Smith W. Brookhart

Smith Wildman Brookhart (February 2, 1869 – November 15, 1944), was twice elected as a Republican to represent Iowa in the United States Senate. He was considered an "insurgent" within the Republican Party; his criticisms of the Harding and Coolidge Administrations and of business interests alienated others within the Republican caucus, leading to his ouster from the Senate over an election challenge. Brookhart's absence from the Senate was brief, as he took the first opportunity to return by challenging and defeating the state's senior Republican senator. He was also a strong supporter of Prohibition and its enforcement, so as public support for prohibition waned, so too did his political career.

Smith Wildman Brookhart
United States senator from Iowa
In office November 8, 1922 – April 12, 1926
Preceded by	Charles A. Rawson
Succeeded by	Daniel F. Steck
In office March 4, 1927 – March 3, 1933
Preceded by	David W. Stewart
Succeeded by	Richard L. Murphy
Personal details
Born	(1869-02-02)February 2, 1869 Arbela, Missouri
Died	November 15, 1944(1944-11-15) (aged 75) Prescott, Arizona
Political party	Republican

Personal background

Brookhart was born in a cabin on a farm in Scotland County, Missouri, the son of Abram C. and Cynthia Wildman Brookhart.[1] He was educated in country schools. Brookhart graduated from Bloomfield High School and then attended Southern Iowa Normal School, both in Bloomfield, Iowa, where he graduated in 1889, with an emphasis in scientific courses.[2] For five years he taught in country schools and high school, meanwhile studying law in offices in Bloomfield and Keosauqua, Iowa.[1] He was admitted to the bar in 1892 and began practice in Washington, Iowa.[1] Four years later his brother, J. L. Brookhart, joined his firm.[2] He served for six years as Washington County Attorney.[2]

On June 22, 1897, he married Jennie Hearne. They had four sons and two daughters, Charles Edward Brookhart, John Roberts Brookhart, Samuel Colar Brookhart, Smith W. Brookhart Jr., Florence Hearne Brookhart Yount, and Edith A. Brookhart Millard.[1][2]

He served in the U.S. Army during the Spanish–American War and World War I, where he reached the rank of lieutenant colonel. He was renowned for his marksmanship with a rifle. Brookhart eventually served as president of the National Rifle Association from 1921 to 1925.

First run for U.S. Senate (1920)

In early 1920 Brookhart announced his candidacy for the Republican nomination for the U.S. Senate seat held since 1908 by Republican Albert B. Cummins. Cummins was a progressive senator but from an earlier generation, and distrusted both corporate interests and unions. Brookhart attempted to build his campaign around his criticism of railroad regulatory legislation Cummins had co-authored, the Esch–Cummins Act, which Brookhart claimed did too little to wrest ownership and control of railroads away from Wall Street interests.[3] Brookhart attempted to lure rank-and-file blue-collar workers to register as Republicans so that they could vote for him in the primary,[3] prompting Cummins to associate Brookhart with radical workers movements such as "the Socialists, reds and Industrial Workers of the World."[4] Cummins was sidelined by illness in the weeks leading up to the primary,[4] but nevertheless defeated Brookhart.[5]

Senate service

1922–1926

On his second attempt, Brookhart was elected to the Senate in 1922.[6] A special election was required because Iowa Senator William S. Kenyon resigned before the completion of his term to accept an appointment as federal judge. After receiving over 41 percent of the vote in a six-way Republican primary,[7] Brookhart was backed by the national Republican Party,[7] and defeated future Governor and U.S. Senator Clyde L. Herring.

As Time would later write, Brookhart's "pugnacious cowhide radicalism nettled patrician Senators."[8] Two years later, in the 1924 election, he made his first attempt to win a full term. Running again as the Republican nominee, Brookhart appeared to have defeated the Democratic candidate, Daniel F. Steck, by a small margin, with Brookhart getting 447,594 votes to Steck's 446,840. Brookhart thus took office on March 4, 1925, but Steck pursued a challenge with the Senate Committee on Elections and Privileges. In the Committee hearings on Steck's challenge, the Iowa Republican Party sided with Democrat Steck. It filed a brief that was sharply critical of Brookhart, accusing him of disloyalty to the Republican presidential ticket in 1924 because of his support for Progressive Party presidential candidate Robert M. La Follette Sr. of Wisconsin.[9]

Brookhart held this seat only until April 12, 1926 when the Senate voted by a margin of 45 to 41 to replace him with Steck, who then served out the remainder of the term. Because the Senate was then firmly in Republican control, his ouster was possible only because over a dozen Republicans voted with Democrats to unseat Brookhart.[10] On other occasions the Senate has settled election disputes before a Senator took office, but this is the only time the results were overturned after the Senator was seated. Biographer George William McDaniel concludes:

between 1924 and 1926, those in charge of the established political machinery united to defeat Brookhart. In part they acted out of fear of his program; some really believed that it would lead to socialism or worse. In part they feared that he intended to remake the Republican party in his own image, a charge he repeatedly denied and one that most thoughtful politicians knew to be unfounded since he never

bothered to build the kind of county-by-county organizations necessary for such a move. In addition, party leaders were upset that he won without them and thus showed that the political party was not necessary as the vehicle for election. Brookhart aided their efforts by his intemperate speech at Emmetsburg, giving them an excuse to read him out of the party.[11]

1927–1933

Immediately upon his ouster from the Senate in April 1926, Brookhart ran for Iowa's other Senate seat, which was still held by Cummins. In the Republican primary, Brookhart stunned his former colleagues and the Iowa Republican establishment by decisively defeating Cummins. As Idaho Republican William Edgar Borah said the following morning, "Senator Cummins was highly respected by everyone who knew him. He was a man of recognized ability, and only a real political revolution could have defeated him."[12] In the general election, Brookhart defeated conservative Democrat Claude R. Porter, a former U.S. Attorney during the Wilson Administration. He settled into a shaky coexistence with the Republican establishment.[13]

Brookhart was a harsh critic of the Federal Reserve: "A more sinister or evil device could not be arranged for using the people's savings to their own injury and the destruction of their property values".[14]

He served a full six-year term. However, in the 1932 Republican primary he was defeated by Henry Field, a Shenandoah, Iowa nurseryman. Field had attacked Brookhart's absences from the Senate while on speaking tours, and the number of his relatives who held federal jobs.[15] Brookhart then ran in the 1932 general election as a "progressive" candidate, but received fewer than 33,000 votes out of over 890,000 cast.

Prohibition politics

Brookhart was what was known as a "fervent dry." In a futile effort to stop the growing sentiment for the repeal of Prohibition, Brookhart began a nationwide tour, during which time he debated Congressman Fiorello LaGuardia, Clarence Darrow, and other prominent "wets" or opponents of Prohibition.

Brookhart favored dramatically increasing Prohibition enforcement appropriations by 240 million dollars. This was a very unpopular position because of widespread unemployment and underemployment during the Great Depression. Those favoring repeal argued that legalizing alcoholic beverages would stimulate the economy and provide desperately needed tax revenue.

It is said that Brookhart's opinions regarding alcohol came from his role as a rifle instructor for the Iowa National Guard. During that time he concluded that alcohol and guns were incompatible. He went as far as to quantify the accuracy harms associated with mild beer, claiming it lowered accuracy by 7%. With this information, he convinced the Governor of Iowa to make the rifle range "bone dry." [16]

After his defeat

After his 1932 defeat, Brookhart was a special advisor to the federal government on Soviet trade, until he resigned in 1935 and returned to Iowa.[8] In this role, he was an early advocate for United States recognition of the Soviet Union.[1]

Upon his return to Iowa, Brookhart made a final attempt to return to the Senate. He joined an already-crowded field of candidates for the Republican nomination for Senate in 1936, but finished a distant second to incumbent L. J. Dickinson.[17] He then announced a plan to unite diverse progressive elements under a new banner, declined an opportunity to run for the Senate under a Farmer-Labor Party nomination, and endorsed Franklin D. Roosevelt's 1936 re-election.[18]

After the 1936 election, Brookhart opened a law office in Washington, D. C., and remained there until 1943, when he went to Arizona for his health.[1] He died in Prescott, Arizona, on November 15, 1944.[1]

One of his sons, U.S. Army Lieutenant Colonel Smith W. Brookhart Jr., served as an assistant trial counsel for the prosecution at the Nuremberg War Trials.[19]

See also

• Smith Wildman and Jennie (Hearne) Brookhart House in Washington, Iowa is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.[20]

References

1. "Ex-Sen. Brookhart Dies in Arizona; Iowa Rites Planned," Mason City Globe-Gazette, 1944-11-16, at 1.
2. Burrell, Howard A. (1909). History of Washington County, Iowa from the First White Settlements to 1908. II. Chicago, Ill.: S J Clarke Publishing Co.
3. "Cummins May Campaign Iowa Before Primary," Waterloo Evening Courier, March 23, 1920 at 7.
4. "Cummins Seems Choice of Black Hawk Co. Voters," Waterloo Evening Courier, June 4, 1920 at 1.
5. "Cummins' Lead over Brookhart is Over 20,000," Waterloo Evening Courier, June 9, 1920 at 1.
6. "Brookhart Sworn as Junior Senator," Waterloo Evening Courier, 1922-12-02, at p. 3.
7. "Brookhart Given 41.1 Percent on All Primary Ballots," Waterloo Evening Courier, June 7, 1922 at 1.
8. "Again, Brookhart," Time, April 20, 1936.
9. "Official Count Indicates Steck is Winner," Cedar Rapids Republican, February 4, 1926 at 4.
10. "Brookhart says he is glad it is all over," Oelwein Daily Register, April 13, 1926 at 1.
11. McDaniel (1987) p 433
12. "Washington Sees Corn Belt Revolt in Brookhart Win," Waterloo Evening Courier, June 8, 1926 at 2.
13. George William McDaniel, "The Republican Party in Iowa and the Defeat of Smith Wildman Brookhart, 1924-1926." The Annals of Iowa 48.7 (1987): 413-434. online
14. July 4, 1927, Bakersfield Californian
15. "Senate Met While Brookhart was on Chautauqua," Boyden Reporter, May 19, 1932 at 6.
16. Plummer, Herbert (October 10, 1929). "A Day Book of Washington". The Evening Tribune, Providence. Retrieved October 10, 2013.
17. "Dickinson and Herring Nomination Winners," Waterloo Daily Courier, June 2, 1936 at 1.
18. 'Brookhart will back Roosevelt," Mason City Globe-Gazette, August 17, 1936.
19. David Cesarani, Holocaust: Critical Concepts in Historical Studies, p. 168 (Routledge: 2004) ISBN 0-415-31872-6.
20. Molly Myers Naumann. "Smith Wildman and Jennie (Hearne) Brookhart House" (PDF). National Park Service. Retrieved December 23, 2015.

United States Congress. "BROOKHART, Smith Wildman (id: B000873)". Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.

Further reading

• McDaniel, George William. "The Republican Party in Iowa and the Defeat of Smith Wildman Brookhart, 1924-1926." The Annals of Iowa 48.7 (1987): 413-434. online
• McDaniel, George William (1995). Smith Wildman Brookhart: Iowa's Renegade Republican (1st ed.). Ames, Iowa: Iowa State Press. ISBN 0-8138-2107-X.
• Editorial Cartoons of J.N. 'Ding' Darling (Iowa Digital Library: University of Iowa Libraries) - Cartoons referencing or depicting Smith W. Brookhart.

External links

• Media related to Smith W. Brookhart at Wikimedia Commons

Party political offices
Preceded by William S. Kenyon	Republican nominee for U.S. Senator from Iowa (Class 2) 1922, 1924	Succeeded by Lester J. Dickinson
Preceded by David W. Stewart	Republican nominee for U.S. Senator from Iowa (Class 3) 1926	Succeeded by Henry Field
U.S. Senate
Preceded by Charles A. Rawson	U.S. senator from Iowa 1922–1926	Succeeded by Daniel F. Steck
Preceded by David W. Stewart	U.S. senator from Iowa 1927–1933	Succeeded by Richard L. Murphy
National Rifle Association
Preceded by William Libbey	President of the NRA 1921–1925	Succeeded by Francis E. Warren
Preceded by Francis E. Warren	President of the NRA 1925–1926	Succeeded by Fred M. Waterbury