John Mott-Smith

John Mott-Smith (November 25, 1824 – August 10, 1895) was the first dentist to set up a permanent practice in the Kingdom of Hawaii. He was also a politician, newspaper editor, and diplomat.

The Honourable John Mott-Smith
Minister of Finance
In office December 21, 1869 – August 25, 1872
Monarch	Kamehameha V
Preceded by	Charles Coffin Harris
Succeeded by	Robert Stirling
In office July 28, 1891 – October 17, 1891
Monarch	Liliʻuokalani
Preceded by	Samuel Parker
Succeeded by	Samuel Parker
Minister of Interior
In office December 5, 1876 – July 3, 1878
Monarch	Kalākaua
Preceded by	William Luther Moehonua
Succeeded by	Samuel Gardner Wilder
Minister to the United States
In office 1891 – January 17, 1893
Monarch	Liliʻuokalani
Preceded by	Henry A. P. Carter
Personal details
Born	(1824-11-25)November 25, 1824 New York City, United States
Died	August 10, 1895(1895-08-10) (aged 70) Honolulu, Oahu, Kingdom of Hawaii
Resting place	Oahu Cemetery
Nationality	Kingdom of Hawaii
Spouse(s)	Ellen Dominis Paty
Children	7
Occupation	Dentist, diplomat, politician

Life

John Mott-Smith was born in New York City on November 13, 1824. His father was also named John Mott Smith (1795–1832), generally spelled without the hyphen, and mother was Amanda Day. His father had trained as a physician, but became a Methodist minister instead, and was Principal of Wesleyan Seminary in New York in 1820. In 1826 the family moved to White Plains, New York with the school, and then in 1832 to Middletown, Connecticut where his father became a professor of classical languages at the new Wesleyan University.[1] His father died in 1832 and was one of the first burials in the university cemetery.[2] Subsequently, having attended Wesleyan, the young Mott-Smith borrowed a book from a friend who was attending dental school and passed the exams to set up a practice in Albany, New York. He moved to California as part of the California Gold Rush in 1849 and practised dentistry there for two years. He sailed to Hawaii in early 1851.[3]

He was only the third Western-trained dentist in the Hawaiian Islands and the first to set up a permanent practice. Two others, M. B. Stevens and George Colburn left after brief stays in the previous two years.[3] For about 15 years he did most of the dental work in Honolulu. He shared an office building with physician William Hillebrand. In 1853 he had his first taste of politics when he was elected to the House of Representatives in the legislature of the Hawaiian Kingdom.[4]

His dentist office in 1853

In 1866 Mott-Smith gave up his dental practice to John Morgan Whitney, the first in Hawaii to actually graduate from a dental school.[3] He became editor of the newspaper Hawaiian Gazette. He used the paper to defend the monarchy, which gained him favor with King Kamehameha V, who made it the official government publication.[5] He returned to the legislature in 1866, and was elected Vice President of it in 1867. In 1868 he was sent to Washington, D.C., to help Elisha Hunt Allen negotiate a trade treaty, but was not successful. On December 21, 1869 he returned and was appointed to the powerful post of Minister of Finance in the cabinet. He served until August 25, 1872.[4] With the king's influence, he was an investor with fellow American politician Charles Coffin Harris in the first Hawaiian Hotel. The government issued bonds to finance its construction.[6] After Kamehameha V's death at the end of 1872, Mott-Smith was out of political power and resumed practising dentistry[3] while he was on the Board of Education until 1874.

After the liberal King Lunalilo died and King Kalākaua was elected in 1874, monarchists were back in political favor. On December 4, 1876 Mott-Smith was appointed Minister of Interior, serving until July 3, 1878. From 1876 through 1886 he served in the upper House of Nobles in the kingdom legislature when he was not traveling.[4] It was widely suspected that Kalākaua's replacement of his cabinet was influenced by Claus Spreckels, who refinanced the King's debts the night before, in order to secure water rights for his sugarcane plantation on Maui.[7][8] Since the bachelor Lunalilo left no heirs, Mott-Smith was appointed to the first board of trustees of the Lunalilo Trust.[9] In 1884 he was put in charge of the Hawaii exhibits at the World Cotton Centennial in New Orleans, Louisiana. He returned and was appointed Minister of Finance by Queen Liliʻuokalani on July 28, 1891. However, by October 17, 1891 he resigned and was sent back to Washington.[4] Samuel Parker acted as finance minister both before and after him. His hope was to negotiate a replacement for the Reciprocity Treaty of 1875, but he was recalled after the 1893 Overthrow of the Kingdom of Hawaii. His position was just below the diplomatic rank of 21st-century ambassador. He retired to Honolulu where he died August 10, 1895 after an illness of several weeks.[10][11] After a funeral at the Sain Andrew Cathedral he was buried in Oahu Cemetery.[12]

Family and legacy

In 1859 he married Ellen Dominis Paty. They had seven children. Son Ernest Augustus Mott-Smith was born May 12, 1873 went to Harvard Law School briefly, married Anna Elizabeth Paty in 1896 and became active in politics.[13] He practised law, and served on various government boards of the Territory of Hawaii, such as the Board of Health from 1901–1925, and territorial secretary from 1907–1914.[14] Other sons were Harold Meade Mott-Smith and Morton Churchill Mott-Smith. Daughters were Martha Paty Smith, Myra Harris Smith who married Reverend James B. Thomas, Ida Campbell Smith who married Robert Morss Lovett in Chicago, and May Henderson Smith. He left a substantial estate after investing in sugar plantations in Hawaii[15] which his newspaper had earlier promoted.[16]

A Mott-Smith building and Mott-Smith drive in Makiki at 21°18′33″N 157°50′13″W are named for him.[17] The three-story brick building built in 1897 at the corner of Hotel and Fort Streets (the site of his former office, later known as The Hub) contained the second electric elevator in Hawaii.[18]

See also

• Hawaiian Kingdom–United States relations
• List of bilateral treaties signed by the Hawaiian Kingdom

References

1. William Buell Sprague (1859). "John Mott Smith of the New York Conference". Annals of the American Pulpit: Methodist. [1859. Robert Carter & Brothers. pp. 567–569.
2. "Wesleyan facts and trivia". Wesleyan University web site. Archived from the original on May 27, 2010. Retrieved May 28, 2010.
3. Robert C. Schmitt (1983). "Royal Crowns and Historic Plaque: Dentistry in Hawaii during the 19th Century". Hawaiian Journal of History. 17. Hawaii Historical Society. pp. 143–155. hdl:10524/355.
4. "Mott-Smith, John office record". state archives digital collections. state of Hawaii. Archived from the original on March 6, 2012. Retrieved May 28, 2010.
5. George F. Nellist, ed. (1925). "Dr. John Mott-Smith". The Story of Hawaii and Its Builders. Honolulu Star-Bulletin.
6. Phillip H. Harris (1993). "Charles Coffin Harris: An Uncommon Life in the Law". Hawaiian Journal of History. 27. Hawaii Historical Society. pp. 151–171. hdl:10524/224.
7. Jacob Adler (July 1965). "The Maui Land Deal: A Chapter in Claus Spreckels' Hawaiian Career". Agricultural History. 39 (3): 155–163. JSTOR 3740255.
8. Ralph Simpson Kuykendall (1967). Hawaiian Kingdom 1874-1893, the Kalakaua Dynasty. 3. University of Hawaii Press. p. 200. ISBN 978-0-87022-433-1.
9. "Lunalilo Trust Leadership". King William Charles Lunalilo Trust. 2009. Retrieved October 17, 2010.
10. "Dr Mott-Smith Dead: Peaceful end of a veteran public man's career". Honolulu Evening Bulletin. August 10, 1895. Retrieved May 28, 2010.
11. "Death of Mott-Smith: A Prominent Citizen Passes Away". The Independent. August 10, 1895. p. 3. hdl:10524/1157.
12. Richard A. Greer (1967). "Here Lies History: Oahu Cemetery, a Mirror of Old Honolulu". Hawaiian Journal of History. 1. Hawaii Historical Society. p. 66. hdl:10524/384.
13. John William Siddall (1921). Men of Hawaii: being a biographical reference library, complete and authentic, of the men of note and substantial achievement in the Hawaiian Islands. Honolulu Star-Bulletin. pp. 289–290.
14. "Mott-Smith, Ernest A. office record". state archives digital collections. state of Hawaii. Retrieved May 28, 2010.
15. "Dr. J. Smith's Will: Several legacies to relatives in New England". Honolulu Evening Bulletin. August 14, 1895. Retrieved May 28, 2010.
16. Helen Geracimos Chapin (1996). Shaping history: the role of newspapers in Hawai'i. University of Hawaii Press. pp. 64–65. ISBN 978-0-8248-1718-3.
17. Mary Kawena Pukui; Samuel H. Elbert; Esther T. Mookini (July 1974). Place names of Hawaii. University of Hawaii Press. p. 158. ISBN 978-0-8248-0524-1.
18. Robert C. Schmitt (1981). "Some Construction and Housing Firsts in Hawaii". Hawaiian Journal of History. 15. Hawaii Historical Society. p. 103. hdl:10524/222.

Further reading

• Robert M. Gibson, Terry Lawhead (1989). Dr. John Mott-Smith: Hawaii's first royal dentist and last royal ambassador. Smilepower Institute. ISBN 978-0-9623371-1-6.

Government offices
Preceded by Charles Coffin Harris	Kingdom of Hawaii Minister of Finance 1869–1872	Succeeded by Robert Stirling
Preceded by William Luther Moehonua	Kingdom of Hawaii Minister of Interior 1876–1878	Succeeded by Samuel G. Wilder
Preceded by Samuel Parker	Kingdom of Hawaii Minister of Finance July 1891 – October 1891	Succeeded by Samuel Parker
Diplomatic posts
Preceded by Henry A. P. Carter	Kingdom of Hawaii Minister to U.S. 1891–1893	Succeeded by Kingdom overthrown