Ulmus 'Nanguen' = Lutece

Ulmus 'Nanguen' (selling name Lutèce) is a complex fourth generation Dutch hybrid cultivar raised at the Dorschkamp Research Institute for Forestry & Landscape Planning, Wageningen. Lutèce was derived from the cross 'Plantyn' × ('Bea Schwarz' selfed), an ancestry comprising four field elms (U. minor), a wych elm (U. glabra), the curious Exeter Elm ('Exoniensis'), and a frost-resistant selection of the Himalayan elm (U. wallichiana).

Ulmus 'Nanguen' = Lutece
Lutèce aged 20 years, Great Fontley, UK
Genus	Ulmus
Hybrid parentage	'Plantyn' × ('Bea Schwarz' × 'Bea Schwarz' selfed)
Cultivar	'Nanguen' = Lutece™
Origin	Wageningen, The Netherlands

Originally identified as clone 812, Lutèce was not promoted by the Dutch owing to unfounded fears that it may prove susceptible to coral spot fungus (Nectria cinnabarina). Instead, 812 was acquired by the French Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique (INRA), which subjected the tree to 20 years of field trials in the Bois de Vincennes, Paris, before patenting and release in 2002 as 'Nanguen' = Lutèce.[1][2]

Lutèce has been deemed the modern cultivar most closely resembling the native European elms.[3]

Description

The stem of Lutèce typically forks at a height of 1–2 m, where 3–5 steeply ascending branches develop in conjunction with more obtusely angled lower side branches to form an amorphous open crown. The ultimate size and shape of this cultivar remain unknown but, given its ancestry, it should make a large tree.[4] The trees planted in the Bois de Vincennes attained an average height of 12.5 m with a trunk diameter of 22 cm at 20 years of age.[5] Quick growing on moist, well-drained soils, increasing in height by an average of 80 cm per annum, the tree commences flowering in late March when aged seven years. The leaves are elliptic to orbicular < 11 cm long × 9 cm wide, the acuminate apex far less pronounced than in most other elms, with coarse, doubly serrate margins; the upper surface is rough. The leaves flush relatively late, rarely before mid-May in England. The samarae are obovate, slightly notched at the outer end, 14–22 mm long by 11–17 mm broad. The seed is not central but slightly nearer the notch, and ripens in late May.

• 
  Lutèce leaf in August
• 
  Lutèce samarae
• 
  White-letter hairstreak on Lutèce, Sweden
• 
  Lutèce, IoW, hosting white-letter hairstreak
• 
  Lutèce root suckering, Ports Down, UK
• 
  Bark of 22-year-old tree

Pests and diseases

Lutèce exhibited a high resistance to Dutch elm disease when inoculated with unnaturally high doses of the causal fungus Ophiostoma novo-ulmi, and was rated 5 out of 5 in Dutch tests.[6] Tests in France by INRA confirmed the tree has 'highly resistant'.[5] [7] In trials conducted by the Istituto per la Protezione delle Piante, Florence, Lutèce suffered 19.8% defoliation and 11.7% dieback when inoculated, compared with 2.8% and 1.2% resp. for 'Sapporo Autumn Gold', and 50% and 35.5% resp. for 'Lobel'.[8][9]

The presence of U. wallichiana in the ancestry of Lutèce poses the risk of susceptibility to elm yellows (phloem necrosis), which seriously damaged its Dutch stablemate 'Lobel' used as a control in the Italian elm breeding programme.[10]

Cultivation

The cultivar is now being widely planted in cities, notably Paris, and rural areas of France.[11] In trials in southern England, the tree has proven very hardy, tolerant of sea winds, summer droughts, and ground waterlogged during winter. However, top-growth can often outpace root development, leaving some trees susceptible to wind-rock when young and necessitating staking for up to six years. Lutèce is cold hardy, and has survived winter temperatures as low as - 30° C in Sweden.

Lutèce was introduced to the UK by the Hampshire & Isle of Wight Branch, Butterfly Conservation, in 2001, as part of its assessment of DED-resistant cultivars as potential hosts of the endangered White-letter Hairstreak. The plants were donated by SAPHO (Syndicate for the improvement of ornamental horticultural plants) ahead of its release to commerce.[12] Lutèce was introduced to North America in 2010, with the supply of two small specimens to the USDA, Washington, D.C., released from quarantine in 2013. Lutèce is not known to have been introduced to Australasia.

Increasing Lutèce by softwood cuttings is relatively straightforward, however these lose their viability as the trees mature, and French nurseries now resort to grafting onto 'Sapporo Autumn Gold' rootstocks. As the latter does not sucker from roots, the practice eliminates natural vegetative regeneration [13]

Hybridization

Lutèce has been found to hybridize readily with Ulmus minor in trials by IRSTEA in France, often producing copious quantities of fertile seed.[13]

Conservation role

Over 5000 Lutèce were planted on the Isle of Wight by Natural Enterprise, and in smaller numbers in Hampshire by Butterfly Conservation and the Forestry Commission, in the hope the tree would host the white-letter hairstreak butterfly (Satyrium w-album), a monophagic species which remains in serious decline as a consequence of Dutch elm disease. This was confirmed in 2015 with the discovery of the butterfly breeding on specimens planted in 2003 at Towngate, Newport, Isle of Wight (see photo 5 in Gallery).[12]

Etymology

The selling name Lutèce is the French derivation of Lutetia, the ancient Roman name for the settlement which later became Paris. The name was adopted in recognition of the trials of the cultivar conducted by INRA in the Bois de Vincennes.

Accessions

Europe

• Brighton & Hove City Council, UK. NCCPG Elm Collection.[14] Stanmer Nursery.
• Great Fontley Farm, Fareham, UK. Butterfly Conservation Elm Trials plantation, Home Field and the Platt, five small whips donated by SAPHO [15] in 2002.
• Longstock Park Arboretum, UK. One juvenile specimen planted 2010.
• Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh, UK. Acc. no. 20042084
• Sir Harold Hillier Gardens, UK. Acc. no. 2004.0515
• Wijdemeren City Council, Netherlands. Elm collection. Used in elm trials Ankeveen 2009.

North America

• National Arboretum, Washington, D.C., US. Two small trees imported in 2010.

Nurseries

Europe

• Batouwe Boomkwekerijen B.V. , Dodewaard, Netherlands. Potted whips.
• F P Matthews 'Trees for Life' , Tenbury Wells, Worcestershire, UK. Potted trees, not grafted.
• Golden Hill Plants , Marden, Kent, UK. Potted trees, not grafted.
• Hilliers Nurseries , Ampfield, UK. P9's and standards.
• Les Pépiniéres Minier (UK: [e-mail]), Beaufort-en-Vallée, France. Bare-rooted grafted whips, minimum export value: €500.
• Van Den Berk (UK) Ltd., , London, UK

References

1. SAPHO. Ulmus 'Nanguen' = Lutèce, , La Menitre, France.
2. Department of Forest Health, Forest Health in France 2002 , Paris, France.
3. Hillier, J. G. & Lancaster, R. (Eds). (2014). The Hillier Manual of Trees and Shrubs, 8th revised edition. Royal Horticultural Society; London. ISBN 978-1907057472
4. Johnson, H. (2010). Trees. London: Mitchell Beazley. ISBN 9781845330552
5. Pinon, J. (July 2007). "Les ormes résistants à la graphiose" [Elms resistant to Dutch Elm Disease] (PDF). Forêt-entreprise. Paris, France: IDF (175): 37–41. ISSN 0752-5974. Retrieved 26 October 2017.
6. Heybroek, H. M., Goudzwaard, L, Kaljee, H. (2009). Iep of olm, karakterboom van de Lage Landen (:Elm, a tree with character of the Low Countries). KNNV, Uitgeverij. ISBN 9789050112819
7. Pinon, J., Lohou, C. & Cadic, A. (1998). Hybrid Elms (Ulmus Spp.): Adaptability in Paris and behaviour towards Dutch elm disease (Ophiostoma novo-ulmi). Acta Horticulturae 496, 107-114, 1998.
8. Santini, A, et al. (2002). 'San Zanobi' and 'Plinio' Elm trees. HortScience 37(7): 1139–1141, 2002.
9. Herling, D. (2014). Resistant Elms.
10. Mittempergher, L., (2000). Elm Yellows in Europe. In: The Elms, Conservation and Disease Management. 103–119. Dunn C.P., ed. Kluwer Academic Press Publishers, Boston, USA.
11. "Lutèce®, a resistant variety brings elms back to Paris". All The News. Nantes, France: Institut national de la recherche agronomique (INRA). 15 April 2005. Archived from the original on 25 November 2006.
12. Brookes, A. H. (2020). Disease-resistant elm cultivars. Butterfly Conservation, Lulworth, England.
13. Brookes, A. H. (2020). Great Fontley Elm Trial, 2020 Report. Butterfly Conservation, Lulworth, England.
14. "List of plants in the {elm} collection". Brighton & Hove City Council. Retrieved 23 September 2016.
15. What is SAPHO?

Pictures

Photographs of the Isle of Wight's Island 2000 Trust planting Lutece elms can be seen at the Flickr website here at and .