Bhim Singh (politician)

Bhim Singh (born 17 August 1941)[1] is an Indian politician, activist, lawyer and author. He is the founder of the Jammu and Kashmir National Panthers Party (JKNPP), a political organisation based in the conflict-torn Indian state of Jammu and Kashmir.[2][3] He survived an assassination attempt by the police, while leading the Jammu student protests of 1966,[4] and went on to found the Panthers Party in 1982, along with his wife Jay Mala. Bhim Singh was Panthers Party chairman for 30 years, until 2012 when he nominated his nephew Harsh Dev Singh in place.[5] In the 2002 Jammu and Kashmir Elections, Panthers Party under his leadership won all seats in the Udhampur district, and formed part of the coalition government.[6] In 2015, Bhim Singh's book Unbelievable - Delhi to Islamabad, was released by Indian vice-president Ansari,[7] chronicling his efforts as a Supreme Court advocate, gaining the release of over 700 falsely accused prisoners, from Indian and Pakistani jails.[8] He is believed to be the first man from India to visit 150 countries, and the second volume of his book documenting these travels, Peace Mission: Around the World on Motorcycle, was released by Dr. Karan Singh the erstwhile crown prince of Jammu and Kashmir.[9] Bhim Singh was elected member of the Jammu and Kashmir Legislative Assembly (1977–87) from Chenani-Ghordi (Udhampur), and was nominated by successive Prime Ministers of India as member of the National Integration Council (1991-2016).[10] Bhim Singh, as leader of the Panthers Party, won the 1988 Udhampur by-election to the Indian parliament, despite the Election Commission of India, attempting to rig it against him.

Bhim Singh
Chief Patron of Jammu and Kashmir National Panthers Party
Assumed office
27 October 2012
Preceded byOffice established
Chairman of Jammu and Kashmir National Panthers Party
In office
23 March 1982 – 27 October 2012
Preceded byOffice established
Succeeded byHarsh Dev Singh
Chairman of India-Pak Joint Defence Committee for Prisoners
Assumed office
13 April 2017
PresidentZulfiqar Ali Jehangir
Executive Chairman of Indo-Palestine Friendship Society
Assumed office
1978
Member of National Integration Council
Assumed office
1991
PresidentPrime Minister of India
Senior Executive Member of Supreme Court Bar Association
Assumed office
2013
General Secretary of All India Congress Committee
In office
1980-1982
PresidentIndira Gandhi
Vice-president of Indian Youth Congress
In office
1977-78
Member of Jammu and Kashmir Legislative Council
In office
2003-2008
Member of Indian Parliament
In office
1988
ConstituencyUdhampur (declared winner after a High Court ruling)
Member of Jammu and Kashmir Legislative Assembly
In office
1977-1987
ConstituencyChenani-Ghordi (Udhampur)
Personal details
Born17 August 1941 (1941-08-17) (age 78)
Bhugterian, Ramnagar, Princely State of Jammu and Kashmir, British India
NationalityIndian
Political partyIndian National Congress (1966-82)
Jammu and Kashmir National Panthers Party (1982-present)
Spouse(s)Jay Mala
RelationsDogra dynasty
Children1
Alma materAligarh Muslim University
University of London
Inns of Court School of Law
Website

In 1988, future Indian prime minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee, joined Bhim Singh on hunger strike in front of the Election Commission offices, in protest to the election they rigged against him, in order to prevent him from joining the Indian Parliament.[11][12] The Jammu and Kashmir High Court ruled in favour of Bhim Singh, judging that he had won the Lok Saba by-election from Udhampur, a seat previously held by his kinsman Karan Singh, former Crown prince of Jammu and Kashmir and its first President.[2]

Bhim Singh has held several key posts in the Indian Youth Congress, such as Vice-president (1977–78), General Secretary (1974–76) and President of Jammu and Kashmir State Youth Congress (1973–74) appointed by Prime Minister Indira Gandhi.[13][14] Before breaking away from the Congress Party to found the JKNPP in 1982, he served as a General Secretary of the All India Congress Committee, the central decision-making assembly of the Indian National Congress Party.

In 1985, in a landmark hearing Bhim Singh was awarded fifty thousand rupees by the Supreme Court of India for his false imprisonment, after being suspended as a Member of the Jammu and Kashmir Legislative Assembly.[15] The order of compensation from his case would change the tort law in India.[16][17]

While his 1996 efforts in moving the Supreme Court and the Election Commission, are seen as instrumental in returning democratic elections after nine years of absence to militancy torn Jammu and Kashmir.[18][19][20] In 2017, Bhim Singh in a historic judgment, defeated the government of India in the Supreme Court, enabling bar council elections to be held in Jammu and Kashmir for the very first time,[21] in accordance to the Advocates Act 1961.[22]

Bhim Singh was born in the village of Bhugterian, near Ramnagar, and is a descendant of the Wazir and General Zorawar Singh,[23][24] referred to by historians as "Conqueror of Ladakh" and "Napoleon of India" for his 19th century conquests of the Himalayan Kingdoms of Ladakh, Tibet and Baltistan.[25][26] While his Dogra Rajput dynasty, is believed to be descended from the mythical Ikshvaku (Solar) dynasty that in Eastern religious scriptures has produced personalities such as Lord Rama, Gautama Buddha, and twenty-two out of the twenty-four Jain Tirthankaras.

Despite his Hindu royal and religious histories, Prof. Bhim Singh has politically and through the judiciary fought for democracy and secularism for over 55 years in Muslim majority Jammu and Kashmir,[27][28] once described by President Bill Clinton as "the most dangerous place in the World."[29][30] In doing so Singh has spent 8 years in jail and endured militancy, Islamic extremism, terrorism and false arrests as consequence of the Jammu and Kashmir insurgencies and the ongoing Jammu and Kashmir armed conflict between India, Pakistan and China.[31][32]

He was allegedly poisoned in the Srinagar Central Jail in 1978 after speaking out against Sheikh Abdullah, the then Chief Minister of Jammu and Kashmir.[16]

He is locally known as Sher-e-Jammu (Lion of Jammu).[27][33][34]

Early life

Family estate confiscated post-Indian Independence

Bhim Singh was born Kunwar (Prince) Bhim Singh on 17 August 1941 in Bhugterian, Ramnagar in the Princely State of Jammu and Kashmir during the British Raj of India.[35] Bhim Singh's father was Thakur (Prince) Birbal Singh,[36] a serviceman who served for the Allies of World War II and later the Indian Army post-independence.[37] In 1951, Bhim Singh's father had thousands of acres of land in Ramnagar forcibly taken with no compensation by the government of Prime Minister Sheikh Abdullah.[38][39]

He was first sent to prison in 1953 while still a student after he had thrown confectionery at PM Abdullah during a school visit by the prime minister.[2] At the time Bhim Singh's father Thakur Birbal was rallying against the government's land reforms in Jammu with Prem Nath Dogra and his anti-Abdullah Jammu Praja Parishad party.

As a college student Bhim Singh was a political activist going on hunger strike as early as 1959.[40] He was imprisoned for over 6 months from 1961-62 in Jammu Central Jail, where he shared a jail cell with Sheikh Nazir the future general secretary of the National Conference party.[41][42]

Assassination attempt in Jammu protests, 1966

Bhim Singh was again arrested in 1966 for leading thousands of students in protest while President of the J&K Students Congress Organization.[35][4][43] During the protests of October 1966, that called for an establishment of a university in Jammu four students were killed and fifty-three injured. On 17 October 1966, Brij Mohan, Subhash Chandra and Gulshan Handa died in protests on the G.G.M. Science College site in Jammu. While the senior superintendent of police shot student leader Gurcharan Singh on 18 October at a students march in Kanak Mandi, Jammu. The superintendent had aimed for Bhim Singh but M.P. Khosla, the future chief secretary of Jammu and Kashmir had intervened to save Bhim Singh's life.[44] Later Bhim Singh escaped curfew to visit and appeal to Prime Minister Indira Gandhi in New Delhi. Gandhi set up an inquiry into the affair under Pranab Mukherjee, the future President of India, that found several government and police officials responsible for the deaths.[45] University of Jammu was subsequently opened in 1969.

World tour on motorbike

Soon after he left India to travel the world from 1967 to 1973. Mostly by the way of motorbike he managed to visit more than a 120 countries. During his travels he was recorded by the Nigerian Times in 1970 as the first person to cross the Sahara Desert on motorcycle from Tan-Tan, Morocco to Senegal through Spanish Sahara and Mauritania.[46] In Chile he was personally received by its then President Salvador Allende, and in the Middle East he met with Yasir Arafat who later accepted Bhim Singh's invitation to India.[47][48][49]

His book documenting his early travels "Peace Mission: Around the World on Motorcycle" was published by Har Anand Publications in 2009.[50] A Hindi version for the book was released a year later by Sheila Dikshit, then Chief Minister of Delhi. At the book release K. Padmanabhaiah former Home Sectary of India, recalled Bhim Singh's contributions to reinstating the democratic process in Jammu and Kashmir in the 1996 assembly elections which were held after a gap of nine years.[20] His next travelogue "Unbelievable—Delhi to Islamabad," addressed the need for fairer treatment of Pakistani prisoners in India. It was released by the Vice-President of India, Mohammad Hamid Ansari.[51] Guest of honour at the book release Amitabh Mattoo, compared Bhim Singh to Che Guevara for his decades long lobbying for amendment to Article 370,[52][53] to fully integrate Jammu and Kashmir into India.[54]

Academics and student leader in Great Britain

On his travels he attended the University of London earning an LL.M and was the first Indian to be elected Secretary of the University of London Union in 1971.[55][46] Later in 1972, Bhim Singh was called to the bar at law, as a specialist on Palestine and Middle East affairs. Before returning to Jammu and Kashmir to engage in politics, Bhim Singh worked as a professor of international law at Cambridge University.[56]

Friendship with Yasser Arafat

Bhim Singh has been a vocal supporter of Arafat for over three decades and is the Chairman of the Indo-Palestine Friendship Society. He first meet a young Yasser Arafat in 1968 at a Red Cross office on the east bank of the Jordan river. In 1973 Bhim Singh would travel to Syria in support of Arafat and join the PLO over the dispute of Golan Heights between Israel and Syria during the Yom Kippur War.[57] When in 1992 Arafat was exiled from Lebanon, Bhim Singh would once again visit him in support in Tunis and a few years later Singh would travel to Ramallah to see Arafat, where he had set up a temporary capital for Palestine.[58][59] In 2016 Palestinian ambassador Adnan Abu Alhaija, released Bhim Singh's documentary film on Yasser Arafat at a screening in New Delhi.[60]

Hiroshima visits

Bhim Singh first visited Hiroshima in 1972. Meeting survivors of the nuclear attacks on Japan, influenced his future campaigning for complete disarmament, and against American military interventions.[61] He would return to Hiroshima several times throughout his political career on 6 August,[62] the anniversary of the atomic bombing, to observe the fast for disarmament at Peace Memorial Park, and lecture on world unity.[63]

Family and personal life

He married Panthers party co-founder Jay Mala. They have one son, Ankit Love who is leader of the One Love Party in Great Britain.[64]

Career

Congress Party

Bhim Singh in 1973 was appointed as President of the Youth Congress in Jammu and Kashmir by then Prime Minister Indira Gandhi,[65][66] he then went on to become a General Secretary of the All India Congress Committee.[14][67]

Founding leader of Panthers Party, 1982

He would later leave the Congress Party due to political and economic differences to found his own political party, the Jammu and Kashmir National Panther's Party (JKNPP) on 23 March 1982 along with a few other prominent political personalities including Jay Mala the former President of the Indian Students Congress.[18][67] He was twice elected as a Member of the Legislative Assembly in the state of Jammu and Kashmir.

Bhim Singh has also been a member of National Integration Council, first in 1991 nominated by Prime Minister of India Narasimha Rao, and then again in 2008 nominated by Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh.[68][69] He has contested seven times in the Indian parliamentary elections including against the former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi in Amethi, and former Bharatiya Janata Party leader LK Advani in New Delhi.[32]

As an advocate he has won many landmark cases in the Supreme Court of India and has been jailed several times while leading movements for students and youth demands including opening a university in Jammu. He has been jailed 54 times, spending an aggregate 8 years in detention, out of which 18 times he was released by order of the Supreme Court.[32]

Udhampur MP election, 1984

Bhim Singh stood in the 1984 general elections for Indian parliament, from the Udhampur constituency. He came second, to the Indian National Congress from which he had recently split to form the Panthers Party. He received 95,149 votes (26.24%).[70]

Chairman of Indo-Palestine Friendship Society

Bhim Singh after forging a friendship with Yasser Arafat on his world travels, on his return to India became chairman of the Indo-Palestine Friendship Society.[71] The society under his leadership, has campaigned strongly for the sovereign recognition of the Palestine state.[72] Bhim Singh has also been highly critical of the formation of the state of Israel, stating that "Israel was created in violation of UN Charter... to exploit and subjugate the Arabs,"[73] and referred to its presence in the Middle East as "illegal occupation."[74] In 1970, Bhim Singh's book An examination of documents on which the State of Israel is based, was published by the PLO research center.[75]

In 2000, the Indo-Palestine society staged a hunger strike protest in front of the Israeli embassy in New Delhi, demanding that Israel withdraw from Palestine, and adhere to UN resolutions.[76] Palestinian ambassador, Adli Sadeq in 2010 at a conference organized by Indo-Palestine Friendship Society, had criticized the government of India,[77] for issuing a weak statement in regards to the killing of nine activists by Israel in the Gaza flotilla raid.[78] In 2015, Bhim Singh criticized the Indian media and prime minister Narendra Modi, for their silence in regards to the unfriendly treatment and embarrassment suffered by the President of India, Pranab Mukherjee at an Israeli airport. Israeli authorities had barred the Indian president, from taking four satellite systems intended as gifts for the Palestinian Al-Aqsa University in Ramallah, which Bhim Singh believed to be an insult to India as well as Palestine.[74]

Bhim Singh v. State of Jammu and Kashmir, 1985

On 17 August 1985 Bhim Singh was suspended from the opening of the budget session of the Jammu and Kashmir Legislative Assembly that was scheduled for 11 September. He subsequently challenged the suspension in the Jammu and Kashmir High Court. After his suspension was stayed by High Court on 9 September, Bhim Singh left Jammu for Srinagar to attend the Legislative Assembly session. En route at 3:00 am on 10 September, he was intercepted by the police at Qazi Kund, 70 km from Srinagar. He was taken away by the police and kept prisoner at an undisclosed location. After attempts to locate him proved futile his wife and advocate Jayamala then moved the court to locate Bhim Singh. On 13 September, the court ordered the inspector general of the police to inform Jayamala where her husband was being held in custody. Only after this was Bhim Singh brought before a magistrate for the first time on 14 September. In the case the court found statements by M.A. Mir, superintendent of police to be false, neither could the superintendent explain why he expected Bhim Singh to travel through Qazi Kund on the night of his arrest. The court also found the lengthy affidavit filed by inspector general Khajuria contained statements of facts that he could not possibly have been aware off. The court found that Bhim Singh was not produced before the magistrate nor sub judge who issued the police orders of remand and that the police obtained the orders in surreptitious circumstances at the residence of the magistrate and after hours from the sub judge. The Supreme Court judge, O. Chinnappa Reddy criticized the conduct of the magistrate and sub judge stating that they had no concern for the subject out of either casual behavior or worse that they had potentially colluded with the police who had deliberately acted mala fide. The court ruled that there "certainly was a gross violation of Shri Bhim Singh's constitutional rights" and condemned the "authoritarian acts of the police." The judges though stated that the police were but minions and that they were in no doubt that the top levels of the Government of Jammu and Kashmir where ultimately responsible.[79]

The Supreme Court in a landmark judgement that impacted tort law in India, awarded Bhim Singh a compensation of fifty thousands rupees for his illegal detention and false imprisonment by the police.[80][81] Bhim Singh had left jail with a fractured leg and claimed during his false imprisonment the police and state agencies had made an attempt on his life.[2]

Udhampur MP By-Election, 1988

At the conclusion of the count on 19 June 1988, local radio and news in Jammu and Kashmir along with AIR correspondent, Ajit Singh announced Bhim Singh as the winner of the Udhampur by-election by 32,000 votes. The former President of India, Giani Zail Singh sent a message of congratulations to Bhim Singh on his victory. However, the Union Home Minister of India, Buta Singh had dispatched Dr. Bhalla, Secretary of the Election Commission by a Home Ministry aircraft to Jammu. Dr. Bhalla ordered the Returning Officer, S.P. Kazal to refer the count result to the Election Commission of India in New Delhi. On 25 June 1988 Peri Shastri the Chief Election Commissioner in New Delhi declared the Congress Party candidate Mohd. Ayub Khan instead as the winner by 2,376 votes.[82] The Returning Officer was later found to have committed suicide with no known motive.[83]

Bhim Singh filed a review petition against the order of the Election Commission of India, stating the declared result was rigged at the instance of Rajiv Gandhi and Farooq Abdullah, leaders of the ruling coalition parties. Atal Behari Vajpayee joined Bhim Singh on hunger strike in front of the Election Commission offices in protest to the vote rigging.[2] The Jammu and Kashmir High Court ruled in favour of Bhim Singh, however when Justice K.K. Gupta delivered the judgement four years later on 15 October 1992, the relevant session of parliament stood dissolved already.[84]

On the night of rigging in June 1988, despite the dishonourable intentions of his opposition Congress party, Bhim Singh had helped to pacify an aggressive set of youth that had come in support of the Panthers Party to stop Dr. Bhalla from escaping to Delhi on a helicopter. Thousands of youth had gathered at the count venue which was at the Kathua Government Degree College. They demanded that the Returning Officer confirm the result there and then as opposed referring it to New Delhi. Bhim Singh later wrote in his book the Murder of Democracy in Jammu and Kashmir, that he had intervened to pacify the crowd at the time despite it costing him the result, as an outbreak of violence at the venue could have resulted in the deaths of hundreds of civilians by the heavily armed police that were present due to an escalation of the insurgency in Jammu and Kashmir.[83]

Jammu and Kashmir state assembly 2002-2008

In the Jammu and Kashmir state assembly elections in 2002, the party which he heads, the Jammu and Kashmir National Panthers Party, won four seats in the state government, enabling them to be part of the ruling coalition,[85] with Bhim Singh's nephew Harsh Dev Singh serving as Education Minister.[5] In its strong hold the Udhampur district, Bhim Singh's party had won all 3 seats.[86] In 2007 he withdrew support to the Congress Party lead coalition, citing differences with the Peoples Democratic Party another member of the coalition.[87] The state government fell soon after when the PDP itself withdrew their support from the Congress Party during the Amarnath land transfer controversy, placing the state under direct rule of the central government for a few months prior to the 2008 Jammu and Kashmir state assembly elections.[88]

Human rights lawyer

As a human rights activist and lawyer in the Supreme Court of India he has aided thousands of helpless prisoners, farmers, employees, and youth all over the country. Through writs he had filed through his political party and the State Legal Aid Committee which he heads, he has secured the release of 300 Pakistani, Pakistan administered Kashmir and Afghan prisoners from Indian jails, some of whom had been held for decades. Bhim Singh has also served as the Chairman of the executive Committee of Legal aid with Chief Justice Bhagwati who described him as, "as crusader for truth and justice."[89] Bhim Singh in December 2016 was re-elected unopposed as a senior executive member of the Supreme Court Bar Association.[90]

Dogra Ratan Awards

He is the Convenor of the Council for Promotion of Dogri Language, Culture and History a body which awards the Dogra Ratan awards. In 2011 the President of India Pratibha Patil, presented the awards at the General Zorawar Singh Auditorium.[91][92]

Call for Governor's Rule, 2016

After the killing of Hizbul Mujahideen commander, Burhan Wani the state of Jammu and Kashmir was engulfed in violent riots leaving over 2,000 injured and the deaths of several civilians and CRPF personnel.[93] In July 2016, Bhim Singh attempted through the judiciary to have the State government dissolved and replaced by Governor's rule. He had attempted to do this by a petition filed on behalf of the Panthers Party calling for gubernatorial rule under section 92 of the Jammu and Kashmir constitution.[94] While the Supreme Court denied Singh's petition after two weeks of curfew in the State, it called for a report by Prime Minister Modi's government on the matter.[95][96] TS Thakur, the Chief Justice of India had requested solicitor general Ranjit Kumar to present a response to Singh's petition on the "ground realities" in the State.[97][98] On 22 August, the Supreme Court stated that the situation of curfew and unrest in the state of Jammu and Kashmir could not be dealt by the courts. It however asked Bhim Singh to join a delegation composed of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the leader of the opposition former Chief Minister Omar Abdullah to find a political solution to the issue. The court further requested that solicitor general Ranjit Kumar arrange a meeting between Prime Minister Modi and Bhim Singh.[99][100]

Supreme Court case against Union of India for J&K bar council, 2017

Despite the passing of the Advocates Act, 1961 Jammu and Kashmir remained the only state of India not allowed to elect a bar council.[21] In February 2017, in a historic judgement, the Supreme Court of India ruled in favor of Bhim Singh, allowing the state for the first time to elect its bar council. In the case lawyers for the Union of India, had argued that it was not conducive to hold bar elections in Jammu and Kashmir. However, Bhim Singh challenged the government's logic, arguing that if bar council elections could not be held in the state due to militancy, that it did would not have made sense to hold assembly and parliamentary elections either.[101]

Poorest candidate in 2019 Indian General Election

In May 2019, Bhim Singh stood as a candidate for Indian parliament from Jammu, and was the poorest and oldest candidate in the constituency.[102] At the time of the election he was over 78 years old and had just INR 30,000 ($420) cash, INR 16,000 ($224) bank deposit, and land valued at INR 38,000 ($533).[103] He finished fourth out of 24 candidates, with 4,016 votes (0.27%).[104]

Controversies

Defence of Saddam Hussein

Bhim Singh along with George Galloway, Natwar Singh and General Baig was a member of the Co-ordination Committee Against Economic Sanctions headed by Iraq's deputy prime minister Tariq Aziz.[105][106] In 2005 he was called ‘Vishwa Ratna,’ as possibly the only person in the world who could refuse 7.3 million barrels of oil vouchers as illustrated in Table 3 of Vol.II in the report of the UN Committee dealing with Oil-for-food program headed by Paul Volcker during sanctions placed on Iraq.[107][108][109] In essence saying no to oil vouchers that would have been worth over $500 million[n 1] at the time of the Paul Volcker Committee report in 2005. Neither was he served notice to appear in front of the United Nations investigation on the matter.[110] Bhim Singh says that he had also turned down a thick envelope stuffed with cash at the residence of the Iraqi ambassador in New Delhi, and that he only ever accepted a few token gifts from Saddam, like a bottle of fine alcohol and a Swiss Longines watch with the Ba'ath Party insignia on its dial .[106]

Later, Bhim Singh was named by Saddam as an advocate to plead his case in the Trial of Saddam Hussein,[32] and set up the International Defence Committee for Saddam, leading a team of 11 lawyers.[111] However, the United States blocked him from traveling to Baghdad.[32] In 2006 at an UNI press conference he had stated that, "a dead Saddam can be more dangerous than a living Saddam for the US and UK... the execution may take a moment. But its consequences will be dangerous and long-term."[112]

Eviction notice from VP House

Bhim Singh was given guest accommodations at VP House in New Delhi and Jammu and Kashmir in 1991 for security reasons by Prime Minister Chandra Shekhar due to the threat posed to his life by terrorist groups in the Jammu and Kashmir Insurgency.[113] In 2015, he was first asked to vacate his accommodation at VP House by the Urban Development Ministry and then given an 8-week eviction notice by the Supreme Court, questioning how he could have stayed as a guest for "30 years" at VP House which is usually meant for visitors of members of parliament.[114] The television channel NewsX reported the story as an abuse of political power for luxury accommodation.[115] Bhim Singh and his Panthers Party however protested the eviction at Jantar Mantar, stating that the accommodations were just a one room-suite used as offices to receive and assist Kashmiris with grievances. Bhim Singh believed that the eviction actions were politically motivated due his Party's opposition to Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the BJP-PDP coalition government in Jammu and Kashmir levying tax on Hindu pilgrims traveling to Vaishno Devi and civil-rights cases that he had pending in the Supreme Court on behalf of Pakistani refugees against the government.[31][113][116] Earlier Bhim Singh and his Panther's Party had also protested the cut down of his 22 personnel Z security cover by the BJP-PDP government as an act of political discrimination.[117][118]

Stance against CIA, ISI & Mossad

Bhim Singh has long alleged that the CIA, Mossad and ISI had become active in the 1970s to remove India's Prime Minister Indira Gandhi from power and dissect Jammu and Kashmir away from under Indian administration.[119][120] Singh who was named as a defence advocate by Slobodan Milosevic for his trial at the Hague claimed that "CIA has not learnt a lesson from the past and it wants to dissect India the way it did with USSR, Yugoslavia and elsewhere."[121] He continued to state that the 2015 coalition between the widely opposed views of the BJP and PDP had continued links to an ISI agenda to separate Jammu and Kashmir from India.[122] Further alleging that the Hurriyat political party was in fact backed by Pakistan's ISI and acted as its agent in the state.[123]

Later, declassified documents from the CIA's Operation Cyclone (1979–1989), revealed that the CIA funded the Jihadi warriors, mujahideen through Pakistan and its ISI. It was the most expensive known covert operation conducted by the CIA, with over $20 billion spent on training and arming the militants.[124]

Support for Gaddafi

In 2011, Bhim Singh who is also Chairman of the Afro-Asian Solidarity Council appealed to the UN Security Council to intervene in the air-raids on Libya on the basis that they were against UN charter. Bhim Singh then visited Libya and encouraged Muammar Gaddafi to invoke democratic reforms at grass root levels.[125] Afterwards he wrote an essay in support of Muammar Gaddafi and condemned his capture and subsequent death as "barbaric," by rebels that he claimed were under a "US lead-NATO command." Bhim Singh believed that a bloody civil war may result as consequence of tribal disputes post-Gaddafi, and that the bifurcation or trifurcation of Libya itself maybe on the US agenda for what he claimed would give a better hold over oil resources. He claimed Gaddafi had been on a US hit list as he had refused to join NATO and for his 1975 "Green Book" that had also put him in opposition to some other Arab leaders and Kings that the US was supporting.[126] At the time Bhim Singh had also stated a need for a universal plan for democracy of all countries under the ruthless rule of Sheikhs, Kings, Sultans and Dictators.[125]

Stance against Abdullah

Bhim Singh had alleged that his opposition Abdullah family were secret billionaires in an interview with NewsX TV channel, calling for a CBI investigation into the sudden death of Haji Yusuf in police custody.[127] Yusuf linked to money corruption within the Abdullah's National Conference party had died in custody vomiting blood, after being detained for hours at the private residence of Omar Abdullah, the then Chief Minister of Jammu and Kashmir.[128]

Comparison to Fidel Castro

After a 1971 meeting with Fidel Castro in Cuba, Bhim Singh has long admired and praised his leadership.[129][130] Bhim Singh himself has been criticized as a dictator in similar fashion to Castro for nominating individuals to office within his party without holding democratic elections.[131]

Work

Bibliography
  • Unbelievable-Delhi to Islamabad by Bhim Singh (Har Anand Publications, 2015), ISBN 9788124118177
  • Jammu and Kashmir: the blunders and way out by Bhim Singh (Har Anand Publications, 2011), ISBN 8124115877 ISBN 9788124115879
  • Peace Mission: Around the World on Motorcycle (Vol. I) by Bhim Singh (Har Anand Publications, 2009), ISBN 8124114323 ISBN 9788124114322
  • Peace Mission Around the World on Motorcycle (Vol. II) by Bhim Singh (Har Anand Publications, 2009), ISBN 8124114641 ISBN 9788124114643
  • Kashmir, A Mirage by Bhim Singh (Har Anand Publications 2007), ISBN 8124106185 ISBN 978-8124106181
  • The Judgement on NATO Aggression Against Yugoslavia by Bhim Singh (Har Anand Publications 2007), ISBN 9788124106419
  • Chetna Yaatra: Kargil Se Kanyakumari (Hindi) by Bhim Singh (Har Anand Publications, 2003), ISBN 8124109273 ISBN 9788124109274
  • Murder of Democracy in Jammu and Kashmir by Bhim Singh (Har Anand Publications 2002) ISBN 8124108641 ISBN 9788124108642
  • Autonomy or Secession: Jammu and Kashmir by Bhim Singh (Har Anand Publications 2002) ISBN 8124107491 ISBN 978-8124107492
  • Iraq: a heroic resistance by Bhim Singh (Har Anand Publications, 2001) ISBN 8124108331 ISBN 9788124108338
  • Flames in Kashmir by Bhim Singh (Har Anand Publications 1998), ISBN 8124105715 ISBN 978-8124105719
  • An examination of documents on which the State of Israel is based by Bhim Singh and Angelina Helou (P.L.O. Research Center, 1970)

Filmography

Documentary film

Notes

Notes

  1. 7,300,000 barrels multiplied by $69.91 (2005 WTI crude oil price high) = $510,343,000.

References

  1. "Prof. Bhim Singh: Affidavit Information of Candidate for 2014 Indian General Elections" (PDF). MyNeta.info. 24 March 2014. Retrieved 12 February 2017. Prof. Bhim Singh, son of late Thakur Birbal, aged 73
  2. Handoo, Bilal (3 February 2016). "Devil's Advocate". Kashmir Life. Retrieved 8 September 2016.
  3. "Jammu & Kashmir National Panthers Party". JKNPP. Archived from the original on 3 March 2012. Retrieved 15 March 2012.
  4. "NPP pays rich tributes to Student Martyrs of 1966 - GroundReport". GroundReport. Retrieved 30 September 2015.
  5. "J&K's Panthers Party gets new chief after 30 years | TwoCircles.net". twocircles.net. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  6. Manhotra, Dinesh (2 December 2014). "Panthers Party feeling heat as BJP goes all out in Udhampur". Tribune India. Retrieved 12 November 2016.
  7. "VICE PRESIDENT RELEASES THE BOOK 'UNBELIEVABLE –DELHI TO ISLAMABAD BY PROF. BHIM SINGH". pib.nic.in. Retrieved 29 May 2019.
  8. "Bhim Singh to move Pakistan apex court for Kulbhushan Jadhav". Hindustan Times. 11 April 2017. Retrieved 29 May 2019.
  9. "Dr. Karan Singh launches 2nd edition of Bhim Singh's book - Early Times Newspaper Jammu Kashmir". www.earlytimes.in. Retrieved 22 November 2019.
  10. "National integration missing from LS elections manifesto: Bhim - JK MONITOR". jkmonitor.org. Retrieved 30 May 2019.
  11. "Bhim Singh files nomination from Udhampur Parliamentary Constituency - Scoop News Jammu Kashmir". www.scoopnews.in. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  12. "Panthers founder Bhim Singh files nomination from Udhampur". Hindustan Times. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  13. "Peace-loving Revolutionary". Prof. Bhim Singh. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  14. "The purpose of Gauhati AICC session was to formulate a national policy: Congress President D.K. BorooahCover Story - India Today". indiatoday.intoday.in. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  15. "False Imprisonment in India". Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  16. "NPP alleges Bhim Singh was poisoned in Srinagar jail in 1978". kashmirpioneer.com. Archived from the original on 28 September 2015. Retrieved 27 September 2015.
  17. Subramanium, Giriraj. "A Jurisprudential Analysis—Bhim Singh v. State of Jammu & Kashmir". Supreme Court Cases. Retrieved 30 September 2015.
  18. "Jammu and Kashmir National Panthers Party (JKNPP) – Party History, Symbol, Founders, Election Results and News". www.elections.in. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  19. "Bhim Singh, President J&K ... vs Election Commissioner Of India ... on 4 April, 1996". indiankanoon.org. Retrieved 24 October 2015.
  20. "Sheila Dikshit releases Bhim Singh's book". The Hindu. The Hindu Group. 10 April 2010. Retrieved 19 March 2013.
  21. "SC allows Bhim Singh's writ petition to hold J&K BC election earliest in accordance with Advocates Act, 1961". Brighter Kashmir. Retrieved 7 February 2017.
  22. Ganai, Naseer (17 March 2017). "A Bar Set Too High". Outlook India. Retrieved 30 March 2017.
  23. Dewanji, Amberish (22 June 2000). "Bhim Singh flays autonomy bill". Rediff. J. Retrieved 19 July 2013.
  24. "Prof. Bhim Singh:: The Panthers Party:: Personality of Jammu province". Jammu Times. J. Archived from the original on 11 August 2013. Retrieved 19 July 2013.
  25. Sharma, Shiv (2008). India - A Travel Guide. India: Diamond Pocket Books (P) Ltd. p. 190. ISBN 978-8128400674.
  26. Singh, Harbakhs (2010). War Despatches: Indo-Pak Conflict 1965. India: Lancer International, Lancer Press. p. 304. ISBN 978-1935501299.
  27. "Bhim Singhs Urdu book, Mission Aalmi Aman". Day After India. Archived from the original on 27 September 2015. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  28. "Bhim Singh ousted from VP House". Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  29. Mishra, Panka (4 March 2010). ""Kashmir: "The World's Most Dangerous Place"". The New York Review of Books. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  30. "Analysis: The world's most dangerous place?". BBC. 23 March 2000. Retrieved 1 April 2016.
  31. "JKNPP protest against Bhim Singh's eviction - State Times". Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  32. "When will Bhim Singh be the king?". Daily News and Analysis. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  33. "South Asia Mail". www.southasiamail.com. Archived from the original on 5 October 2015. Retrieved 3 October 2015.
  34. "NPP condoles death of Yash Sharma - Scoop News Jammu Kashmir". www.scoopnews.in. Retrieved 3 October 2015.
  35. Kunwar Bhim Singh vs State Of Jammu And Kashmir And Anr. (JKHC 12 May 1966) ("The liberty of a subject is the most precious achievement of a democracy and depriving a person of his free movements should sparingly be re-sorted to."). Text
  36. "Affidavit of Prof. Bhim Singh s/o late Thakur Birbal" (PDF). Chief Electoral Officer. 24 March 2014.
  37. "Bhim assures full support to ex-servicemen at Jantar Mantar". Greater Jammu. Retrieved 7 September 2016.
  38. "Warns Omar, Azad, Taj to disclose assets or face action". Early Times. Retrieved 7 September 2016.
  39. "Bhim hangs out his Payjama for public ridicule". Early Times. 5 May 2008.
  40. "I did not receive any notice: Bhim Singh". Jammu Kashmir Newspoint. JK Media Group. 6 November 2005. Retrieved 15 March 2012.
  41. "Bhim Singh's tributes to Sheikh Nazir, his co-prisoner in Jammu Jail in 1962". JK Monitor. 26 February 2016. Retrieved 8 September 2016.
  42. "NPP Supremo recalls his jail days with Nazir Sheikh". Daily North In News. 25 February 2015. Retrieved 8 September 2016.
  43. "Young Bites : Daily | Leading News Paper of Jammu Kashmir". youngbites.in. Archived from the original on 2 October 2015. Retrieved 30 September 2015.
  44. "NPP pays tributes to Jammu student martyrs of 1966". Retrieved 30 September 2015.
  45. "Bhim Singh launches Jammu State Students Movement on Martyrs' 48th Anniversary - Scoop News Jammu Kashmir". www.scoopnews.in. Retrieved 30 September 2015.
  46. "Prince of peace' Ankit Love tries his luck at London's mayoral polls". Daily News and Analysis. 5 May 2016. Retrieved 31 December 2016. In fact Singh was the first Indian to get elected as Secretary of the London University Students Union in 1971. He crossed the Sahara Desert (from Tan Tan, Morocco to Senegal in 1971) becoming the first person in the world to cross the 2,200 km Sahara Desert in about 21 days with the banner of peace, human love and mutual co-existence.
  47. "Arjun Singh releases Bhim Singh's Book "Around the World on Motorcycle"". News Blaze. Alan Gray. 10 January 2009. Retrieved 17 March 2012.
  48. "The Tribune, Chandigarh, India - Delhi and neighbourhood". www.tribuneindia.com. Retrieved 3 October 2015.
  49. "Panthers Chief Bhim Singh in London on Peace Mission - Scoop News Jammu Kashmir". www.scoopnews.in. Retrieved 3 October 2015.
  50. Bhim, Singh (2008). Peace Mission Around the World on Motorcycle. 1. Har-anand Publications. p. 320. ISBN 978-8124114322.
  51. "VICE PRESIDENT RELEASES THE BOOK UNBELIEVABLE DELHI TO ISLAMABAD BY PROF". Business Standard. Retrieved 22 February 2016.
  52. "Ceasefire violations will continue till 'Kashmir issue is resolved': Bhim Singh". Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  53. "Bhim Singh called on Parliament to amend Article 370 - Scoop News Jammu Kashmir". www.scoopnews.in. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  54. "Vice President releases Bhim's book 'Unbelievable—Delhi to Islamabad' - State Times". Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  55. "Ankit Love contesting for London Mayor Election". Pakistan Christian Post. 29 April 2016. Retrieved 13 November 2016.
  56. "NPP Chief appeals Hackney electorate". Pakistan Christian Post. 9 September 2016. Retrieved 21 September 2016.
  57. "Udhampur Captured 'terrorist': Prof. Bhim Singh smells doubt on Govt statement, raised questions | Only Kashmir - Behind the News". onlykashmir.in. Archived from the original on 4 October 2015. Retrieved 3 October 2015.
  58. "Pakistan Christian Post". www.pakistanchristianpost.com. Retrieved 3 October 2015.
  59. Manager. "NPP welcome Vetican's decision to recognize, Palestine a great step towards peace". northnews.co.in. Retrieved 3 October 2015.
  60. "Diplomats hail documentary film on Yasser Arafat made by Bhim Singh". Pakistan Christian Post. Retrieved 20 December 2016.
  61. "Visit of Obama to Hiroshima and meeting with A-bomb survivors was more than apology". Pakistan Christian Post. 28 May 2016. Retrieved 15 February 2017.
  62. "NPP observes 69th anniversary of US bombing of Hiroshima& Nagasaki". Kashmir Times. Retrieved 15 February 2017.
  63. "Fast by Bhim Singh in Hiroshima for Disarmament, Peace & Brotherhood". Scoop News. Retrieved 15 February 2017.
  64. Rashid, Saima. "All of a Sudden, Kashmir Has a King, Living in Exile!". Kashmir Life. Retrieved 20 December 2016.
  65. "Indira Gandhi:Tallest leader of world:Bhim - Scoop News Jammu Kashmir". scoopnews.in. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  66. "Prof. Bhim Singh Official Website". profbhimsingh.com. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  67. "Bhim greets Atal Bihari on his 84th birthday - Scoop News Jammu Kashmir". www.scoopnews.in. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  68. "PM nominates Bhim Singh". News Blaze. Alan Gray. 8 October 2008. Retrieved 17 March 2012.
  69. Saraf, Pushp (4 June 1994). "Migration from Doda takes explosive turn". The Indian Express. The Indian Express Group. Retrieved 17 March 2012.
  70. "STATISTICAL REPORT ON GENERAL ELECTIONS, 1984" (PDF). National and State Abstracts & Detailed Results: 38. Archived from the original (PDF) on 18 July 2014.
  71. "Several Indian organizations condemn Israel for illegal occupation of Palestinian land". Pakistan Christian Post. Retrieved 12 February 2017.
  72. "Indo-Palestine Friendship Society/ Statement". Syria Times. Retrieved 12 February 2017.
  73. "As Gaza bleeds, Kashmir to remember Palestinian 'martyrs' this Eid". The Authint. 28 July 2014. Archived from the original on 13 February 2017. Retrieved 12 February 2017.
  74. "PM Modi's surprising silence on humiliation met to President of India at Israeli International Airport". Kashmir Watch. 15 October 2015. Retrieved 12 February 2017.
  75. Singh, Bhim; Helou, Angelina (1 January 1970). An Examination of Documents on which the State of Israel is Based. P.L.O. Research Center.
  76. "Arab rage, solidarity spreads". New Worker. Retrieved 12 February 2017. In New Delhi meanwhile, activists of the Indo-Palestine Friendship Society staged a oneday hunger strike in front of the Israeli embassy. They demanded Israel withdraw, adhere to UN resolutions, apologise for the massacre and compensate victims and their families for the death and destruction caused.
  77. "India's statement on Israeli attack weak: Palestine". Thaindian News. Archived from the original on 14 March 2016. Retrieved 12 February 2017.
  78. Koshy, Ninan. "INDIA: ISRAEL AND PALESTINE". Foreign Policy Research Centre. Archived from the original on 13 February 2017. Retrieved 12 February 2017. The Palestine Ambassador Adli Sadeq said he was ‘surprised’ over India’s ‘weak’ statement on May 31 Israeli attack on the flotilla of civilian aid ships. He was speaking at a conference organized by Indo-Palestine Friendship Society in New Delhi.
  79. Bhim Singh, MLA vs State Of J&K And Ors. (Supreme Court 22 November 1985) ("There certainly was a gross violation of Shri Bhim Singh's constitutional rights under Articles 21 and 22(2).") Full Text
  80. Khosa, Aasha (2 May 2006). "Bhim Singh seeks damages from Pathak panel". The Indian Express. The Indian Express Group. Retrieved 17 March 2012.
  81. "Trespass to person | Law Teacher". Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  82. Chopra, Joginder Kumar (1989). Politics of Election Reforms in India. Delhi: Mittal Publications. p. 282. ISBN 817099103X.
  83. Singh, Bhim (2002). Murder of Democracy in Jammu and Kashmir. New Delhi: Har-Anand Publications PVT LTD. pp. 27–30. ISBN 9788124108642.
  84. "Bhim meets CEC, demands re-poll in Udhampur". Kashmir Times. 24 April 2014. Retrieved 21 September 2016.
  85. "Panthers Party to contest 5 seats in J&K". The Hindu. The Hindu Group. 22 March 2004. Retrieved 17 March 2012.
  86. "Statistical Report on General Election 2002 to the Legislative Assembly of Jammu & Kashmir" (PDF). Election Commission of India. 2002. Retrieved 2 November 2016.
  87. Santoshi, Neeraj (18 June 2007). "Panthers Party withdraws support to J-K coalition". The Indian Express. The Indian Express Group. Retrieved 17 March 2012.
  88. Amarnath row divides Jammu and Kashmir Archived 10 August 2008 at the Wayback Machine NDTV, 16 August 2008
  89. Ganjoo, RC (15 July 2014). "India Legal". Champion of the Chained. p. 29. Retrieved 26 September 2015 – via ISSU.
  90. "Bhim Singh elected unopposed for Bar Association of Supreme Court of India". Pakistan Christian Post. 10 December 2016. Retrieved 18 December 2016.
  91. "Dogra Rattan Awards presented". Kashmir Times. Kashmir Times. 24 November 2011. Retrieved 17 March 2012.
  92. "Eight to get Dogra Rattan Award". The Tribune. Tribune Trust. 24 November 2011. Retrieved 17 March 2012.
  93. "SC rejects petition seeking governors rule in Jammu and Kashmir". India Today. Retrieved 1 August 2016.
  94. "Apex court says 'no' to plea for Governor's rule in J&K". The Hindu. 30 July 2016. ISSN 0971-751X. Retrieved 1 August 2016.
  95. "Supreme Court promises all help to Kashmiris, seeks report". The Economic Times. The Times Group. 29 July 2016. Retrieved 1 August 2016.
  96. "Court Seeks Report From Centre On 'Ground Realities' In Jammu And Kashmir". NDTV. 29 July 2016. Retrieved 1 August 2016.
  97. "SC asks Centre for report on 'ground realities' in J-K as protests continue". Hindustan Times. HT Media. 30 July 2016. Retrieved 1 August 2016.
  98. "SC for status report on J and K ground reality". Indian Express. 30 July 2016. Retrieved 1 August 2016.
  99. Vishwanath, Apurva (23 August 2016). "Jammu and Kashmir unrest cannot be dealt with by courts: Supreme Court". Retrieved 24 August 2016.
  100. "Kashmir issue can be resolved politically, not judicially: SC - Times of India". Retrieved 24 August 2016.
  101. ANI (6 February 2017). "SC to hear case seeking implementation of Advocates Act in J-K". Business Standard India. Retrieved 7 February 2017.
  102. "JKNPP leader oldest, poorest among candidates fighting LS polls from twin seats of Jammu region". Outlook India. Retrieved 4 February 2020.
  103. "Lok Sabha Elections 2019: JKNNP's Bhim Singh poorest candidate, BJP's Jugal Kishore richest in Jammu seat". Hindustan Times. 28 March 2019. Retrieved 4 February 2020.
  104. "Jammu & Kashmir Lok Sabha Election Results Live Update 2019, 2014, 2009 - List of Winning MPs". www.elections.in. Retrieved 4 February 2020.
  105. "Tap opens on Iraq oil offer - I was told of help to others: Bhim". The Telegraph India. Retrieved 21 December 2016.
  106. "Natwar was at Iraq anti-sanctions meetings: Bhim". Telegraph India. Retrieved 21 December 2016.
  107. "Volcker Report names Natwar Singh and Congress Party as "beneficiaries"". The Hindu. The Hindu Group. 29 October 2005. Retrieved 15 March 2012.
  108. "The Tribune, Chandigarh, India - Main News". www.tribuneindia.com. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  109. "Bhim Singh finds foreign hand in Volcker controversy". Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  110. Praveen, Swami (6 November 2005). "I did not receive any notice: Bhim Singh". The Hindu. The Hindu Group. Retrieved 15 March 2012.
  111. Ul-Hassan, Ishfaq (31 December 2006). "A friend mourns the dictator". Daily News and Analysis. Retrieved 19 June 2017.
  112. "'Dead Saddam can be more dangerous than living Saddam':Bhim Singh". www.oneindia.com. Retrieved 31 October 2015.
  113. "JKNPP Leaders protest against persecution - Scoop News Jammu Kashmir". www.scoopnews.in. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  114. "Lutyens Squatter Bhim Singh gets a Supreme eviction notice". India News Analysis Opinions on Niti Central. Archived from the original on 27 September 2015. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  115. "Supreme Court asks Bhim Singh to vacate VP house in Jammu and Kashmir in two months time". www.indianewschannels.com. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  116. Limited, InLinks Communication Private. "Panthers Burn Prime Minister's effigy - Jammu Links News". jammulinksnews.com. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
  117. "NPP for restoration of Bhim Singh's security cover". www.greaterkashmir.com. Retrieved 8 November 2015.
  118. "'Restore security to Bhim Singh' - State Times". State Times. State Times. Retrieved 8 November 2015.
  119. KD, Srinagar. "CIA, Mossad active to 'dissect Kashmir from India', says Jammu Dogra leader". KashmirDispatch. Retrieved 19 January 2016.
  120. "CIA trying to separate JK from India, claims Bhim Singh". Greater Kashmir. Retrieved 19 January 2016.
  121. "Look who's crying for Milosevic". Indian Express. Retrieved 19 January 2016.
  122. "PM Modi must explain his conduct for alliance with PDP in Kashmir". Pakistan Christian Post. Retrieved 19 January 2016.
  123. "'ISI agent' Hurriyat is 'no party', says Bhim Singh". Zee News. Retrieved 19 January 2016.
  124. "Cold War (1945-1991): External Course". The Oxford Encyclopedia of American Military and Diplomatic History. Oxford University Press. 8 January 2013. p. 219. ISBN 978-0199759255.
  125. "Bhim urges UN to stop NATO genocide in Libya, Pakistan - Scoop News Jammu Kashmir". Scoop News. Retrieved 19 January 2016.
  126. "Did Gaddafi Deserve to Die in Barbaric Way?". News Blaze. Retrieved 19 January 2016.
  127. "Panthers party Chief demands CBI probe over J&K custodial death". NewsX. 6 October 2011. Retrieved 17 October 2016.
  128. "Raja Aijaz hits back: Says Omar main accused in Haji Yousuf case". Greater Kashmir. 6 December 2014. Retrieved 17 October 2016.
  129. "National Panthers Party mourns death of Fidel Castro". Pakistan Christian Post. 26 November 2016. Retrieved 12 December 2016.
  130. "People of India congratulate Cuban victory after 54 years of their resistance". National Turk. Retrieved 12 December 2016.
  131. "Common between Bhim, Fidel Castro". Early Times Newspaper Jammu Kashmir. 6 June 2009. Retrieved 12 December 2016.
  132. "NPP Supremo Releases Film On Christ – 'Star Of Bethlehem'". www.maahyderabad.in. Retrieved 13 February 2017.
gollark: Why does this work really fast during testing but really slow if used?
gollark: ++experimental_qa Bee When is bee?
gollark: I see.
gollark: ++experimental_qa Israel Israel or Palestine?
gollark: ++experimental_qa Bee When is bee?
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.