Adolf Hitler and Stefanie Rabatsch

Stefanie Rabatsch (née Isak; born 28 December 1887 – died unknown, after 1973) was an Austrian woman who was allegedly an unrequited love of then-teenage Adolf Hitler, a claim made by Hitler's childhood friend August Kubizek. Her Jewish-sounding maiden name, Isak, has been subject to speculation in this context. However, there is no evidence apart from Kubizek that Hitler ever had such an attachment.

Stefanie Rabatsch
Stefanie Isak in 1907
Born	Stefanie Beata Isak (1887-12-28)December 28, 1887 Niemes, Kingdom of Bohemia, Austria-Hungary
Nationality	Austrian
Known for	Alleged love-interest of Adolf Hitler
Spouse(s)	Maximilian Rabatsch

Kubizek, a childhood friend and later biographer of his childhood experience with Hitler, wrote about Stefanie in his book, Adolf Hitler, My Childhood Friend. He alleges that Hitler fell in love with her after she passed by him during her daily daughter-mother stroll in Linz, glancing at him. In Kubizek's account, although in love with her to the point of suicide, Hitler never once spoke with her, and she later married an Austrian army officer. Stefanie stated in interviews that she was unaware of Hitler's feelings towards her, and little is known about her life.

The one-sided relationship has been discussed in many books. Some question the accuracy of Kubizek's memoir, the only source for the story. Others accept that there is some basis of fact, but downplay the significance of the youthful infatuation, while yet others consider that it gives valuable insight into the development of Hitler's personality.

Background

August Kubizek, a music student from Linz, first met Hitler when the two were competing for a place to stand during an opera performance.[1] According to him, Hitler's passion for Stefanie began in spring 1905, when he was 16 and attending school in Linz, and she was 17; and lasted until 1909, when he was 20.[1][lower-alpha 1] Kubizek describes the first time he heard about Hitler's obsession as follows: "One evening in the spring of 1905, as we were taking our usual stroll, Adolf gripped my arm and asked me excitedly what I thought of that slim blonde girl walking along the Landstrasse arm-in-arm with her mother. 'You must know, I'm in love with her,' he added resolutely."[1]

Stefanie Beata Isak was born on 26 December 1887 in Niemes, Kingdom of Bohemia.[2] She came from a family of higher social class than Hitler's and was more than a year older than him. Stefanie had returned to Linz after professional training in Munich and Geneva.[1] She had a brother, Karl Richard Isak, who was studying law in Vienna.[3] In the 1950s, Dr. Franz Jetzinger had two pictures of Stefanie in her youth, one from 1904 and one in ball dress from 1907.[4] Kubizek describes her as "a distinguished-looking girl, tall and slim. She had thick fair hair, which she mostly wore swept back in a bun. Her eyes were very beautiful".[1]

Alleged interaction with Hitler

According to Kubizek, Hitler never spoke to Stefanie, always saying he would do so "tomorrow".[5] Kubizek wrote that Hitler loathed those who flirted with her, especially the military officers, whom he called "conceited blockheads";[6] he came to feel an "uncompromising enmity towards the officer class as a whole, and everything military in general. It annoyed him that Stefanie mixed with such idlers who, he insisted, wore corsets and used scent".[6]

Hitler insisted that Kubizek stalk Stefanie and delivered daily reports on her activity while he was away visiting his mother or family.[7] In one report, Kubizek wrote that Stefanie loved to dance and had taken lessons. Hitler disliked dancing and reportedly replied, "Stefanie only dances because she is forced to by society on which she unfortunately depends on. Once Stefanie is my wife, she won't have the slightest desire to dance!"[7] In June 1906, Stefanie allegedly gave Hitler a smile and a flower from her bouquet as she was passing him in her carriage.[8] Kubizek later described the scene:

"Never again did I see Adolf as happy as he was at that moment. When the carriage had passed he dragged me aside and with emotion he gazed at the flower, this visible pledge of her love. I can still hear his voice, trembling with excitement, 'She loves me!' "[8]

After Hitler's mother died of breast cancer in 1907, the funeral procession went through Urfahr to Leonding. Kubizek remarks that Hitler said he had seen Stefanie at the funeral procession, which gave him some consolation.[6] Kubizek claims that "Stefanie had no idea how deeply Adolf was in love with her; she regarded him as a somewhat shy, but nevertheless remarkably tenacious and faithful, admirer. When she responded with a smile to his inquiring glance, he was happy and his mood became unlike anything I had ever observed in him. But when Stefanie, as happened just as often, coldly ignored his gaze, he was crushed and ready to destroy himself and the whole world."[6]

Kubizek claims that Hitler finally stated he planned to kidnap Stefanie and kill both her and himself by jumping off a bridge into the Danube.[9] Instead he moved to Vienna, where, according to Kubizek, an idealised image of Stefanie became his moral touchstone.[10] Stefanie stated in later interviews that she was unaware of Hitler at the time, but that she had received an anonymous love letter asking her to wait for him to graduate and then to marry him, which she only realised after being questioned about him, must have been from Hitler.[10] She recalled: "I once received a letter from someone who said they were to attend the Academy of Arts, and that I should wait for him; he could come back and marry me! I had no idea who the letter might have been from or who I should have send it to."[11]

At Christmas in 1913, when he was living in Munich, Hitler was said to have placed an anonymous personal ad in the Linz newspaper with his best wishes to her, but she was already married and in Vienna by then.[12]

Later years

St. Gertrud, Vienna, where Stefanie was married to Maximilian Rabatsch

Little is known about Stefanie's overall life.[11] She became engaged in 1908 to an officer in the Hessian regiment stationed in Linz.[13] On 24 October 1910, Stefanie married Maximilian Rabatsch in Vienna in St. Gertrud, Gertrudplatz 5, in the parish of Währing. Maximilian was appointed captain on 1 November 1909.[14] He was promoted to major on 1 October 1917 and to colonel on 1 August 1918.[4] According to Kubizek, her husband became a high-ranking officer, she was widowed, and after the end of World War II (1939–45) she lived in Vienna.[1]

Stefanie was interviewed and Hitler's alleged love for her dramatised in a 1973 Austro-German television film called A Young Man From the Innviertel.[15] She could not understand why Hitler, if he felt so strongly, had not given her any indication of his attachment, saying, "Hitler would hardly have suffered from too much shyness".[16]

Maiden name

Stefanie's maiden name, Isak, sounds Jewish, although she was not Jewish.[17] Kubizek spelled it Isaak. The correct spelling was identified by Anton Joachimsthaler in his 2003 Hitlers Liste. Ein Dokument persönlicher Beziehungen (Munich, 2003, pp 46–52).[17] Some historians opine that Hitler would have assumed Stefanie was of Jewish origin. American historian Graeme Donald believes Hitler would have inferred that she was Jewish, but saw no problems with this at the time.[18] This view is supported by German historian Anton Joachimsthaler, who stated in a BBC interview that Hitler must have assumed she was Jewish because of her Jewish surname.[11] British singer-songwriter, author, journalist and paranormal researcher Paul Roland wrote in his book Nazi Women that it did not make the slightest difference to Hitler whether she was Jewish or not.[19]

Scholarly reactions

The role of Rabatsch in Hitler's life has been widely studied. Sherree Owens Zalampas, in a book analyzing the relationship between Hitler's views on art and his psychology, notes that the stories about Rabatsch have been rejected by some scholars and accepted by others. Among those who reject stories about Rabatsch are Franz Jetzinger and Bradley F. Smith.[20] Bradley F. Smith discussed the story in his 1967 Adolf Hitler; his family, childhood, and youth.[20] Franz Jetzinger discussed the story in his 1958 Hitler's Youth.[21] Jetzinger attacked Kubizek in his book, but confirmed that Stefanie existed although she did not at the time know of the alleged infatuation.[17] In Jetzinger's analysis, Kubizek overstates the relationship between Rabatsch and Hitler, and some of the interactions Kubizek describes are impossible given the timelines of their lives, and the focus of biographers on the relationship represents a misguided attempt to fabricate an early "love interest" for Hitler.[21] Werner Maser agrees with this view in his 1971 Adolf Hitler: Legende, Mythos, Wirklichkeit, and suggests that Hitler's behavior towards Rabatsch was typical for Austrian adolescents of his era.[20]

Zalampas notes that Kubizek claims that Hitler was interested in Rabatsch's singing voice, which Kubizek claimed was a soprano, and its suitability for singing Wagnerian roles. She suggests that Hitler had a fantasy view of Stefanie which is indicative of the young Hitler's mixing of reality and fantasy and his views about art, war, the novels of Karl May, and Wagnerian themes.[22] Robert G. L. Waite in his 1993 The Psychopathic God: Adolf Hitler writes that Rabatsch "served as a defense against feelings of sexual inadequacy." He suggests that Hitler feared interacting with Rabatsch in person, since her reality may fall short of the ideal of Germanic virtue which Hitler had fantasized she represented. He repeats Kubizek's belief that Hitler left Linz because he was unable to bear remaining in the same place as Rabatsch.[23]

Kubizek's story has been touched on by a number of other writers. William L. Shirer drew on Kubizek's account of the one-sided romance in his 1960 The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich.[24] In 1973 Der Spiegel reported that the German and Austrian broadcasters ZDF and ORF had produced a TV docudrama on Hitler's youth that portrayed the story of his infatuation with Stefanie Rabatsch.[15] Brigitte Hamann draws on the story in her 2010 Hitler's Vienna: A Portrait of the Tyrant as a Young Man.[25] Rose Montero draws on Kubizek's account in her 2013 Dictadoras: Las mujeres de los hombres más despiadados de la historia.[26] Danielle Zumbo cites Kubizek in her 2013 Operazione Stalingrado: Storia di un eroe.[27]

Hugh Trevor-Roper considered Kubizek's memoirs to be a valuable examination of Hitler's early life, and said, "... it will have an important place among the source books of history."[28] Ian Kershaw relates the story in his 2008 Hitler: A Biography.[29] Kershaw felt that Kubizek had been helped in creating his book by a ghostwriter.[30] He considers the story of Stefanie exaggerated, writing, "There can be little doubt that Kubizek greatly embellishes what was at most a passing juvenile infatuation."[17] However, Kershaw concludes that although Kubizek's book has weaknesses it also has intrinsic value as a portrait of the young Hitler.[31] Frederic Spotts in his 2009 Hitler and the Power of Aesthetics notes that no documentation or sources other than Kubizek's book provide any substantiation for the alleged infatuation.[32]

References

Notes

1. Historian Brigitte Hamann believes It is more likely to have begun in spring 1906, by which time he had dropped out of school.[33]

Citations

1. Kubizek 2011, p. 66.
2. Bruppacher 2014, p. 16.
3. Joachimsthaler 2003, p. 48.
4. Joachimsthaler 2003, p. 51.
5. Kubizek 2011, p. 74.
6. Kubizek 2011, p. 67.
7. Kubizek 2011, pp. 68–69.
8. Kubizek 2011, p. 70.
9. Kubizek 2011, p. 69.
10. Kubizek 2011, p. 216.
11. TimeWatch 2015.
12. Hamann 1999, p. 262.
13. Hamann 1999, p. 30.
14. Joachimsthaler 2003, p. 50.
15. Hitler Film – Der Spiegel 2015.
16. Joachimsthaler 2003, p. 52.
17. Kershaw 2011, p. 13.
18. Donald 2009, p. 80.
19. Roland 2014, p. 6.
20. Zalampas 1990, p. 151.
21. Jetzinger 1958, pp. 105–108.
22. Zalampas 1990, p. 14.
23. Waite 1993, pp. 179–180, 190–191.
24. Shirer 2011, p. 15.
25. Hamann 2010, pp. 25ff.
26. Montero 2013, p. 43.
27. Zumbo 2013, pt10.
28. Trevor-Roper 1955, p. 3.
29. Kershaw 2008, p. 13.
30. Kershaw 2011, p. 11.
31. Kershaw 2011, p. 15.
32. Spotts 2009, pp. xv–xvi.
33. Hamann 1999, pp. 24–25.

Bibliography

• Bruppacher, Paul (2 April 2014), Adolf Hitler und die Geschichte der NSDAP Teil 1: 1889 bis 1937 (in German), BoD – Books on Demand, ISBN 978-3-7322-6870-2, retrieved 12 February 2017
• Donald, Graeme (2009), Loose Cannons: 101 Things They Never Told You about Military History, Osprey Publishing, ISBN 978-1849086493
• Hamann, Brigitte (1999). Hitler's Vienna: A Dictator's Apprenticeship. University of Oxford. ISBN 978-0195125375.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Hamann, Brigitte (2010), Hitler's Vienna: A Portrait of the Tyrant as a Young Man, Tauris Parke Paperbacks, ISBN 978-1-84885-277-8, retrieved 2 February 2017
• Hitler Film (in German), Der Spiegel, retrieved 15 March 2015
• Jetzinger, Franz (1958), Hitler's Youth, Greenwood Press
• Joachimsthaler, Anton (2003), Hitlers Liste (in German), Herbig, ISBN 978-3-7766-2328-4, retrieved 12 February 2017
• Kershaw, Ian (2008). Hitler: A Biography. New York: W. W. Norton & Company. ISBN 978-0-393-06757-6.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Kershaw, Ian (31 May 2011), Introduction, The Young Hitler I Knew: The Memoirs of Hitler's Childhood Friend, by Kubizek, August, translated by Brooks, Geoffrey, Frontline Books, ISBN 978-1-84832-607-1, retrieved 3 February 2017
• Kubizek, August (31 May 2011), The Young Hitler I Knew: The Memoirs of Hitler's Childhood Friend, translated by Brooks, Geoffrey, Frontline Books, ISBN 978-1-84832-607-1, retrieved 3 February 2017
• Montero, Rosa (2013), "Cartas de amor anónimas", Dictadoras: Las mujeres de los hombres más despiadados de la historia (in Spanish), Penguin Random House Grupo Editorial Argentina, ISBN 978-950-07-4580-2, retrieved 2 February 2017
• Roland, Paul (2014). Nazi Women: The Attraction of Evil. Arcturus Publishing. ISBN 978-1784280468.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Shirer, William L. (11 October 2011), The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich: A History of Nazi Germany, Simon and Schuster, ISBN 978-1-4516-5168-3, retrieved 3 February 2017
• Spotts, Frederic (2009), Hitler and the Power of Aesthetics, Overlook Press, ISBN 978-1-59020-178-7
• "The Making of Adolf Hitler". TimeWatch. Retrieved 18 March 2015.
• Trevor-Roper, H. R. (1955), Introduction, The Young Hitler I Knew, by Kubizek, August, translated by Anderson, E. V., Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin, retrieved 3 February 2017
• Waite, Robert G. L. (1993), The Psychopathic God: Adolf Hitler, Da Capo Press
• Zalampas, Sherree Owens (1990), Adolf Hitler: A Psychological Interpretation of His Views on Architecture, Art, and Music, Popular Press
• Zumbo, Daniele (13 June 2013), Operazione Stalingrado: Storia di un eroe (in Italian), Youcanprint, ISBN 978-88-911-1364-1