Fragged (Battlestar Galactica)
"Fragged" is the third episode of the second season of the reimagined Battlestar Galactica television series. It aired originally on the Sci Fi Channel on July 29, 2005. It is the first episode in which Starbuck does not appear.
| "Fragged" | |
|---|---|
| Battlestar Galactica episode | |
 Gaius Baltar (James Callis), immediately after fragging Crashdown. | |
| Episode no. | Season 2 Episode 3 |
| Directed by | Sergio Mimica-Gezzan |
| Written by | Dawn Prestwich Nicole Yorkin |
| Original air date | July 29, 2005 |
| Guest appearance(s) | |
| |
In the episode, on Kobol, Crashdown leads an ill fated assault on a Cylon missile battery. Gaius Baltar frags Crashdown, to Head Six's approval, shortly before the survey team is rescued. On Galactica, Colonel Saul Tigh's gambit to discredit President Laura Roslin fails, and he declares martial law.
"Fragged" received an award at the 2005 VES Awards for the (animated) Cylon Centurions appearing in the episode. Critics reviewed "Fragged" favorably.
Plot
In "Scattered", Head Six told Baltar that they would have a child. Crashdown ordered Specialist Tarn to retrieve medical supplies to treat the wounded Specialist Socinus, but Tarn died in a Cylon ambush.[1] In "Valley of Darkness", Chief Galen Tyrol and Specialist Cally brought the supplies, but Socinus died anyway.[2]
Kobol
Crashdown leads a brief funeral for Tarn and Socinus. Six tells Baltar that, because they died on Kobol, Tarn and Socinus have only oblivion waiting them. Later, Baltar asks why God would want to bring a child into a world so full of killing; Six replies that God wants to give humanity a chance at redemption.
Tyrol observes Cylons building a missile battery, which he believes they will use to shoot down human search parties. Crashdown orders an attack on the battery despite the team's inexperience in combat and inadequate equipment. Tyrol privately tries to persuade him to instead attack the guidance system, which is less heavily guarded, but Crashdown waves the bloody shirt of Tarn and Socinus and pulls rank. Tyrol is unconvinced but nonetheless silences Baltar's protests during Crashdown's briefing.
Six warns Baltar that one of the survivors will betray the others and that his life is in danger, because what happens on Kobol is not God's will. Crashdown refuses to change the plan even after discovering that the Cylons have reinforced the battery. Cally freezes up under pressure, and Crashdown threatens to kill her unless she obeys his orders. Baltar shoots Crashdown before he can carry out his threat; Six congratulates him.
Tyrol destroys the Cylon guiding system in time to save the rescue Raptors, which in turn destroy the Cylons. The survivors cover up Crashdown's murder. Baltar despairs at the thought that killing rather than culture is humanity's legacy.
Galactica
Doctor Cottle arrives and operates on Commander William Adama, saving his life. Cottle is unavailable to provide Roslin with her cancer medication, and she undergoes severe withdrawal. A drunken Colonel Tigh lashes out at his subordinates. The Quorum of Twelve demands access to Roslin, who is still in Galactica's brig. Ellen Tigh persuades her husband to agree, believing the sight of Roslin's delirious condition will undermine her authority. The plan backfires after Roslin's Marine guard smuggles her medication. She denounces Adama's coup and convinces at least some of the Quorum that she is the leader foretold in their sacred scriptures who will guide humanity to Earth.[lower-alpha 2] Furious, Tigh dissolves the Quorum and declares martial law.
Deleted scenes
In a deleted scene, Roslin has a vision of arguing with Billy Keikeya about the Scriptures. Billy taunts her for her mistakes and then stabs her as the vision ends.[3]
Analysis
In a review of "Fragged", Jen Segrest of AOL's TV Squad discusses Baltar's character, calling his "descent into madness... tragic,"[4] but also noting that the audience can identify with his guilt for allowing the Cylons into the Colonies' defense computers[4] in the miniseries that served as the series's backdoor pilot.[5] Segrest also notes how Baltar's instinct for self-preservation helps him defend himself and the other survivors against the Cylons and attributes his lie about Crashdown's death to "a bit of honor left in him".[4]
In another review, Jason Davis of Mania reflects on Head Six's comments about humanity's inclination toward killing, noting that Babylon 5 covered similar ground. He describes a difference between humans and Cylons in this regard: humans kill one another, while Cylons do not. Davis also proposes a mythology within the Battlestar Galactica universe, in which the humans killed their creators, the gods who once lived with them on Kobol, whether literally or in the sense of Nietzsche (God is dead). In Davis's view, "The Cylons, having reached a certain advanced point of development, now seek to do likewise"[6] to their own creators, humanity.[6] In his review of the episode "Home, Part 1", Davis compares the Cylons' journey with the events of Star Trek: The Motion Picture.[7] In a January 2006 interview, executive producer Ronald D. Moore said of the Cylons, "they see themselves as the children of humanity, and their worldview says they’ll never really achieve their full potential while their 'parents' are still alive".[8]
Reception
"Fragged" won the 2005 Visual Effects Society Award for the Centurions in the category "Outstanding Performance by an Animated Character in a Live Action Broadcast Program, Commercial, or Music Video".[9]
Critical reaction to "Fragged" was favorable. Segrest reviewed the episode favorably, saying, "Anyone who thought the show would suffer a sophomore slump should be eating their words. This show doesn't just deserve a Hugo award, it deserves Emmys."[4] Davis gave "Fragged" an A and praised the performances of Michael Hogan (Tigh), Richard Hatch (Zarek), and Donnelly Rhodes (Cottle).[6] Susan Tankersley of Television Without Pity gave "Fragged" a B.[10]
Eric Goldman of IGN ranked Tigh taking command at #11 on his list of the top 20 storylines and moments in the re-imagined Battlestar Galactica. He ranked Crashdown's failure of leadership at #12, commenting, "The entire storyline with these characters on Kobol provided the opportunity to elevate several members of the supporting cast in intriguing ways".[11] Jackson Alpern of Maxim ranked Baltar fragging Crashdown as the 10th best moment in the series.[12]
Notes
- Special guest star
- The connection between the Earth of the re-imagined Battlestar Galactica and the real-life Earth is unknown at this point in the series.
References
- "Scattered". Battlestar Galactica. Season 2. Episode 1. 15 Jul 2005. Sci Fi.
- "Valley of Darkness". Battlestar Galactica. Season 2. Episode 2. 22 Jul 2005. Sci Fi.
- Battlestar Galactica DVD, season 2.0, disc 1, "Fragged" deleted scenes.
- Segrest, Jen (30 Jul 2005). "Battlestar Galactica: Fragged". TV Squad. Retrieved 19 Jul 2011.
- "Battlestar Galactica miniseries". 8–9 Dec 2003. Sci Fi. Missing or empty
|series=(help) - Davis, Jason (4 Aug 2005). "Battlestar Galactica - Fragged". Mania. Archived from the original on 2012-10-18. Retrieved 19 Jul 2011.
- Davis, Jason (22 Aug 2005). "Battlestar Galactica - Home, Part One". Archived from the original on 2012-10-18. Retrieved 22 Jul 2011.
- Moore, Ronald D. (4 Jan 2006). Chicago Tribune (Interview). Interviewed by Maureen Ryan http://featuresblogs.chicagotribune.com/entertainment_tv/2006/01/president_rosli.html. Retrieved 24 Aug 2011. Missing or empty
|title=(help) - Visual Effects Society. "4th Annual VES Awards". Archived from the original on 2012-04-10. Retrieved 9 Aug 2011.
- Tankersley, Susan (Strega) (3 Aug 2005). "Paths of glory". Television Without Pity. Archived from the original on 2012-10-12. Retrieved 19 Jul 2011.
- Goldman, Eric (26 Mar 2009). "Battlestar Galactica: 20 best storylines and moments". IGN. Retrieved 18 Jul 2011.
- Alpern, Jackson (21 Oct 2009). "The 10 best Battlestar Galactica moments". Maxim. Archived from the original on 5 February 2011. Retrieved 22 Jul 2011.