David Whitmer

David Whitmer (January 7, 1805 – January 25, 1888) was an early adherent of the Latter Day Saint movement who eventually became the most interviewed of the Three Witnesses to the Book of Mormon's golden plates.

David Whitmer
President of the Church (Church of Christ—Whitmerites)
January 28, 1876 – January 25, 1888
Successor	John C. Whitmer[1]
Reason	Reorganized
President of the Church (Church of Christ—Whitmerites)
September 7, 1847[2] – ca. 1848[3]
Reason	William McLellin asserted Whitmer's claim[4]
End reason	Separated from McLellin.
President High Council
July 3, 1834 – January, 1838
Reason	Elected by vote of the Council.
End reason	Vote of the Council.
President of Zion
July 7, 1834 – February 5, 1838
End reason	Vote of members.
Latter Day Saint Apostle
June 1829 – June, 1838[5]
End reason	Separated from the Church
Mayor of Richmond, Missouri[6]
In office
1867 – 1868
Councilman
In office
pre-1867 – pre-1867
Personal details
Born	(1805-01-07)January 7, 1805 Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, United States
Died	January 25, 1888(1888-01-25) (aged 83) Richmond, Missouri
Resting place	Richmond Cemetery 39.279°N 93.986°W / 39.279; -93.986 (Richmond Cemetery)
Baptism Date	June 3, 1829
Known For	Book of Mormon Witness Founding Church Member
Monuments	David Whitmer at Find a Grave
Notable works	A Proclamation (1881) An Address To Believers in the Book of Mormon (1887) An Address to All Believers in Christ (1887)
Spouse(s)	Julia Ann Jolly (m. January 9, 1831)
Children	David J. Whitmer (1833-1895) Julia Ann (Schweich)(1835-1914)
Signature

Early life

Whitmer was born near Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, the fourth of nine children of Peter Whitmer Sr. and Mary Musselman. Whitmer's ancestry on both sides of his family was German, and the family spoke with a German accent. His grandfather was George Witmer, who was born in Prussia, and his great-grandfather was born in Switzerland.[7] By the 1820s, the Whitmer family had moved to a farm in Fayette, in New York's Finger Lakes area. On March 12, 1825, Whitmer was elected sergeant in a newly organized militia called the Seneca Grenadiers.[8]

Role in the early Latter Day Saint movement

Whitmer and his family were among the earliest adherents to the Latter Day Saint movement. Whitmer first heard of Joseph Smith and the golden plates in 1828 when he made a business trip to Palmyra, New York, and there talked with his friend Oliver Cowdery, who believed that there "must be some truth to the matter."[9]

Book of Mormon witness

Photo of Whitmer By R. B. Rice, c. 1864

Whitmer eventually accepted the story and brought his father's family to join the Smiths in Palmyra. Whitmer was baptized in June 1829, nearly a year prior to the formal organization of the Church of Christ. During that same month, Whitmer said that he, along with Smith and Cowdery, saw an angel present the golden plates in a vision. Martin Harris reported that he experienced a similar vision with Smith later in the day. Evidence places this event near his father's home in Fayette, New York, on June 28, 1829.[10] Whitmer, Cowdery, and Harris then signed a joint statement declaring their testimony to the reality of the vision. The statement was published in the first edition of the Book of Mormon and has been included in nearly every subsequent edition.[11]

Whitmer later said that Smith had received a revelation that Hiram Page and Cowdery would sell the copyright of the Book of Mormon in Toronto. After Page and Cowdery returned from Canada empty handed, Whitmer asked Smith why they had been unsuccessful, and Smith received another revelation "through the stone" that "some revelations are of God: some revelations are of men: and some revelations are of the devil."[12]

Founding church member

When Smith organized the Church of Christ on April 6, 1830, Whitmer was one of six original members. (In his 1838 history, Smith said the church was organized at the home of Whitmer's father, Peter Whitmer Sr., in Fayette, New York, but in an 1842 letter, Smith said that the church was organized at Manchester, New York.)[13]

Church offices

Whitmer had been ordained an elder of the church by June 9, 1830, and he was ordained to the office of high priest by Cowdery on October 5, 1831. Soon after the organization of the church, Smith set apart Jackson County, Missouri, as a "gathering place" for Latter Day Saints. According to Smith, the area would be the "center place" of the City of Zion, the New Jerusalem. On July 7, 1834, Smith ordained Whitmer to be the president of the church in Missouri and his own successor, should Smith "not live to God".

By virtue of his position as President of the High Council in Zion, David Whitmer was sustained as "the president of the church in Zion," not merely as a Stake President. Since the Quorum of the Twelve and the First Quorum of the Seventy had not yet been organized, this meant that there was a short period of time—from July 3, 1834, until February 14, 1835—when the High Council in Zion stood in an administrative position next to the First Presidency. It also meant that from July 3, 1834, until December 5, 1834, at which time Oliver Cowdery was made the Associate President of the Church, David Whitmer, as President of the High Council in Zion, was the Prophet's rightful successor."[14]

Although a revelation dated June 1829 referred to Whitmer and Cowdery as receiving the same calling as the apostle Paul,[15] Smith had not yet started a church or created the office known today as apostle. Cowdery and Whitmer did have a visionary experience and like Paul, were called to preach.[16] They were also called to "search out" twelve "disciples",[17] who later were called "apostles." None of the Three Witnesses were ordained to that apostleship.[18]

Separation from the church

Advertisement for Whitmer's livery stable

Whitmer continued to live in Kirtland, Ohio, and his counselors, W. W. Phelps and John Whitmer (Whitmer's brother) presided over the church in Missouri until the summer of 1837. After the collapse of the Kirtland Safety Society bank, Smith and his counselor Sidney Rigdon, battered by creditors, moved to Far West, Missouri, to evade arrest.[19] The ensuing leadership struggle led to the dissolution of the presidency of the church in Missouri. Whitmer resigned and separated from the church.[20]

Whitmer and the other excommunicated Latter Day Saints became known as the "dissenters." Some of the dissenters owned land in Caldwell County, Missouri, which they wanted to retain.[21] The church presidency and other members looked unfavorably upon them. Rigdon preached his "Salt Sermon", which called for their expulsion from the county. A number of Latter Day Saints formed a secret society known as the Danites, whose stated goal was removal of the dissenters. Eighty prominent Mormons signed the so-called Danite Manifesto, which warned the dissenters to "depart or a more fatal calamity shall befall you." Shortly afterward, Whitmer and his family fled to nearby Richmond, Missouri.

Whitmer, other dissenters, and Mormons loyal to Smith complained to the non-Mormons in northwestern Missouri about their forcible expulsion and the loss of their properties and began to file lawsuits to recover them. Non-Mormon residents were alarmed by this and a revelation by Smith which said:

29 Wherefore, the land of Zion shall not be obtained but by purchase or by blood, otherwise there is none inheritance for you.

31 And if by blood, as you are forbidden to shed blood, lo, your enemies are upon you, and ye shall be scourged from city to city, and from synagogue to synagogue, and but few shall stand to receive an inheritance. (D&C 63:29,31)[22]

Tensions escalated, bringing about the 1838 Mormon War after which Governor Boggs issued Missouri Executive Order 44 (AKA Extermination Order) in October 1838 authorizing deadly force in the removal of Mormons. Consequently, most of the Latter Day Saints were expelled from Missouri by early 1839.[23]

In response to "persecutions" from a "secret organization" formed within the LDS church that denounced "dissenters," Whitmer used his position as one of the Three Witnesses to condemn the church: "If you believe my testimony to the Book of Mormon," wrote Whitmer, "if you believe that God spake to us three witnesses by his own voice, then I tell you that in June, 1838, God spake to me again by his own voice from the heavens and told me to 'separate myself from among the Latter Day Saints, for as they sought to do unto me, so it should be done unto them.'"[24] Whitmer interpreted God's command to include the RLDS Church, (now known as the Community Of Christ): "God commanded me by his voice to stand apart from you."[25]

Whitmer continued to live in Richmond, where he operated a successful livery stable and became a prominent and respected citizen. In 1867, he was elected to fill an unexpired term as mayor (1867–68).

President of the Church of Christ (Whitmerite)

Portrait of David Whitmer by Lewis A. Ramsey

After the death of Smith in 1844, several rival leaders claimed to be Smith's successor, including Brigham Young, Sidney Rigdon, and James J. Strang. Many of Rigdon's followers became disillusioned by 1847 and some, including apostle William E. McLellin and Benjamin Winchester, remembered Whitmer's 1834 ordination to be Smith's successor. At McLellin's urging, Whitmer exercised his claim to be Smith's successor and the Church of Christ (Whitmerite) was formed in Kirtland, Ohio. However, Whitmer never joined the body of the new church and it dissolved relatively quickly.

Around this time, fellow Book of Mormon witness Oliver Cowdery began to correspond with Whitmer. After traveling from Ohio to Kanesville (Council Bluffs), Cowdery attended the Kanesville Tabernacle meeting, called to sustain Brigham Young as the new President of the Church. Cowdery bore, with conviction, his testimony of the truthfulness of everything that had happened spiritually regarding Smith and the Book of Mormon. Meeting with Young at Winter Quarters, Nebraska, he requested readmission into the church, and he was re-baptized into the church there. Cowdery then traveled to meet with Whitmer in Richmond to persuade him to move west and rejoin the Saints in Utah Territory. Cowdery, however, succumbed to tuberculosis and died March 3, 1850.[26]

In January 1876, Whitmer resurrected the Church of Christ (Whitmerite) by ordaining his nephew, John C. Whitmer, an elder, and giving him the title "First Elder".[27]

In 1887, Whitmer published a pamphlet entitled "An Address to All Believers in Christ", in which he affirmed his testimony of the Book of Mormon, but denounced the other branches of the Latter Day Saint movement. Whitmer died in Richmond. The Whitmerite church survived until the 1960s.

Religious views

Address to Believers

Whitmer stated his religious views in three publications: "A Proclamation" published March 24, 1881, "An Address To Believers in the Book of Mormon" published April 1887, and "An Address to All Believers in Christ" also published April 1887.

Polygamy

I do not endorse polygamy or spiritual wifeism. It is a great evil, shocking to the moral sense, and the more so, because practiced in the name of religion. It is of man and not God, and is especially forbidden in the Book of Mormon itself.[28]

High Priests

As to the High Priesthood, Jesus Christ himself is the last Great High Priest, this too after the order of Melchisedec, as I understand the Holy Scriptures.[28]

Name change

I do not endorse the change of the name of the church, for as the wife takes the name of her husband so should the Church of the Lamb of God, take the name of its head, even Christ himself. It is the Church of Christ.[28]

The name change just prior to Whitmer's objection was to add "of Latter-day Saints" based on the April 26, 1838 revelation to Smith recorded in DC 115:3. Thus, the name "The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints" was formalized through incorporation in 1851, thirty years before Whitmer published his objection.

The most interviewed Book of Mormon witness

Photo of David Whitmer, Ca 1880s

Because Cowdery died in 1850 at age 43 and Martin Harris died in 1875 at age 92, Whitmer was the only survivor of the Three Witnesses for 13 years. At Richmond, Missouri, he sometimes received several inquirers daily asking about his connection to the Book of Mormon, including missionaries of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS Church) who were traveling from Utah Territory to the eastern United States and Europe. Despite his hostility toward the LDS Church, Whitmer always stood by his claim that he had actually seen the golden plates.[29]

Some of the 71 recorded interviews he gave between 1838 and 1888 contained different details than others.[30] Recounting the vision to Orson Pratt in 1878, Whitmer claimed to have seen not only the golden plates but the "Brass Plates, the plates containing the record of the wickedness of the people of the world ... the sword of Laban, the Directors (i.e. the ball which Lehi had) and the Interpreters. I saw them just as plain as I see this bed".[31]

In 1880, John Murphy interviewed Whitmer and later published an account suggesting that perhaps Whitmer's experience was a "delusion or perhaps a cunning scheme." Murphy's account said that Whitmer had not been able to describe the appearance of an angel and had likened Whitmer's experience to the "impressions as the quaker [receives] when the spirit moves, or as a good Methodist in giving a happy experience."[32] Whitmer responded by publishing "A Proclamation", reaffirming his testimony and saying,

"It having been represented by one John Murphy, of Polo, Caldwell County, Mo., that I, in a conversation with him last summer, denied my testimony as one of the three witnesses to the BOOK OF MORMON. To the end, therefore, that he may understand me now, if he did not then; and that the world may know the truth, I wish now, standing as it were, in the very sunset of life, and in the fear of God, once for all to make this public statement: That I have never at any time denied that testimony or any part thereof, which has so long since been published with that Book, as one of the three witnesses. Those who know me best, well know that I have always adhered to that testimony. And that no man may be misled or doubt my present views in regard to the same, I do again affirm the truth of all of my statements, as then made and published. He that hath an ear to hear, let him hear; it was no delusion!"[33]

To the "Proclamation" Whitmer attached an affidavit attesting to his honesty and standing in the community.[34] Whitmer ordered that his testimony to the Book of Mormon be placed on his tombstone.[35]

In response to a question by Anthony Metcalf, Whitmer attempted to clarify the "spiritual" versus "natural" viewing of the plates:

In regards to my testimony to the visitation of the angel, who declared to us Three Witnesses that the Book of Mormon is true, I have this to say: Of course we were in the spirit when we had the view, for no man can behold the face of an angel, except in a spiritual view, but we were in the body also, and everything was as natural to us, as it is at any time. Martin Harris, you say, called it 'being in vision.' We read in the Scriptures, Cornelius saw, in a vision, an angel of God. Daniel saw an angel in a vision, also in other places it states they saw an angel in the spirit. A bright light enveloped us where we were, that filled at noon day, and there in a vision, or in the spirit, we saw and heard just as it is stated in my testimony in the Book of Mormon. I am now passed eighty-two years old, and I have a brother, J. J. Snyder, to do my writing for me, at my dictation. [Signed] David Whitmer.[36]

Interviews of David Whitmer

The following table shows which interviews were cited in the following publications:

• Kenneth W. Godfrey, "David Whitmer and the Shaping of Latter-day Saint History," in The Disciple As Witness: Essays on Latter-Day Saint History and Doctrine in Honor of Richard Lloyd Anderson, edited by Richard Lloyd Anderson, Stephen D. Ricks, Donald W. Parry, and Andrew H. Hedges, Provo: FARMS, 2000, pp. 223–56.
• Lyndon W. Cook, David Whitmer Interviews, Grandin Book, 1991.
• Dan Vogel, Early Mormon Documents, Vol. V, Signature Books, 2003.
• John W. Welch and Erick B. Carlson eds., Opening the Heavens, Accounts of Divine Manifestations 1820–1844, Deseret Book, 2005. Twenty-one interviews were cited, the "x-#" refers to the document number in this volume only.
• Richard Lloyd Anderson, Investigating the Book of Mormon Witnesses, Deseret Book, 1981.

Interviewer	Interview Date	Name of Publication	Publication Date	Godfrey	Cook	Vogel	Welch	Anderson
Eber D. Howe	1834	Mormonism Unvailed	1834			x
Lumon Andros Shurtliff	21 August 1836	Autobriography, LDS Church Archives	1852–1876			x
Thomas B. Marsh	1838	Deseret News	24 March 1858	x		x
David H. Cannon	1861	Beatrice Cannon Evans and Janath Russell Cannon, eds. Cannon Family Historical Treasury, 250.	1967			x
David H. Cannon	1861	A. Karl Larson and Katherine Miles Larson, eds., Diary of Charles Lowell Walker, 1773—74, (11 June 1894).	1980	x	x	x
Davis H. Bays	13 September 1869	Saints' Herald	1 November 1869	x		x
Henry Moon	9 January 1872	Deseret Evening News	10 April 1872	x		x		x
Eri B. Mullin	1874	Saints' Herald 27, 76	1 March 1880	x		x	x-83
James Caffall	August 1874	Saints' Herald	15 September 1874	x		x
Mark H. Forscutt	2 March 1875	Scrapbook, 16-17, reproduced in Inez Smith Davis The Story of the Church. Independence, Missouri: Herald House, 75	1964			x
Chicago Times reporter	August 1875	Chicago Times	7 August 1875	x		x		x
Dr. James N. Seymour	8 December 1875	Saints' Herald 26, 223 (Letter from Whitmer)	1879		x	x		x
Thomas Wood Smith	January 1876	Fall River Herald (Massachusetts)	28 March 1879			x	x-80
Thomas Wood Smith	January 1876	Saints' Herald 27, 13	1 January 1880	x		x	x-82
Edward Stevenson	22—23 December 1877	Diary of Edward Stevenson, LDS Church Archives		x		x		x
Edward Stevenson	22—23 December 1877	Journal History, LDS Church Archives		x		x
Edward Stevenson	22—23 December 1877	Salt Lake Herald	2 February 1878	x		x
Edward Stevenson	22—23 December 1877	Reminiscences of Joseph, the Prophet and the Coming Forth of the Book of Mormon	1893			x
Joseph Smith III	2 February 1878	Community of Christ Library Archives (letter)			x	x
P. Wilhelm Poulson	13 August 1878	Deseret Evening News	16 August 1878	x		x	x-79	x
Orson Pratt, Joseph F. Smith	7—8 September 1878	Joseph F. Smith Diary, LDS Church Archives		x				x
Orson Pratt, Joseph F. Smith	7—8 September 1878	Deseret News	16 November 1878	x
Orson Pratt, Joseph F. Smith	7—8 September 1878	Orson Pratt correspondence, LDS Church Archives		x	x	x
Orson Pratt, Joseph F. Smith	7—8 September 1878	Andrew Jenson, Historical Record 6, 1886, 210.	1886				x-78
Orson Pratt, Joseph F. Smith	7—8 September 1878	Joseph F. Smith Collection, LDS Church Archives		x
Orson Pratt, Joseph F. Smith	7—8 September 1878	Brian H. Stuy. Collected Discourses, Burbank: B.H.S. Pub. vol 2	1987–92			x
William E. McLellin	June 1879	William E. McLellin Collection, New York Public Library. (Letter to James T. Cobb)	14 August 1880		x	x
J. L. Traughber Jr.	October 1879	Saints' Herald 26, 341	15 November 1879	x			x-81
J. L. Traughber	October 1879	T. A. Schroeder Papers, New York Public Library. (Letter to Theodore A. Schroeder)	21 August 1901
Heman C. Smith	5 December 1876	Community of Christ Library Archives (Letter)			x	x
John Murphy	June 1880	Hamiltonian	21 January 1881			x		x
John Murphy	June 1880	Kingston Times	16 December 1887			x
E. S. Gilbert	1 August 1880	New Light on Mormonism by Ellen E. Dickson, New York: Funk and Wagnalls.	1885			x
David Whitmer	19 March 1881	"Proclamation" - Leaflet	19 March 1881			x		x
David Whitmer	19 March 1881	"Proclamation" in Richmond Conservator	24 March 1881			x		x
David Whitmer	19 March 1881	"Proclamation" in Hamiltonian	8 April 1881			x
David Whitmer	19 March 1881	"Proclamation" in Saints' Herald	1 June 1881			x
David Whitmer	19 March 1881	"Proclamation" in "Address to All Believers in Christ"	1 April 1887			x
Jesse R. Badham	20 March 1881	Diary of Jesse R. Badham, RLDS Church Library—Archives		x	x	x
Jesse R. Badham	20 March 1881	Saints' Herald	1 April 1881	x	x	x
Kansas City Daily Journal reporter	1 June 1881	Kansas City Daily Journal	5 June 1881	x			x-84	x
David Whitmer's corrections to Kansas City Daily Journal	(13 June 1881)	Kansas City Daily Journal	19 June 1881	x			x-85
Chicago Times correspondent	14 October 1881	Chicago Times	17 October 1881	x			x-86	x
Edwin Gordon Woolley	1882	Diary of Edwin Gordon Woolley, BYU Library—Archives		x	x	x
Edwin Gordon Woolley	1882	E. G. Woolley Biography, BYU Library—Archives		x
William H. Kelley, G. A. Blakeslee	15 January 1882	Saints' Herald 29, 68	1 March 1882	x			x-87	x
Joseph Smith III et al.	4 April 1882	Saints' Herald	1 May 1882	x	x	x
John Morgan, Matthias F. Cowley	13 April 1882	John Morgan Diary, LDS Church Archives		x	x	x
John Morgan, Matthias F. Cowley	13 April 1882	Arthur M. Richardson and Nicholas G. Morgan.The Life and Ministry of John Morgan. 323	1965	x	x	x
John Morgan, Matthias F. Cowley	13 April 1882	Diary of Matthias F. Cowley, LDS Church Archives		x	x	x
J. W. Chatburn	No date	Saints' Herald	15 June 1882	x
S. T. Mouch	18 November 1882	Whitmer Papers, Community of Christ Library Archives (Letter from Whitmer).			x	x
Moroni Pratt, S. R. Marks, et al.	30 June 1883	Bear Lake Democrat	3 & 14 July 1883	x	x	x
Moroni Pratt, S. R. Marks, et al.	30 June 1883	Deseret News	19 & 21 July 1883	x	x	x
James H. Hart	21 August 1883	James H. Hart Notebook (see Mormon in Motion: The Life and Journals of James H. Hart, 1825—1906 [Windsor Books, 1976], 216)		x
James H. Hart	23 August 1883	Deseret Evening News	4 September 1883	x				x
James H. Hart	21 August 1883	Bear Lake Democrat	15 September 1883	x
James H. Hart	21 August 1883	Contributor 5, 9–10	October 1883	x		x
James H. Hart	21 August 1883	"An Interview with David Whitmer in August, 1883" (poem)	1883			x
George Q. Cannon	27 February 1884	George Q. Cannon Journal, LDS Church Archives		x			x-90
George Q. Cannon	27 February 1884	Instructor 80, 520	1945					x
James H. Hart	10 March 1884	Deseret Evening News	25 March 1884	x			x-89
James H. Hart	10 March 1884	Deseret Evening News	10 April 1884	x
James H. Hart	10 March 1884	Bear Lake Democrat	28 March 1884	x
E. C. Briggs, Rudolph Etzenhouser	25 April 1884	Saints' Herald 31, 396–97	21 June 1884	x			x-88
J. Frank McDowell	8 May 1884	Saints' Herald	22 July and 9 August 1884	x	x	x
Heman C. Smith, William H. Kelley	19 June 1884	Saints' Herald 31, 442	12 July 1884	x	x	x		x
Heman C. Smith, William H. Kelley	19 June 1884	Joseph Smith III, Heman C. Smith, and F. Henry Edwards. The History of the Reorganized Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. Independence, Missouri: Herald House, 4:448–49	1968		x	x
Joseph Smith III et al.	mid-July 1884	Saints' Herald	28 January 1936	x
St. Louis Republican	mid-July 1884	St. Louis Republican	16 July 1884	x			x-91
Unknown	July 1884	"The True Book of Mormon" unknown newspaper clipping in William H. Samson Scrapbook, 18:76–77, Rochester Public Library.	July 1884			x
B. H. Roberts	1884	Contributor 9, 169	March 1888			x
B. H. Roberts	1884	Millennial Star 50, 120	20 February 1888			x
B. H. Roberts	1884	Conference Report, 126	October 1926			x
Editor	9 January 1885	Richmond Conservator (statement)	9 January 1885		x	x
Zenas H. Gurley	14 January 1885	Gurley Collection, LDS Church Archives	January 21, 1885	x			x-92
Zenas H. Gurley	14 January 1885	Autumn Leaves 5, 452	1892					x
E. C. Brand	8 February 1885	Kingston Times (Missouri)	23 December 1887			x
Franklin D. Richards and Charles C. Richards	25 May 1885	Charles C. Richards, "An Address Delivered by Charles C. Richards at the Sacrament Meeting Held in SLC, UT, Sunday Evening, April 20, 1947," signed. LDS Church Archives.	1947			x
James H. Moyle	28 June 1885	James H. Moyle Journal, LDS Church Archives		x				x
James H. Moyle	28 June 1885	24 November 1928 reminiscence		x
James H. Moyle	28 June 1885	Conference Report	April 1930	x
James H. Moyle	28 June 1885	Deseret News [Church Section]	2 August 1944	x
James H. Moyle	28 June 1885	Instructor	1945	x				x
Chicago Tribune correspondent	15 December 1885	Chicago Tribune	17 December 1885	x			x-93	x
Edward Stevenson	9 February 1886	Diary of Edward Stevenson, LDS Church Archives		x
Edward Stevenson	9 February 1886	Millennial Star	8 March 1886	x
Edward Stevenson	9 February 1886	Utah Journal	10 March 1886	x
Nathan Tanner, Jr.	13 April 1886	Nathan Tanner, Jr. Journal, LDS Church Archives		x				x
Nathan Tanner, Jr.	13 April 1886	Tanner reminiscence, LDS Church Archives		x
Nathan Tanner, Jr.	May 1886	Nathan A. Tanner, Jr. to Nathan A. Tanner, LDS Church Archives	17 February 1909				x-98
Omaha Herald correspondent	10 October 1886	Omaha Herald	17 October 1886	x			x-94	x
Omaha Herald correspondent	10 October 1886	Chicago Inter-Ocean	17 October 1886				x-94
Omaha Herald correspondent	10 October 1886	Saints' Herald, 33:706	13 November 1886				x-94
D. C. Dunbar	10 October 1886	Dunbar correspondence, LDS Church Archives		x
M. J. Hubble	13 November 1886	Missouri State Historical Society, Columbia, Missouri		x			x-95
Edward Stevenson	2 January 1887	Diary of Edward Stevenson, LDS Church Archives		x
Edward Stevenson	2 January 1887	Juvenile Instructor	15 February 1887	x
Edward Stevenson	2 January 1887	Millennial Star	14 February 1887	x
David Whitmer		"An Address to All Believers in Christ: By a Witness to the Divine Authenticity of the Book of Mormon", Richmond, Missouri	1887			x	x-96	x
Edward Stevenson	2 January 1887	Juvenile Instructor	1 January 1889	x
Sister Gates	11 February 1887	Whitmer Papers, Community of Christ Library Archives. (Letter from Whitmer)			x	x
Robert Nelson	15 February 1887	Whitmer Papers, Community of Christ Library Archives. (Letter from Whitmer)			x	x
Anthony Metcalf	March 1887	Ten Years Before the Mast, 74	1888 Malad, Idaho					x
Angus M. Cannon	7 January 1888	Angus M. Cannon Diary, LDS Church Archives		x	x	x
Angus M. Cannon	7 January 1888	Deseret Evening News	13 February 1888	x	x	x		x
Chicago Tribune correspondent	23 January 1888	Chicago Tribune	24 January 1888	x
Unidentified Chicago man	[No date]	Chicago Times	26 January 1888	x	x	x		x
Richmond Conservator report	26 January 1888	Richmond Conservator	26 January 1888	x	x	x		x
Richmond Democrat report	January 1888	Richmond Democrat (Borrowed from Omaha Herald. Article written by Joe Johnson)	26 January 1888	x				x
Richmond Democrat report	January 1888	Richmond Democrat (re-run)	2 February 1888				x-97	x
John C. Whitmer	September 1888	Deseret News	13 & 17 September 1888			x
John C. Whitmer	September 1888	Saints' Herald (Reprint of Deseret News)	13 October 1888			x
George W. Schweich	1899	Woodbridge I. Riley. The Founder of Mormonism. New York: Dodd, Mead and Co., 1903, 219–20. (Letter from George W. Schweich to I. Woodbridge)	22 September 1899		x	x
Philander Page	January 25, 1888	George Edward Anderson Diary, Daughters of Utah Pioneers Museum, 27–28.	1907			x
John J. Snyder	1886–87	W. H. Cadman. A History of the Church of Jesus Christ, Organized at Green Oak, Pennsylvania, U.S.A., in the Year 1862. Monongola, Pennsylvania: The Church of Jesus Christ, 1945, 24–25.	10 October 1928			x

Notes

1. There was no formal beginning. John C. Whitmer was baptized at the age of 44 on September 15, 1875, then ordained an Elder January 28, 1876 and commissioned to "go forth and preach the Gospel...organize a new church...was to be the first Elder." (Andrew Jenson, Edward Stevenson, and Joseph S. Black, "Historical Landmarks," Deseret News, 37, September 26, 1888, p. 579.)
2. On this day David was "re-ordained" (according to his previous ordination by Joseph Smith in July 8, 1834) by William McLellin, Hiram Page, Jacob Whitmer, & John Whitmer. This entailed "holy priesthood," "high priests," and a "presidency" framework. See William E. McLellin, ed., Ensign of Liberty, vol. 1, August 1849.
3. McLellin was based in Kirtland. Whitmer however never traveled to Kirtland or assisted McLellin to grow his branch. McClellin did have a publication called Ensign of Liberty which the Whitmer branch refused after June 1848.
4. Whitmer did not seek the position but acknowledged that he was in fact ordained by Joseph Smith to succeed him. Whitmer was ordained a "prophet, seer, and revelator." (Newell G. Bringhurst and John C. Hamer eds., Scattering of the Saints, Schism within Mormonism, John Whitmer Books, 2007, p. 59.)
5. For the date Whitmer said he left the Mormons: An Address to All Believers in Christ, p. 8.
6. The North-West Conservator, Richmond, MO, June 22, 1867.
7. Dan Vogel, Early Mormon Documents, Vol. V, 2003, p. 9.
8. Seneca Farmer, March 23, 1825.
9. David Whitmer interview with Kansas City Journal, June 1, 1881, in Early Mormon Documents 5:74.
10. Anderson, Gale Yancey (Spring 2012), "Eleven Witnesses Behold the Plates", Journal of Mormon History, 38 (2): 146–52
11. Richard Lyman Bushman, Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2005), pp. 77-79.
12. "Joseph looked into the hat in which he placed the stone, and received a revelation that some of the brethren should go to Toronto, Canada, and that they would sell the copyright of the Book of Mormon. Hiram Page and Oliver Cowdery went to Toronto on this mission, but they failed entirely to sell the copyright, returning without any money. Joseph was at my father's house when they returned. I was there also, and am an eye witness to these facts. Jacob Whitmer and John Whitmer were also present when Hiram Page and Oliver Cowdery returned from Canada. Well, we were all in great trouble; and we asked Joseph how it was that he had received a revelation from the Lord for some brethren to go to Toronto and sell the copyright, and the brethren had utterly failed in their undertaking. Joseph did not know how it was, so he enquired of the Lord about it, and behold the following revelation came through the stone: 'Some revelations are of God: some revelations are of men: and some revelations are of the devil.' So we see that the revelation to go to Toronto and sell the copyright was not of God, but was of the devil or of the heart of man." David Whitmer, An Address to All Believers in Christ, in EMD 5: 198.
13. For evidence regarding these contradictory statements, see Richard Lyman Bushman, Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2005), pp. 109, 586, n.2.
14. Hyrum L. Andrus, Doctrines of the Kingdom, Bookcraft, 1973, p. 195.
15. Doctrine and Covenants, Covenant 18:37
16. Galatians 1:1,12,16
17. Doctrine and Covenants, Covenant 18:27,37
18. The Three Witnesses did not ordain the apostles: "The First Presidency anointed only one apostle, the Twelve's president Thomas B. Marsh. Marsh then anointed the other apostles, and Smith spoke prophetic words to each one but did not anoint them." (D. Michael Quinn, The Mormon Hierarchy: Origins of Power, p. 60; see also Joseph Smith diary, 21 January 1836, in History of the Church, 2:379–83; Faulring, An American Prophet's Record, 118–21, in Jessee, Personal Writings of Joseph Smith, 145–46, and in Jessee, Papers of Joseph Smith, 2:156–58.)
19. Richard S. Van Wagoner, Sidney Rigdon: A Portrait of Religious Excess, Signature Books, 1994, p. 193.
20. David Whitmer separated from the church and was never excommunicated. See Far West Record, pp. 123–25; Ebenezer Robinson, "Items of Personal History of the Editor," The Return, (Davis City, Iowa: Church of Christ), Vol. 1, No. 9, September 1889, pp. 134–35.
21. David Whitmer did not own land. See Saints' Herald, vol. 34, No. 7, February 5, 1887.
22. Joseph Smith, History of the Church, vol. 1, chapter 27, pp. 374–76; Richard L. Bushman, "Mormon Persecutions in Missouri, 1833," BYU Studies, vol. 3, 1960–1961, no. 1, Autumn 1960; David Whitmer, An Address to all Believers in Christ, 1887, p. 55.
23. Bushman, 328–55.
24. (http://latterdaytruth.org/pdf/100023.pdf%7C"All Believers In Christ", by D. Whitmer, 1887)
25. (Metcalfe, 1993, p. 176)
26. David Whitmer, An Address to All Believers in the Book of Mormon, 1887, p. 1; Scott H. Faulring, "The Return of Oliver Cowdery," Archived 2011-10-21 at the Wayback Machine Maxwell Institute, Provo, Utah.
27. Deseret News; The Return, vol. 3, no. 3, October 1892, pp. 3–5; George Sweich, "David Whitmer and the Church of Christ," Magazine of Western History, New York, vol. 14, May 1891—October 1891, p 520.
28. A Proclamation
29. The earliest known signed testimony of Whitmer was recorded in a letter to Mark H. Forscutt of March 2, 1875: "Dear Sir: My testimony to the world is written concerning the Book of Mormon. And it is the same that I gave at first, and it is the same as shall stand to my latest hour in life, linger with me in death and shine as gospel truth beyond the limits of life, among the tribunals of heaven. And the nations of the earth will have known to[o] late the divine truth written on the pages of that book is the only sorrow of this servant of the Almighty Father." (Davis, 1981, p. 75)
30. Lyndon W. Cook ed., David Whitmer Interviews, Grandin Book, 1991, p. xxvi.
31. David Whitmer interview with Orson Pratt, September 1878, in EMD, 5: 43.
32. Hamilton Newspaper, January 21, 1881; Kingston (Missouri) Times, December 16, 1887; "David Whitmer Interview with John Murphy, June 1880," Dan Vogel, ed., Early Morning Documents Signature Books, 2003, vol. 5, p. 63.
33. Richmond (Missouri) Conservator, March 24, 1881; Hamiltonian (Missouri) Newspaper, April 8, 1881; Saints' Herald, June 1, 1881, vol. 28, p. 168; David Whitmer, An Address to All Believers in Christ, Richmond, 1887, pp. 8-10; LDS Church Archives; Ebbie Richardson, "David Whitmer," M.A. Thesis, BYU, 1952, pp. 178–80; "David Whitmer: The Independent Missouri Businessman," Improvement Era, vol. 72, April 1969, p. 79; Lyndon W. Cook, pp. 79–80; Dan Vogel, ed., Early Morning Documents Signature Books, 2003, 5:68–71.
34. Dan Vogel, ed., Early Morning Documents Signature Books, 2003, 5:63. Excerpt – Early Mormon Documents, Vol. 5 Archived 2012-07-13 at Archive.today
35. David Whitmer at Find a Grave
36. Letter of David Whitmer to Anthony Metcalf, March 1887, cit. Anthony Metcalf, Ten Years Before the Mast (Malad, Idaho, 1888) p. 74; cited in Richard Lloyd Anderson, Investigating the Book of Mormon Witnesses (Salt Lake City, Utah: Deseret Book, 1981) p. 86. ISBN 0877478465.

References

• Cook, Lyndon W. (ed) (1991). David Whitmer Interviews, A Restoration Witness. Orem, Utah: Grandin Book. ISBN 978-0-910523-38-7.CS1 maint: extra text: authors list (link)

• Davis, Inez Smith (1981). The Story of the Church (10th ed.). Independence, Missouri: Herald House. p. 75.
• Metcalfe, Brent Lee (1993). "Apologetic and Critical Studies Assumptions about Book of Mormon Historicity". Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought. 26 (3): 153–184.
• Vogel, Dan (ed) (1996–2003). Early Mormon Documents. (Vols. 1-5). Salt Lake City, Utah: Signature Books. ISBN 1-56085-072-8.CS1 maint: extra text: authors list (link)

External links

• Media related to David Whitmer at Wikimedia Commons
• Quotations related to David Whitmer at Wikiquote
• David Whitmer at Find a Grave