History of Norsk Data

Norsk Data (ND) was a Norwegian manufacturer of minicomputers which operated between 1967 and 1992. The company was established as A/S Nordata – Norsk Data-Elektronikk on 7 July 1967 and took into use the Norsk Data brand in 1975. The company was founded by Lars Monrad-Krohn, Rolf Skår and Per Bjørge, three computer engineers working at the Norwegian Defence Research Establishment which had just built the minicomputer SAM 2. ND's first contract was the delivery of a Nord-1 computer to Norcontrol. Initially in competition with Kongsberg, ND started delivering computers to Norwegian institutions. By 1972 the company had developed Sintran operating system, the 32-bit Nord-5 and a time sharing system.

Corporate logo from 1976 to 1992

The international break-through came with the 1973 delivery of computers to CERN and the company soon had half their sales abroad. Two years later the database program Sibas(SIBAS is (tm) of SRS that has full rights to the code developed at the Central Institute for Industrial Research by Olli, Salter, Aschim and Hoffmann) had been completely ported and made available, and the following year a 150-terminal system connected via X.21/X.25 based XMSG and a flight simulator backbone for the F-16 were delivered. In 1978 Norsk Data both bought Tandberg and launched its office suite Notis, although Tandberg was sold again in 1980. ND became the first foreign-listed Norwegian company in 1981, which also saw the launch of the 32-bit ND-500. Throughout the 1980s ND acquired a series of domestic and foreign hardware and software companies, many loosely oriented at increased hardware sales. At the peak in 1986 and 1987, Norsk Data had 4,500 employees, 2.5 billion Norwegian krone (NOK) in revenue and was Norway's second-largest company by market capitalization—having increased fifty-fold between 1977 and 1985.

Despite late attempts to develop Ndix, ND never succeeded at entering the Unix market which started to dominate in the late 1980s. The company's share value halved on 19 October 1987 and never recovered. The company went through a series of reorganizations, but the company never succeeded at making money on open systems and the last area with profits was sales to existing Sintran customers. From 1988 the company was gradually split up; parts were sold to foreign competitors while others were spun off as subsidiaries or sold. By 1993 all equity had been lost and the remaining parts of the company sold off or taken over by the creditors. The main parts of company were bought by Telenor.

Establishment

Per Bugge-Asperheim, Svein Strøm, Per Klevan, Lars Monrad-Krohn, Per Bjørge, Asbjørn Horn, Olav Landsverk and Yngvar Lundh which made up the NDRE's digital division in 1962

Norsk Data grew out of the development Simulation for Automatic Machinery 2 (SAM 2), a minicomputer developed at the Norwegian Defence Research Establishment (NDRE). The computer was ordered in 1966 for analysis of satellite data at Tromsø Satellite Station (TSS) and was the third computer built by NDRE.[1] The main developers of the system were Rolf Skår, Per Bjørge, Lars Monrad-Krohn and Yngvar Lundh. SAM 2 was the first in Europe and among the first three in the world which used integrated circuits.[2] The project was risky, as TSS originally had proposed buying an American computer and NDRE would have to buy such a computer if SAM 2 failed.[1]

As there was time between SAM 2 was completed and it had to be in Tromsø, the designers took it on a tour to Bergen and Trondheim. While in Bergen the group met an old fellow student, Ivar Aanderaa, who was working as an entrepreneur.[1] He inspired the others of the joys of being self-employed and a discussion went on all night on the 23 April 1967 about starting up a computer-manufacturing company. Based on that they had a technological edge and believed to have good timing, a decision to start a company was made.[3]

For the entrepreneurs the main challenge was that their newly created computer was the property of the NDRE, which again had a strategic cooperation with Kongsberg, both government-owned. They expressed interest in the technology and considered themselves putting it into production. The other company which showed interest for the technology was the Horten-based Norcontrol, which was working on a project for ship automation but needed a computer to run the system.[4] To raise capital, Skår took contact with his former college-mate Terje Mikalsen, who was working at Norcontrol. Mikalsen had married into a ship-owning family and was thus able to provide capital the others could not.[5]

At this time NDRE was working with Kongsberg for plans to build a computer for a field artillery system.[6] Monrad-Krohn proposed that their company should try to get this contract,[7] but after it was awarded to NDRE, they had increased difficulty finding investors. The company had estimated a need for NOK 600,000.[8] A founding meeting was held on 7 July 1967 with fifteen people present. The largest investor was Mosvold Shipping Group which invested NOK 100,000,[9] while remaining investors put in NOK 94,000.[8] The company was established as A/S Nordata – Norsk Data-Elektronikk.[10] As "Nordata" was already registered by a company in Trondheim, the name was changed to A/S Norsk Data-Elektronikk on 20 July.[11]

A Nord-1 minicomputer

The company's first offices were located at Ole Deviks vei 10 in Oslo, which was located in the facilities of a fan manufacturer. Operations commenced on 19 September with the three founders, Monrad-Krohn, Skår and Bjørge.[12] They received the same wages as they had at NDRE.[10] None of the entrepreneurs had any education or experience in business and operations started without a budget. The company's culture was inherited from NDRE—technology-oriented with focus on creativity and challenges.[13] The first other employee was Tove Pedersen; she had an interview with the fan company, but had instead met up at ND. Monrad-Krohn did not let her inn on the error and instead carried out an interview and offered her a job, which she accepted.[12]

Nord-1

Bjørge was responsible for hardware, Skår for software and Konrad-Mohn for sales.[11] The company's first computer was Nord-1, which was a further development of SAM 2. It offered 0.5 million instructions per second (MIPS) and would sell for a few hundred thousand krone.[7] To secure a bank guarantee for the first loan, life insurance was taken out on the three founders, with the beneficiary going to the bank.[14] The development work started while the trio were working at NDRE, which was cooperating with the Institute for Energy Technology and Kongsberg. Preliminary work was therefore sent to both organizations to allow them to build computers.[15]

A strategic cooperation with Norcontrol started in November 1967, when Norsk Data bought shares for NOK 200,000 in Norcontrol, which again bought shares for NOK 70,000 in Norsk Data.[16] Norcontrol placed the first order for a Norsk Data computer on 26 January 1968.[17] Shortly afterwards computers were ordered by the Central Institute for Industrial Research and the Chr. Michelsen Institute.[18] Norsk Data and Kongsberg signed a market sharing agreement on 23 April 1968, in which Kongsberg would deliver computers to the military industry while Norsk Data would deliver to the civilian sector.[19] In the early years, Kongsberg would continue to be Norsk Data's main competitor as the only other Norwegian manufacturer of minicomputers.[20] Additional Norsk Data shares were issued in May 1968, bringing the share capital to NOK 894,000. New investors included Norsk Elektrisk & Brown Boveri (NEBB),Habberstad and Tharald Brøvig Jr..[21]

The first Nord-1 was inaugurated on 21 May 1968 and sent to the Norwegian Institute of Technology (NTH) to have instruments installed.[22] It spent a year in Trondheim and was constantly needing repairs. However, once it was not constantly being tweaked by engineers it operated for eighteen months without any failures. The Nord-1 was installed on MS Taimyr—a newly constructed Wilh. Wilhelmsen freight vessel—on 16 June 1969. This was the world's first such on-ship computer, which both featured an automatic radar plotting aid and an automated machine room.[23] By 1973, Norsk Data had delivered 105 units to Norcontrol.[24]

Ibb Høivold, Norcontrol's chief executive officer (CEO), was appointed chairman of the board in June 1968. This created some conflict of interest, as Kongsberg CEO Jens Christian Hauge sat on Norcontrol's board. For 1968 Norsk Data had a revenue of NOK 730,000, sold four computers plus additional memory for SAM 2, had thirteen employees at the end of the year and had a profit of NOK 21,000.[25] That year a cooperation started with NEBB to develop an automatic hydroelectricity reservoir regulation system with a Nord-1 at its heart.[26] The first system was installed in 1970 and remained in use for eighteen years.[27]

Originally every user of the Nord-1 coded their own operating system (OS). This was highly inefficient and ND decided to launch a common OS. Sintran was developed at SINTEF in Trondheim. Later Sintran II was launched. This was the first major competitive edge ND had on Kongsberg.[28] In 1969 the company relocated to a larger facility.[29] The following year, fifteen Nord-1s were manufactured[30] and the company had 88 employees.[29] During these years Norsk Data secured a customer base in universities, college and research institutions in Norway. By 1971 nearly every such institution had a Nord-1 computer.[31] NOK 2 million in venture capital was received in 1971.[32]

Internationalization

Norsk Data employee working at a Nord-20 computer in 1971

Monrad-Krohn was appointed professor of digital technology at NTH in December 1969. He chose to combine the professorship with the position as CEO of Norsk Data.[33] Stord Verft took delivery of the first Nord-20 the following year and Norcontrol took delivery of the first of its 28 Nord-4s. The first major conflict in top management took place in February 1971 regarding a new organizational structure, with Monrad-Krohn on the one side and Bjørge and Skår on the other.[30] Although revenue continued to rise, the company failed to create good profit margins. The issues caused two board members to resign[34] and in June ten employees were laid off after orders were NOK 3 million below budget.[35]

The company was saved by a NOK 6-million contract with the Norwegian Meteorological Institute which ND won in February 1971 in competition with major international players. The Nord Integrated Computer System (Nordic) was completed in April 1972[35] and consisted of three Nord-1s and a new Nord-5. The latter was the first 32-bit minicomputer in the world.[36] This solution was chosen to allow the Nord-5 to act as a number cruncher while the Nord-1s would handle smaller tasks. One of these was used to collect information from a global network of weather stations.[37]

When the project finished Norsk Data was without orders. Sales representatives were not appreciated in the company and were typically fired about once a year. The company's strategy was to create excellent products which could sell themselves.[38] As the twenty-five people involved in the Nordic project were not required elsewhere, they were moved to the marketing department. It was first with this move that the company's management started realizing the importance of marketing.[39] However, other non-technical departments, especially finances, had also not been keeping up with the company's growth.[40][Kolbjørn Johansen was therefore hired as chief financial officer in 1969. The board decided on 18 October 1972 to replace Monrad-Krohn with Johansen as CEO, with the former becoming chair of the board.[41] He would within a few years leave Norsk Data and establish Mycron and Tiki Data.[42]

Bo Lewendal was hired in 1970 and was set to lead the development of a timesharing system,[43] Nord-TSS.[44] Monrad-Krohn articulated in 1972 that he hoped for the company to first grow into Scandinavia and then Europe. He emphasized that ND's small size was an advantage, as it allowed quicker production of newer and thus faster computers.[45] The company decided to participate with eighty-seven other suppliers to win a contract with the European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN) for its accelerator.[46] The first tender was unsuccessful, but a delegation from CERN visited all the European manufacturers, largely out of courtesy as they had a long history of choosing American suppliers.[47] ND chose to only demonstrate the computer from a terminal, rather than display the hardware.[48]

Twin Nord-10 unit

ND bid sixty percent lower than the prototype supplyer, Digital Equipment Corporation, and ND was only underbid by three manufacturers, all which were found to not meet their technical criteria by CERN.[49] A decision was taken by CERN's technical committee on 19 September 1972, in which German and French interest failed to get their technically disqualified and higher priced Mitra and Dietz computers selected.[48] The decision fell on Norsk Data, with the contract signed in January 1973.[49] The computer was delivered and accepted on 12 July 1973, twelve days after the contract specified.[50] The contract included twenty-four computers and a revenue of NOK 12 million.[51]

Norsk Data took a strategic decision to abandon their role as system supplier for a few, large customers and decided to become a European-wide minicomputer supplier which could compete directly with American manufacturers.[52] Sintran III was launched as a further development of Sintran II which included Nord-TSS and introduced virtual memory, which was launched with a new generation of hardware, the Nord-10,[53] in 1973.[54] CERN later followed up with purchasing a Nord-10 in 1975 for their largest department.[51] Additional orders were made and by the end of 1976 CERN were operating fifty ND computers.[52] The delivery to CERN combined with a more efficient software portfolio with the Nord-10 were key factors in the continued growth.[53] For instance, ND delivered a turn-key system for meteorology in Algeria in 1974, complete with software developed in-house.[55] Half the company's revenue came from international sales that year.[56]

Market orientation

Norsk Data continued to undermine marketing until the mid-1970s. Sales personnel had low wages, little to no influence on product development, high turnover, and were often trained in engineering rather than business.[56] In the first years, ND sales representatives wore jeans and would present the products to other engineers and computer personnel, with the focus on the technical details.[57] This changed in the mid-1970s when the company started selling computers to the business sector, where the customer representatives typically were heads of the accounting or warehouse departments. These instead expected suit-dressed salesmen and were interested in issues regarding efficiency and reliability.[58] Profits, and the profit-based bonuses, sank through these years, giving an incentive for technical personnel to give marketing increased importance.[56]

The first sale in Sweden was to ASEA-Atom in 1974 to control nuclear power plants.[54] A Swedish subsidiary was established the following year.[59] Because of the proprietary system architecture of each manufacturer, companies would fall into a vendor lock-in; therefore purchase of computer systems were often more of a strategic than product-specific purchase. An important aspect for ND was therefore to convince their potential customers that they would be able to deliver in the long run.[60]

Økernsenteret where Norsk Data had offices throughout most of the 1970s

Sintran II VS and the Nord-50 were released in 1975. The following year the company had a revenue of NOK 81 million, NOK 4 million in profits and 221 employees.[61] In 1977 subsidiaries were established in Germany and the United Kingdom. In Oslo, ND moved into a second facility, in Furuset. By then there was an uproar against Johansen within the organization as he was regarded by many as too empathetic; this had caused him to several times not make hard enough decisions and other times let the decisions be taken by others.[62] He was replaced by Skår as CEO on 8 November.[63]

From the mid-1970s ND started serving a more differentiated customer base and was increasingly dependent on the sales force coming with feedback as to which functionality needed to be developed. Norsk Tipping was in the first years of the 1970s the first customer to apply an ND system to accounting. The software was developed and owned by ND, but Skår rejected proposals that the company should develop a portfolio of administrative software. At the time this was based on the strategy that the high profit margins were in the central parts of the hardware while independent software firms were not making money. Towards the end of the 1970s this strategy started to backfire, as hardware-oriented customers, such as universities, were pressing down prices while companies which wanted turn-key solutions were increasingly willing to pay full price.[64]

The Central Institute ported the database program Sibas in 1975 on the ND platform based on the Univac Fortran IV source. The first commercial ND system which was sold to handle a database was to Jonas Øglænd. The second contract was to Vinmonopolet and required remote terminals in Bergen and Trondheim.[65] In 1976 Norsk Data won a contract with the Norwegian State Railways to manage their fleet of goods wagons. This was achieved by connecting the 150 terminals via XMSG and remained in use until 1990.[66] The same system was delivered to the Swedish Armed Forces. ND started working on a system for the National Insurance Service, but delays caused the system to not be ordered until 1984, in which more than half the system was delivered by IBM.[67]

Data Logic developed in 1975 typesetting software for the ND platform for Amedia in Sweden. ND decided to start a campaign to sell typesetting computers to Norwegian newspapers and developed along with Data Logic GMS-12, later renamed Nortext. The first client were Arbeiderbladet, Østlendingen and Dagbladet the following year, but sales were slow after that.[68]

An important contract was signed in the aftermath of Norway, Denmark, the Netherlands and Belgium ordering the F-16 Fighting Falcon fighter jets. The Americans were obliged to use subcontractors from these countries in areas where they were competitive. Norsk Data put its eye on the simulator, as only two other manufacturers, Interdata and Systems Engineering Laboratories, had previously built similar systems.[69] Norsk Data originally cooperated with the small simulator manufacturer Hydrosystems, but this spurred Singer Link, the world's largest manufacturer, to investigate ND's systems. In the end, three of four simulator contenders bid with ND-based systems and the contract was awarded Singer Link.[70]

Tandberg

1975 saw the creation of a new government plan to consolidate the Norwegian information technology industry into three companies: Tandberg, Elektrisk Bureau and Kongsberg, which would become the "cornerstone companies". The plan was launched by Hauge, who started negotiations of purchasing Mikkelsen's shares in both Norcontrol and Norsk Data.[71] He chose to sell Norcontrol to Kongsberg, but would not sell Norsk Data. The government continued to press the issue and promised a large grant to the industry if it merged, but Norsk Data stood on its rejection.[72]

Norsk Data was a major customer of Tandberg Data's TDV-2215 terminals, as they were bundled with ND minicomputers

By December 1978, one of the cornerstones, Tandberg, filed for bankruptcy.[73] The company was split up and Norsk Data became one of the shareholders, although the computer division, Tandberg Data, was spun off. In April 1979 Norsk Data agreed to take over Tandberg's training materials' division and its facilities at Skullerud in Oslo, which would give ample space for expansion.[74] However, Parliament decided in May that they wanted Tandberg to continue operations in the same scale, and offered a NOK 105-million subsidy and a large discount in the Skullerud facility to Norsk Data if they took over all of Tandberg. ND accepted the deal and paid NOK 12 million for 92 percent of the company, the last part being owned by the Industrial Development Corporation of Norway.[75] Tandberg saw a NOK 13-million loss of a NOK 130 million revenue in 1979, which were consolidated into Norsk Data's accounts. Not until a February 1980 deal with Mobil secured a NOK 25-million advance did the company stop being a burden.[76]

There was a bad relationship between the two companies, in part caused by opposition from within Tandberg against a start-up managing the old company's affairs. Tandberg had split its production between Skullerud and Kjelsås, also in Oslo, which was part of its inefficiency problems. A relocation to Kjelsås was desired, but this resulted in a struggle between the two companies regarding a NOK 20-million advance that Tandberg had paid ND.[77] When resolved, this allowed ND to Take over the Skullerud facilities. To eliminate the negative cash flow and debt in Tandberg, it was sold to ND's shareholders in early 1981.[78]

A Tandberg keyboard and monitor tailor-made for Norsk Data and Notis

Development of the office suit Notis started in January 1978 out of the existing expertise in typesetting and a desire to sell computers to the public sector.[79] The word processing section was based on a program which had been developed by an employee while working at CERN and this was combined with systems for incorporating tables with figures such as budgets. The system also features search and e-mail. At first the QED text editor was used,[80] but this was later replaced with TED, developed by Kvam Data. Notis was installed on all systems from 1980 and quickly became popular among customers.[81] Because ND's screens were not optimized for text processing, from 1982 Tandberg Data delivered tailor-made keyboards and keyboards. Because text processing required high performance and extra peripherals, ND made high margins on the implementation.[82] ND bought the typesetting system Comtec in 1981, which was combined with Nortext and resulted in large increases in the sale of the systems.[83]

Boom

The Nord-100 was introduced in 1979, which was specialized at flexibility and focused on administrative applications.[84] When Digital launched their VAX-11 in 1977, Norsk Data had the Nord-5 32-bit computer ready for CERN. As the VAX-11 was 32-bit and regarded as a superminicomputer, Norsk Data did not initially see it as a competitor since the Nord-5 had much better processing power. Nord-50 had similar processing power to the Nord-5, but was not a general-purpose computer. The 32 bit computer used a Nord-10 front processor that ran the SINTRAN III operating system. Development of the ND-500 started in 1978 and had so fundamental changes to the system architecture (was not made from bit-slice components but microprogrammed with a new instruction set) that all software had to be rewritten - except for the SINTRAN.[85] The computer was launched in 1981, but with fundamental shortcomings imposed by the OS[86] It was much faster than the VAX, but did not meet the general customers' expectation of being a multi-purpose computer. Later models improved the performance and tweaking of the system allowed it to become a multipurpose system at the performance of a special purpose super computer as sold by Cray.[87] A major contract with the ND-500 was the Joint European Torus project, which took delivery of twenty-seven ND-100 and -500 units.[88] Development of the ND-5000 started before the ND-500 was completed. The design was changed to become more modular; this increased the development costs, but reduced production costs and increased scalability.[89] On the ND-5000, components were placed in cards that were interconnected, initially to simplify cooling but also to enable the high clock frequency. If an electric current is switched at a clock frequency of 1GHz, it travels about one foot per cycle, so 10cm is a delay of a clock cycle at 3GHz. The ND-500 computers had timing problems caused by wire-distance, and going faster just required everything to be close.

ND's European sales operations were based at Benham Park in Berkshire, England

Norsk Data's sales in the United Kingdom was originally carried out by the agent Richard B. Norton. An ND-owned subsidiary was established in 1980 and based at Benham Park, which the company bought and renovated.[90] Between 1972 and 1981 the company had an average annual revenue increase of forty-five percent.[91] It split its profits seventy percent to reinvest in the company and thirty percent as bonus. Such bonuses were only paid in good years and for the best years was equal to the salary.[92] The company was a growth stock and only paid marginal dividends.[91] Norsk Data became the second Norwegian company, after Norsk Hydro, to be listed on a foreign stock exchange. The company was listed on the London Stock Exchange in July 1981. It carried out a placement of shares worth NOK 30 million in August 1981 and for NOK 100 million in March 1982.[93] ND received the Company of Year Award in 1983.[94] The company's market capitalization was NOK 9 million in 1977, NOK 20 million in 1980 and NOK 4.5 billion in 1985.[91]

ND introduced the marketing concept ND-SAFE in 1982, where the company focused on the scalability of the systems.[95] Except for the municipal and university sectors,[96] ND did not attempt at market segmentation to capture customers within a specific industry; this often made it difficult to sell as clients often found it difficult to purchase from a non-niche manufacturer.[97] For instance, ND attempted to sell to the Scandinavian banking market; they were asked by clients if they would make this a prioritized market, but ND responded that they only would if they received sufficient sales. The answer caused the banking industry to go elsewhere for its products, despite an initial enthusiasm for ND's products.[98]

Norsk Data's head offices at Skullerud in Oslo

The company started the process of being listed on the NASDAQ exchange in New York in January 1983.[99] No Norwegian company had previously been listed in the US; the legislation was not harmonized and there were restrictions on twenty percent foreign ownership of Norwegian companies.[100] The limit was raised to forty-nine percent, but this was regarded by ND as too low, so they split the ownership into A- and B-shares, with and without voting rights.[101] With this change, Norwegian authorities permitted an eighty percent foreign ownership in the company, but only the non-voting B shares were permitted to be listed on NASDAQ.[102] The initial public offering brought in NOK 400 million in capital.[103]

Norsk Data started a cooperation with Dietz Computer Systems for distribution of ND computers in Germany. ND became a majority shareholder in July 1983 and the following year Dietz was merged into ND.[104] By 1985 Dietz' plant was producing ND systems and their old systems taken off the market.[105] On 30 October 1984 ND and Matra signed an agreement where the latter would distribute ND computers in France.[106]

The company peaked its financial performance in 1986. That year Datamation ranked it the world's 75th largest information technology company, and the world's 13th largest minicomputer manufacturer. It was the world's third-most profitable and had the seventh-highest growth rate.[107] That year the company's profits hit a record-high NOK 475 million from a NOK 2,576 million revenue. The peak revenue was 2,934 million in 1989, while the peak employment was 4,488 employees in 1987.[108] In 1987 Norsk Data had the 50th highest revenue of Norwegian companies, but had the second-highest market capitalization, behind Norsk Hydro.[109]

Bust

During the mid-1980s, the market shifted such that customers went away from purchasing hardware and instead wanted complete systems including software, preferably tailor-made for the industry. This was a disadvantage for ND, as they had their advantage in designing hardware systems. Their lack of industry-specific software was combined with that all software development was outsourced, which meant that ND's most important sales arguments were being determined by a third party.[110] Another development was the open standards, especially Unix, which was disliked at ND. This would remove the vendor lock-in and the well-liked Notis, which was instrumental in creating profits. Management had a high pressure from investors to create high growth rates, which again caused the company to choose short-term profit margins ahead of long-term strategic positioning.[111]

As an increasing number of customers asked for open standard solutions, such as personal computers (PC) and Unix, ND started developing products to meet the demand. An ND PC was developed, but sold poorly.[112] The Unix variant Ndix was launched in 1985, but was only offered as a last resort to customers only interested in Unix systems. Use of Ndix required separate hardware. The software was developed by a third party and was so slow that the hardware was out of date by the time the software was completed. Many competitors licensed an existing variant of Unix, but ND chose to develop its own. In addition, ND chose to not port its software to Unix, despite demands from customers for Sibas and Notis on the Unix platform. Sales were further reduced by ND's reluctance to pay software developers to port common programs to Ndix.[113]

Tandberg-built ND keyboard for Notis

On 9 September 1986, the company's course division invited representatives form the largest customers to a dialog with ND's top management. While the management at the time believed they had an excellent product, the customers pointed at several weaknesses in the organization and products. In the middle of the meeting, Skår chose to leave to reach another meeting.[114] A summary was distributed to all employees and soon was creating headlines in the press. The process also created mistrust and doubt within the organization and within a short time all the employees in the course division had quit.[115]

The software companies Infologic and Data Inform were bought by DN in 1986,[115] while ND and Fjellanger Widerøe established the cartography company Pumatec.[116] The following year, Computas Complete and Alfa Data were bought and merged with Infologic to create ND Application, which had 350 employees. The new subsidiary was to merge the existing software into a new portfolio. While the old companies had sold well because they were tailored to a particular industry, such as Computas for the processing industry and Infologic for wholesalers, the unified systems were so general that it lost its competitive advantage to all industries.[117]

The new company was plagued by internal disputes over which suit to base the new product on and a large number of customers disputes, leaving little capacity for product development. At the time software developers had low margins. The companies had been bought with a short-term goal to sell more minicomputers and ND lacked a strategic plan for them. The problem was accelerated because the sales force lacked intricate knowledge of the industries they were selling to.[117]

After thirteen years of high annual growth, the sales flattened in 1987. On 16 October, the company announced that its sales targets for the year would not be met,[118] and a planned placement of new shares was canceled. On the morning of 19 October 1987, the share price fell from NOK 240 to 180. By the end of trading on NASDAQ, the share price was down to NOK 120. The price continued to fall and hit NOK 80 some days later, in part because many employees had to sell shares to pay their taxes.[119] The economy of Norway was hit hard and employees in ND were especially stricken because of their bonuses having been paid in shares. From 1988, ND stopped recruiting new employees. A reorganization took place in which all group leaders were laid off and told to apply for new jobs as project leaders.[120] The issue resulted in severe bad media coverage.[121]

The company started in early 1988 developing a strategy and products to switch ND's focus to open standards. The project was publicly launched on 11 April and included PCs, Unix-servers and software to link new and old systems. Upon questions from a journalist, ND also announced that they would not port ND Application's portfolio to Unix. However, the journalist's question made the executives realize they had not properly planned its strategy. ND became caught between two customer groups: one which was happy with the existing systems and wanted ND to continue to deliver its own system and software, and other which wanted open standards. ND's signals to switch to Unix caused the first group of customers to place their orders on hold, while new customers did not order because ND's Unix-based products did not exist yet.[122]

ND started working to find new market segments it could create tailor-made systems for on top of its existing product lines. The first such market was computer-aided design and computer-aided manufacturing, but this was largely rejected by the international sales divisions. Of fear of the company failing completely to the side, projects were abandoned as was the Ndix project.[123] 1988 became the first year since 1967 that Norsk Data did not make a profit.[124] That year also saw the company's share equity halve.[125]

Spin-offs and finale

Personal computers in the foreground were in 1991 replacing the ND-100 and ND-500 computers in the background at Joint European Torus.

Management announced on 24 January 1989 a major restructuring of the company. The development division would be reduced from several hundred to less than a hundred employees, there would be large down-scaling in the foreign sales offices and the development of Unix-based systems would be spun off in Dolphin Server Technology. ND would not develop its own hardware any more, but purchase components from third parties, including Dolphin.[126] At a public meeting, Skår responded to a question by stating that Notis would be replaced with new systems. Development of Notis was spun off in its own company, Notis AS, which continued to develop the program for ND. Sales fell dramatically as customers lost confidence in that ND could deliver the products in the future and by the internal process demotivating the sales employees.[127] Only in Germany did sales not decrease during 1988 and 1989.[128]

The financial problems were cause by a lack of focus on single market segments. ND had bought several software and hardware companies without a defined strategy, and often without adding new segments to the portfolio, as they often had overlapping products.[129] The purchases were made in the hope that new software would bring new clients to choose ND hardware, which was the only product ND made profits from. Rolf Skår stated in 1988 that the company should focus on the banking industry, but this was never carried out.[130] Sales had continued to fall during 1989, as customers were concerned that the Sintran-based product line would be discontinued.[131]

Norsk Data engaged a number of consultancy companies to analyze the firm in 1989. One important finding was that the customers' perception of ND's strengths and weaknesses was completely different from the employees' perception.[128] Another was that the customers did not understand ND's strategy and a general dissatisfaction with software and the high turnover in the sales force. Also administrative routines were found to be a shortcoming and one consultant company stated that ND was the company they had investigated which had the most room for improvement.[132] Management introduced a company-wide program to increase all employees' focus on market orientation, but the top management carried out several public blunders in poor customer management through the press.[125] Terje Mikkelsen started negotiations to sell ND to a major competitor, but no deal was ever made.[129]

Skår resigned as CEO in August 1989 and was replaced by the newly hired Erik Engebretsen, who had a business education.[133] This also resulted in a several new people in the top management, which became dominated by businesspeople rather than engineers.[134] In September, all jobs in the company's new organizational structure were announced and all ND employees had to apply for the new jobs. Several functions were outsourced,[135] while the internal parts were organized as business units. These included ND StatsPartner for sales towards the central government, ND LokalPartner for sales to local government, ND BusinessPartner for sale towards selected large corporate clients and ND DataShop for sale of standardized products. These would then purchase products from ND ServiceTeam for hardware and ND SystemTeam, a continuation of ND Application. Towards the end of 1989 ND was able to turn the tide and experienced a growth in sales.[136]

Thus the re-organized ND was in a situation where it sold PCs, Sintran systems and Unix systems.[137] In January 1990, the business units started negotiating the internal prices. Although top management had originally proposed that the partners could buy services from outside the company and the teams sell outside the company, such transactions were stopped by top management. ServiceTeam achieved high internal prices through the negotiations as they held all the cards.[138] With the introduction of standard hardware platforms, computer manufacturers had to deliver unique software portfolios to avoid a pure price competition. With the spin-off of Notis, ND allowed one of their few competitive advantages to be available for all platforms. The three partner divisions were pure sales divisions and secured all the revenue for the team-divisions and DataShop. However, the partner divisions had very low margins so the profits were being made in the other business units, and thus receiving the praise of top management.[139]

The reorganizing also made a drastic change to the corporate culture. While ND previously had allowed a high degree of autonomy for its employees and divisions, issues became increasingly top-managed. Motivation and sales dropped, and the company lost much of its ability to get employees to work free overtime. In early 1991 a new round of layoffs was carried through, followed by a new reorganization.[140] New control mechanisms were introduced to ensure that all employees understood the new model. Few employees would admit to not understanding it, but in reality most did not, enhancing the problem. New rounds of lay-offs took place in June and September, the latter consisting of 500 people. ND lost all its large customers and signed no large contracts in 1990 and 1991. One of the main reasons was that sales personnel were forced to call back to the office to confirm every step in negotiations.[141]

By then the partner divisions were merged to NordPartner, later renamed ND-Partner. In October 1991 the division was sold to Siemens Nixdorf,[142] SystemTeam was sold to Avenir and the buildings at Skullerud to a contractor.[143] ND lost NOK 810 million in 1991,[144] and with an eighty percent decrease was the European company to have the second-largest share price loss in 1991.[145] After failed negotiations over many months to sell Comtec, ND decided to close the division in February 1992.[146] This was followed up with the sale of Technovision to Intergraph in March 1992.[147]

Tor Alfheim took over as CEO in July 1992.[148] DataShop was sold in late August to a group of investors from the company's management.[149] The following month ND ServiceTeam, which at the time had 560 employees, was renamed Comma. The company cited the reason as being that the Norsk Data brand no longer entailed confidence among customers.[150] As the only profitable part of ND, it was able to make a NOK 100-million profit in 1992. The revenue and margins were being made on selling Sintran-based systems to existing customers, and was described by an analyst as "having a monopoly of a melting iceberg" and that the company was not creating a new customer base of non-Sintran systems.[151] Norsk Data was delisted from Oslo Stock Exchange on 2 March 1993.[152] Formula Open Soft was sold to Merkantildata effective 1 April.[153]

ND started debt settlement proceedings at Oslo District Court on 11 May 1993.[154] Norsk Data merged with Nordic Data and Comma on 31 December to create Comma Data Services, which had 800 employees. All ND shareholders lost their values, the creditors received 25 percent of their claims and the new company became owned by the two largest creditors, Den norske Bank (70 percent) and Fokus Bank (30 percent).[155] Dolphin was on 30 November announced closed and all employees were laid off, but on 23 December it was instead sold to the Telenor-owned TDK.[156] Comma was sold to Telenor in March 1995.[157]

References

1. Heradstveit: 33
2. Heradstveit: 29
3. Heradstveit: 34
4. Heradstveit: 35
5. Heradstveit: 36
6. Heradstveit: 38
7. Heradstveit: 39
8. Heradstveit: 40
9. Steine: 19
10. Heradstveit: 41
11. Heradstveit: 47
12. Heradstveit: 43
13. Heradstveit: 45
14. Heradstveit: 46
15. Heradstveit: 48
16. Heradstveit: 55
17. Heradstveit: 53
18. Heradstveit: 54
19. Heradstveit: 50
20. Heradstveit: 52
21. Heradstveit: 56
22. Heradstveit: 57
23. Heradstveit: 59
24. Heradstveit: 60
25. Heradstveit: 63
26. Steine: 27
27. Steine: 29
28. Steine: 34
29. Heradstveit: 68
30. Heradstveit: 69
31. Steine: 26
32. Heradstveit: 148
33. Heradstveit: 70
34. Heradstveit: 71
35. Heradstveit: 72
36. Heradstveit: 73
37. Heradstveit: 74
38. Heradstveit: 77
39. Heradstveit: 78
40. Heradstveit: 80
41. Heradstveit: 83
42. Heradstveit: 84
43. Heradstveit: 91
44. Steine: 33
45. Heradstveit: 87
46. Heradstveit: 93
47. Heradstveit: 92
48. Steine: 31
49. Heradstveit: 94
50. Heradstveit: 99
51. Heradstveit: 101
52. Heradstveit: 102
53. Steine: 35
54. Heradstveit: 161
55. Heradstveit: 105
56. Heradstveit: 104
57. Steine: 36
58. Steine: 37
59. Steine: 104
60. Steine: 105
61. Heradstveit: 106
62. Heradstveit: 128
63. Heradstveit: 129
64. Steine: 89
65. Steine: 83
66. Steine: 84
67. Steine: 85
68. Steine: 91
69. Heradstveit: 131
70. Heradstveit: 134
71. Heradstveit: 107
72. Heradstveit: 108
73. Heradstveit: 111
74. Heradstveit: 112
75. Heradstveit: 113
76. Heradstveit: 116
77. Heradstveit: 117
78. Heradstveit: 120
79. Steine: 93
80. Steine: 94
81. Steine: 95
82. Steine: 96
83. Steine: 92
84. Heradstveit: 160
85. Steine: 98
86. Steine: 99
87. Steine: 100
88. Heradstveit: 170
89. Steine: 101
90. Heradstveit: 188
91. Heradstveit: 149
92. Heradstveit: 140
93. Heradstveit: 138
94. Heradstveit: 145
95. Steine: 107
96. Steine: 110
97. Steine: 113
98. Steine: 115
99. Heradstveit: 151
100. Heradstveit: 152
101. Heradstveit: 153
102. Heradstveit: 154
103. Heradstveit: 155
104. Heradstveit: 174
105. Heradstveit: 175
106. Heradstveit: 177
107. Steine: 11
108. Steine: 16
109. Steine: 5
110. Steine: 135
111. Steine: 137
112. Steine: 140
113. Steine: 141
114. Steine: 143
115. Steine: 144
116. Steine: 146
117. Steine: 145
118. Steine: 147
119. Steine: 148
120. Steine: 149
121. Steine: 150
122. Steine: 152
123. Steine: 154
124. Steine: 153
125. Steine: 163
126. Steine: 155
127. Steine: 157
128. Steine: 159
129. Steine: 164
130. Steine: 165
131. Steine: 169
132. Steine: 161
133. Steine: 167
134. Steine: 168
135. Steine: 170
136. Steine: 173
137. Steine: 174
138. Steine: 177
139. Steine: 178
140. Steine: 179
141. Steine: 180
142. Steine: 183
143. Steine: 198
144. Pedersen, Hugo (20 February 1992). "NDs minus ble 810 millioer". Aftenposten (in Norwegian). p. 30.
145. Otterdal, Magne (4 February 1992). "ND på bunn i Europa". Dagens Næringsliv (in Norwegian). p. 6.
146. Borrevik, Line Noer (4 February 1992). "ND-Comtec legges ned – ingen ville overta". Dagens Næringsliv (in Norwegian). p. 6.
147. Olsen, Claude Roland (14 March 1992). "Technovision solgt til amerikansk dataselskap". Dagens Næringsliv (in Norwegian). p. 11.
148. Jensen, Thor Christian (21 July 1992). "Alfheim tar over ND". Dagens Næringsliv (in Norwegian). p. 6.
149. Hansen, Lars Ditlev (27 August 1992). "Norsk Data selger ND DataShop". Aftenposten (in Norwegian). p. 44.
150. Ekanger, Merethe (16 September 1992). "Comma". Nordlys (in Norwegian). p. 13.
151. Hellstrøm, Ulf P. (11 February 1993). "Rekordresultat for ND-selskap". Aftenposten (in Norwegian). p. 32.
152. "Norsk Data tatt vekk fra børsen". Aftenposten (in Norwegian). 8 February 1993. p. 3.
153. "Selger FOS". Dagens Næringsliv (in Norwegian). 18 February 1993. p. 6.
154. "Ber om gjeldsforhandlinger: Norsk Data til skifteretten". Aftenposten (in Norwegian). 12 May 1993. p. 27.
155. Ziolko, Janina (30 December 1993). "Comma setter punktum". Aftenposten (in Norwegian). p. 18.
156. "Landet rundt TBK overtar Dolphin". Aftenposten (in Norwegian). 24 December 1993. p. 11.
157. "Norges største IT-bedrift". Dagens Næringsliv (in Norwegian). 24 March 1995. p. 5.

Bibliography

• Heradstveit, Per Øyvind (1985). Norsk Data – A Success Story. Oslo: J. M. Stenersens Forlag. ISBN 82-7201-044-5.
• Steine, Tor Olav (1992). Fenomenet Norsk Data (in Norwegian). Oslo: Universitetsforlaget. ISBN 82-00-21501-6.