Bill Denny

William Joseph "Bill" Denny, MC (6 December 1872 – 2 May 1946) was a South Australian journalist, lawyer, politician and decorated soldier who held the South Australian House of Assembly seats of West Adelaide from 1900 to 1902 and then Adelaide from 1902 to 1905 and again from 1906 to 1933. After an unsuccessful candidacy as a United Labor Party (ULP) member in 1899, he was elected as an "independent liberal" in a by-election in 1900. He was re-elected in 1902, but defeated in 1905. The following year, he was elected as a ULP candidate, and retained his seat for that party (the Australian Labor Party from 1917) until 1931. Along with the rest of the cabinet, he was ejected from the Australian Labor Party in 1931, and was a member of the Parliamentary Labor Party until his electoral defeat at the hands of a Lang Labor Party candidate in 1933.

The Honourable William Joseph Denny MC
William Joseph Denny c. 1910
29th Attorney-General of South Australia
In office 17 April 1930 – 18 April 1933
Premier	Lionel Hill then Robert Richards
Preceded by	Hermann Homburg
Succeeded by	Shirley Jeffries
In office 16 April 1924 – 8 April 1927
Premier	John Gunn
Preceded by	Hermann Homburg
Succeeded by	Hermann Homburg
In office 3 June 1910 – 17 February 1912
Premier	John Verran
Preceded by	Hermann Homburg
Succeeded by	Hermann Homburg
Member of the South Australian Parliament for Adelaide
In office 3 November 1906 – 7 April 1933
In office 3 May 1902 – 26 May 1905
Member of the South Australian Parliament for West Adelaide
In office 17 March 1900 – 2 May 1902
Personal details
Born	(1872-12-06)6 December 1872 Adelaide, South Australia
Died	2 May 1946(1946-05-02) (aged 73) Norwood, South Australia
Resting place	West Terrace Cemetery, Adelaide
Political party	Independent liberal (1900–05) United Labor Party (1906–17) Labor Party (1917–31) Parliamentary Labor Party (1931–33)
Spouse(s)	Winefride Mary (née Leahy)
Parents	Thomas Joseph Denny Annie Denny (née Dwyer)
Alma mater	Christian Brothers College, Adelaide University of Adelaide
Profession	journalist, solicitor, soldier
Military service
Branch/service	Australian Army
Years of service	1915–19
Rank	Captain
Unit	9th Light Horse Regiment 5th Divisional Ammunition Column 1st Divisional Artillery AIF Administrative Headquarters
Battles/wars	First World War Western Front
Awards	Military Cross

Denny was the Attorney-General of South Australia and Minister for the Northern Territory in the government led by John Verran (1910–12). In August 1915, Denny enlisted in the First Australian Imperial Force to serve in World War I, initially as a trooper in the 9th Light Horse Regiment. After being commissioned in 1916, he served in the 5th Division Artillery and 1st Divisional Artillery on the Western Front. He was awarded the Military Cross in September 1917 when he was wounded while leading a convoy into forward areas near Ypres, and ended the war as a captain.

He was again Attorney-General in the Labor governments led by John Gunn (1924–26), Lionel Hill (1930–33) and Robert Richards (1933), and held other portfolios in those governments, including housing, irrigation and repatriation. Denny published two memoirs of his military service, and when he died in 1946 aged 73, he was accorded a state funeral.

Early life

William Joseph Denny was born in Adelaide, South Australia, on 6 December 1872, one of three children of Thomas Joseph Denny, a publican, and his wife Annie (née Dwyer). He attended Christian Brothers College, Adelaide,[1] then worked as a weather clerk at the General Post Office, Adelaide under the Postmaster General, Sir Charles Todd.[2] According to a contemporary source, in 1893 he became the editor of the Catholic The Southern Cross newspaper, which published news about and for the Catholic community of South Australia.[3] A more recent source states he commenced as editor of The Southern Cross in 1896.[1] He replaced James O'Loghlin, who later became a United Labor Party (ULP) senator for South Australia.[4] Denny was a councillor of the Adelaide City Council from 1898,[1] representing Grey Ward. During his early twenties he was active in the literary and debating societies of Adelaide, was Chairman of the Christian Brothers Old Collegians Association, and captain of two city rowing clubs.[2] He unsuccessfully contested the two-member seat of West Adelaide in the 1899 South Australian colonial election as a ULP candidate, gaining 27.7 per cent of the vote.[5]

When a by-election was held for West Adelaide on 17 March 1900, Denny was elected to the single vacancy created by the resignation of the former Premier of South Australia, Charles Kingston.[6] He ran as an "independent liberal" candidate,[7] gaining 66.8 per cent of the vote.[6] Prior to the 1902 state election the electoral district of West Adelaide was abolished. Denny contested the new four-member electoral district of Adelaide, and was elected second in the count with 14.3 per cent of the votes cast.[8] He was defeated at the 1905 state election, gaining only 9.9 per cent of the votes.[9] The following year, having abandoned his former liberalism,[10] he contested the seat of Adelaide at the state election as a ULP candidate, and was elected first, receiving 19.3 per cent of the votes cast.[11] He was again returned first at the 1910 state election,[12] after which the ULP led by John Verran formed the first Labor government of South Australia on 3 June.[13][14] Having begun studying law at the University of Adelaide in 1903,[1][3] Denny was articled to J.R. Anderson KC,[15] and was admitted as a solicitor in the Supreme Court of South Australia in 1908.[1]

Attorney-General

Denny was appointed Attorney-General of South Australia and Minister controlling the Northern Territory on 3 June 1910. After conducting negotiations with the Commonwealth Government, he relinquished his ministerial responsibility for the Northern Territory on 31 December 1910,[16] when its administration was transferred to the Commonwealth.[17] During his time as Attorney-General, Denny drafted and led several important legislative reforms. These included the Advances for Homes Act 1910, which allowed for 80 per cent of the value of a property to be advanced to a worker at 4.5 per cent interest over 36.5 years. In his speeches Denny highlighted that many workers were faced with high rents and poor conditions.[18] He also sponsored the Female Law Practitioners Act 1911, which enabled women to practice law in South Australia for the first time. Tall, with "long, spindly legs",[1] Denny was a favourite of cartoonists.[19]

Verran called an election in February 1912, and the ULP were defeated by the Liberal Union, although Denny was again returned first in the seat of Adelaide with 15.8 per cent of votes cast.[20] He became a member of the University of Adelaide Council in April 1912, as a representative of the Parliament.[21] In 1913, a referendum to fix the closing time of licensed premises was proposed by the ULP. Even after the governing Liberal Union agreed to the conduct of the referendum at the next state election, Denny attacked them, claiming that they had no intention of implementing the outcome of the referendum if they were re-elected.[22] Denny was returned unopposed at the March 1915 state election.[23]

World War I

Denny enlisted in the Australian Imperial Force (AIF) on 17 August 1915 at the age of 43, initially as a trooper.[1] Before departing overseas, Denny had always been an advocate of conscription.[24] He was later commissioned as a second lieutenant in the 9th Light Horse Regiment. While in Egypt, he transferred to the divisional artillery of the 5th Division, which then shipped to France, and he was promoted to lieutenant in June 1916.[1] In January 1917, despite his previous stance on conscription, Denny refused requests to endorse it, instead stating that he did not think that intervention would be compatible with his duties as a soldier. He also considered that the majority of soldiers voted against it, and deplored the split in the Labor Party that conscription had created.[25] In mid-1917 he was attached to the divisional artillery of the 1st Division.[1] On the night of 15 September 1917, he was leading a convoy carrying water to forward areas when it was hit by a heavy artillery barrage, and he was wounded. His recommendation for the Military Cross read:[26]

For conspicuous gallantry and devotion to duty whilst engaged in pack transport work near HOGGE on the night of 15 September 1917. Lieutenant DENNY showed great coolness and initiative throughout, especially when his convoy came under very heavy barrage in the vicinity of CLAPHAM JUNCTION. Although wounded himself, Lieut. DENNY personally obtained assistance for two of his men who were wounded. He then reorganised his command and succeeded in reaching his destination. Lieut. DENNY after delivering this water then went to the dressing station where he dictated a report to D.H.Q. before being evacuated.

He was invested with the Military Cross by King George V at Buckingham Palace in November 1917.[27] After recovering from his wounds, he was attached to the repatriation section of AIF Administrative Headquarters in London from January 1918. He was promoted to captain in September that year. He resigned his commission in the AIF in 1919 and published a memoir titled The Diggers,[1] the foreword of which was written by General Sir William Birdwood, who had commanded the AIF from 1915 until the end of the war.[3]

Return to Parliament

"Walking Willy" – 1912. Denny's tall frame and long legs made him a favourite of cartoonists.

Still serving overseas at the time of the 1918 state election, Denny was returned first of three in Adelaide with 30.2 per cent of the ballots cast.[28] He was repatriated to Australia via the United States on 2 August 1919,[3] returning to his seat. While in the United States, he had been regularly published in the New York Herald.[15] He married Winefride Mary Leahy, a pianist and singer,[1] on 15 January 1920 at St. Ignatius Church, Norwood. His brother, the Reverend Richard Denny, officiated at their wedding.[29] He was elected second of two in 1921 and second of three in 1924 with similar proportions of the vote.[30] He was appointed Attorney-General in the Labor government of John Gunn in April 1924, and was also Minister for Housing, and initially, Assistant Minister for Repatriation. In January 1925 he was appointed as Minister for Irrigation and Minister for Repatriation, while retaining his Attorney-General and housing portfolios.[16]

During this period he carried out several significant legislative changes.[1] In 1924, as Minister for Housing, Denny was closely associated with the Thousand Homes Scheme, which aimed to provide affordable housing, particularly for returned soldiers and their families, and lower income groups.[31] The land used for this development was the site of the Mitcham military camp at which Denny had trained before embarking for service overseas.[32] Denny's work on the Scheme resulted in a clash with former Premier Sir Henry Barwell, whom he sued for libel after Barwell made statements suggesting that Denny had made false statements to induce merchants to provide goods and services. Barwell later apologised for his comments.[33]

Another change was the transition to the use of judges as the electoral returning officer for South Australia. This was done to impose state control on a system which had effectively combined the administration of the national and state electoral rolls.[34] On 27 May 1925,[35] Denny arranged the appointment of Judge Herbert Kingsley Paine of the Insolvency Court to be appointed as Electoral Officer for the state,[36] replacing Charles Mathews, a state public servant who had held the position since 1907.[37] Denny had previously worked for Paine as a legal associate.[36]

As a returned soldier, Denny was an exception among Labor politicians at both state and federal level in the 1920s. Willing and able to speak about his personal war experiences, he was one of the few Labor politicians invited to unveil memorials. He performed this role for the Soldiers' Memorial Hall at Lameroo in 1926, where his "address was punctuated with applause". When his political enemies persistently queried the circumstances under which he was awarded the Military Cross, he published the citation in response.[38] Despite Labor's loss in the 1927 state election, Denny was returned first of three in the seat of Adelaide, with over 25 per cent of the vote.[39] At the April 1930 state election, he was returned first of three with nearly 82 per cent of the ballots cast.[40] Appointed Attorney-General in the Labor government of Lionel Hill, Denny was also Minister of Railways, and for the first six months he was also Minister of Local Government.[16] On Anzac Day 1931, acting as Premier in Hill's absence, he officiated at the unveiling of the National War Memorial at the corner of North Terrace and Kintore Avenue, Adelaide, before a crowd of about 75,000.[41] Denny is one of only a few South Australian ministers to have ever had military experience.[42]

In 1931, Denny was expelled from the Labor Party, along with Hill and the rest of the cabinet, for supporting the "Premiers' Plan", which sought to impose austerity measures due to the poor economic conditions. The cabinet formed the Parliamentary Labor Party which continued to govern the state, led by Hill and then by Robert Richards, with the support of the opposition until the 1933 state election. At the 1933 election, Denny lost his seat to a Lang Labor Party candidate.[1]

Later life

Captain W.J. Denny, MC

In September 1936, Bill's brother, the Catholic priest Reverend Denny, and his sister, Mary Catherine Denny, were involved in a vehicle accident in which Mary received fatal injuries. Reverend Denny suffered from an illness that resulted from the accident which contributed to his death in June 1941.[43] Denny wrote a further autobiographical book, A Digger at Home and Abroad, which was published in 1941. He continued to practice law until his death, despite difficulties associated with rheumatoid arthritis. He died on 2 May 1946[1] of a heart attack which developed at his home on Osmond Terrace, Norwood, after he returned from his office in Adelaide.[44] He was survived by his wife, one son and three daughters. He was accorded a state funeral, and was buried at West Terrace Cemetery.[1]

Denny was the patron of the West Adelaide Football Club for 20 years ending in 1930.[45] He enjoyed diving for crayfish under the rocks at the back of Rosetta Head near Victor Harbor on Encounter Bay, and was often accompanied by Ephriam "Brownie" Tripp, an Aboriginal man from the Point McLeay Aboriginal Mission.[46] According to his entry in the Australian Dictionary of Biography, "his preferred reading was Shakespeare and the Bible and he quoted liberally from both. His integrity, versatility and wide knowledge were unquestioned, and he was proud of the democratic legislation he had sponsored."[1]

Bibliography

• Denny, Capt. W. J. (1919). The Diggers. London: Hodder and Stoughton. OCLC 2306667.
• Denny, William Joseph (1941). A Digger at Home and Abroad. Melbourne: Popular Publications. OCLC 3836864.

Notes

1. Lincoln 1981.
2. The Adelaide Observer 1899.
3. The Sunday Times 1919.
4. Powell 2014.
5. Jaensch 2007, p. 143.
6. Jaensch 2007, p. 145.
7. Howell 2002, p. 115.
8. Jaensch 2007, p. 156.
9. Jaensch 2007, p. 167.
10. Howell 2002, p. 315.
11. Jaensch 2007, p. 176.
12. Jaensch 2007, p. 188.
13. Howell 2002, p. 312.
14. Sharman 2014.
15. The Daily Herald 1921.
16. Parliament of South Australia.
17. Walker 1999, p. 122.
18. Donovan & Painter 1990, p. 47.
19. The Daily Herald 1912.
20. Jaensch 2007, p. 198.
21. The Advertiser 1912.
22. Brooks, Gill & Weste 2008, pp. 39–40.
23. Jaensch 2007, p. 208.
24. The Chronicle 1915.
25. The Daily Herald 1917.
26. Australian War Memorial.
27. The Adelaide Observer 1917.
28. Jaensch 2007, p. 219.
29. The Advertiser 1920.
30. Jaensch 2007, pp. 232 & 235.
31. The Advertiser 1946.
32. City of Mitcham.
33. The Adelaide Observer 1926.
34. Macilwain 2007, pp. 9–10.
35. Macilwain 2007, p. 12.
36. Macilwain 2007, p. 11.
37. Macilwain 2007, p. 4.
38. Inglis & Brazier 2008, pp. 197–198.
39. Jaensch 2007, p. 238.
40. Jaensch 2007, p. 243.
41. Inglis & Brazier 2008, pp. 281–282.
42. Coulthard-Clark 1996, p. 106.
43. The Narracoorte Herald 1941.
44. The Australian Worker 1946.
45. The Register News-Pictorial 1930.
46. The Victor Harbour Times 1944.

References

Books

• Coulthard-Clark, Chris (1996). Soldiers in Politics: The Impact of the military on Australian Political Life and Institutions. St. Leonards, NSW: Allen & Unwin. ISBN 1-86448-185-4.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Donovan, P. F.; Painter, Alison (1990). Real History: The Real Estate Institute of South Australia 1919–1989. Canberra, ACT: Real Estate Institute of Australia. ISBN 978-0-646-02056-3.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Howell, Peter (2002). South Australia and Federation. Kent Town, SA: Wakefield Press. ISBN 978-1-86254-549-6.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Inglis, Ken; Brazier, Jan (2008). Sacred Places: War Memorials in the Australian Landscape. Carlton, VIC: The Miegunyah Press. ISBN 978-0-522-85479-4.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Walker, David (1999). Anxious Nation: Australia and the Rise of Asia, 1850–1939. St Lucia, QLD: University of Queensland Press. ISBN 978-0-7022-3131-5.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)

Papers

• Brooks, David; Gill, Zoe; Weste, John, eds. (2008). "South Australian Referenda, 1896–1991" (PDF). Research Paper No. 7. Adelaide, South Australia: South Australian Parliament Research Library. ISSN 0816-4282. Archived from the original (PDF) on 9 April 2015.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Jaensch, Dean (2007). History of South Australian Elections 1857–2006 House of Assembly. 1. Rose Park, South Australia: State Electoral Office. ISBN 978-0-9750486-3-4.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Macilwain, Margaret (2007). History of the State Electoral Office. Rose Park, South Australia: State Electoral Office. ISBN 978-0-9750486-2-7. Archived from the original on 24 March 2015. Retrieved 4 April 2015.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)

Newspapers

• "Captain Denny MP Married". The Advertiser. Adelaide, SA: National Library of Australia. 16 January 1920. p. 10. Retrieved 18 January 2015.
• "Capt. W.J. Denny MC". The Sunday Times. Sydney, NSW: National Library of Australia. 3 August 1919. p. 3. Retrieved 18 January 2015.
• "Councillor W. J. Denny". The Adelaide Observer. Adelaide, SA: National Library of Australia. 4 February 1899. p. 41. Retrieved 5 April 2015.
• "Death of Mr. W.J. Denny". The Advertiser. Adelaide, SA: National Library of Australia. 3 May 1946. p. 8. Retrieved 5 April 2015.
• "Death of the Rev. Father R.P. Denny". The Narracoorte Herald. Narracoorte, SA: National Library of Australia. 13 June 1941. p. 3. Retrieved 18 January 2015.
• "July". The Adelaide Observer. Adelaide, SA: National Library of Australia. 9 January 1926. p. 18. Retrieved 6 April 2015.
• "Late "Brownie" Tripp". The Victor Harbour Times. Victor Harbour, SA: National Library of Australia. 10 March 1944. p. 2. Retrieved 18 January 2015.
• "Lieutenant Denny". The Daily Herald. Adelaide, SA: National Library of Australia. 16 January 1917. p. 4. Retrieved 6 April 2015.
• "Military Honours". The Adelaide Observer. Adelaide, SA: National Library of Australia. 17 November 1917. p. 38. Retrieved 18 January 2015.
• "Mr. Denny on Camp Life". The Chronicle. Adelaide, SA: National Library of Australia. 25 September 1915. p. 36. Retrieved 6 April 2015.
• "Obituary". The Australian Worker. Sydney, NSW: National Library of Australia. 8 May 1946. p. 4. Retrieved 18 January 2015.
• "The University of Adelaide". The Advertiser. Adelaide, SA: National Library of Australia. 29 April 1912. p. 14. Retrieved 18 January 2015.
• "Walking Willy". The Daily Herald. Adelaide, SA: National Library of Australia. 21 September 1912. p. 9. Retrieved 18 January 2015.
• "West Football Sensation: Mr. Edwards Ousts Mr. Denny". The Register News-Pictorial. Adelaide, SA: National Library of Australia. 21 February 1930. p. 2. Retrieved 19 January 2015.
• "W.J. Denny". The Daily Herald. Adelaide, SA: National Library of Australia. 31 March 1921. p. 6. Retrieved 6 April 2015.

External links

• "Hon William Denny". Parliament of South Australia. State of South Australia. 2014. Retrieved 17 January 2015.
• Lincoln, Merrilyn (1981). "Denny, William Joseph (Bill) (1872–1946)". Australian Dictionary of Biography. National Centre of Biography. Retrieved 17 January 2015.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• "Mitcham Army Camp". City of Mitcham. 2015. Archived from the original on 3 April 2015. Retrieved 5 April 2015.
• Powell, Graeme (2014). "O'Loghlin, James Vincent (1852–1925)". The Biographical Dictionary of the Australian Senate. Parliament of Australia. Retrieved 5 April 2015.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• "Recommendation of Lieutenant William Joseph DENNY for the Military Cross". Australian War Memorial. Retrieved 17 January 2015.
• Sharman, Campbell (2014). "Parliament of South Australia, Assembly election 2 April 1910". Australian Politics and Elections Database. University of Western Australia. Retrieved 17 January 2015.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)

Political offices
Preceded by Hermann Homburg	Attorney-General of South Australia 1910–1912	Succeeded by Hermann Homburg
Preceded by Laurence O'Loughlin	Minister for the Northern Territory 1910	Succeeded by Ministry abolished
Preceded by Henry Barwell	Attorney-General of South Australia 1924–1927	Succeeded by Hermann Homburg
Preceded by New ministry	Minister for Housing 1924–1927	Succeeded by Ministry abolished
Preceded by Hermann Homburg	Attorney-General of South Australia 1930–1933	Succeeded by Shirley Jeffries
Preceded by George Jenkins	Minister for Railways 1930–1933	Succeeded by Malcolm McIntosh
Parliament of South Australia
Preceded by Charles Kingston	Member for West Adelaide 1900–1902	Succeeded by Electorate abolished
Preceded by New electorate	Member for Adelaide 1902–1905	Succeeded by William David Ponder Ernest Roberts James Zimri Sellar
Preceded by Lewis Cohen	Member for Adelaide 1906–1933	Succeeded by Doug Bardolph Bob Dale Tom Howard