Hearthstone in esports

Blizzard Entertainment's online collectible card game Hearthstone became played professionally quickly after its release in March 2014. The game is played as an esport, with high-level tournaments such as Blizzard's official World Championship featuring prize pool of up to $1 million,[1] and livestreamers can earn money streaming gameplay on Twitch.

History of Hearthstone competition

2014

The first Hearthstone tournament was held at BlizzCon on 2013-11-8, only a few months after the release of the game's closed beta and several months before the official release of the game on 2014-03-11. Blizzard selected eight prominent Hearthstone players to compete at what they titled the "Hearthstone Innkeeper's Invitational". The tournament was won by Artosis, who was subsequently crowned the "Grandmaster of the Hearth".[2][3] After the official release of the game, more Hearthstone tournaments followed, including events at EGX Rezzed and DreamHack Bucharest.[4][5] BlizzCon 2014 featured a Hearthstone tournament with a $250,000 USD prize pool, the largest up to that point, and players from the Americas, Europe, and Asia qualified for the event through winning regional tournaments.[6][7]

In June 2014, the organization of Assembly Summer 2014, a Finnish qualifying tournament for the International e-Sports Federation's (IeSF) World Championship, sparked controversy when it was announced that tournament would be open for men only. The cause was that the World Championship was also slated to have an all-male line-up, and its qualifying events were subject to the same rules. According to the IeSF, the rule was set in place in order to "secure traditional sports status" for esports. The forced gender division was abolished a few days after it was announced for Assembly Summer when the IeSF switched to an "open for all" format.[8][9]

June also saw a cheating scandal when Radu "Rdu" Dima won first prize and US$10,000 at DreamHack Summer. During Rdu's final match against AmazHS, he got a Battle.net message stating the content of AmazHS' hand. Though the information was no longer relevant in the game, Rdu was upset about the unsolicited help and tournament organizers called for a 20-minute break in which Rdu's "friend list" was deleted, though they decided the round was won fairly. Though AmazHS gave his support to Rdu afterward, he stated that DreamHack should have been better at organizing the tournament and implored Blizzard to implement game modes in which such forms of cheating are not possible.[10][11]

In Hearthstone's first year, a total of 52 tournaments and series awarded US$1,000 or more to individual players. Over the year, over US$1,000,000 worth of prize money was awarded during 2014, large tournaments being the World Championships and the World Cyber Arena. James "Firebat" Kostesich was the most successful tournament player, winning a total of US$105,650. Fifteen players made above the United States federal minimum wage through tournaments alone in 2014, and many players make more through livestreaming their Hearthstone games.[12]

Hearthstone's inaugural World Championship concluded at BlizzCon 2014 and featured a total prize pool of US$250,000 and the Last Hero Standing format.[13][14] James "Firebat" Kostesich defeated Wang "Tiddler Celestial" Xieyu in the finals, becoming the first World Champion and earning US$100,000.[13]

2015

In March 2015, Red Bull's Jon Partridge stated that Hearthstone was "emerging as one of the world's top esports." Technology company Nvidia held a professional Hearthstone tournament series that spanned eight weeks, from the end of March to the middle of May, with a total prize pool of US$25,000. The tournament, which was split up in Professional Division of 16 high-level players and an open worldwide Amateur Division, was a qualifying event of the 2015 World Championship.[15][16][17]

Blizzard's official 2015 Hearthstone World Championship tournament concluded at BlizzCon 2015. Sixteen players qualified for the event by improving their rankings at Blizzard-sanctioned tournaments. Four players per region eventually qualified for the World Championship by improving their regional rankings in Europe, North and Latin America, China, and Asia-Pacific.[18][19] This World Championship was the first to be held with the Conquest format with a ban.[13][20] Swedish player Sebastian "Ostkaka" Engwall defeated Canadian player Dylan "Hotform" Mullins to earn US$100,000 and the title of World Champion.[13]

2016

Hearthstone competition "Throne of Cards IV" in Vienna, Austria

In November 2015, Blizzard announced a change in the Hearthstone season structure, where the game's esports calendar would be split into Summer, Fall, Winter, and Spring seasons, each running for three months. Players have to earn enough HCT points in order to qualify for major tournaments at the end of each season which are held in three of the game's regions. Companies like Kyoto esports, StriveWire, and Zotac host tournaments that give players points to qualify for the seasonal major tournaments. The winners of each tournament qualified automatically for the World Championship. Through this setup, 12 players qualify for the event, while Blizzard appoints four players from China in some other manner.[21] The 2016 Hearthstone World Tour featured over US$1,900,000 in prize money.[22]

The third Hearthstone World Championship was held at BlizzCon 2016 on November 5 with the Conquest format and a prize pool of US$1,000,000, four times as much as in 2015.[13][21] It was played in a Swiss tournament format and one class could be banned from use by one's opponent. The winner was Russian Pavel "Pavel" Beltiukov, who defeated Artem "DrHippi" Karevets to earn the top prize of US$250,000.[13][23]

2017

The 2017 Hearthstone World Championship is the fourth year of the Hearthstone World Championship. Breaking from the tradition of previous years, the 2017 Hearthstone World Championship took place in January 2018, instead of during BlizzCon near the end of the year. The winner was Chen "Tom60229" WeiLin from Taiwan, who defeated Frank "Fr0zen" Zhang to earn the top prize of US$250,000.[24]

Date: January 18–21, 2018 Location: Amsterdam, Netherlands Prize Pool: $1,000,000

2018

The 2018 Hearthstone World Championship will be the Hearthstone Championship Tour's final event and was held in April 2019 in Taipei, Taiwan with a $1 million prize pool.[25] The fifth Hearthstone World Championship winner was Norwegian Casper "Hunterace" Notto that received $250,000.[26]

2019

Blizzard is replacing the previously used tour system with three variations of a single class deck called "Specialist". More than $4 million will be available in the prize pool. Blizzard will hold the first tournaments primarily online and will be region-locked. The winners will go on to compete in the live global tournaments throughout 2019.[25] The fifth Hearthstone World Championship took place in April 2019 and was held in Taipei; the winner was Norwegian Casper "Hunterace" Notto that received $250,000.[27]

Grandmasters Season 2 will remove the Specialist format used in Season 1. Instead, players will bring four decks, each from a different class. Before the match begins, each player chooses a deck to "shield", which means the other player cannot ban it. Then each player will ban one deck from the opponent. If a player wins with a deck, then the next match another deck must be played. If a player loses, then they can replay the deck.[28]

In October 2019, Blizzard announced it would ban a player for one year from competing and forfeited all of his winnings earned during Season 2 because he spoke in support of the 2019–20 Hong Kong protests during a tournament interview, which violated the rule against promoting a political stance during a broadcast.[29] A few days later, Blizzard revised its decision so it gave back the prize money and reduced the suspension to six months.[30]

The sixth Hearthstone World Championship winner was Chinese Xiaomeng "VKLiooon" Li that received $200,000; VKLiooon was also the first woman to win a Hearthstone world championship and to win a BlizzCon tournament.[31]

Streaming

For many professional Hearthstone players, rather than tournament earnings, livestreaming is their main source of income.[12] In 2014, Kinguin project coordinator Giovanni Varriale stated that Hearthstone was one of the most popular games on Twitch, with "thousands of people spend[ing] hours watching the best players in action."[32]

Game design

See also: Gameplay of Hearthstone

Hearthstone is a digital and online card game, comparable to traditional collectible card games such as Magic: The Gathering.

Expansions

The game features a large amount of inherent randomness as calculated through a random number generator (a property referred to as "RNG"). Some cards may have excessively random effects and may be able to completely sway a game through RNG. Various fans are worried about the future of the game's competitive scene due to unbalanced cards being introduced in new expansions. In an interview with Polygon, Hearthstone associate designer Dean Ayala stated that newly introduced cards can add to the strategy of the game, and that expanding Hearthstone is "all about finding the balance with what is ok and what isn't ok." Ayala explained that a large part of adding new cards to the game is trying to view each card through the lens of each possible type of player and how the card may be used.[33]

Culture

The practice of "win trading", where players forfeit games in order to help other players gain in ranking, can be used to reach Legend ranking with less effort. However, win trading is considered cheating, and Blizzard gives out permanent bans for people who indulge in the practice.[34]

In 2014, professional coaching services became popular, where high-level players discuss strategies with their clients and give tips for improvement. Nathan 'ThatsAdmirable' Zamora stated that the work is his main source of income, and that the service is useful for players that have plateaued and are unsure on how to change their play style.[35]

In August 2014, competitive Hearthstone player Ryan "Realz" Masterson was hired by Blizzard in order to help with the balancing of the game.[36][37]

Controversy

During a GrandMasters Season 2 match on October 6, 2019, player Chung "Blitzchung" Ng Wai made statements in support of the ongoing protests in Hong Kong. During a post-match interview on the official Taiwanese broadcast, Blitzchung wore ski goggles and a respirator mask similarly to the protesters, and used the popular pro-democracy slogan "Liberate Hong Kong, revolution of our time".[38] Blizzard considered the gesture to be a violation of rules forbidding players from engaging in conduct that "brings [the player] into public disrepute, offends a portion or group of the public or otherwise damages" the reputation of the company. As a result, Blizzard removed Blitzchung from the tournament, rescinded his Season 2 prize winnings, and banned him from Hearthstone competitions for one year. Blizzard also terminated its contract with the two casters involved in the broadcast.[39] Blizzard stated that while it "[stands] by one's right to express individual thoughts and opinions", players were still subject to their official rules and regulations during competition.[39][40][41]

The removal of Blitzchung led to criticism of Blizzard and calls for a boycott of the company. As coverage of the protests have been subject to censorship in mainland China, critics considered the decision to be an act of self-censorship intended to appease Chinese investors and stakeholders. Chinese conglomerate Tencent owns a minority stake in Activision Blizzard.[42][43] Comparisons were also drawn with a recent controversy involving Daryl Morey, owner of the Houston Rockets basketball team, over a Twitter posting that similarly pledged support for the protests.[39][44] The developers of the similar game Gods Unchained invited Blitzchung to its own tournament, offering to also repay the winnings that Blizzard had rescinded.[40]

References

1. Changes Coming to Hearthstone Competitive Tour for 2017 Hearthpwn, Retrieved October 26, 2016
2. Tach, Dave (2013-10-10). "Blizzard hosting a Hearthstone tournament at BlizzCon". Polygon.
3. Warr, Philippa (2014-06-04). "Hearthstone Q&A: Kripparrian". Red Bull.
4. Bramwell, Tom (2014-03-27). "Hearthstone tournament taking place at EGX Rezzed". Eurogamer.
5. "Hearthstone Help: Interview with Dreamhack Bucharest winner". PC Gamer. 2014-05-21.
6. Macy, Seth G. (2014-05-23). "Hearthstone Blizzcon Tournament Prize Pool is $250,000 USD". IGN.
7. Tassi, Paul (2014-05-25). "Blizzard Throwing 'Hearthstone' World Championship With $100K First Prize". Forbes.
8. Savage, Phil (2014-07-03). "IeSF removes male-only restriction from its e-sports tournaments". PC Gamer.
9. Grubb, Jeff (2014-07-02). "E-sports league that prohibited women Hearthstone players reverses policy after talking with Blizzard". VentureBeat.
10. Peel, Jeremy (2014-06-17). "Most lucrative Hearthstone win marred by controversy; "Rdu is not cheating," says Amaz". PCGamesN.
11. Schreier, Jason (2014-06-17). "'Cheating' Scandal Hits $10,000 Hearthstone Tournament". Kotaku.
12. Leslie, Callum (2014-12-31). "Hearthstone players won more than $1 million in the game's first year". The Daily Dot. Archived from the original on 9 May 2016.
13. "Hearthstone World Championship". Hearthstone Wiki. Retrieved 2018-01-20.
14. "Tournaments". Hearthstone Wiki. Retrieved 2018-01-20.
15. Chalk, Andy (2015-02-16). "Nvidia announces Pro/Am Hearthstone Tournament with $25k prize pool". PC Gamer.
16. Parfitt, Ben (2015-02-26). "Nvidia is hosting its own Hearthstone tournament". MCV.
17. Partridge, Jon (2015-05-11). "Nvidia Hearthstone comp pits you against the pros". Red Bull.
18. Bogos, Steven (2015-01-31). "2015 Hearthstone World Championship Announced". The Escapist.
19. Nunnely, Stephany (2015-01-16). "Here's how you earn a spot in the 2015 Hearthstone World Championship". VG247.
20. "Tournaments". Hearthstone Wiki. Retrieved 2018-01-20.
21. Mamiit, Aaron (2015-11-27). "Blizzard Getting Serious On eSports: 'Hearthstone' World Championship Prize Money Quadrupled To $1M, Structure Changed". Tech Times.
22. Lingle, Samuel (2015-11-25). "The 2016 Hearthstone World Tour will feature over $1.9 million in prizes". The Daily Dot.
23. Tassi, Paul. "Russia's Pavel Wins BlizzCon's 2016 'Hearthstone' World Championship".
24. "Hearthstone World Championship". playhearthstone.com. Retrieved 2018-10-28.
25. "Taipei to Host 'Hearthstone' HCT World Championship". Retrieved 2019-01-30.
26. "Hunterace wins 2019 Hearthstone World Championship". Slack News. Retrieved May 1, 2019.
27. "Hunterace wins 2019 Hearthstone World Championship". Slack News. Retrieved May 1, 2019.
28. 'Hearthstone' Dumps One-Hero Specialist Card Format In Esports Competitions July 30, 2019.
29. "After Hearthstone player's ban, Blizzard is in hot water with lawmakers". October 8, 2019. Retrieved October 9, 2019.
30. "Blizzard Statement On Hong Kong Controversy: We Will Continue To Punish Political Speech". October 12, 2019. Retrieved October 14, 2019.
31. "'Just forget your gender': Xiaomeng 'VKLiooon' Li becomes first female Hearthstone Grandmasters Global Finals champion". The Washington Times. Retrieved November 5, 2019.
32. Higgins, Chris (2014-12-11). "eSports tournaments trading cards for charity". Red Bull.
33. Kollar, Phillip (2016-08-26). "Hearthstone devs are not worried about randomness ruining the game". Polygon.
34. Benson, Julian (2014-10-31). "Hearthstone win trading results in permanent bans and tournament disqualification". PCGamesN.
35. Clark, Tim (2014-08-20). "What I learned from playing with a professional Hearthstone coach". PC Gamer.
36. Blanchard, Ryan (2014-08-30). "Professional 'Hearthstone' Player Hired By Blizzard". Game Rant.
37. "Blizzard Hires Hearthstone Pro as Associate Game Designer". IGN. 2014-08-28.
38. "Eight Chinese characters that have the Hong Kong government worried". South China Morning Post. 2019-08-06. Retrieved 2019-10-08.
39. Campbell, Colin (2019-10-08). "After Hearthstone player's ban, fans call for a Blizzard boycott". Polygon. Retrieved 2019-10-08.
40. Serrels, Mark. "Blizzard pulls Blitzchung from Hearthstone tournament over support for Hong Kong protests". CNET. Retrieved 2019-10-08.
41. Spangler, Todd (2019-10-08). "Blizzard Bans 'Hearthstone' Player From Esports Tournaments for Pro-Hong Kong Protest Statement". Variety. Retrieved 2019-10-08.
42. Hunter, Gregor Stuart; Huang, Zheping (October 8, 2019). "Blizzard Bans Gamer, Rescinds Money, on Hong Kong Protest Support". Bloomberg News. Archived from the original on October 8, 2019. Retrieved October 8, 2019.
43. Kelly, Makena (October 8, 2019). "After Hearthstone player's ban, Blizzard is in hot water with lawmakers". The Verge. Archived from the original on October 8, 2019. Retrieved October 8, 2019.
44. Victor, Daniel (2019-10-08). "'South Park' Creators Offer Fake Apology After Show Is Erased in China". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2019-10-08.