Jones v Lock

Jones v Lock (1865) 1 Ch App 25 is an English trusts law case, concerning the formality for creating a gift, and the possibility that if the gift were not properly completed with the required legal form, a trust could be found. The Court of Appeal in Chancery held that equity would not "perfect an imperfect gift" by creating a trust, if the proper formality for the gift had not been completed.

Jones v Lock
CourtCourt of Appeal in Chancery
Citation(s)(1865) 1 Ch App 25
Case opinions
Lord Cranworth LC
Keywords
Certainty, express trusts

Facts

A father returned from a business trip without a gift for his son. When the family told him off, he put a £900 cheque in the baby’s hand, and said

look you here, I give this to baby; it is for himself and I am going to put it away for him, and will give him a great deal more along with it.

The wife said the baby might tear it, and the father said, ‘it is his own, and he may do what he likes with it’. He locked it in the safe and died six days later. It was argued that although there was never an outright transfer, because he had not actually endorsed the cheque by signing it, there was no trust of the cheque for the baby.

Judgment

The Court of Appeal in Chancery held that there was no trust, because the father’s intention was an outright transfer. They refused to perfect an imperfect gift through a successful declaration of trust. Lord Cranworth LC gave the judgment of the court.

gollark: At my school I discovered that they had keyloggers in place and detected some words you typed. By typing some stereotypical terroristy keywords into an empty document (not saving it, obviously). I explained that I had done it randomly and not really expected anything to happen and they just complained about how I had apparently wasted 45 minutes of people's time as they dealt with this grave issue.
gollark: windows good, linux bad
gollark: It can come shipped with a recipe book, and a browser extension to replace "meat" with "EVIL" or something.
gollark: What if we make a Linux distribution *for* vegans?
gollark: <@316638846207131648> Windows 10 is a *newer* version. That does not make it a *better* version.

See also
  • English trusts law

Notes

    References
        This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.