Edgar Benson

Edgar John "Ben" Benson PC, FCA, BComm (May 28, 1923 – September 2, 2011) was a Canadian politician, businessman, diplomat, and university professor. He held four cabinet posts, most notably that of Minister of Finance under Pierre Trudeau, where he was instrumental in reforming Canada's income tax law.[1] He was described as "Pierre Trudeau's unflappable finance minister, the pipe-smoking financial wizard who raised the ire of corporate Canada in the 1970s by bringing in a capital gains tax."[1]

For Edgar A. Benson, founder of an eponymous 1920s swing orchestra, see Benson Orchestra of Chicago.

The Honourable Edgar John Benson PC, FCA, BComm
Member of Parliament for Kingston (1962–1968); Kingston and the Islands (1968–1972)
In office 1962–1968
Preceded by	Benjamin Graydon Allmark
Succeeded by	Flora MacDonald
In office April 20, 1968 – January 28, 1972
Preceded by	Mitchell Sharp
Succeeded by	John Turner
Personal details
Born	May 28, 1923 Cobourg, Ontario
Died	September 2, 2011(2011-09-02) (aged 88) Ottawa, Ontario
Resting place	Beechwood Cemetery
Political party	Liberal
Spouse(s)	Marie Louise van Laer (1946–1974) Mary Jane Binks (1987–2011)
Alma mater	Queen's University (1949)
Profession	Chartered Accountant (1952)
Military service
Branch/service	Canadian Army
Years of service	1941–1946
Rank	Sergeant
Unit	1st Survey Regiment, RCA I Canadian Corps

Early years

After serving overseas in the Second World War as a sergeant in the Royal Canadian Artillery, Benson attended Queen's University in Kingston, Ontario, where he obtained his Bachelor of Commerce degree. He became a chartered accountant and partner in the accounting firm of England, Leonard, Macpherson and Company, and co-owner of CKLC.[2] Prior to his entry into politics, he was also a lecturer in Business Administration at Queen's, in the capacity of Assistant Professor of Commerce.[3][4]

Political life

He was first elected to the House of Commons of Canada in the 1962 general election as the Liberal Member of Parliament (MP) for Kingston, Ontario. Initially appointed in 1962 as Parliamentary Secretary to then Minister of Finance Walter Gordon, he entered the Cabinet of Prime Minister Lester Pearson in 1964 as Minister of National Revenue, and served concurrently from 1966 to 1968 as the first President of the Treasury Board.

He was an early supporter of Pierre Trudeau in the 1968 Liberal leadership campaign to replace the retiring Pearson, and, together with Jean Marchand, was co-chairman of Trudeau's leadership bid.[1] He was later appointed Minister of Finance, serving from 1968 to 1972.

Tax reform (1971)

Benson's balanced budget for 1969-70 would be the last until Paul Martin's budget of 1997-98.[5] Later in 1969, he introduced his white paper on Canadian tax reform, which paved the way for:

• a capital gains tax[6]
• a tax deduction for child care as a means of helping mothers enter the workforce[7]
• greater use of Registered Retirement Savings Plans[8]

The proposals were subjected to intensive debate that lasted more than a year. Those concerning the capital gains tax were severely criticized by the business community, particularly Israel Asper, who condemned the measure.[9] The reforms were only passed after significant amendment, and even then only through the use of closure.[1] They came into effect on January 1, 1972, as prescribed by the 1971 Canadian federal budget[10]

Marc Lalonde, a colleague and future Finance Minister, later said, "He was in finance at a critical time, he revolutionized the system. He launched a revolution. It was a revolution, a necessary step and a demanding task. What he did was economically justified. The basic tax structure that he put in place is still alive. No one has really touched it since."[1]

Impact

He was also instrumental in rolling out a national medical care plan and supplementary old age pensions and played a key role in federal-provincial relations.

Benson wore a pair of new shoes on budget day in 1968, although he said, "He didn't buy them just for the budget."[11] The following year he did not wear new shoes when delivering the budget, saying jokingly that he couldn't afford them,[12] and in 1970 proudly displayed his worn soles on budget day.[13]

He later served as Minister of National Defence from January to August 1972, when he retired from politics, choosing not to run in the 1972 election.

Later life and death

Benson served as President of the Canadian Transport Commission from 1972 to 1982,[14] and as Canadian Ambassador to Ireland from 1982 to 1985.[15] He died on September 2, 2011 at the age of 88.[16]

Honours

Benson was conferred honorary degrees as a Doctor of Laws from:

• Royal Military College of Canada in 1973
• Queen's University in 2008[17]

Electoral record

Kingston

1962 Canadian federal election
Party		Candidate	Votes
	Liberal	Edgar John Benson	16,828
	Progressive Conservative	Benjamin Allmark	13,599
	New Democratic	John McKinnon	1,468
	Social Credit	Ernest Hogan	214

1963 Canadian federal election
Party		Candidate	Votes
	Liberal	Edgar John Benson	18,425
	Progressive Conservative	J. Earl McEwen	12,879
	New Democratic	Denis Kalman	2,400
	Social Credit	Grace C.A. Gough	194

1965 Canadian federal election
Party		Candidate	Votes
	Liberal	Edgar John Benson	16,022
	Progressive Conservative	J. Earl McEwen	12,766
	New Democratic	John Meister	3,530

Kingston and the Islands

1968 Canadian federal election
Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Liberal	Edgar Benson	16,234	49.7
	Progressive Conservative	Boggart Trumpour	11,799	36.1
	New Democratic	Brendan McConnell	4,636	14.2
Total valid votes			32,669	100.0

Further reading

• Benson, E.J. (1969). Proposals for tax reform (PDF). Ottawa: Queen's Printer for Canada.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Benson, E.J. (1971). Summary of 1971 Tax Reform Legislation (PDF). Ottawa: Queen's Printer for Canada.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)

References

1. Hustak 2011.
2. "Radio station history - CKLC-FM". Canadian Communications Foundation. Archived from the original on 2017-03-05.
3. "Tax Reform (speech)". Empire Club of Canada. February 13, 1969.
4. "Flags lowered for former School of Business professor". Queen's Gazette. Queen's University. September 9, 2011. Archived from the original on September 19, 2016. Retrieved August 23, 2016.
5. Brian Lee Crowley; Jeff Waldman (2011). Fearful Symmetry - The Fall and Rise of Canada's Founding Values. Ottawa: Macdonald-Laurier Institute. ISBN 978-1-4566-0552-0.
6. Benson 1969, ch. 3.
7. Benson 1969, par. 2.7-2.9.
8. Benson 1969, par. 2.45-2.52.
9. Israel Asper (1970). The Benson iceberg: a critical analysis of the white paper on tax reform in Canada. Toronto: Clarke, Irwin & Company. OL 5396963M.
10. An Act to amend the Income Tax Act and to make certain provisions and alterations to the statute law related to or consequential upon the amendments to that Act, S.C. 1970-71-72, c. 63
11. Robert Hull (October 23, 1968). "Name makes tax no sweeter". The Windsor Star. p. 16.
12. "Busy day for Mr. Benson". The Montreal Gazette. June 4, 1969. p. 16.
13. "Setting an example?". The Windsor Star. March 13, 1970. p. 13.
14. "Taking Control - The Canadian Transport Commission, 1967 to 1988". Canadian Transportation Agency. Archived from the original on 2013-05-29. Retrieved April 10, 2013.
15. "Benson, Hon. Edgar J. (Non-career)". Foreign Affairs and International Trade Canada. Archived from the original on 2012-10-19. Retrieved 2013-04-10.
16. "Edgar John Benson". Kingston Whig-Standard.
17. "Honorary Degree Recipients 2008-2010". Queen's University. Retrieved April 11, 2013.

External links

• "Edgar J. Benson fonds". Library and Archives Canada. Archived from the original on 2013-12-21.
• Edgar Benson – Parliament of Canada biography
• Alan Hustak (September 13, 2011). "Unflappable finance minister rewrote Canada's tax rules". The Globe and Mail.