I, I

I, I (stylized as i,i) is the fourth studio album by American indie folk band Bon Iver. It was released track by track per hour on August 8, 2019; the intro only being available on the Bon Iver fan subreddit until August 9, when the album was released properly on all services, with a physical release to follow on August 30. The album was preceded by the singles "Hey, Ma" and "U (Man Like)", and the tracks "Faith" and "Jelmore" were released alongside the album pre-order.[1] I, I features contributions from James Blake, Aaron Dessner, Bruce Hornsby, Moses Sumney, and Channy Leaneagh, among others.[2] The album was nominated for Best Recording Package, Album of the Year and Best Alternative Music Album at the 62nd Annual Grammy Awards, as well as Record of the Year for the song "Hey, Ma".

I, I
Studio album by Bon Iver
Released	August 9, 2019
Studio	April Base (Eau Claire, Wisconsin) Sonic Ranch (Tornillo, Texas)
Genre	Chamber folk experimental folktronica
Length	39:34
Label	Jagjaguwar
Producer	Chris Messina Brad Cook Justin Vernon
Bon Iver chronology
22, A Million (2016) I, I (2019)
Singles from I, I
"Hey, Ma" / "U (Man Like)" Released: June 3, 2019 "Faith" / "Jelmore" Released: July 11, 2019

Background

The project was first teased during an Instagram Live broadcast by Justin Vernon's personal account, in which he revealed a snippet of the song previously known as "We Maddie Parry" (later shortened to "We") and showed a song list with working titles.[3] After the band's show at All Points East 2019, they premiered two new songs; U (Man Like) and Hey, Ma, which were released as singles next day, as well as dates for the fall 2019 tour.[4] On July 11, they announced that their fourth album, "i,i" would be released on August 30 (later moved to August 9) and released the third and fourth singles, "Jelmore" and "Faith".[5] The band likened the album to the season of fall, with I, I completing a cycle that began with the "winter" of For Emma, Forever Ago (2007), followed by "the frenetic spring of Bon Iver, Bon Iver (2011), and the unhinged summer of 22, A Million (2016)".[6] Vernon additionally described the album as "very much like the most adult record, the most complete" and "more honest, generous work".[7] The album was recorded over an extended period of time at April Base in Wisconsin, and was completed at Sonic Ranch in Texas.[8] On July 31, 2019, the band released a documentary short called Bon Iver: Autumn, featuring Vernon and bandmates discussing the new album and aspects of the upcoming Autumn 2019 tour.[9] To promote the album, listening parties took place on August 7 in several countries.[10]

On August 8, without prior announcement, eight of the album's nine remaining songs were released digitally (one each hour) and the ninth, "Yi", was posted on Reddit.[11] This was followed by the band moving the album's digital release date three weeks forward to August 9, with the physical release on August 30.[12]

Music

I, I has been characterized as a chamber folk album.[14] A number of publications have considered its sound to be a merger of the musical elements of Bon Iver's previous three albums,[15][16][17] with Chris DeVille of Stereogum considering it the first of their albums "that sounds more familiar than new."[18] Its production includes acoustic guitars, horns, piano, synthesizers, woodwind, organ and interwoven voices along with "jittery electronics," "otherworldly beats, whispering brass and fragmentary structures."[19][20][14][21] Music journalists have noted its electronic and experimental features reminiscent of those found on 22, A Million, but note that it has been used more sparingly than on the aforementioned album, with DIY writer opining that it "[provides] the foundation for the record’s truly big moments."[15][16]

Critical reception

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
Album of the Year	81/100[22]
AnyDecentMusic?	7.8/10[23]
Metacritic	80/100[24]
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[25]
The Daily Telegraph	[26]
Entertainment Weekly	A−[27]
The Guardian	[28]
NME	[15]
The Observer	[29]
Pitchfork	8.8/10[30]
Q	[31]
Rolling Stone	[32]
The Times	[33]

I, I received acclaim from critics. At Metacritic, which assigns a normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream critics, I, I has an average score of 80 based on 33 reviews.[24] Hannah Mylrea of NME gave the album a perfect score, considering it "pieced [...] in an impossibly intelligent way."[15] DIY writer Ben Tipple also gave it full marks, dubbing it "an emotional tour-de-force that displays an unparalleled understanding of the power of music," further praising its "masterful delicacy" and sparing use of electronic experimentation.[16] Pitchfork awarded it the "Best New Music" accolade, with editor Matthew Strauss calling it the band's "most honest and forthright music ever"; he additionally noted Vernon's vocal performance, considering that he "sings with more texture and conviction than ever before."[30] Damien Morris of The Observer hailed it as "complex and majestic," saying that "i,i spins a mesmerising web of superficially insubstantial yet intensely majestic music."[29]

Some critics had their reservations. Chase McMullen of The 405 deemed the album underwhelming, considering it to be inferior to the band's previous work, he noted that they are "doing the things they know well," and that while "at times, this can work in i,i's favor, [...] it can feel a bit limited and complacent."[34] Ben Beaumont-Thomas named it Bon Iver's "first ever misfire" in his assessment for The Guardian, lamenting its "weak melodies and bad poetry."[28] In a mixed review for The Independent, Jazz Monroe described it as an "exquisite album that is otherwise frustratingly apolitical."[21]

Track listing

Writers adapted from iTunes.

No.	Title	Writer(s)	Length
1.	"Yi"	Justin Vernon Trever Hagen BJ Burton	0:31
2.	"iMi"	Vernon James Blake Rob Moose Brad Cook Mike Lewis Mike Noyce Burton Jeremy Nutzman Channy Leaneagh Wheezy Josh Berg	3:16
3.	"We"	Vernon Wheezy B. Cook Phil Cook Andrew Sarlo	2:22
4.	"Holyfields,"	Vernon B. Cook Chris Messina Moose	3:07
5.	"Hey, Ma"	Vernon B. Cook Burton	3:36
6.	"U (Man Like)"	Vernon Bruce Hornsby Naeem Hanks Messina	2:25
7.	"Naeem"	Vernon Burton Hagen JT Bates Noah Goldstein B. Cook	4:22
8.	"Jelmore"	Vernon Buddy Ross	2:30
9.	"Faith"	Vernon Camilla Staveley-Taylor Burton Francis Farewell Starlite	3:37
10.	"Marion"	Vernon Moose	2:21
11.	"Salem"	Vernon Sean Carey Leaneagh Andrew Broder	3:44
12.	"Sh'Diah"	Vernon Ryan Olson	4:11
13.	"RABi"	Vernon B. Cook Lewis	3:32
Total length:			39:34

Samples

• "Naeem" incorporates elements of "That Storm", performed by Naeem, and "More Love", written by Gary Nicholson and Tim O'Brien, and performed by Tim O'Brien.
• "Sh'Diah" incorporates elements of "Waves" performed by Velvet Negroni.

Personnel

Credits adapted from the band's official website.[35]

Bon Iver

• Sean Carey – drums, piano, voice
• Matt McCaughan – drums, synthesis
• Andrew Fitzpatrick – synthesis, guitar
• Michael Lewis – bass guitar, synthesizers, saxophone
• Justin Vernon – guitar, bass guitar, synthesizers, voice; radio (1)

Featuring:

• Jenn Wasner – guitar, synthesizers, voice; chorus (9)
• Rob Moose – violin (2, 4–7, 9–11), viola (2, 4–7, 9–11), octave viola (4, 6, 9), piano (2, 10), string arrangements (4–7, 9–11), all "Worm Crew" arrangements (2, 5–7, 9–12)

Worm Crew – horns (2, 5–7, 9–12)

• Rob Moose – conducting
• CJ Camerieri – trumpet, flugelhorn, french horn
• Michael Lewis – tenor and soprano saxophones
• Hideaki Aomori – clarinets, alto saxophone
• Tim Albright – trombone
• Randy Pingrey – trombone
• Ross Garren – harmonicas

Additional musicians

• Trever Hagen – barn (1), shoes (1), slides (2), prepared trumpet f. (8)
• Wheezy – drum programming (2), programming (3)
• James Blake – Prophet 600 (2), vocals (2)
• Mike Noyce – vocals (2)
• Jeremy Nutzman a.k.a. Velvet Negroni – vocals (2)
• Camilla Staveley-Taylor – vocals (2), distorted vocals (9)
• Aaron Dessner – piano (2), guitar (2)
• BJ Burton – programming (2), arrangement (2), TR 8's (9)
• Buddy Ross – synthesizer (2, 4, 5, 9, 11, 13), Messina (8), piano (9), Wurlitzer (12)
• Joe Rainey, Sr. – vocals (3)
• Michael Migizi Sullivan, Sr. – vocals (3)
• Phil Cook – piano (3, 6), B3 (6), voice (6)
• Zach Hanson – piano (3), keyboards (9), Juno (11)
• Brad Cook – synthesizer (4), basses (5), Folktek Modified Omnichord (8)

Chris Messina (Record Producer)– synthesizer (4)

• Ben Lester – CP-70 electric piano (5)
• Psymun – sampling (5, 7)
• Brian Moen – drums (5)
• Jake Luppen – guitar (5)
• Bruce Hornsby – piano (6), voice (6)
• Elsa Jensen – voice (6)
• Moses Sumney – voice (6)
• Brooklyn Youth Chorus – chorus (6, 7, 9)
• Bryce Dessner – chorus (6, 7, 9), piano (9)
• Toni Pierce-Sands – claps (7)
• Christian Warner – voice (7)
• Graham Tolbert – voice (7)
• Noah Goldstein – programming (7)
• Francis Starlite – Buchla (9)
• Sad Sax of Shit – saxophones (9)
• Joe Westerlund – shaker (9)
• JT Bates – drums (11)
• Jeremy Ylvisaker – electric guitar (13)

Technical

• Chris Messina – production, engineering, mixing
• Brad Cook – production
• Justin Vernon – production
• Zach Hanson – engineering, mixing
• Marta Salogni – additional engineering
• Jerry Ordonez – assistant engineering, additional mixing
• Zac Hernandez – assistant engineering
• Alli Rogers – assistant engineering
• Rob Moose – string arrangements engineering
• Greg Calbi – mastering
• BJ Burton – production (5), additional production (1–3, 7–9), additional engineering (2, 5, 7–9), mixing (3, 5, 12)
• Trever Hagen – additional production (1), additional engineering (1)
• Andrew Sarlo – additional production (2, 3), additional engineering (2, 3, 5)
• Wheezy – additional production (3)
• TU Dance – additional production (7)
• Buddy Ross – additional production (8)
• Ryan Olson – additional production (12)
• Josh Berg – additional engineering (3)
• Wayne Pooley – additional engineering (6)
• Bella Blasko – additional engineering (6, 7, 9)
• Noah Goldstein – additional engineering (7)

Artwork and release

• Andra Chumas – executive production
• Eric Timothy Carlson – art, direction
• Aaron Anderson – art, direction
• Graham Tolbert – photography
• TU Dance – dance movement and visuals
  • Toni Pierce-Sands
  • Uri Sands
  • Taylor Collier – dancing
  • Jacob Lewis – dancing
  • Alexander Pham – dancing
  • Randall Riley – dancing
  • Alexis Staley – dancing
  • Christian Warner – dancing

Charts

Weekly charts Chart (2019) Peak position Australian Albums (ARIA)[36] 8 Austrian Albums (Ö3 Austria)[37] 21 Belgian Albums (Ultratop Flanders)[38] 5 Belgian Albums (Ultratop Wallonia)[39] 51 Canadian Albums (Billboard)[40] 14 Danish Albums (Hitlisten)[41] 12 Dutch Albums (Album Top 100)[42] 21 French Albums (SNEP)[43] 97 German Albums (Offizielle Top 100)[44] 18 Irish Albums (IRMA)[45] 11 Italian Albums (FIMI)[46] 54 Latvian Albums (LAIPA)[47] 13 Lithuanian Albums (AGATA)[48] 8 New Zealand Albums (RMNZ)[49] 32 Norwegian Albums (VG-lista)[50] 17 Scottish Albums (OCC)[51] 9 Spanish Albums (PROMUSICAE)[52] 11 Swedish Albums (Sverigetopplistan)[53] 29 Swiss Albums (Schweizer Hitparade)[54] 12 UK Albums (OCC)[55] 11 US Billboard 200[56] 26 US Folk Albums (Billboard)[57] 1 US Independent Albums (Billboard)[58] 1 US Top Alternative Albums (Billboard)[59] 3 US Top Rock Albums (Billboard)[60] 3

Year-end charts Chart (2019) Position Belgian Albums (Ultratop Flanders)[61] 120 US Top Rock Albums (Billboard)[62] 92

References

1. Monroe, Jazz (July 11, 2019). "Bon Iver Announce New Album i,i, Share 2 New Songs: Listen". Pitchfork. Retrieved July 11, 2019.
2. Murray, Robin (July 11, 2019). "Bon Iver Announces New Album 'i,i'". Clash. Retrieved July 11, 2019.
3. "justin just played a new song on instagram, i caught some of it live". December 13, 2018.
4. https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/reviews/bon-iver-all-points-east-review-new-songs-justin-vernon-22-a-million-a8941441.html
5. https://boniver.org/news/2019/new-album-ii-out-august-30/
6. "Bon Iver announce new album 'i,i'". DIY. July 11, 2019. Retrieved July 11, 2019.
7. Bruce-Jones, Henry (July 11, 2019). "Bon Iver enlist James Blake, Moses Sumney and more for new album, i,i". Fact. Retrieved July 11, 2019.
8. "New album 'I,I' – out August 30". Bon Iver. July 11, 2019. Retrieved July 12, 2019.
9. "Bon Iver Releases Mini-Documentary About Upcoming Tour: Watch". July 31, 2019.
10. "Bon Iver announce i,i listening parties in London, New York and Europe". Crack Magazine. July 19, 2019. Retrieved July 11, 2019.
11. Rossignol, Derrick (August 8, 2019). "Bon Iver Are Releasing Their New Album, 'i,i,' A Few Weeks Early". Uproxx. Retrieved August 8, 2019.
12. @jagjaguwar (August 8, 2019). "Tonight, @boniver will release 'i,i' digitally around the globe. Find the songs here: (link: boniver.ffm.to/icommai) boniver.ffm.to/icommai #icommai" (Tweet). Retrieved August 9, 2019 – via Twitter.
13. Joe Coscarelli (September 6, 2019). "5 Years, 28 People, 1 Song: No One Writes Quite Like Bon Iver". The New York Times. Retrieved December 21, 2019.
14. Davis, Clive; Cairns, Dan; Verrico, Lisa; Edwards, Mark (August 11, 2019). "On record: Pop, rock and jazz, August 11". The Sunday Times. Retrieved August 12, 2019.
15. Mylrea, Hannah (August 8, 2019). "Bon Iver – 'i, i' review". NME. Retrieved November 28, 2019.
16. Tipple, Ben (August 9, 2019). "Bon Iver – i, i". DIY. Retrieved August 9, 2019.
17. Feibel, Adam (August 12, 2019). "Bon Iver i,i". Exclaim!. Retrieved August 13, 2019.
18. DeVille, Chris (August 9, 2019). "Premature Evaluation: Bon Iver i,i". Stereogum. Retrieved August 13, 2019.
19. Gallagher, Marianne (August 8, 2019). "Bon Iver - i,i". Clash. Retrieved August 13, 2019.
20. Beviglia, Jim (August 11, 2019). "Bon Iver: i,i". American Songwriter. Retrieved August 13, 2019.
21. Monroe, Jazz (August 8, 2019). "Bon Iver review, i,i: Immersive lullabies that crackle with nostalgia". The Independent. Retrieved August 8, 2019.
22. "Bon Iver, i,i". Album of the Year. Retrieved May 9, 2020.
23. "i, i by Bon Iver reviews". AnyDecentMusic?. Retrieved September 2, 2019.
24. "I, I by Bon Iver Reviews and Tracks". Metacritic. Retrieved August 8, 2019.
25. Sendra, Tim. "I, I – Bon Iver". AllMusic. Retrieved October 19, 2019.
26. McCormick, Neil (August 7, 2019). "Bon Iver, i, i album review: anguish and ecstasy from the singer who gives technology a human heart". The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved August 8, 2019.
27. Greenblatt, Leah (August 8, 2019). "Bon Iver sounds more confident than ever on i,i". Entertainment Weekly. Retrieved August 9, 2019.
28. Beaumont-Thomas, Ben (August 8, 2019). "Bon Iver: i,i review – his first ever misfire". The Guardian. Retrieved August 11, 2019.
29. Morris, Damien (August 11, 2019). "Bon Iver: i,i review – complex and majestic". The Observer. Retrieved August 12, 2019.
30. Strauss, Matthew (August 9, 2019). "Bon Iver: i,i". Pitchfork. Retrieved August 9, 2019.
31. Segal, Victoria (October 2019). "Bon Iver: I,I". Q (403): 110.
32. Hermes, Will (August 14, 2019). "Bon Iver's 'i, i' is About Getting In Touch With Your Human Side". Rolling Stone. Retrieved August 16, 2019.
33. Hodgkinson, Will (August 8, 2019). "Bon Iver: i, i review — Justin Vernon returns to doing what he does best". The Times. Retrieved August 8, 2019.
34. McMullen, Chase (August 12, 2019). "Review: Bon Iver stick to the doldrums of straightforward nostalgia on the still pleasant i,i". The 405. Retrieved August 9, 2019.
35. "Album Credits". Bon Iver. Retrieved August 8, 2019.
36. "Australiancharts.com – Bon Iver – I,I". Hung Medien. Retrieved August 17, 2019.
37. "Austriancharts.at – Bon Iver – I,I" (in German). Hung Medien. Retrieved September 12, 2019.
38. "Ultratop.be – Bon Iver – I,I" (in Dutch). Hung Medien. Retrieved September 6, 2019.
39. "Ultratop.be – Bon Iver – I,I" (in French). Hung Medien. Retrieved September 6, 2019.
40. "Bon Iver Chart History (Canadian Albums)". Billboard. Retrieved August 20, 2019.
41. "Danishcharts.dk – Bon Iver – I,I". Hung Medien. Retrieved August 21, 2019.
42. "Dutchcharts.nl – Bon Iver – I,I" (in Dutch). Hung Medien. Retrieved September 6, 2019.
43. "Le Top de la semaine : Top Albums Fusionnes – SNEP (Week 36, 2019)" (in French). Syndicat National de l'Édition Phonographique. Retrieved September 16, 2019.
44. "Offiziellecharts.de – Bon Iver – I,I" (in German). GfK Entertainment Charts. Retrieved September 6, 2019.
45. "Irish Albums Chart: 16 August 2019". Irish Recorded Music Association. Retrieved August 17, 2019.
46. "Album – Classifica settimanale WK 36 (dal 30.08.2019 al 05.09.2019)" (in Italian). Federazione Industria Musicale Italiana. Retrieved September 7, 2019.
47. "Mūzikas Patēriņa Tops/ 33. nedēļa" (in Latvian). LAIPA. Archived from the original on October 10, 2019. Retrieved November 27, 2019.
48. "Savaitės klausomiausi (TOP 100)" (in Lithuanian). AGATA. August 16, 2019. Retrieved December 2, 2019.
49. "NZ Top 40 Albums Chart". Recorded Music NZ. September 9, 2019. Retrieved September 7, 2019.
50. "VG-lista – Topp 40 Album uke 36, 2019". VG-lista. Retrieved September 10, 2019.
51. "Official Scottish Albums Chart Top 100". Official Charts Company. Retrieved September 7, 2019.
52. "Top 100 Albumes – Semana 36: del 30.8.2019 al 5.9.2019" (in Spanish). Productores de Música de España. Retrieved September 11, 2019.
53. "Veckolista Album, vecka 33". Sverigetopplistan. Retrieved August 16, 2019.
54. "Swisscharts.com – Bon Iver – I,I". Hung Medien. Retrieved August 21, 2019.
55. "Official Albums Chart Top 100". Official Charts Company. Retrieved August 17, 2019.
56. "Bon Iver Chart History (Billboard 200)". Billboard. Retrieved August 20, 2019.
57. "Bon Iver Chart History (Top Americana/Folk Albums)". Billboard. Retrieved August 24, 2019.
58. "Bon Iver Chart History (Independent Albums)". Billboard. Retrieved August 24, 2019.
59. "Bon Iver Chart History (Top Alternative Albums)". Billboard. Retrieved August 24, 2019.
60. "Bon Iver Chart History (Top Rock Albums)". Billboard. Retrieved August 24, 2019.
61. "Jaaroverzichten 2019". Ultratop. Retrieved December 20, 2019.
62. "Top Rock Albums – Year-End 2019". Billboard. Retrieved June 27, 2020.