Jack Walker (ice hockey)

John Phillip "Jack" Walker (November 29, 1888 – February 16, 1950) was a Canadian professional ice hockey forward who played for the Toronto Blueshirts, Seattle Metropolitans, Victoria Cougars, and Detroit Cougars. He played in all the big professional leagues at the time: the NHA, PCHA, WCHL, and NHL.

Jack Walker
Hockey Hall of Fame, 1960
Walker with the Seattle Metropolitans.
Born	(1888-11-29)November 29, 1888 Silver Mountain, Ontario, Canada
Died	February 16, 1950(1950-02-16) (aged 61) Seattle, Washington, United States
Height	5 ft 8 in (173 cm)
Weight	153 lb (69 kg; 10 st 13 lb)
Position	Rover/Winger
Shot	Left
Played for	Oakland Sheiks Hollywood Stars Seattle Eskimos Detroit Cougars Victoria Cougars Seattle Metropolitans Moncton Victorias Toronto Blueshirts Port Arthur Lake City
Playing career	1907–1933

Walker won three Stanley Cups in his career: in 1914 with the Toronto Blueshirts, in 1917 with the Seattle Metropolitans, and in 1925 with the Victoria Cougars. Teammates on all three Stanley Cup winning teams were goaltender Harry "Hap" Holmes and forward Frank Foyston. Walker is one of only 11 players in Stanley Cup history to win the Cup with three or more different teams.[1]

Outside of his three Stanley Cup victories Walker also appeared in four other instances where his team played for the Stanley Cup, either in challenge games or in Stanley Cup series: in 1911 with Port Arthur Lake City, in 1919 and 1920 with the Seattle Metropolitans, and in 1926 with the Victoria Cougars. In 1911, 1920 and 1926 he was on the losing side of either the challenge game or the series, and in 1919 the Stanley Cup series between the Seattle Metropolitans and the Montreal Canadiens was cancelled because of the Spanish flu pandemic with the two teams tied at 2-2 in a best-of-five format.[2]

Biography

Port Arthur

Born in Silver Mountain, Ontario Walker grew up in Port Arthur, Ontario (present day Thunder Bay) where his parents had lived since 1870. He played with the Port Arthur Lake City team in the New Ontario Hockey League (NOHL) from 1907–1912. On March 16, 1911 he and teammate Eddie Carpenter played for the Port Arthur Hockey Club against the Ottawa Senators of the NHA for the Stanley Cup. Carpenter and Walker each scored a goal but the Port Arthur team lost 4-13 in front of 3,000 spectators at the Laurier Avenue Arena in Ottawa.[3]

Impressed by Walker's play in the Stanley Cup challenge game the Ottawa Senators tried to land him for the 1911–12 season, but Walker declined the offer as he thought Port Arthur had a strong enough team to again compete for the Stanley Cup.[4] For the 1911–12 season future Hockey Hall of Fame members Harry Cameron and Frank Nighbor joined the Port Arthur team from Pembroke, Ontario, but after the team had defeated the Saskatoon Wholesalers 12-6 (11-1, 1-5) in a qualifying two-game series on March 2 and 4, 1912 for a chance to challenge the National Hockey Association champions (Quebec Bulldogs) for the Stanley Cup, Port Arthur nonetheless turned down the opportunity because they felt they had practically no chance to defeat the NHA champions.[5]

Walker, third from the right in the back row, with the 1913–14 Toronto Blueshirts.

Toronto Blueshirts

During the 1912–13 season, Walker and Eddie Carpenter played for the Moncton Victorias of the MaPHL, and Walker also played one initial game with the Toronto Blueshirts of the NHA. Walker had first signed a contract with the Toronto club for the 1912–13 NHA season, but jumped contract to Moncton along with Fred Doherty after only one game in the NHA for a higher salary in the Maritimes.[6] In 1913–14 Walker became a full time member of the Toronto Blueshirts.

Back in Toronto Walker helped the 1913–14 Toronto Blueshirts win the Stanley Cup by defeating the Montreal Canadiens. The two teams tied each other for first place in the NHA, and Toronto won the deciding playoffs 6-2 (0-2, 6-0) over two games on March 7 and 11. Toronto Blueshirts then defeated the Victoria Aristocrats, champions of the PCHA, in three straight games 5-2, 6-5 and 2-1 between March 14 to 19.[7]

Walker played with the Toronto Blueshirts also in 1914–15, but prior to the 1915–16 season Lester and Frank Patrick, the men behind the Pacific Coast Hockey Association (PCHA), took advantage of a turbulent situation in the NHA when Major Frank Robinson, owner of the Blueshirts, was about to sell his team to join the military. The Patricks raided the Blueshirts and created a new PCHA team in the Seattle Metropolitans, stocking it with Walker, Eddie Carpenter, Harry "Hap" Holmes, Frank Foyston and Carol "Cully" Wilson.[8]

Seattle Metropolitans

In his second season with the Metropolitans, in 1916–17, Walker helped the American team to a first place finish in the PCHA, in front of the Vancouver Millionaires, Portland Rosebuds and Spokane Canaries. In the following Stanley Cup finals the Metropolitans defeated the Montreal Canadiens of the NHA 3 games to 1 to claim the Stanley Cup[9], making it the first time an American team had laid its hand on the coveted trophy.

Walker, in the upper right corner, with the 1916–17 Seattle Metropolitans.

World War I had a big impact on the game and prior to the 1917–18 season Walker and Eddie Carpenter were stuck in Port Arthur working on a dry dock. They had been given exemption from the war on ground that they continued with their employment in the city, which held them out from rejoining the Metropolitans in the PCHA.[10] Walker and Carpenter instead played with different Port Arthur teams in the NOHL.

Back in the PCHA for the 1918–19 season Walker again helped the Metropolitans reach the Stanley Cup finals, a rematch against the Montreal Canadiens from two seasons prior. The 1919 series became a more even affair than the 1917 series but had to be cancelled with the teams tied at 2-2 in the best-of-five format due to the Spanish flu pandemic when several players on the Canadiens ended up sick in hospital.[2] Joe Hall, Hockey Hall of Fame defenseman on the Canadiens team, subsequently died of pneumonia, related to his influenza, in a hospital in Seattle on April 5, only four days after the series had been cancelled.

In 1919–20 Walker again helped the Metropolitans to the Stanley Cup finals, this time against the Ottawa Senators. The Senators, led offensively by Frank Nighbor, Walker's old teammate from Port Arthur during the 1911–12 season, won the series 3 games to 2 after a 6-1 decision in game five on April 1, 1920.[11]

Victoria Cougars – Detroit Cougars

Walker played four more seasons with the Metropolitans, but when the team folded after the 1923–24 season Walker, along with his longtime teammates "Hap" Holmes and Frank Foyston, joined the Victoria Cougars in the Western Canada Hockey League for the 1924–25 season. The Cougars, led offensively by their Icelandic-Canadian star forward Frank Fredrickson, only finished at third place in the 1924–25 WCHL standing, but they succeeded in winning the following league playoffs (defeating both the Saskatoon Crescents and the Calgary Tigers) which gave them the opportunity to play NHL champions Montreal Canadiens for the Stanley Cup. Walker, who had had a modest regular season offensively speaking with the Cougars, turned it on for the playoffs, scoring 4 goals during the WCHL playoffs and 4 goals in the Stanley Cup finals, helping the Cougars defeat the Canadiens 3 games to 1 while being matched against the Canadiens young star forward Howie Morenz.[12]

Victoria Cougars in 1925 became the last non-NHL team to win the Stanley Cup. In 1926 the team was back in the Stanley Cup finals, after winning the WHL playoffs, but the Montreal Maroons of the NHL turned out too difficult to overcome winning the series 3 games to 1, with Montreal goaltender Clint Benedict recording three shutouts in the series.[13]

When the WHL folded after the 1925–26 season Walker moved along with the Victoria Cougars to Detroit and the NHL where the team became the Detroit Cougars. Walker, then aged 37, played two seasons with the Detroit Cougars in the NHL before he headed back to Seattle where he played three seasons with the Seattle Eskimos of the Pacific Coast Hockey League. During the 1931–32 and 1932–33 seasons Walker was a playing manager for the Hollywood Stars and the Oakland Sheiks respectively in the California Hockey League[14], a league where several other old PCHA stars such as Moose Johnson, Lloyd Cook and Fred "Smokey" Harris also played during their twilight years.

After his playing career Walker stayed on the West Coast where he was active as an ice hockey coach, and he finally settled down in Seattle where he died on February 16, 1950 at an age of 61.

He was inducted posthumously into the Hockey Hall of Fame in 1960.[15]

Playing style

"Walker, at rover, is a crackerjack, his skating and use of the famous poke check making him the most conspicuous figure on the ice."

Ottawa Journal on Walker after the March 16, 1911 Stanley Cup challenge game between the Ottawa Senators and Port Arthur.[16]

During his hockey career Walker played mostly as a rover (the archaic seven man game forward position between defense and the centre forward) or, in the six man game against opponents from the NHA, as a winger. He was a good stick-handler and had lots of speed, something which both the Ottawa Journal and the Ottawa Citizen complimented him on after the Port Arthur Lake City aggregation had played the Ottawa Senators for the Stanley Cup on March 16, 1911.[16][17]

"Johnny Walker, the rover, a Port Arthur boy, in his 21st year, was by a wide margin the finest of the visitors. Walker has speed to burn, handles the stick neatly and checks with the sure sign every time. He never fagged and was up and back with almost every rush of the night."

Ottawa Citizen on Walker after the March 16, 1911 Stanley Cup challenge game between the Ottawa Senators and Port Arthur.[17]

Walker with Port Arthur Lake City in the early 1910s.

Walker was a prominent two-way player who could make a difference at both ends of the rink, and he is often credited with introducing the hook check (a defensive technique in which the player sweeps or hooks his stick low to the ice in an effort to remove the puck from an opponent's stick) to the game of hockey.[18] Walker's forward teammate on the 1911–12 Port Arthur Lake City team Frank Nighbor was another defensive specialist during the same era who excelled at both the poke check[note 1] and the sweep check.[19] In a 1960 interview with Bill Westwick (son of Ottawa Silver Seven player Harry "Rat" Westwick) of the Ottawa Journal Nighbor claimed he had learned his famous poke checking technique by watching Walker while the two players were teammates in Port Arthur.[20]

One instance in which Walker used his hook check with great success was during the 1917 Stanley Cup Finals against the Montreal Canadiens. Canadiens had won the first game of the best-of-five series 8 goals to 4, but in game two Walker used his hook check effectively on Didier Pitre, one of the star forwards on the Montreal team who had scored four goals in the first game, helping his team to hold the Canadiens to only one goal in a 6-1 victory.[21] The Seattle Metropolitans then won game three 4-1 and game four 9-1, winning the Stanley Cup as the first American team in history.

Whether or not Walker came up with his hook checking technique by himself, or if he drew inspiration from contemporary players, is disputed. Both Joel Rochon and William "Bud" Saurel[note 2], two players from Fort William whom Walker played against in the NOHL, claimed to have originated the check.[22] Rochon's claim was echoed by Fort William native Hockey Hall of Fame member Jack Adams who claimed Frank Nighbor must have learned his poke check after having played against Rochon and Fort William in the NOHL, something Nighbor himself denied.[20] Harry Scott, a teammate of Walker with the 1912–13 Moncton Victorias and an opponent of him in the NOHL between 1907–1911, claimed that it was "Bud" Saurel who had learned Walker the check.[23]

In an era that was known for a lot of on-ice violence Walker was known as a clean and gentlemanly player, which reflected not only in a comparatively low amount of penalty minutes but also in a comparatively low amount of serious injuries. One serious injury he did suffer happened during the 1921–22 season when he was hit over his already injured left hand in a game in Victoria on February 10 and blood-poisoning set in to the wound. He was taken to General Hospital in Vancouver where he was operated on on February 13[24], and he could later come back and finish the season.

Lester Patrick, the hockey mogul behind the PCHA and later a two-time Stanley Cup winning coach with the New York Rangers, had high praise for Walker, calling him "one of the greatest players who ever lived" in a 1950 Maclean's magazine interview, but he also stated that in comparison with contemporary players like Cyclone Taylor, Frank Nighbor, Howie Morenz, Eddie Shore, Moose Johnson, Ching Johnson and Frank Fredrickson, Walker, much like his Seattle Metropolitans teammate Frank Foyston, "lacked color" and "no matter how brilliant he was, he didn’t bring the crowd to their feet".[25]

Career statistics

Regular season and playoffs

Walker, first player from left, with the Moncton Victorias in 1912–13.

				Regular season						Playoffs
Season	Team	League		GP	G	A	Pts	PIM		GP	G	A	Pts	PIM
1907–08	Port Arthur Lake City	NOHL		6	3	0	3	—		—	—	—	—	—
1908–09	Port Arthur Lake City	NOHL		12	8	0	8	—		—	—	—	—	—
1909–10	Port Arthur Lake City	NOHL		12	20	0	20	21		—	—	—	—	—
1910–11	Port Arthur Lake City	NOHL		14	30	0	30	—		2	2	0	2	0
1910–11	Port Arthur Lake City	St-Cup		—	—	—	—	—		1	1	0	1	0
1911–12	Port Arthur Lake City	NOHL		13	17	0	17	—		2	3	0	3	0
1912–13	Toronto Blueshirts	NHA		1	0	0	0	0		—	—	—	—	—
1912–13	Moncton Victorias	MPHL		15	21	0	21	9		—	—	—	—	—
1913–14	Toronto Blueshirts	NHA		20	20	16	36	17		2	3	0	3	2
1913–14	Toronto Blueshirts	St-Cup		—	—	—	—	—		2	3	0	3	2
1914–15	Toronto Blueshirts	NHA		19	12	7	19	11		—	—	—	—	—
1915–16	Seattle Metropolitans	PCHA		18	13	6	19	6		—	—	—	—	—
1916–17	Seattle Metropolitans	PCHA		24	11	15	26	3		—	—	—	—	—
1916–17	Seattle Metropolitans	St-Cup		—	—	—	—	—		4	1	2	3	0
1917–18	Port Arthur Lake City	NOHL		8	22	0	22	—		—	—	—	—	—
1918–19	Seattle Metropolitans	PCHA		20	9	6	15	9		2	0	2	2	0
1918–19	Seattle Metropolitans	St-Cup		—	—	—	—	—		5	3	0	3	9
1919–20	Seattle Metropolitans	PCHA		22	4	8	12	3		2	1	1	2	0
1919–20	Seattle Metropolitans	St-Cup		—	—	—	—	—		5	1	3	4	0
1920–21	Seattle Metropolitans	PCHA		23	6	4	10	6		2	0	0	0	0
1921–22	Seattle Metropolitans	PCHA		20	8	4	12	0		2	0	0	0	0
1922–23	Seattle Metropolitans	PCHA		29	13	10	23	4		—	—	—	—	—
1923–24	Seattle Metropolitans	PCHA		29	18	5	23	0		2	0	1	1	0
1924–25	Victoria Cougars	WCHL		28	7	7	14	6		4	4	0	4	0
1924–25	Victoria Cougars	St-Cup		—	—	—	—	—		4	4	2	6	0
1925–26	Victoria Cougars	WHL		30	9	8	17	16		4	0	0	0	2
1925–26	Victoria Cougars	St-Cup		—	—	—	—	—		4	0	0	0	0
1926–27	Detroit Cougars	NHL		37	3	4	7	6		—	—	—	—	—
1927–28	Detroit Cougars	NHL		43	2	4	6	12		—	—	—	—	—
1928–29	Seattle Eskimos	PCHL		34	5	8	13	4		5	0	2	2	2
1929–30	Seattle Eskimos	PCHL		26	6	11	17	2		—	—	—	—	—
1930–31	Seattle Eskimos	PCHL		34	2	13	15	8		4	0	3	3	0
1931–32	Hollywood Stars	Cal-Pro			5	13	18			—	—	—	—	—
1932–33	Oakland Sheiks	Cal-Pro								—	—	—	—	—
NOHL totals				65	100	–	100	–		–	–	–	–	–
NHA totals				40	32	23	55	28		2	3	0	3	2
PCHA totals				186	82	58	140	31		10	1	4	5	0
WCHL/WHL totals				58	16	15	31	22		8	4	0	4	2
NHL totals				80	5	8	13	18		—	—	—	—	—
St-Cup totals				—	—	—	—	—		26	11	7	18	12

Awards and achievements

• Stanley Cup – 1914 with Toronto Blueshirts, 1917 with Seattle Metropolitans and 1925 with Victoria Cougars
• PCHA First All-Star Team – 1920–21, 1921–22 and 1923–24
• PCHA Second All-Star Team – 1916–17, 1918–19 and 1919–20

References

Bibliography

• Podnieks, Andrew (2003). Players: the ultimate A-Z guide of everyone who has ever played in the NHL. Doubleday Canada. ISBN 0-385-25999-9.
• Holzman, Morey; Nieforth, Joseph (2002). Deceptions and doublecross : how the NHL conquered hockey. Dundurn Press. ISBN 1-55002-413-2.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)

Remarks

1. The hook check and the poke check despite being two different checks were quite similar in nature and the two names were sometimes used interchangeably in contemporary newspaper reports.
2. Name also spelled Sorel in newspaper reports.

Notes

1. "Players on Stanley-Cup Winning Teams". Retrieved 2010-04-13.
2. Weinreb, Michael (Mar 18, 2020). "When the Stanley Cup Final Was Canceled Because of a Pandemic". Smithsonian Magazine. Smithsonian Institution. Retrieved 2020-07-24.
3. "Stanley Cup remains in Ottawa – Port Arthur beaten by 13 to 4" Ottawa Citizen. Mar. 17, 1911 (pg. 8). Retrieved 2020-07-24.
4. "Walker not going east – Port Arthur Rover Declines Offer From Ottawa" Winnipeg Tribune. Dec. 9, 1911 (pg. 6). Retrieved 2020-07-23.
5. "Will not come east – Port Arthur club abandoned Stanley Cup trip" Ottawa Citizen. Mar. 6, 1912 (pg. 8). Retrieved 2020-08-05.
6. "Moncton club steals Walker, Doherty and McGregor from Toronto teams" Ottawa Citizen. Dec. 27, 1912 (pg. 9). Retrieved 2020-07-24.
7. Stanley Cup Annual Record 1914 nhl.com
8. Holzman & Nieforth 2002, p. 88.
9. Stanley Cup Annual Record 1917 nhl.com
10. "Patricks may have two club series – Or May Suspend the Coast League For This Season" Ottawa Journal. Dec. 28, 1917 (pg. 10).
11. Stanley Cup Annual Record 1920 nhl.com
12. Stanley Cup Annual Record 1925 nhl.com
13. Stanley Cup Annual Record 1926 nhl.com
14. "Skippers Sheik Six" Oakland Tribune. Dec. 19, 1932 (pg. 13). Retrieved 2020-07-25.
15. Jack Walker hhof.com
16. "Port Arthur failed to lift the Stanley Cup – Improvement Will Come" Ottawa Journal. Mar. 17, 1911 (pg. 4). Retrieved 2020-07-24.
17. "Walker starred on line" Ottawa Citizen. Mar. 17, 1911 (pg. 8). Retrieved 2020-07-24.
18. Biography hhof.com
19. Podnieks, Andrew (2003)
20. "'The Old Master' Sets Things Straight" Westwick, Bill. Ottawa Journal. Dec. 21, 1960 (pg. 13). Retrieved 2020-07-23.
21. "Mets All But Blank Frenchmen in Second Game of Series – P.C.H.A. Champions Win Six-Man Go With Hook-Check – Poor Pitre" Brougham, Royal. Vancouver Sun. Mar. 21, 1917 (pg. 6). Retrieved 2020-07-23.
22. "Frank Nighbor member of the aviation corps" Calgary Herald. Oct. 27, 1917 (pg. 20). Retrieved 2020-07-23.
23. "Sorel touted inventor of the "poke-check"" Victoria Daily Times. Dec. 31, 1914 (pg. 11). Retrieved 2020-07-28.
24. "Jack Walker out of tonight's game – Seattle Star in Hospital Suffering from Blood-poisoning" Daily Province. Feb. 18, 1922 (pg. 18). Retrieved 2020-07-23.
25. "Lester Patrick’s 50 Years on Ice – Part Two – Poor Kids Are the Best" Maclean's. Hutchison, Bruce. March 15, 1950 (pg. 55).

External links

• Biographical information and career statistics from Hockey-Reference.com, or Legends of Hockey, or The Internet Hockey Database