2019 Cebu City local elections

Local elections were held in Cebu City on May 13, 2019 within the Philippine general election. Registered voters of the city elected candidates for the following elective local posts: mayor, vice mayor, district representative, and eight councilors at-large for each district. There are two legislative districts in the city.

This article is about city elections. For its provincial elections, see 2019 Cebu local elections.
2019 Cebu City mayoral election
May 13, 2019
 
Nominee Edgardo Labella Tomas Osmeña
Party PDP–Laban LDP
Running mate Michael Rama Mary Ann
De Los Santos
Popular vote 265,738 246,813
Percentage 51.40 47.74
Mayor before election

Tomas Osmeña
BOPK-Liberal Party

 Elected Mayor

Edgardo Labella
Barug-PDP-Laban

On May 14, 2019, after more than 24 hours since the polls have closed, Edgardo Labella was proclaimed as Cebu City's new mayor. He led the mayoral race with 265,738 votes, followed by Osmeña with 246,813 votes.[1]

Background
See also: 2016 Cebu City local elections and Cebu City Council

Tomas Osmeña of Bando Osmeña – Pundok Kauswagan (BOPK), who allied his group with Liberal Party, won the 2016 election with 53.40% of the votes defeating then incumbent Mayor Michael Rama of BARUG Team Rama, which was allied with United Nationalist Alliance. Meanwhile, Rama's running mate, incumbent Vice Mayor Edgardo Labella of BARUG Team Rama (BARUG), defeated Osmeña's running mate, then Councilor Nestor Archival of BOPK, in the vice mayoralty election.[2] Rama initially challenged the victory of Osmeña by holding a prayer rally with his supporters and threatened to file an electoral protest claiming that Osmeña committed electoral fraud.[3][4][5]

On May 16, 2016, seven days after the 2016 election, Rama conceded to Osmeña during the 3rd prayer rally in front of the Cebu City Hall. He reiterated however that he would pursue an electoral protest to question the results of the election.[6]

On June 28, 2016, Vice President-elect Leni Robredo administered the oath to Osmeña and 6 BOPK councilors who won in the 2016 election at Cebu City Sports Center.[7]

Despite winning as Mayor, Osmeña had to deal with a Cebu City Council that was dominated by councilors from Rama's party with 11 councilors including Cebu City Liga ng mga Barangay President Phillip Zafra who sits as an ex-officio member.[6] During the inaugural session of the 14th Sangguniang Panlungsod, BARUG councilors prevented BOPK councilors from being able to get committee chairmanships and memberships. Instead, BOPK councilors were given with executive functions by Osmeña by designating them as deputy mayors in different fields. Osmeña defined the term "deputy mayor" as someone higher compared to holding a committee chairmanship or membership in the Cebu City Council which in turn made them as his alter egos.[8]

The Cebu City Council experienced several shifts during the 14th Sangguniang Panlungsod which started when Councilor Dave Tumulak left BARUG, where he ran and won during the 2016 election, on August 24, 2016 to become an independent politician after a closed-door meeting with Councilor Margot Osmeña, wife of Mayor Osmeña. Tumulak cited the reason that he was tired of political quarrels in Cebu City and indicated his support on Osmeña's plans for Cebu City.[9] Several days after, on August 30, 2016, Councilor Nendell Hanz Abella also left BARUG to become an independent politician producing a city council with nine councilors from BARUG, six from BOPK and two from the independent bloc.[10] On March 25, 2017, Councilor Jerry Guardo, who was meted with a 3-month suspension by the DILG, left BARUG after he alleged that fellow party member Lemar Alcover, son of Councilor Pastor Alcover, Jr., was behind the push for the implementation of his suspension.[11][12][13] On the same day, Tumulak also confirmed that he was joining BOPK while Mayor Osmeña confirmed that Abella has joined them.[14] This in turn gave the majority in the Cebu City Council to BOPK with nine councilors against BARUG's eight councilors.[15]

BOPK's majority in the Cebu City Council was short-lived when Abella announced his resignation after he was appointed by President Rodrigo Duterte as commissioner in the 7th Division of the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) thus giving the two council blocs at an even 8–8 but still had Vice Mayor Edgardo Labella of BARUG to break the tie for party-line voting in the council.[16][17] The names of Renato "Junjun" Osmeña, Jr. and Inayawan Barangay Captain Lutherlee "Lotlot" Ignacio-Soon were recommended as replacements to Abella. Both Osmeña, Jr. and Ignacio-Soon ran with BARUG but failed to make it to the Cebu City Council.[18] Councilor Joel Garganera accused Mayor Osmeña of maneuvering the appointment of their party ally as replacement of Abella in the Cebu City Council by claiming that BOPK reached out to Senator Manny Pacquiao to let former vice president Jejomar Binay, head of the United Nationalist Alliance (UNA), appoint instead Rengelle Pelayo to the council.[19][20] Eventually, UNA endorsed Osmeña, Jr. to fill the position vacated by Abella.[21]

Councilor James Anthony Cuenco of BARUG was dismissed from public service on October 3, 2017 by the Office of the Ombudsman for alleged irregularities when he served as chief of staff of his father, former Cebu City South District Representative Antonio Cuenco reducing BARUG's councilors to 7.[22] Upon the appointment of Osmeña, Jr. by President Duterte, the council standing returned to 8-8.[23] Erik Miguel Espina, son of former Cebu governor and senator Rene Espina, was nominated by BARUG to replace Cuenco.[24][25] Espina's appointment gave BARUG the majority once again.[26]

During the 2018 barangay and Sangguniang Kabataan elections, 49 out of the 80 elected barangay captains and 41 out of the 80 elected SK chairpersons in Cebu City were identified with BOPK.[27][28] In the election for SK Federation President, BARUG fielded Sonia Cal of Barangay Tisa while BOPK fielded Jessica Resch of Barangay San Nicolas Proper. Resch won with 44 votes becoming the SK Federation President of Cebu City and ex-officio member of the Cebu City Council.[29] Three barangay captains were initially floated as candidates for Liga ng mga Barangay (LNB) President namely Franklyn Ong of Barangay Kasambagan, Prisca Niña Mabatid of Barangay Mabolo and incumbent LNB President & Councilor Phillip Zafra of Barangay Tisa. BOPK chose Ong as its candidate while Mabatid was chosen by BARUG after its candidate Zafra bowed out from the race. Despite the walkout of Mabatid's allies during the LNB elections, Ong still won with 51 votes. The election of Resch and Ong returned the majority of the Cebu City Council to BOPK with 10 councilors.[30][31][32]

In December 2018, BARUG was accredited as a political party by the Commission on Elections (COMELEC).[33]

Councilor Espina announced on December 14, 2018 that he will only remain in his post until January 1, 2019 after the Court of Appeals reversed the ruling of the Office of the Ombudsman finding suspended Councilor Cuenco guilty of serious dishonesty and grave misconduct and ordered his reinstatement to the Cebu City Council.[34][35] Cuenco reported back to work as councilor on January 3, 2019.[36]

BARUG had no mayoralty candidate for the 2019 elections as two of its leaders namely former Mayor Rama and Vice Mayor Labella both expressed their intentions to run as mayor.[37][38] On August 30, 2018, Rama announced his decision to run for vice mayor instead and give way to Labella.[39]

Osmeña named two of his allies, Councilors Tumulak and Mary Ann De Los Santos, as his possible candidate for vice mayor.[40] There were also reports of BOPK-allied barangay captains pushing for an Osmeña-Ong tandem but Ong declined since he wanted to focus as LNB President.[41] Osmeña officially declared De Los Santos as his candidate for vice mayor during BOPK's rally at Lahug Elementary School gym. Osmeña also announced that BOPK was no longer affiliated with the Liberal Party (LP) as they have pledged allegiance to the Laban ng Demokratikong Pilipino (LDP) party of Senator Sonny Angara.[42]

Debate

The Integrated Bar of the Philippines (IBP)-Cebu City Chapter organized the only mayoral and vice mayoral debate for Cebu City originally scheduled on April 22, 2019 at Cebu City Sports Club. Osmeña, his running-mate De Los Santos, and Labella confirmed their attendance.[43] Rama was the only one who declined to participate and tried to convince Labella to join him in ditching the debate saying that it would only put Osmeña on the spotlight.[44]

IBP-Cebu City Chapter then moved the debate schedule to May 6, 2019 to give candidates quality time to observe the Holy Week.[45] Upon Labella's request, the debate was once again postponed since he had to attend a meeting with President Duterte in Malacañang. IBP-Cebu City Chapter granted his request to move the schedule to May 10, 2019 which the other participants also agreed.[46]

Mayoralty and vice mayoralty elections

Mayor
Board of Canvassers chairman Chauncey Boholst (foreground) proclaims Vice Mayor Edgardo Labella (second from right) as mayor-elect of Cebu City. Labella garnered 265,436 votes against incumbent Mayor Tomas Osmeña's 246,399 votes.

Tomas Osmeña ran for his second term as the Mayor of Cebu City. Meanwhile, Edgardo Labella, who served as Vice Mayor of Cebu City under the administrations of Michael Rama and Osmeña, ran for his first time as Mayor and defeated Osmeña.[47]

Cebu City mayoral election
Party Candidate Votes %
PDP–Laban Edgardo Labella 265,738 51.40
LDP Tomas Osmeña (incumbent) 246,813 47.74
Independent Paulino Osmeña 2,735 0.53
Independent Junry Concepcion 1,000 0.19
Independent John Edwin Dayondon 703 0.14
Total votes 516,989 100.00
Margin of victory 18,925 3.66
PDP–Laban gain from Liberal

Vice Mayor

Mary Ann De Los Santos, who was on her second term as Cebu City Councilor for the North District and was eligible for a third and final term, opted to run for Vice Mayor. Michael Rama, who served 2 terms as Mayor and 3 terms as Vice Mayor, ran again as Vice Mayor and defeated De Los Santos.[47]

Cebu City Vice mayoral election
Party Candidate Votes %
UNA Michael Rama 261,685 51.91
LDP Mary Ann De Los Santos 235,007 46.62
Independent Federico Peredo 3,749 0.74
Independent Antonio Rosaroso 3,633 0.72
Total votes 504,074 100.00
Margin of victory 26,678 5.29
UNA hold

District representatives

1st District

Raul del Mar ran for his third and final term, and won.

2019 Philippine House of Representatives election in the 1st District of Cebu City
Party Candidate Votes %
Liberal Raul del Mar (incumbent) 135,528 61.34
PDP–Laban Richard Edison Yap 81,575 36.92
Independent Florencio Villarin 2,244 1.02
Independent Ricardo Dungog 1,609 0.73
Total votes 220,956 100.00
Margin of victory 53,953 24.42
Liberal hold

2nd District

Rodrigo Abellanosa ran for his third and final term, and won.

2019 Philippine House of Representatives election in the 2nd District of Cebu City
Party Candidate Votes %
LDP Rodrigo Abellanosa (incumbent) 163,752 61.22
PDP–Laban Jocelyn Pesquera 103,717 38.78
Total votes 267,469 100.00
Margin of victory 60,035 22.44
LDP gain from Liberal

City Council

Incumbents are expressed in italics. Number indicates the ballot number assigned for the candidates by COMELEC.[48][49]

By ticket

Laban ng Demokratikong Pilipino/Bando Osmeña – Pundok Kauswagan

Partido Demokratiko Pilipino-Lakas ng Bayan/Partido Barug

Partido Federal ng Pilipinas
Cebu City South District (2nd District)
#NameParty
1.Reynaldo Abad PFP

Independents
Independent Cebu City North District (1st District)
#NameParty
15.Eliseo Tumulak Independent
Independent Cebu City South District (2nd District)
#NameParty
3.Sherwin Luie Abella Independent
6.Alejandro Cabido Independent
14.Napoleon Navarro Independent
15.Ian Anthony Osmeña Independent

By district

1st District

Note: Incumbent councilors Alvin Arcilla and Sisinio Andales were disqualified by COMELEC after it issued a writ of execution for the certificate of finality of the earlier decision canceling Arcilla's and Andales' certificate of candidacy (COC).[50][51][52][53]

  • Key: Italicized: incumbent
City Council election at Cebu City's 1st district
Party Candidate Votes %
LDP Nestor Archival 124,466 8.55
PDP–Laban Prisca Niña Mabatid 113,908 7.83
LDP Joy Augustus Young 112,707 7.75
LDP Lea Ouano-Japson 106,218 7.30
LDP Sisinio Andales[50][51] 106,185 7.30
LDP Alvin Arcilla[52][53] 104,476 7.18
LDP Alvin Dizon 102,911 7.07
PDP–Laban Raymond Alvin Garcia 101,578 6.98
LDP Jerry Guardo 99,115 6.81
PDP–Laban Joel Garganera 96,561 6.64
PDP–Laban Noel Eleuterio Wenceslao 93,522 6.43
LDP Marlo Maamo 86,189 5.92
UNA Pastor Alcover, Jr. 84,359 5.80
PDP–Laban Ramil Ayuman 83,377 5.73
PDP–Laban Ernesto Herrera II 75,094 5.16
PDP–Laban Reynald Lauron 68,099 4.68
Independent Eliseo Tumulak 20,851 1.43
Total votes 1,455,150 100.00

2nd District
  • Key: Italicized: incumbent
City Council election at Cebu City's 2nd district
Party Candidate Votes %
PDP–Laban Donaldo Hontiveros 161,347 8.34
Nacionalista David Tumulak 156,755 8.10
PDP–Laban Eduardo Rama, Jr. 141,716 7.32
PDP–Laban Antonio Cuenco 140,139 7.24
LDP Eugenio Gabuya, Jr. 123,477 6.38
PDP–Laban Renato Osmeña, Jr. 121,884 6.30
LDP Raul Alcoseba 117,991 6.10
PDP–Laban Phillip Zafra 115,292 5.96
LDP Roberto Cabarrubias 111,090 5.74
LDP Marie Velle Abella 110,131 5.69
PDP–Laban Gerard Joe Carillo 108,247 5.59
PDP–Laban Pancrasio Esparis 103,406 5.34
LDP Michael Gacasan 94,258 4.87
PDP–Laban Erik Miguel Espina 82,327 4.25
LDP Rengelle Pelayo 78,394 4.05
LDP Kirk Bryan Repollo 71,896 3.71
Independent Ian Anthony Osmeña 42,182 2.18
Independent Sherwin Luie Abella 20,262 1.05
Independent Napoleon Navarro 13,769 0.71
PFP Reynaldo Abad 12,012 0.62
Independent Alejandro Cabido 8,782 0.45
Total votes 1,935,357 100.00

Ongoing electoral dispute

In a five-page decision promulgated on June 28, 2019, the COMELEC First Division declared Sherwin Luie Abella a nuisance candidate after he failed to answer the petition for his disqualification filed by BOPK candidate for councilor Atty. Marie Velle "Amay" Abella, who received 110,131 votes in the 2019 elections. Both candidates share the same surname and ran for an elective post for councilor in Cebu City's 2nd (South) district. The female Abella was furnished a copy of the said order on July 2, 2019.

The female Abella hoped to get the 20,262 votes cast for Sherwin giving her 130,393 votes, which would dislodge newly-elected councilor Phillip Zafra who clinched the 8th slot in the Cebu City Council for south district. She only needs 5,162 votes to unseat Zafra. Should she succeed in unseating Zafra, this will raise the number of BOPK-allied councilor from six to seven.[54]

On August 30, 2019, the COMELEC First Division ruled with finality that Sherwin has been disqualified for being a nuisance candidate. However, the election body ruled that not all of the votes garnered by Sherwin will go to the female Abella. Upon the checking of ballots, if a voter voted for both candidates, this vote will not be credited to the female Abella. Only votes cast for Sherwin will automatically be credited to the female Abella according to the decision.[55][56]

On May 26, 2020, the female Abella passed away due to illness according to Cebu City south district representative Rodrigo Abellanosa.[57]

gollark: > flat tax> regressive tax
gollark: That sounds nice, though there'll inevitably be other taxes tacked on top.
gollark: ... isn't that actually quite significant?
gollark: I don't think you can blame just *one* factor like contractors for government inefficiency.
gollark: The not-sold-as-reusable ones actually can last for a while. We have loads of them around at home for shopping.

References
  1. "Labella proclaimed Cebu City mayor | PNA". pna.gov.ph. Retrieved 2019-07-05.
  2. "Osmeña is Cebu City's mayor-elect | Rappler". rappler.com. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  3. "Team Rama, supporters hold prayer rally to protest Osmeña's victory | SunStar Cebu". sunstar.com.ph. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  4. "Rama to file petition vs Osmeña's 'unbelievable' win | SunStar Cebu". sunstar.com.ph. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  5. "Mike Rama, allies: Loss 'statistically improbable' | Rappler". rappler.com. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  6. "Rama accepts loss, packs up | SunStar Cebu". sunstar.com.ph. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  7. "Robredo swears in Osmeña as Cebu City mayor | Rappler". rappler.com. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  8. "Team Rama councilors 'lord over' committees | SunStar Cebu". sunstar.com.ph. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  9. "Tumulak bolts out of Team Rama | CDN Digital". cebudailynews.inquirer.net. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  10. "Councilor Abella bolts Team Rama | CDN Digital". cebudailynews.inquirer.net. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  11. "Guardo faces 3-month suspension | SunStar Cebu". sunstar.com.ph. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  12. "Team Rama asked: Clarify suspension | SunStar Cebu". sunstar.com.ph. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  13. "Guardo defects amid row over suspension woe | SunStar Cebu". sunstar.com.ph. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  14. "Tumulak confirms jumping from Team Rama to BOPK | SunStar Cebu". sunstar.com.ph. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  15. "BOPK gets council majority | The Freeman". philstar.com. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  16. "Abella gets NLRC post, to resign as councilor | SunStar Cebu". sunstar.com.ph. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  17. "Duterte appoints Abella to NLRC | The Freeman". philstar.com. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  18. "Losing partymates eyed to replace Abella in City Council | CDN Digital". cebudailynews.inquirer.net. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  19. "BOPK 'maneuvers' Abella's replacement | SunStar Cebu". sunstar.com.ph. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  20. "BOPK 'using Pacquiao influence' to endorse Abella replacement | The Freeman". philstar.com. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  21. "UNA endorses Junjun to replace Abella | The Freeman". philstar.com. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  22. "Cuenco dismissed | CDN Digital". cebudailynews.inquirer.net. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  23. "Duterte appoints Renato Osmeña Jr as Cebu City councilor | Rappler". rappler.com. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  24. "Son of ex-Cebu governor to replace Cuenco in City Council | The Freeman". philstar.com. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  25. "Espina takes oath as Cebu City's councilor | CDN Digital". cebudailynews.inquirer.net. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  26. "Team Rama regains slim council majority | The Freeman". philstar.com. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  27. "BOPK bets rule barangay polls | The Freeman". philstar.com. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  28. "BOPK: 49 Team Rama: 31 | CDN Digital". cebudailynews.inquirer.net. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  29. "Half-Austrian voted Cebu SK Federation president | Philippine News Agency". pna.gov.ph. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  30. "Ong is 'BOPK's pick' for ABC president | SunStar Cebu". sunstar.com.ph. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  31. "Zafra out, Mabatid in as Barug choice for ABC prexy – Labella | CDN Digital". cebudailynews.inquirer.net. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  32. "Allies of BOPK sweep ABC seats | SunStar Cebu". sunstar.com.ph. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  33. Delta Dyrecka Letigio (11 December 2018). "Barug Team Rama changes group's name to Partido Barug". CDN Digital. Retrieved 21 December 2019.
  34. "CA reinstates James Cuenco in council | CDN Digital". cebudailynews.inquirer.net. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  35. "Barug councilor resigns | SunStar Cebu". sunstar.com.ph. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  36. "Councilor Cuenco reinstated, back at work at Cebu City Council | CDN Digital". cebudailynews.inquirer.net. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  37. "Rama: I will run for mayor in 2019 | The Freeman". philstar.com. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  38. "Labella declares he's running for mayor | SunStar Cebu". sunstar.com.ph. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  39. "IT'S OFFICIAL: Rama to run as vice mayor | CDN Digital". cebudailynews.inquirer.net. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  40. "Osmeña eyes Tumulak, Delos Santos for VM | The Freeman". philstar.com. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  41. "Osmeña-Ong tandem for 2019 elections floated | SunStar Cebu". sunstar.com.ph. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  42. "Tomas picks Mary Ann as running mate for 2019 | CDN Digital". cebudailynews.inquirer.net. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  43. "3 Cebu City candidates for mayor, VM ready for debate | SunStar Cebu". sunstar.com.ph. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  44. "Rama wants Labella to ditch IBP debate | The Freeman". philstar.com. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  45. "IBP debate postponed anew | The Freeman". philstar.com. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  46. "IBP-sponsored debate for Cebu City poll bets moved to May 10 | Philippine News Agency". pna.gov.ph. Retrieved 2019-08-25.
  47. "Labella, Mike Rama proclaimed winners | Philstar.com". philstar.com. Retrieved 2019-07-05.
  48. "Official Ballot - BABAG, CEBU CITY, CEBU" (PDF). comelec.gov.ph. Commission on Elections. Retrieved 22 January 2020.
  49. "Official Ballot - ADLAON, CEBU CITY, CEBU" (PDF). comelec.gov.ph. Commission on Elections. Retrieved 22 January 2020.
  50. "Andales out, panday Joel in | Sunstar.com.ph". sunstar.com.ph. Retrieved 2019-07-09.
  51. "After Arcilla, Comelec disqualifies Andales' candidacy in May 2019 elections | CDN Digital". cebudailynews.inquirer.net. Retrieved 2019-07-09.
  52. "Final: Arcilla out, Guardo in | Philstar.com". philstar.com. Retrieved 2019-07-09.
  53. "Arcilla disqualification affirmed; Guardo to be proclaimed as Cebu City councilor | CDN Digital". cebudailynews.inquirer.net. Retrieved 2019-07-09.
  54. "Comelec favors disqualification case filed by BOPK ally vs candidate with same surname in May polls | CDN Digital". cebudailynews.inquirer.net. Retrieved 2019-09-04.
  55. "Comelec rules with finality: Sherwin Luie Abella disqualified | The Freeman". philstar.com. Retrieved 2019-09-04.
  56. "Comelec disqualifies Sherwin Abella as Cebu City Council bet, but not all his votes may go to Amay | CDN Digital". cebudailynews.inquirer.net. Retrieved 2019-09-04.
  57. "Gone too soon: Friends, supporters, allies say goodbye to Lawyer Amay Abella online". CDN Digital. May 26, 2020. Retrieved June 10, 2020.
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.