R (Venables and Thompson) v Home Secretary

R (Venables and Thompson) v Home Secretary [1997] UKHL 25 is a UK constitutional law case, concerning the exercise of independent judgement in judicial review.

R (Venables and Thompson) v Home Secretary
CourtUK Supreme Court
Citation(s)[1997] UKHL 25, [1998] AC 407
Keywords
Health

Facts

Venables and Thompson claimed that the Home Secretary had unlawfully decided not to release them from prison, after they were convicted of murder as children. The Home Secretary took into account public petitions demanding the murderer be imprisoned for life. He refused to take account of their progress and development during detention. He increased the ‘tariff period’ from 10 to 15 years to delay release, and said they should be dealt with on the same basis as adult offenders, where mandatory life sentences were imposed.

Judgment

The House of Lords held by 3 to 2, that the Home Secretary acted unlawfully by taking into account irrelevant considerations (a public petition) and failing to take into account relevant considerations (progress in detention).

Lord Steyn said the following of the Home Secretary.

His legal premise was wrong: the two sentences are different. A sentence of detention during Her Majesty’s pleasure requires the Home Secretary to decide from time to time ... whether detention is still justified. The Home Secretary misunderstood his duty. This misdirection by itself renders his decision unlawful.

gollark: Or, well, sort of does but not really.
gollark: But the company doesn't exist now.
gollark: I had a Wileyfox Swift before, which was very niche but had a removable battery and ran LineageOS and whatnot.
gollark: It's very annoying that I have to put in so much effort with custom ROMs and whatnot to make Android non-spying and actually usable. I suppose I would *mostly* be okay with just root access if I could still have microG work somehow.
gollark: There are something like 60 listed with all that except good custom ROM support, which is annoying.

See also

Notes

    References
      This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.