Edward McTiernan

Sir Edward Aloysius McTiernan, KBE (16 February 1892 – 9 January 1990), was an Australian lawyer, politician, and judge. He served on the High Court of Australia from 1930 to 1976, the longest-serving judge in the court's history.

The Right Honourable Sir Edward McTiernan KBE
McTiernan in his chambers, 1954.
Justice of the High Court of Australia
In office 20 December 1930 – 12 September 1976
Nominated by	James Scullin
Appointed by	Lord Stonehaven
Preceded by	Sir Isaac Isaacs
Succeeded by	Sir Keith Aickin
Member of the Australian House of Representatives
In office 12 October 1929 – 19 December 1930
Preceded by	Charles Marr
Succeeded by	Charles Marr
Constituency	Parkes
Attorney General of New South Wales
In office 12 April 1920 – 13 April 1922
Premier	John Storey James Dooley
Preceded by	John Garland
Succeeded by	Thomas Bavin
In office 17 June 1925 – 26 May 1927
Premier	Jack Lang
Preceded by	Thomas Bavin
Succeeded by	Andrew Lysaght
Member of the New South Wales Legislative Assembly
In office 20 March 1920 – 7 September 1927
Preceded by	Seat created
Succeeded by	Seat abolished
Constituency	Western Suburbs
Personal details
Born	(1892-02-16)16 February 1892 Glen Innes, New South Wales, Australia
Died	9 January 1990(1990-01-09) (aged 97) Turramurra, New South Wales, Australia
Political party	Labor (to 1930)
Spouse(s)	Kathleen Lloyd ( m. 1948)

McTiernan was born in Glen Innes, New South Wales. He graduated from the University of Sydney in 1915, and was called to the bar the following year. McTiernan was elected to the New South Wales Legislative Assembly in 1920, representing the Labor Party, and was soon after appointed Attorney-General of New South Wales. He served as attorney-general under John Storey, James Dooley, and Jack Lang, but left state politics in 1927. McTiernan was elected to the House of Representatives in 1929, but served for little over a year before Prime Minister James Scullin nominated him to the High Court. He was 38 at the time; only H. V. Evatt (another Scullin nominee) was appointed at a younger age. On the court, McTiernan was considered a moderate, and was known for the consistency of his decisions. He generally favoured the position of the federal government, upholding the constitutionality of contentious legislation from both sides of politics. McTiernan retired reluctantly at the age of 84, after just under 46 years on the High Court bench. He lived to the age of 97, and was the last surviving MP from the 1920s.

Early years

McTiernan was born in Glen Innes, New South Wales, the second of three sons born to Isabella (née Diamond) and Patrick McTiernan. His parents were Irish Catholic immigrants; his father worked as a policeman. McTiernan began his education at Metz Public School, located in a small settlement west of Hillgrove. He and his family moved to Sydney in 1900, when he was about eight. He completed his education at Catholic schools, Christian Brothers' High School, Lewisham, and St Mary's Cathedral College.[1]

McTiernan left school in 1908 initially lacking the funds to attend university, instead joining the Commonwealth Public Service as a clerk. He eventually began studying part-time at the University of Sydney, graduating with a Bachelor of Arts in 1912. He subsequently served his articles of clerkship at Sly & Russell while completing a Bachelor of Laws, graduating with first-class honours in 1915. He was called to the bar the following year and was taken on as an associate of Justice George Rich, whom he would eventually join on the High Court. He was rejected for military service during World War I due to an arm fracture sustained in childhood that had never properly healed.[1]

Political career

McTiernan as a member of the New South Wales Legislative Assembly.

After five years as a barrister, McTiernan was elected to the New South Wales Legislative Assembly in 1920 as the Member for Western Suburbs. McTiernan served in the ministry as Attorney-General of New South Wales from April 1920 to April 1922 and again from June 1925 to May 1927,[2] He was heavily involved in Premier Jack Lang's attempt to abolish the New South Wales Legislative Council. He retired from the Assembly in 1927 and took up a position as a law lecturer with his alma mater. Two years later, however, he was elected to federal parliament as the member for Parkes. This was to be short-lived, as in 1930, one year into McTiernan's term, Prime Minister James Scullin nominated him to the High Court of Australia, along with H. V. Evatt. Their appointment was controversial, due to their youth (McTiernan was 38 and Evatt 36), perceived inexperience, and political connections – both were members of the Labor Party up until taking office, and the Labor caucus had publicly resolved "that the government should appoint to the bench two men known to have social views sympathetic to Labor".[1]

High Court

McTiernan c. 1930

As a judge of the High Court, McTiernan was involved in several significant cases in Australian legal history, including Bank of New South Wales v Commonwealth, which struck down an attempt to nationalise the banks, Australian Communist Party v The Commonwealth, which struck down an attempt to ban the Communist Party of Australia and R v Kirby; ex parte Boilermakers' Society of Australia, which reinforced the doctrine of the separation of powers. He was the sole dissenter in Attorney-General (Vic) ex rel Dale v Commonwealth (1945), which struck down the Chifley Government's Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme and triggered a constitutional amendment. He served under five Chief Justices - Sir Isaac Isaacs, Sir Frank Gavan Duffy, Sir John Latham, Sir Owen Dixon and Sir Garfield Barwick, and was knighted himself in 1951.[3]

McTiernan was one of only eight justices of the High Court to have served in the Parliament of Australia prior to his appointment to the Court; the others were Edmund Barton, Richard O'Connor, Isaac Isaacs, H. B. Higgins, John Latham, Garfield Barwick, and Lionel Murphy.[4] He was also one of six justices to have served in the Parliament of New South Wales, along with Barton, O'Connor, Albert Piddington, Adrian Knox and H. V. Evatt.

McTiernan was a member of the High Court for 46 years, making him the longest-serving judge in its history. This record is unlikely to be broken, as a constitutional change in 1977 introduced compulsory retirement ages for federal judges; a justice of the High Court must now retire at 70.[5] McTiernan had no intention of resigning from the bench even into the 1970s, but, after breaking a hip at the age of 84 in 1976 while chasing a cricket in his hotel with a rolled up newspaper, Chief Justice Barwick's refusal to include a wheelchair ramp in the design of the new High Court building prompted his retirement.[6]

Secret inquiry

In 1943, McTiernan was approached by Attorney-General H. V. Evatt to conduct an inquiry into claims that test results at the Aircraft Production Commission Testing Laboratory in Sydney had been fabricated. This might have compromised the structural integrity of Bristol Beaufort bombers being used by the Royal Australian Air Force (RAAF). Arthur Calwell, the Minister for Information, applied strict wartime censorship to the inquiry, with no press coverage allowed. The full report has never been made public, although a summary prepared for cabinet is held by the National Archives. McTiernan was effectively granted the powers of a Royal Commissioner. His inquiry is the third and most recent occasion on which a sitting High Court judge was called upon to investigate a matter on behalf of the federal government (usually regarded as a breach of separation of powers). The other two instances occurred during World War I, when George Rich and Samuel Griffith conducted Royal Commissions.[7]

Personal life

According to Jack Lang, McTiernan was "very much attached to his parents". He did not marry until the age of 56, wedding Kathleen Lloyd on 27 December 1948 at St Roch's Catholic Church, Glen Iris, Melbourne. The couple had no children. McTiernan died in Turramurra, Sydney, on 9 January 1990, at the age of 97. He was buried in Rookwood Cemetery. He is the oldest lived High Court judge, and at the time of his death was the last remaining member of parliament from the 1920s.[1]

References

1. John M. Williams and Fiona Wheeler, 'McTiernan, Sir Edward Aloysius (Eddie) (1892–1990)', Australian Dictionary of Biography, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University, http://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/mctiernan-sir-edward-aloysius-eddie-14854/text26039, published first in hardcopy 2012, accessed online 18 October 2017
2. "Sir Edward Aloysius McTiernan (1892-1990)". Former Members of the Parliament of New South Wales. Retrieved 11 May 2019.
3. Sir Edward McTiernan (family history)
4. Evatt served in the Federal Parliament after his resignation from the High Court.
5. Constitution section 71, after Constitution Alteration (Retirement of Judges) 1977
6. Marr, David (1980). Barwick. Sydney: Allen & Unwin. p. 290.
7. Fiona Wheeler (30 November 2011). "'Anomalous Occurrences in Unusual Circumstances'? Towards a History of Extra‐Judicial Activity by High Court Justices" (PDF). High Court of Australia Public Lectures.

External links

New South Wales Legislative Assembly
New district	Member for Western Suburbs 1920–1927 With: Lazzarini, Hoskins, Shillington/Ness, Wilson/Jarvie	District abolished
Political offices
Preceded by John FitzGerald	Minister for Justice 1920	Succeeded by William McKell
Preceded by John Garland	Attorney General of New South Wales 1920–1921	Succeeded by Thomas Bavin
Preceded by Thomas Bavin	Attorney General of New South Wales 1921–1922
Preceded by Thomas Bavin	Attorney General of New South Wales 1925–1927	Succeeded by Andrew Lysaght
Diplomatic posts
Preceded by Sir Timothy Coghlan	Agent-General for New South Wales (acting) 1926	Succeeded by The Viscount Chelmsford
Parliament of Australia
Preceded by Charles Marr	Member for Parkes 1929–1930	Succeeded by Charles Marr
Legal offices
Preceded by Sir Isaac Isaacs	Puisne Justice of the High Court of Australia 1930–1976	Succeeded by Sir Keith Aickin