handguns to use that night: two Browning pistols (one M1900 and one M1906), two Colt M1911 pistols, two Mauser C96s, one Smith & Wesson and seven Belgian-made Nagants. The Nagant operated on old black gunpowder which produced a good deal of smoke and fumes; smokeless powder was only just being phased in.[91]

In the commandant's office, Yurovsky assigned victims to each killer before distributing the handguns. He took a Mauser and Colt while Ermakov armed himself with three Nagants, one Mauser and a bayonet; he was the only one assigned to kill two prisoners (Alexandra and Botkin). Yurovsky instructed his men to "shoot straight at the heart to avoid an excessive quantity of blood and get it over quickly."[92] At least two of the Letts, an Austro-Hungarian prisoner of war named Andras Verhas and Adolf Lepa, himself in charge of the Lett contingent, refused to shoot the women. Yurovsky sent them to the Popov House for failing "at that important moment in their revolutionary duty".[93] Neither Yurovsky nor any of the killers went into the logistics of how to efficiently destroy eleven bodies.[83] He was under pressure to ensure that no remains would later be found by monarchists who would exploit them to rally anti-communist support.[94]

Execution

From left to right: Grand Duchesses Maria, Olga, Anastasia and Tatiana Nikolaevna of Russia in captivity at Tsarskoe Selo in the spring of 1917. One of the last known photographs of Nicholas II's daughters

While the Romanovs were having dinner on 16 July 1918, Yurovsky entered the sitting room and informed them that kitchen boy Leonid Sednev was leaving to meet his uncle, Ivan Sednev, who had returned to the city asking to see him; Ivan had already been shot by the Cheka.[95] The family was very upset as Leonid was Alexei's only playmate and he was the fifth member of the imperial entourage to be taken from them, but they were assured by Yurovsky that he would be back soon. Alexandra did not trust Yurovsky, writing in her final diary entry just hours before her death, "whether its [sic] true & we shall see the boy back again!" Leonid was kept in the Popov House that night.[90] Yurovsky saw no reason to kill him and wanted him removed before the execution took place.[88]

Around midnight on 17 July, Yurovsky ordered the Romanovs' physician, Eugene Botkin, to awaken the sleeping family and ask them to put on their clothes, under the pretext that the family would be moved to a safe location due to impending chaos in Yekaterinburg.[96] The Romanovs were then ordered into a 6 m × 5 m (20 ft × 16 ft) semi-basement room. Nicholas asked if Yurovsky could bring two chairs, on which Tsarevich Alexei and Alexandra sat.[97] Yurovsky's assistant Grigory Nikulin remarked to him that the "heir wanted to die in a chair.[98] Very well then, let him have one."[86] The prisoners were told to wait in the cellar room while the truck that would transport them was being brought to the House. A few minutes later, an execution squad of secret police was brought in and Yurovsky read aloud the order given to him by the Ural Executive Committee:

Nikolai Alexandrovich, in view of the fact that your relatives are continuing their attack on Soviet Russia, the Ural Executive Committee has decided to execute you.[99]

Nicholas, facing his family, turned and said "What? What?"[100] Yurovsky quickly repeated the order and the weapons were raised. The Empress and Grand Duchess Olga, according to a guard's reminiscence, had tried to bless themselves, but failed amid the shooting. Yurovsky reportedly raised his Colt gun at Nicholas's torso and fired; Nicholas fell dead, pierced with at least three bullets in his upper chest. The intoxicated Peter Ermakov, the military commissar for Verkh-Isetsk, shot and killed Alexandra with a bullet wound to the head. He then shot at Maria, who ran for the double doors, hitting her in the thigh.[101] The remaining executioners shot chaotically and over each other's shoulders until the room was so filled with smoke and dust that no one could see anything at all in the darkness nor hear any commands amid the noise.

Alexey Kabanov, who ran onto the street to check the noise levels, heard dogs barking from the Romanovs' quarters and the sound of gunshots loud and clear despite the noise from the Fiat's engine. Kabanov then hurried downstairs and told the men to stop firing and kill the family and their dogs with their gun butts and bayonets.[102] Within minutes, Yurovsky was forced to stop the shooting because of the caustic smoke of burned gunpowder, dust from the plaster ceiling caused by the reverberation of bullets, and the deafening gunshots. When they stopped, the doors were then opened to scatter the smoke.[100] While waiting for the smoke to abate, the killers could hear moans and whimpers inside the room.[103] As it cleared, it became evident that although several of the family's retainers had been killed, all of the Imperial children were alive and only Maria was injured.[100][104]

The basement where the Romanov family was killed. The wall had been torn apart in search of bullets and other evidence by investigators in 1919. The double doors leading to a storeroom were locked during the execution.[87]

The noise of the guns had been heard by households all around, awakening many people. The executioners were ordered to use their bayonets, a technique which proved ineffective and meant that the children had to be dispatched by still more gunshots, this time aimed more precisely at their heads. The Tsarevich was the first of the children to be executed. Yurovsky watched in disbelief as Nikulin spent an entire magazine from his Browning gun on Alexei, who was still seated transfixed in his chair; he also had jewels sewn into his undergarment and forage cap.[105] Ermakov shot and stabbed him, and when that failed, Yurovsky shoved him aside and killed the boy with a gunshot to the head.[101] The last to die were Tatiana, Anastasia, and Maria, who were carrying a few pounds (over 1.3 kilograms) of diamonds sewn into their clothing, which had given them a degree of protection from the firing.[106] However, they were speared with bayonets as well. Olga sustained a gunshot wound to the head. Maria and Anastasia were said to have crouched up against a wall covering their heads in terror until they were shot. Yurovsky killed Tatiana and Alexei. Tatiana died from a single shot to the back of her head.[107] Alexei received two bullets to the head, right behind the ear.[108] Anna Demidova, Alexandra's maid, survived the initial onslaught but was quickly stabbed to death against the back wall while trying to defend herself with a small pillow which she had carried that was filled with precious gems and jewels.[109] While the bodies were being placed on stretchers, one of the girls cried out and covered her face with her arm.[110] Ermakov grabbed Alexander Strekotin's rifle and bayoneted her in the chest,[110] but when it failed to penetrate he pulled out his revolver and shot her in the head.[111][112]

While Yurovsky was checking the victims for pulses, Ermakov walked through the room, flailing the bodies with his bayonet. The execution lasted about 20 minutes, Yurovsky later admitting to Nikulin's "poor mastery of his weapon and inevitable nerves".[113] Future investigations calculated that a possible 70 bullets were fired, roughly seven bullets per shooter, of which 57 were found in the basement and at all three subsequent gravesites.[102] Some of Pavel Medvedev's stretcher bearers began frisking the bodies for valuables. Yurovsky saw this and demanded that they surrender any looted items or be shot. The attempted looting, coupled with Ermakov's incompetence and drunken state, convinced Yurovsky to oversee the disposal of the bodies himself.[112] Only Alexei's spaniel, Joy, survived to be rescued by a British officer of the Allied Intervention Force,[114] living out his final days in Windsor, Berkshire.[115]

Alexandre Beloborodov sent a coded telegram to Lenin's secretary, Nikolai Gorbunov. It was found by White investigator Nikolai Sokolov and reads:[116]

Inform Sverdlov the whole family have shared the same fate as the head. Officially the family will die at the evacuation.[117]

Aleksandr Lisitsyn of the Cheka, an essential witness on behalf of Moscow, was designated to promptly dispatch to Sverdlov soon after the executions of Nicholas and Alexandra's politically valuable diaries and letters, which would be published in Russia as soon as possible.[118] Beloborodov and Nikulin oversaw the ransacking of the Romanov quarters, seizing all the family's personal items, the most valuable piled up in Yurovsky's office whilst things considered inconsequential and of no value were stuffed into the stoves and burned. Everything was packed into the Romanovs' own trunks for dispatch to Moscow under escort by commissars.[119] On 19 July, the Bolsheviks nationalized all confiscated Romanov properties,[64] the same day Sverdlov announced the tsar's execution to the Council of People's Commissars.[120]

Disposal

The bodies of the Romanovs and their servants were loaded onto a Fiat truck equipped with a 60-hp engine,[112] with a cargo area 6 × 10 feet in size.[110] Heavily laden, the vehicle struggled for nine miles on boggy road to reach the Koptyaki forest. Yurovsky was furious when he discovered that the drunken Ermakov had brought only one shovel for the burial.[121] About half a mile further on, near crossing no. 185 on the line serving the Verkh-Isetsk works, 25 men working for Ermakov were waiting with horses and light carts. These men were all intoxicated and they were outraged that the prisoners were not brought to them alive. They expected to be part of the lynch mob.[122] Yurovsky maintained control of the situation with great difficulty, eventually getting Ermakov's men to shift some of the bodies from the truck onto the carts.[122] A few of Ermakov's men pawed the female bodies for diamonds hidden in their undergarments, two of whom lifted up Alexandra's skirt and fingered her genitals.[122][123] Yurovsky ordered them at gunpoint to back off, dismissing the two who had groped the tsarina's corpse and any others he had caught looting.[123] One of the men sniggered that he could "die in peace",[122] having touched the "royal cunt".[123]

In the hasty disposal of the bodies, several belongings like these topazes were overlooked by Yurovsky's men and eventually recovered by Sokolov in 1919.[15]

The truck was bogged down in an area of marshy ground near the Gorno-Uralsk railway line, during which all the bodies were unloaded onto carts and taken to the disposal site.[122] The sun was up by the time the carts came within sight of the disused mine, which was a large clearing at a place called the 'Four Brothers'.[124] Yurovsky's men ate hardboiled eggs supplied by the local nuns (food that was meant for the imperial family), while the remainder of Ermakov's men were ordered back to the city as Yurovsky did not trust them and was displeased with their drunkenness.[4]

Yurovsky and five other men laid out the bodies on the grass and undressed them, the clothes piled up and burned while Yurovsky took inventory of their jewellery. Only Maria's undergarments contained no jewels, which to Yurovsky was proof that the family had ceased to trust her ever since she became too friendly with one of the guards back in May.[4][125] Once the bodies were "completely naked" they were dumped into a mineshaft and doused with sulphuric acid to disfigure them beyond recognition. Only then did Yurovsky discover that the pit was less than 3 metres (9 feet) deep and the muddy water below did not fully submerge the corpses as he had expected. He unsuccessfully tried to collapse the mine with hand grenades, after which his men covered it with loose earth and branches.[126] Yurovsky left three men to guard the site while he returned to Yekaterinburg with a bag filled with 18 lb of looted diamonds, to report back to Beloborodov and Goloshchyokin. It was decided that the pit was too shallow.[127]

Sergey Chutskaev of the local Soviet told Yurovsky of some deeper copper mines west of Yekaterinburg, the area remote and swampy and a grave there less likely to be discovered.[83] He inspected the site on the evening of 17 July and reported back to the Cheka at the Amerikanskaya Hotel. He ordered additional trucks to be sent out to Koptyaki whilst assigning Pyotr Voykov to obtain barrels of petrol, kerosene and sulphuric acid, and plenty of dry firewood. Yurovsky also seized several horse-drawn carts to be used in the removal of the bodies to the new site.[128] Yurovsky and Goloshchyokin, along with several Cheka agents, returned to the mineshaft at about 4 am on the morning of 18 July. The sodden corpses were hauled out one by one using ropes tied to their mangled limbs and laid under a tarpaulin.[127] Yurovsky, worried that he might not have enough time to take the bodies to the deeper mine, ordered his men to dig another burial pit then and there, but the ground was too hard. He returned to the Amerikanskaya Hotel to confer with the Cheka. He seized a truck which he had loaded with blocks of concrete for attaching to the bodies before submerging them in the new mineshaft. A second truck carried a detachment of Cheka agents to help move the bodies. Yurovsky returned to the forest at 10 pm on 18 July. The bodies were again loaded onto the Fiat truck, which by then had been extricated from the mud.[129]

Railroad ties on the Koptyaki Road in 1919. Investigator Nikolai Sokolov took this photograph as evidence of where the Fiat truck had got stuck at 4:30am on 19 July, unaware that it was in fact the second burial site.[130]

During transportation to the deeper copper mines on the early morning of 19 July, the Fiat truck carrying the bodies got stuck again in mud near Porosenkov Log ("Piglet's Ravine"). With the men exhausted, most refusing to obey orders and dawn approaching, Yurovsky decided to bury them under the road where the truck had stalled.[131] They dug a grave that was 6 × 8 ft in size and barely 60 centimetres (2 ft) deep.[132] Alexei Trupp's body was tossed in first, followed by the Tsar's and then the rest. Sulphuric acid was again used to dissolve the bodies, their faces smashed with rifle butts and covered with quicklime. Railroad ties were placed over the grave to disguise it, with the Fiat truck being driven back and forth over the ties to press them into the earth. The burial was completed at 6 am on 19 July.[132]

Yurovsky separated the Tsarevich Alexei and one of his sisters to be buried about 15 metres (50 ft) away, in an attempt to confuse anyone who might discover the mass grave with only nine bodies. Since the female body was badly disfigured, Yurovsky mistook her for Anna Demidova; in his report he wrote that he had actually wanted to destroy Alexandra's corpse.[133] Alexei and his sister were burned in a bonfire and their remaining charred bones were thoroughly smashed with spades and tossed into a smaller pit.[132] 44 partial bone fragments from both corpses were found in August 2007.[134]

Sokolov's investigation

After Yekaterinburg fell to the anti-communist White Army on 25 July, Admiral Alexander Kolchak established the Sokolov Commission to investigate the murders at the end of that month. Nikolai Sokolov, a legal investigator for the Omsk Regional Court, was appointed to undertake this. He interviewed several members of the Romanov entourage in February 1919, notably Pierre Gilliard, Alexandra Tegleva and Sydney Gibbes.[135]

The Sokolov investigation inspecting the mineshaft in Spring 1919

The remains of the dog "Jimmy" found by Sokolov

Sokolov discovered a large number of the Romanovs' belongings and valuables that were overlooked by Yurovsky and his men in and around the mineshaft where the bodies were initially disposed. Among them were burned bone fragments, congealed fat,[136] Dr Botkin's upper dentures and glasses, corset stays, insignias and belt buckles, shoes, keys, pearls and diamonds,[14] a few spent bullets, and part of a severed female finger.[106] The corpse of Anastasia's King Charles Spaniel, Jimmy, was also found in the pit.[137] The pit revealed no traces of clothing, which was consistent with Yurovsky's account that all the victims' clothes were burned.[138]

Sokolov ultimately failed to find the concealed burial site on the Koptyaki Road; he photographed the spot as evidence of where the Fiat truck had become stuck on the morning of 19 July.[130] The impending return of Bolshevik forces in July 1919 forced him to evacuate, and he brought the box containing the relics he recovered.[139] Sokolov accumulated eight volumes of photographic and eyewitness accounts.[140] He died in France in 1924 of a heart attack before he could complete his investigation.[141] The box is stored in the Russian Orthodox Church of Saint Job in Uccle, Brussels.[142]

Recovered Romanov belongings on display at the Holy Trinity Seminary in Jordanville, New York. On the right is a blouse that belonged to one of the grand duchesses.[143]

His preliminary report was published in a book that same year in French and then Russian. It was published in English in 1925. Until 1989, it was the only accepted historical account of the murders.[16] He wrongly concluded that the prisoners died instantly from the shooting, with the exception of Alexei and Anastasia, who were shot and bayoneted to death,[144] and that the bodies were destroyed in a massive bonfire.[145] Publication and worldwide acceptance of the investigation prompted the Soviets to issue a government-approved textbook in 1926 that largely plagiarized Sokolov's work, admitting that the empress and her children had been murdered with the Tsar.[16]

The Soviet government continued to attempt to control accounts of the murders. In 1938, during a period of purges, Joseph Stalin issued a clampdown on all discussion of the Romanov murders.[18] Sokolov's report was also banned.[130] Leonid Brezhnev's Politburo deemed the Ipatiev House of lacking "sufficient historical significance" and it was demolished in September 1977 by KGB chairman Yuri Andropov,[9] less than a year before the sixtieth anniversary of the murders. Yeltsin wrote in his memoirs that "sooner or later we will be ashamed of this piece of barbarism". The destruction of the house did not stop pilgrims or monarchists from visiting the site.[18]

Local amateur sleuth Alexander Avdonin and filmmaker Geli Ryabov located the shallow grave on 30–31 May 1979 after years of covert investigation and a study of the primary evidence.[18][130] Three skulls were removed from the grave, but after failing to find any scientist and laboratory to help examine them, and worried about the consequences of finding the grave, Avdonin and Ryabov reburied them in the summer of 1980.[146] The presidency of Mikhail Gorbachev brought with it the era of glasnost (openness) and perestroika (reform), which prompted Ryabov to reveal the Romanovs' gravesite to The Moscow News on 10 April 1989,[146] much to Avdonin's dismay.[147] The remains were disinterred in 1991 by Soviet officials in a hasty 'official exhumation' that wrecked the site, destroying precious evidence. Since there were no clothes on the bodies and the damage inflicted was extensive, controversy persisted as to whether the skeletal remains identified and interred in St. Petersburg as Anastasia's were really hers or in fact Maria's.[20]

On 29 July 2007, another amateur group of local enthusiasts found the small pit containing the remains of Alexei and his sister, located in two small bonfire sites not far from the main grave on the Koptyaki Road.[20][148] Although criminal investigators and geneticists identified them as Alexei and Maria, they remain stored in the state archives pending a decision from the church,[149] which demanded a more "thorough and detailed" examination.[134]

Executioners

Peter Ermakov survived the civil war unscathed; however, unlike the other killers, he received no awards or advancements, for which he grew bitter. For the rest of his life,[150] he fought relentlessly for primacy by inflating his role in the murders as well as the revolution.[151] Local Communist Party members annually pay tribute to his gravestone on the anniversary of the murders, though on a few occasions it was also vandalized.[152]

Ivan Plotnikov, history professor at the Maksim Gorky Ural State University, has established that the executioners were Yakov Yurovsky, Grigory P. Nikulin, Mikhail A. Medvedev (Kuprin), Peter Ermakov, Stepan Vaganov, Alexey G. Kabanov (former soldier in the tsar's Life Guards and Chekist assigned to the attic machine gun),[48] Pavel Medvedev, V. N. Netrebin, and Y. M. Tselms. Filipp Goloshchyokin, a close associate of Yakov Sverdlov, being a military commissar of the Uralispolkom in Yekaterinburg, however did not actually participate, and two or three guards refused to take part.[153] Pyotr Voykov was given the specific task of arranging for the disposal of their remains, obtaining 570 litres (150 gal) of gasoline and 180 kilograms (400 lbs) of sulphuric acid, the latter from the Yekaterinburg pharmacy. He was a witness but later claimed to have taken part in the murders, looting belongings from a dead grand duchess.[110] After the killings, he was to declare that "The world will never know what we did with them." Voykov served as Soviet ambassador to Poland in 1924, where he was assassinated by a Russian monarchist in July 1927.[114]

The men who were directly complicit in the murder of the imperial family largely survived in the immediate months after the murders.[114] Stepan Vaganov, Ermakov's close associate,[154] was attacked and killed by peasants in late 1918 for his participation in local acts of brutal repression by the Cheka. Pavel Medvedev, head of the Ipatiev House guard and one of the key figures in the murders,[67] was captured by the White Army in Perm in February 1919. During his interrogation he denied taking part in the murders, and died in prison of typhus.[114] Alexandre Beloborodov and his deputy, Boris Didkovsky, were both killed in 1938 during the Great Purge. Filipp Goloshchyokin was shot in October 1941 in an NKVD prison and consigned to an unmarked grave.[151]

Three days after the murders, Yurovsky personally reported to Lenin on the events of that night and was rewarded with an appointment to the Moscow City Cheka. He held a succession of key economic and party posts, dying in the Kremlin Hospital in 1938 aged 60. Prior to his death, he donated the guns he used in the murders to the Museum of the Revolution in Moscow,[74] and left behind three valuable, though contradictory, accounts of the event.

A British officer who met Yurovsky in 1920 alleged that he was remorseful over his role in the execution of the Romanovs.[155] However, in a final letter that was written to his children shortly before his death in 1938, he only reminisced about his revolutionary career and how "the storm of October" had "turned its brightest side" towards him, making him "the happiest of mortals";[156] there was no expression of regret or remorse over the murders.[9] Yurovsky and his assistant, Nikulin, who died in 1964, are buried in the Novodevichy Cemetery in Moscow.[157] His son, Alexander Yurovsky, voluntarily handed over his father's memoirs to amateur investigators Avdonin and Ryabov in 1978.[158]

Lenin saw the House of Romanov as "monarchist filth, a 300-year disgrace",[82] and referred to Nicholas II in conversation and in his writings as "the most evil enemy of the Russian people, a bloody executioner, an Asiatic gendarme" and "a crowned robber."[159] A written record outlining the chain of command and tying the ultimate responsibility for the fate of the Romanovs back to Lenin was either never made or carefully concealed.[82] Lenin operated with extreme caution, his favored method being to issue instructions in coded telegrams, insisting that the original and even the telegraph ribbon on which it was sent be destroyed. Uncovered documents in Archive No. 2 (Lenin), Archive No. 86 (Sverdlov) as well as the archives of the Council of People's Commissars and the Central Executive Committee reveal that a host of party 'errand boys' were regularly designated to relay his instructions, either by confidential notes or anonymous directives made in the collective name of the Council of People's Commissars.[33] In all such decisions Lenin regularly insisted that no written evidence be preserved. The 55 volumes of Lenin's Collected Works as well as the memoirs of those who directly took part in the murders were scrupulously censored, emphasizing the roles of Sverdlov and Goloshchyokin.

Lenin was, however, aware of Vasily Yakovlev's decision to take Nicholas, Alexandra and Maria further on to Omsk instead of Yekaterinburg in April 1918, having become worried about the extremely threatening behavior of the Ural Soviets in Tobolsk and along the Trans-Siberian Railway. The Biographical Chronicle of Lenin's political life confirms that first Lenin (between 6 and 7 pm) and then Lenin and Sverdlov together (between 9:30 and 11:50 pm) had direct telegraph contact with the Ural Soviets about Yakovlev's change of route. Despite Yakovlev's request to take the family further away to the more remote Simsky Gorny District in Ufa province (where they could hide in the mountains), warning that "the baggage" would be destroyed if given to the Ural Soviets, Lenin and Sverdlov were adamant that they be brought to Yekaterinburg.[160] On 16 July, the editors of Danish newspaper Nationaltidende queried Lenin to "kindly wire facts" in regards to a rumour that Nicholas II "has been murdered"; he responded, "Rumor not true. Ex-tsar safe. All rumors are only lies of capitalist press." By this time, however, the coded telegram ordering the execution of Nicholas, his family and retinue had already been sent to Yekaterinburg.[161]

Lenin also welcomed news of the death of Grand Duchess Elizabeth, who was murdered in Alapayevsk along with five other Romanovs on 18 July 1918, remarking that "virtue with the crown on it is a greater enemy to the world revolution than a hundred tyrant tsars".[162][163] Soviet historiography portrayed Nicholas as a weak and incompetent leader whose decisions led to military defeats and the deaths of millions of his subjects,[35] while Lenin's reputation was protected at all costs, thus ensuring that no discredit was brought on him; responsibility for the 'liquidation' of the Romanov family was directed at the Ural Soviets and Yekaterinburg Cheka.[33]

Aftermath

The Church of All Saints, built on the spot of the Ipatiev House

The final resting places of the Romanov family and their servants in St. Catherine's Chapel in the Peter and Paul Cathedral. The names of Maria (third from right) and Alexei (far left) on the wall do not have a burial date inscribed at the bottom.

Early the next morning, when rumors spread in Yekaterinburg about the disposal site, Yurovsky removed the bodies and hid them elsewhere (56.942222°N 60.473333°E / 56.942222; 60.473333). When the vehicle carrying the bodies broke down on the way to the next chosen site, Yurovsky made new arrangements, and buried most of the acid-covered bodies in a pit sealed and concealed with rubble, covered over with railroad ties and then earth (56.9113628°N 60.4954326°E / 56.9113628; 60.4954326) on Koptyaki Road, a cart track (subsequently abandoned) 19 kilometres (12 mi) north of Yekaterinburg.

On the afternoon of 19 July, Filipp Goloshchyokin announced at the Opera House on Glavny Prospekt that "Nicholas the bloody" had been shot and his family taken to another place.[164] Sverdlov granted permission for the local paper in Yekaterinburg to publish the "Execution of Nicholas, the Bloody Crowned Murderer – Shot without Bourgeois Formalities but in Accordance with our new democratic principles",[120] along with the coda that "the wife and son of Nicholas Romanov have been sent to a safe place".[165] An official announcement appeared in the national press, two days later. It reported that the monarch had been executed on the order of Uralispolkom under pressure posed by the approach of the Czechoslovaks.[166]

Over the course of 84 days after the Yekaterinburg murders, 27 more friends and relatives (14 Romanovs and 13 members of the imperial entourage and household)[167] were murdered by the Bolsheviks: at Alapayevsk on 18 July,[168] Perm on 4 September,[61] and the Peter and Paul Fortress on 24 January 1919.[167] Unlike the imperial family, the bodies at Alapayevsk and Perm were recovered by the White Army in October 1918 and May 1919 respectively.[61][169] However, only the final resting places of Grand Duchess Elizabeth Feodorovna and her faithful companion Sister Varvara Yakovleva are known today, buried alongside each other in the Church of Mary Magdalene in Jerusalem.

Although official Soviet accounts place the responsibility for the decision with the Uralispolkom, an entry in Leon Trotsky's diary reportedly suggested that the order had been given by Lenin himself. Trotsky wrote:

My next visit to Moscow took place after the fall of Yekaterinburg. Talking to Sverdlov I asked in passing, "Oh yes and where is the Tsar?" "It's all over," he answered. "He has been shot." "And where is his family?" "And the family with him." "All of them?" I asked, apparently with a touch of surprise. "All of them," replied Yakov Sverdlov. "What about it?" He was waiting to see my reaction. I made no reply. "And who made the decision?" I asked. "We decided it here. Ilyich [Lenin] believed that we shouldn't leave the Whites a live banner to rally around, especially under the present difficult circumstances."[27]

However, as of 2011, there has been no conclusive evidence that either Lenin or Sverdlov gave the order.[28] V. N. Solovyov, the leader of the Investigative Committee of Russia's 1993 investigation on the shooting of the Romanov family,[29] has concluded that there is no reliable document that indicates that either Lenin or Sverdlov were responsible.[30][31] He declared:

According to the presumption of innocence, no one can be held criminally liable without guilt being proven. In the criminal case, an unprecedented search for archival sources taking all available materials into account was conducted by authoritative experts, such as Sergey Mironenko, the director of the largest archive in the country, the State Archive of the Russian Federation. The study involved the main experts on the subject – historians and archivists. And I can confidently say that today there is no reliable document that would prove the initiative of Lenin and Sverdlov.

— V. N. Solovyov[30]

In 1993, the report of Yakov Yurovsky from 1922 was published. According to the report, units of the Czechoslovak Legion were approaching Yekaterinburg. On 17 July 1918, Yakov and other Bolshevik jailers, fearing that the Legion would free Nicholas after conquering the town, murdered him and his family. The next day, Yakov departed for Moscow with a report to Sverdlov. As soon as the Czechoslovaks seized Yekaterinburg, his apartment was pillaged.[170]

Skull of Skeleton №4 (Nikolai Romanov)

Over the years, a number of people claimed to be survivors of the ill-fated family. In May 1979, the remains of most of the family and their retainers were found by amateur enthusiasts, who kept the discovery secret until the collapse of Communism.[171] In July 1991, the bodies of five family members (the Tsar, Tsarina, and three of their daughters) were exhumed.[172] After forensic examination[173] and DNA identification,[174] the bodies were laid to rest with state honors in the St. Catherine Chapel of the Peter and Paul Cathedral in Saint Petersburg, where most other Russian monarchs since Peter the Great lie.[22] Boris Yeltsin and his wife attended the funeral along with Romanov relations, including Prince Michael of Kent. The Holy Synod opposed the government's decision in February 1998 to bury the remains in the Peter and Paul Fortress, preferring a "symbolic" grave until their authenticity had been resolved.[175] As a result, when they were interred in July 1998, they were referred to by the priest conducting the service as "Christian victims of the Revolution" rather than the imperial family.[176] Patriarch Alexy II, who felt that the Church was sidelined in the investigation, refused to officiate at the burial and banned bishops from taking part in the funeral ceremony.[22]

The remaining two bodies of Tsesarevich Alexei and one of his sisters were discovered in 2007.[134][177]

On 15 August 2000, the Russian Orthodox Church announced the canonization of the family for their "humbleness, patience and meekness".[178] However, reflecting the intense debate preceding the issue, the bishops did not proclaim the Romanovs as martyrs, but passion bearers instead (see Romanov sainthood).[178]

Over the years 2000 to 2003, the Church of All Saints, Yekaterinburg was built on the site of Ipatiev House.

On 1 October 2008, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation ruled that Nicholas II and his family were victims of political repression and rehabilitated them.[179][180] The rehabilitation was denounced by the Communist Party of the Russian Federation, vowing the decision will "sooner or later be corrected".[181]

On Thursday, 26 August 2010, a Russian court ordered prosecutors to reopen an investigation into the murder of Tsar Nicholas II and his family, although the Bolsheviks believed to have shot them in 1918 had died long before. The Russian Prosecutor General's main investigative unit said it had formally closed a criminal investigation into the killing of Nicholas because too much time had elapsed since the crime and because those responsible had died. However, Moscow's Basmanny Court ordered the re-opening of the case, saying that a Supreme Court ruling blaming the state for the killings made the deaths of the actual gunmen irrelevant, according to a lawyer for the Tsar's relatives and local news agencies.[182]

In late 2015, at the insistence by the Russian Orthodox Church,[183] Russian investigators exhumed the bodies of Nicholas II and his wife, Alexandra, for additional DNA testing,[184] which confirmed that the bones were of the couple.[185][186][187]

A survey conducted by the Russian Public Opinion Research Center on 11 July 2018 revealed that 57% of Russians aged 35+ "believe that the execution of the Royal family is a heinous unjustified crime", 46% among those aged between 18 and 24 believe that Nicholas II had to be punished for his mistakes, and 3% "were certain that the Royal family's execution was the public's just retribution for the emperor's blunders".[188] On the centenary of the murders, over 100,000 pilgrims took part in a procession led by Patriarch Kirill in Yekaterinburg, marching from the city center where the Romanovs were murdered to a monastery in Ganina Yama.[189] There is a widespread legend that the remains of the Romanovs were completely destroyed at the Ganina Yama during the ritual murder and a profitable pilgrimage business developed there. Therefore, the found remains of the martyrs, as well as the place of their burial in the Porosyonkov Log, are ignored.[190] On the eve of the anniversary Russian government announced that its new probe had confirmed once again that the bodies were the Romanovs’. The state also remained aloof from the celebration, as Putin considers Nicholas II a weak ruler.[191]

See also

• Ganina Yama
• List of unsolved murders
• Regicide

References

1. Sokolov, Nikolai A. Ubiistvo Tsarskoi Sem’i (Убийство царской семьи). / Slowo-Verlag. Berlin/ 1925/ p. 191
2. William H. Honan (12 August 1992), A Playwright Applies His Craft To Czar Nicholas II's Last Days, New York Times, retrieved 25 February 2017
3. Massie, Robert K. (2012). The Romanovs: The Final Chapter. Random House. pp. 3–24.
4. Rappaport, p. 198.
5. Sokolov, Nikolai A. Ubiistvo Tsarskoi Sem’i. Terra, Moscow (1925/reprinted 1996)
6. Clifford J. Levy (25 November 2007), Sleuths say they've found the last Romanovs, The New York Times, retrieved 30 September 2016
7. «17/VII 1918 в Екатеринбурге (ныне Свердловск), в связи с угрозой занятия города белыми, по постановлению Уральского областного совета бывший царь Николай Романов вместе с членами его семьи и приближенными был расстрелян». — Большая советская энциклопедия / гл. ред. О. Ю. Шмидт. - Москва : Советская энциклопедия, 1926-. Т. 49: Робер - Ручная граната. - 1941. / статья: «Романовы» / кол. 134
8. «3 (16)/VII 1918 при приближении к Екатеринбургу чехословацких контрреволюционных войск Николай II со всей семьей был расстрелян». — Большая советская энциклопедия / гл. ред. О. Ю. Шмидт. - Москва : Советская энциклопедия, 1926-. Т. 42: Нидерланды - Оклагома. - 1939. / статья: «Николай II» / кол. 137
9. Pringle, p. 261.
10. From the archive, 22 July 1918: Ex-tsar Nicholas II executed, The Guardian, 22 July 2015, retrieved 29 September 2016
11. Joshua Hammer (November 2010), Resurrecting the Czar, Smithsonian, retrieved 29 September 2016
12. Wendy Slater, p. 153.
13. Massie, p. 16.
14. Rappaport, p. 218.
15. Photographic scans of Sokolov's investigation, published in 1924, 18 December 2015, retrieved 9 March 2017
16. Massie, p. 19.
17. Erin Blakemore (18 October 2018), Why the Romanov Family’s Fate Was a Secret Until the Fall of the Soviet Union, History, retrieved 20 October 2018
18. Rappaport, p. 219.
19. Michael D. Coble (26 September 2011), The identification of the Romanovs: Can we (finally) put the controversies to rest?, Investigative Genetics, retrieved 30 September 2016
20. Rappaport, p. 220.
21. The mystery of the Romanovs' untimely demise - Page 4, Russia Beyond the Headlines, archived from the original on 16 January 2017, retrieved 15 January 2017
22. "Romanovs laid to rest". BBC News. 17 July 1998.
23. Alec Luhn (23 September 2015), Russia reopens criminal case on 1918 Romanov royal family murders, The Guardian, retrieved 30 September 2016
24. Rappaport, Four Sisters (2014), p. 381.
25. Robert Gellately. Lenin, Stalin, and Hitler: The Age of Social Catastrophe Knopf, 2007 ISBN 1-4000-4005-1 p. 65.
26. Figes, Orlando (1997). A People's Tragedy: The Russian Revolution 1891–1924. Penguin Books. p. 638. ISBN 0-19-822862-7.
27. King, G. (1999). The Last Empress, Replica Books, p. 358. ISBN 0735101043.
28. The Daily Telegraph (17 January 2011). "No proof Lenin ordered last Tsar's murder".
29. "Расследование убийства Николая II и его семьи, продолжавшееся 18 лет, объявлено завершенным" (in Russian). НТВ-новости. Archived from the original on 11 February 2013. Retrieved 29 December 2012.
30. ""Уголовное дело цесаревича Алексея". На вопросы обозревателя "Известий" Татьяны Батенёвой ответил следователь по особо важным делам Следственного комитета Российской Федерации Владимир Соловьёв". 17 January 2011.
31. Интервью следователя Соловьёв, Владимир Николаевич (следователь) – В. Н. Соловьёва и Аннинский, Лев Александрович – Л. А. Аннинского (2008). Расстрельный дом (in Russian). Archived from the original on 1 May 2015.CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
32. Serge, Victor (1932). Year One of the Russian Revolution. Chicago: Haymarket (published 2015). p. 315. ISBN 9781608462674.
33. Rappaport, p. 142.
34. The Associated Press (18 July 1998), Address by Yeltsin: 'We Are All Guilty', The New York Times, retrieved 3 April 2017
35. Martin Vennard (27 June 2012), Tsar Nicholas - exhibits from an execution, BBC News, retrieved 3 April 2017
36. Tames, p. 56.
37. Tames, p. 62.
38. Rappaport, p. 22.
39. Rappaport, Four Sisters (2014), p. 371.
40. Rappaport, p. 20.
41. Rappaport, p. 23.
42. Rappaport, p. 102.
43. Rappaport, p. 31.
44. Rappaport, Four Sisters (2014), p. 372.
45. Massie, p. 283.
46. King, G., and Wilson, P., (year) p. 127.
47. Rappaport, p. 27.
48. Radzinsky, p. 383.
49. John Browne, Hidden Account of the Romanovs, p. 471.
50. Massie, p. 278.
51. Rappaport, p. 16.
52. Massie, p. 289.
53. Rappaport, p. 17.
54. Rappaport, pp. 118–119.
55. Rappaport, pp. 17–18.
56. Rappaport, p. 29.
57. Rappaport, p. 21.
58. Rappaport, p. 25.
59. Rappaport, p. 24.
60. Rappaport, p. 34.
61. Rappaport, Four Sisters (2014), p. 377.
62. Rappaport, Four Sisters (2014), p. xv.
63. Rappaport, Four Sisters (2014), p. xiv.
64. Rappaport, p. 157.
65. Rappaport, p. 159.
66. Rappaport, p. 160.
67. Rappaport, p. 171.
68. Rappaport, p. 97.
69. Rappaport, p. 140.
70. Rappaport, pp. 86–87.
71. Bullock, David (2012) The Czech Legion 1914–20, Osprey Publishing ISBN 1780964587
72. Rappaport, p. 130.
73. Rappaport, p. 125.
74. Slater, p. 53.
75. Rappaport, p. 120.
76. Rappaport, p. 144.
77. Rappaport, p. 132.
78. Rappaport, p. 134.
79. Rappaport, pp. 34–35.
80. Rappaport, p. 117.
81. Rappaport, Four Sisters (2014), p. 378.
82. Rappaport, p. 141.
83. Rappaport, p. 201.
84. Rappaport, p. 167.
85. Rappaport, p. 168.
86. Rappaport, p. 186.
87. Rappaport, p. 176.
88. Rappaport, p. 178.
89. Rappaport, pp. 178–179.
90. Rappaport, p. 180.
91. Rappaport, p. 181.
92. Montefiore, p. 644.
93. Rappaport, p. 182.
94. Rappaport, pp. 175–176.
95. Rappaport, pp. 179–180.
96. Massie (2012). The Romanovs: The Final Chapter. pp. 3–24.
97. Massie (2012). The Romanovs: The Final Chapter. p. 4.
98. Slater, p. 5.
99. William Clarke (2003). The Lost Fortune of the Tsars. St. Martin's Press. p. 66.
100. 100 великих казней, M., Вече, 1999, p. 439 ISBN 5-7838-0424-X
101. Montefiore, p. 645.
102. Rappaport, p. 193.
103. Rappaport, pp. 189–190.
104. Greg King; Penny Wilson (6 July 2014). The Fate of the Romanovs. Lulu.com. p. 357. ISBN 978-1-312-33381-9.
105. Rappaport, p. 191.
106. Massie, p. 8.
107. King, G., and Wilson, P., The Fate of the Romonovs, p. 303.
108. Massie, p. 6.
109. Radzinsky (1992), pp. 380–393.
110. Rappaport, p. 194.
111. Jeffrey A. Frank (19 July 1992), RELIVING A MASSACRE, The Washington Post, retrieved 2 October 2016
112. Slater, p. 8.
113. Rappaport, p. 192.
114. Rappaport, p. 214.
115. Kate Baklitskaya, Go East (21 January 2014), Royal dog fled from Siberia into British exile, living in shadow of Windsor Castle, The Siberian Times, archived from the original on 11 July 2017, retrieved 13 March 2017
116. Excerpt of Sokolov's investigation, archived from the original on 12 March 2017, retrieved 9 March 2017
117. Из архива сэра Чарльза Элиота, 18 December 2015, retrieved 9 March 2017
118. Rappaport, p. 195.
119. Rappaport, p. 200.
120. Rappaport, p. 208.
121. Rappaport, p. 196.
122. Rappaport, p. 197.
123. Slater, p. 9.
124. Slater, p. 10.
125. Montefiore, p. 639.
126. Rappaport, p. 199.
127. Rappaport, p. 203.
128. Rappaport, p. 202.
129. Rappaport, p. 204.
130. Massie, p. 26.
131. Slater, pp. 13–14.
132. Rappaport, p. 205.
133. Massie, p. 27.
134. Luke Harding (25 August 2007). "Bones found by Russian builder finally solve riddle of the missing Romanovs". The Guardian. Retrieved 13 March 2017.
135. Rappaport, Four Sisters (2014), p. 379.
136. Massie, p. 124.
137. Massie, p. 10.
138. Massie, p. 39.
139. Massie, p. 123.
140. Rappaport, p. 212.
141. Alla Astanina (18 April 2015), Nikolai Sokolov: The man who revealed the story of the Romanov killings, Russia Beyond the Headlines, retrieved 10 March 2017
142. Remnick, Reporting: Writings from the New Yorker, p. 222.
143. Eve M. Kahn (3 April 2014), Treasures and Trivia of the Romanov Era, New York Times, retrieved 30 March 2017
144. Sokolov, p. 12
145. Slater, p. 45.
146. Massie, p. 30.
147. Massie, p. 31.
148. Russia dig finds 'tsar's family', BBC News, 24 August 2007, retrieved 13 March 2017
149. Anna Malpas, 100 years on, debate rolls on over Russia's last tsar, Yahoo News, retrieved 13 March 2017
150. Radzinsky, p. 397.
151. Rappaport, p. 215.
152. Paul Gilbert (18 July 2014), Communists Lay Flowers at the Grave of the Murderer of Russia's Imperial Family, Royal Russia News, archived from the original on 2 February 2017, retrieved 1 October 2016
153. Plotnikov, Ivan (2003). О команде убийц царской семьи и ее национальном составе Журнальный зал, No. 9 (in Russian)
154. Rappaport, p. 127.
155. Yakov Yurovsky, a biographical sketch adapted from King, Greg; Wilson, Penny (2005). The Fate of the Romanovs. Wiley. ISBN 978-0471727972.
156. Rappaport, p. 216.
157. Radzinsky, p. 430.
158. Massie, p. 28.
159. Rappaport, p. 137.
160. Rappaport, p. 139.
161. John Curtis Perry, Constantine V. Pleshakov, p. 193
162. The French Revolution and the Russian Anti-Democratic Tradition: A Case of False Consciousness (1997). Dmitry Shlapentokh. Transaction Publishers. ISBN 1-56000-244-1. p. 266.
163. The Speckled Domes (1925). Gerard Shelley. p. 220.
164. Rappaport, p. 206.
165. Rappaport, p. 207.
166. Steinberg, Mark D.; Khrustalëv, Vladimir M.; Tucker, Elizabeth (1995). The Fall of the Romanovs. Yale University Press. ISBN 0-300-07067-5.
167. King & Wilson, Epilogue section.
168. Massie, p. 251.
169. Rappaport, p. 213.
170. "Murder of the Imperial Family – Yurovsky Note 1922 English". Alexander Palace. Retrieved 21 November 2015.
171. Massie, pp. 32–35.
172. Massie, pp. 40 ff.
173. Покаяние. Материалы правительственной комиссии по изучению вопросов, связанных с исследованием и перезахоронением останков Российского Императора Николая II и членов его семьи (Repentance. Proceedings of the government commission to study issues related to the study and reburial of the remains of the Russian Emperor Nicholas II and his family) ISBN 5-87468-039-X
174. Gill, P; Ivanov, PL; Kimpton, C; Piercy, R; Benson, N; Tully, G; Evett, I; Hagelberg, E; Sullivan, K (1994). "Identification of the remains of the Romanov family by DNA analysis". Nature Genetics. 6 (2): 130–5. doi:10.1038/ng0294-130. PMID 8162066.
175. The Last Tsar, Russian Archives Online, retrieved 15 April 2017
176. Rappaport, p. 221.
177. Coble, Michael D.; et al. (2009). "Mystery solved: the identification of the two missing Romanov children using DNA analysis". PLOS ONE. 4 (3): e4838. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0004838. PMC 2652717. PMID 19277206.
178. "Nicholas II And Family Canonized For 'Passion'". New York Times. 15 August 2000. Retrieved 10 December 2008.
179. BBCNews (1 October 2008). Russia's last tsar rehabilitated. Retrieved on 1 October 2008.
180. Blomfield, Adrian (1 October 2008). Russia exonerates Tsar Nicholas II The Telegraph.
181. Last Tsar rehabilitated by Russian justice, France 24, 1 October 2008, retrieved 28 October 2019
182. "Russia: Inquiry Into Czar's Killing Is Reopened". The New York Times. 27 August 2010.
183. "Russia readies to exhume Tsar Alexander III in Romanov probe". AFP.com. Agence France-Presse. 3 November 2015. Archived from the original on 9 November 2015.
184. "Russia exhumes bones of murdered Tsar Nicholas and wife". BBC News. BBC. 24 September 2015. Retrieved 28 June 2018.
185. Porter, Tom (13 November 2015). "New DNA tests establish remains of Tsar Nicholas II and wife are authentic".
186. Editorial, Reuters. "Russia says DNA tests confirm remains of country's last tsar are..."
187. "DNA Testing Verifies Bones of Russia's Last Tsar".
188. Romanov murders: Poll reveals near 60% of Russians see Czar’s family homicide as atrocity, Russian News Agency TASS, 16 July 2018, retrieved 22 July 2018
189. 100,000 Pilgrims March in Memory of the Romanovs on the Centenary of Their Execution, The Moscow Times, 17 July 2018, retrieved 22 July 2018
190. Плужников, Алексей (12 July 2018). "Скандал вокруг царской семьи мешает устоявшемуся бизнесу РПЦ". Московский Комсомолец (in Russian). Retrieved 21 November 2019.
191. On Centenary, Russian State and Orthodox Church at Odds Over Romanovs, The Moscow Times, 18 July 2018, retrieved 22 July 2018

Further reading

• Bykov, Pavel Mikhailovich. The Last Days of Tsar Nicholas. New York: International Publishers. 1935.
• Cross, Anthony (2014). In the Lands of the Romanovs: An Annotated Bibliography of First-hand English-language Accounts of the Russian Empire (1613-1917). Cambridge, UK: Open Book Publishers. 2014. doi:10.11647/OBP.0042
• Massie, Robert K. (2012). The Romanovs: The Final Chapter. Random House.
• McNeal, Shay. The Secret Plot to Save the Tsar: New Truths Behind the Romanov Mystery. HarperCollins, 2003. ISBN 0-06-051755-7, ISBN 978-0-06-051755-7
• Montefiore, Simon Sebag. The Romanovs: 1613-1918, Alfred A. Knopf, 2016. ISBN 978-0307266521
• Pringle, Robert W. Historical Dictionary of Russian and Soviet Intelligence. Rowman & Littlefield, 2015. ISBN 978-1-4422-5318-6 (e-book)
• Radzinsky, Edvard. The last Tsar: the life and death of Nicholas II (Random House, 2011)
• Rappaport, Helen. Four Sisters: The Lost Lives of the Romanov Grand Duchesses. Pan Macmillan, 2014. ISBN 978-1-4472-5935-0
• Rappaport, Helen. The Last Days of the Romanovs: Tragedy at Ekaterinburg. St. Martin's Griffin, 2010. ISBN 978-0312603472
• Rappaport, Helen (2018). The Race to save the Romanoffs. New York: St Martin’s Press. ISBN 978-1-250-15121-6.
• Slater, Wendy. The Many Deaths of Tsar Nicholas II: Relics, Remains and the Romanovs (Routledge, 2007)
• Tames, R. (1972) Last of the Tsars, Pan Books, ISBN 0330029029
• Welch, Frances (2018). The Imperial Tea Party: Family, Politics and Betrayal; The Ill-fated British and Russian Royal Alliance. London: Short Books. ISBN 978-1-78072-306-8.
• John Curtis Perry, Constantine V. Pleshakov. The Flight Of The Romanovs: A Family Saga. Basic Books (A Member of the Perseus Books Group), 1999. ISBN 0-465-02463-7

External links

• In search of the Romanovs (Time.com)
• Execution Of The Romanov Family on YouTube as seen in the movie The Romanovs: An Imperial Family
• Alexander Palace Time Machine