Eagles–Steelers rivalry
The Eagles–Steelers rivalry is a National Football League (NFL) rivalry between the Philadelphia Eagles and the Pittsburgh Steelers. Unofficially nicknamed "The Battle of Pennsylvania", this is an in-state, interconference rivalry between the two NFL teams located in the state of Pennsylvania.
| First meeting | November 19, 1933 Eagles 25, Steelers 6 |
|---|---|
| Latest meeting | September 25, 2016 Eagles 34, Steelers 3 |
| Next meeting | 2020 |
| Statistics | |
| Meetings total | 79 meetings |
| All-time series | Eagles, 48–28–3 |
| Current win streak | Eagles, 1 |
| Championship success | |
| Super Bowl Championships (7) | |
The rivalry is one of the oldest in the NFL, dating back to 1933. During the first three decades of the rivalry, the Steelers and Eagles were in the NFL's Eastern Division and played twice annually. As a result of the AFL-NFL merger, the Steelers were placed in the AFC Central, while the Eagles were placed in the NFC East, resulting in infrequent meetings – The teams have only met 12 times since 1970. Under the current NFL scheduling formula, the teams play each other once every four years. The teams last played in 2016, a 34–3 Eagles win in Philadelphia.[1]. They will next play in 2020 in Pittsburgh.
The rivalry is one of two the Steelers have with NFC East teams, the other being their rivalry with the Dallas Cowboys. Much like other rivalries between Philadelphia and Pittsburgh, the rivalry is mostly fueled by the two cities being within Pennsylvania and their sociocultural differences, with Philadelphia and the neighboring Lehigh Valley and Wyoming Valley being part of the Northeast megalopolis while Pittsburgh and Western Pennsylvania in general being part of the Rust Belt and Appalachia. Central Pennsylvania is considered battleground territory between the two teams.
The Eagles lead the all-time series 48–28–3. The teams have met once in the playoffs, a 21–0 Eagles victory in the 1947 Eastern Division Playoff. As the two teams are in different conferences, the only way they can currently meet in the playoffs is if they both make it to the Super Bowl. While this has never occurred, both teams have made it to their respective Conference Championship Game in 2001, 2004, and 2008.
History
Early years
Both teams were officially founded in 1933, with the Steelers then being known as the Pittsburgh Pirates. However, their histories predate that, with the Steelers being known as the J.P. Rooneys dating to 1921 as a semipro team, while the Eagles are arguably descended from the Frankford Yellow Jackets based in Philadelphia's Frankford neighborhood dating to 1899. The NFL considers both teams having started in 1933 alongside the now-defunct Cincinnati Reds. Both teams took advantage of Pennsylvania relaxing their blue laws in 1933 that previously didn't allow sporting events on Sundays, when most NFL games took place. The blue laws, combined with general issues related to The Great Depression, were among the reasons the Yellow Jackets failed despite winning the NFL champsionship in 1926.
The first meeting between the teams was on November 19, with the Eagles winning, 25–6. The two teams would struggle their first decade in the NFL both on the field and financially, with the Steelers staying afloat mostly due to team founder Art Rooney's gambling habits. Eventually, in late 1940 Rooney sold the Steelers to Alexis Thompson, a 26-year-old steel heir from Boston frequently described in the press as "a well-heeled New York City playboy". Thompson planned to move the franchise to Boston and play games in Fenway Park. Eagles owner Bert Bell brokered the deal between Rooney and Thompson for $160,000, and Rooney used $80,000 of the proceeds to buy a partnership in the Eagles, which at the time was owned by Bell. The deal also involved the trade of several players between the two teams.
The two owners planned to field a combined Philadelphia-Pittsburgh team called the Pennsylvania Keystoners that would play home games in both cities. The original proposition was that Thompson would buy the franchise and take the Pittsburgh club to Boston and Bell and Rooney would pool their interests in the Eagles to form a Philadelphia-Pittsburgh club, splitting the home games between Forbes Field in Pittsburgh and Philadelphia's Municipal Stadium. Thompson, however, was unable to secure a place to play in Boston. After meeting with Rooney, plans changed whereby Thompson's club (ostensibly the former Steelers) would play in Philadelphia as the Eagles, while the Rooney-Bell owned team would play in Pittsburgh as the Steelers, effectively trading the two clubs between their cities.
Steagles and post-war activity
The notion for a single team between the two cities was revived, when for one season in 1943, forced to do so by player shortfalls brought on by World War II, the two clubs temporarily merged as the Philadelphia-Pittsburgh "Steagles". The league only approved the merger for one year; Pittsburgh was willing to merge again for 1944 but not Philadelphia. This forced the Steelers to merge with the Chicago Cardinals (as Card-Pitt) for 1944.
Following the end of the war, both teams fortunes changed, with the Eagles and Steelers both clinching playoff spots in the late 1940s, including their only postseason meeting to date in 1947, when the Eagles shut out the Steelers 21–0 at Forbes Field. It would be the Steelers only playoff appearance until the Immaculate Reception 25 years later. The Eagles, under head coach Greasy Neale, won NFL championships in 1948 and 1949.
During the 1950s and 1960s, both teams success and failures would be relative to one another, to the point that both teams would be "competing" for the worst record in the NFL in 1968 and the chance to draft O.J. Simpson. Ultimately, the Atlanta Falcons had the NFL's worst record and the Buffalo Bills of the American Football League would win out on what was at that point the common draft. The Eagles, drafting third, would select Leroy Keyes while the Steelers, drafting fourth, would draft relative unknown Joe Greene. New Steelers head coach Chuck Noll would say later that the team would've drafted Greene even if it had the first overall pick, while Keyes (like Simpson a running back) was viewed by Eagles fans as more of a "consolation prize". Ultimately (Simpson's successful NFL career aside), Keyes lasted five years in the NFL; Greene would become a key member of the Steel Curtain defense and is now a member of the Pro Football Hall of Fame and one of two Steelers to have their number officially retired.
Results
| Date | Winner | Score | Location | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| November 19, 1933 | Eagles | 25–6 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 1–0 |
| September 26, 1934 | Eagles | 17–0 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 2–0 |
| October 7, 1934 | Pirates | 9–7 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 2–1 |
| September 13, 1935 | Pirates | 17–7 | Philadelphia | Tie, 2–2 |
| October 9, 1935 | Eagles | 17–6 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 3–2 |
| October 14, 1936 | Pirates | 17–0 | Pittsburgh | Tie, 3–3 |
| November 5, 1936 | Pirates | 6–0 | Philadelphia | Pirates, 4–3 |
| September 5, 1937 | Pirates | 27–14 | Pittsburgh | Pirates, 5–3 |
| October 31, 1937 | Pirates | 16–7 | Pittsburgh | Pirates, 6–3 |
| September 16, 1938 | Eagles | 27–7 | Pittsburgh | Pirates, 6–4 |
| November 20, 1938 | Eagles | 27–7 | Pittsburgh | Pirates, 6–5 |
| November 23, 1939 | Eagles | 17–7 | Philadelphia | Tie, 6–6 |
| November 26, 1939 | Pirates | 24–12 | Pittsburgh | Pirates, 7–6 |
| November 10, 1940 | Steelers | 7–3 | Pittsburgh | Steelers, 8–6 |
| November 10, 1940 | Eagles | 7–0 | Philadelphia | Steelers, 8–7 |
| Septembeer 21, 1941 | Eagles | 10–7 | Pittsburgh | Tie, 8–8 |
| November 9, 1941 | Tie | 7–7 | Philadelphia | Tie, 8–8–1 |
| September 13, 1942 | Eagles | 24–14 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 9–8–1 |
| October 18, 1942 | Steelers | 14–0 | Philadelphia | Tie, 9–9–1 |
| November 4, 1945 | Eagles | 45–3 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 10–9–1 |
| November 18, 1945 | Eagles | 30–6 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 11–9–1 |
| November 17, 1946 | Steelers | 10–7 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 11–10–1 |
| December 1, 1946 | Eagles | 10–7 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 12–10–1 |
| October 19, 1947 | Steelers | 35–24 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 12–11–1 |
| November 30, 1947 | Eagles | 21–0 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 13–11–1 |
| December 21, 1947 * | Eagles | 21–0 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 14–11–1 |
| October 31, 1948 | Eagles | 24–7 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 15–11–1 |
| November 28, 1948 | Eagles | 17–0 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 16–11–1 |
| October 30, 1949 | Eagles | 38–7 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 17–11–1 |
| November 27, 1949 | Eagles | 34–17 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 18–11–1 |
| October 22, 1950 | Eagles | 17–10 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 19–11–1 |
| November 5, 1950 | Steelers | 9–7 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 19–12–1 |
| November 5, 1950 | Eagles | 34–14 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 20–12–1 |
| November 25, 1951 | Steelers | 17–13 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 20–13–1 |
| September 28, 1952 | Eagles | 31–25 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 21–13–1 |
| October 12, 1952 | Eagles | 26–21 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 22–13–1 |
| October 17, 1953 | Eagles | 23–7 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 23–13–1 |
| November 1, 1953 | Eagles | 35–7 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 24–13–1 |
| October 9, 1954 | Eagles | 24–22 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 25–13–1 |
| October 23, 1954 | Steelers | 17–7 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 25–14–1 |
| October 15, 1955 | Steelers | 13–7 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 25–15–1 |
| October 30, 1955 | Eagles | 24–0 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 26–15–1 |
| October 14, 1956 | Eagles | 35–21 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 27–15–1 |
| November 11, 1956 | Eagles | 14–7 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 28–15–1 |
| October 27, 1957 | Steelers | 6–0 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 28–16–1 |
| December 1, 1956 | Eagles | 7–6 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 29–16–1 |
| October 12, 1958 | Steelers | 24–3 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 29–17–1 |
| November 9, 1958 | Steelers | 31–24 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 29–18–1 |
| October 11, 1959 | Eagles | 28–24 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 30–18–1 |
| November 29, 1959 | Steelers | 31–0 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 30–19–1 |
| November 6, 1960 | Eagles | 34–7 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 31–19–1 |
| December 11, 1960 | Steelers | 27–21 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 31–20–1 |
| October 8, 1961 | Eagles | 21–16 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 32–20–1 |
| December 3, 1961 | Eagles | 35–24 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 33–20–1 |
| October 6, 1962 | Steelers | 13–7 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 33–21–1 |
| December 9, 1962 | Steelers | 26–17 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 33–22–1 |
| September 15, 1963 | Tie | 21–21 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 33–22–2 |
| December 1, 1963 | Tie | 20–20 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 33–22–3 |
| October 4, 1964 | Eagles | 21–7 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 34–22–3 |
| October 25, 1964 | Eagles | 34–10 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 35–22–3 |
| October 24, 1965 | Steelers | 26–17 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 35–23–3 |
| December 12, 1965 | Eagles | 47–13 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 36–23–3 |
| October 16, 1966 | Eagles | 31–14 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 37–23–3 |
| December 4, 1966 | Eagles | 27–23 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 38–23–3 |
| October 1, 1967 | Eagles | 34–24 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 39–23–3 |
| October 27, 1968 | Steelers | 6–3 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 39–24–3 |
| September 28, 1969 | Eagles | 41–27 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 40–24–3 |
| December 30, 1970 | Eagles | 30–20 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 41–24–3 |
| November 3, 1974 | Steelers | 27–0 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 41–25–3 |
| September 30, 1979 | Eagles | 17–14 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 42–25–3 |
| November 13, 1988 | Eagles | 27–26 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 43–25–3 |
| September 22, 1991 | Eagles | 23–14 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 44–25–3 |
| December 11, 1994 | Steelers | 14–3 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 44–26–3 |
| November 23, 1997 | Eagles | 23–20 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 45–26–3 |
| November 12, 2000 | Eagles | 26–23(OT) | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 46–26–3 |
| November 7, 2004 | Steelers | 27–3 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 46–27–3 |
| September 21, 2008 | Eagles | 15–6 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 47–27–3 |
| October 7, 2012 | Steelers | 16–14 | Pittsburgh | Eagles, 47–28–3 |
| September 25, 2016 | Eagles | 34–3 | Philadelphia | Eagles, 48–28–3 |
| 2020 | Pittsburgh |
Summary of results
| Overall | at Philadelphia Eagles | at Pittsburgh Steelers | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pre–AFL–NFL merger, regular season (1933–69) | Eagles, 39–24–3 | Eagles, 22–9–2 | Eagles, 17–15–1 | |
| Post-merger (1970–present), regular season | Eagles, 8–4 | Eagles, 6–0 | Steelers, 4–2 | |
| Overall regular season | Eagles, 47–28–3 | Eagles, 28–9–2 | Tie, 19–19–1 | |
| Playoffs | Eagles, 1–0 | no games | Eagles, 1–0 | 1947 Eastern Division Playoff |
| Regular season and playoffs | Eagles, 48–28–3 | Eagles, 28–9–2 | Eagles, 20–19–1 |