O. A. Cargill

Otto Arthur Cargill (February 26, 1885[1] – March 20, 1973[2][3]) was a prominent lawyer, author, politician and buffalo rancher during Oklahoma's early days. He was mayor of Oklahoma City April 4, 1923 - April 12, 1927.[4]

O. A. Cargill
20th Mayor of Oklahoma City
In office April 4, 1923 – April 12, 1927
Preceded by	Mike Donnelly (acting)
Succeeded by	Walter C. Dean
Personal details
Born	(1885-02-26)February 26, 1885 Viola, Arkansas
Died	March 20, 1973(1973-03-20) (aged 88)

Early life

Otto "O.A." Cargill was born in Viola, Arkansas, on February 26, 1885. His father was a physician and Baptist minister. He was educated at Mountain Home College in Mountain Home, Arkansas. He married Delia Arnold on May 2, 1905, in Cushing, Oklahoma,[1] and they settled in Oklahoma City in 1912.[4] During his early days in Oklahoma and Indian territories he was a Deputy U.S. Marshal under Bill Depew.[5] Cargill worked as a streetcar conductor, became an Oklahoma City police officer,[4] and was admitted to the Oklahoma Bar Association in 1916. He was county attorney of Oklahoma County 1919–1920.[1]

Political career

Cargill was elected mayor in 1923, defeating Allen Street.[4] Assuming office when the city was in a bad financial condition, Cargill found his reform efforts frustrated, particularly by supporters of the former mayor Jack Walton who had remained in office after the election.[2] In 1926, the electorate voted to replace Oklahoma City's existing city commission government with a mayor–council form of government.[4] He ran unsuccessfully for governor in 1926[6] against Henry S Johnson who was supported by the Ku Klux Klan. Cargill, being bitterly opposed to the Klan, came in third.

Role in the murder of Claude Chandler

Cargill's gubernatorial campaign claim that he opposed the Ku Klux Klan starkly contradicted at least one dark chapter in the life of a man who admitted to being a former member of the KKK.[7] Cargill, as District Attorney of Oklahoma County, ordered a raid on the property of a suspected moonshine bootlegger, Charles Chandler of Logan County, which took place on the morning of August 29, 1920. "Crush it", he had instructed, though the property was outside his jurisdiction.[8]

What occurred at the scene of the raid is not clear. Evidence is clear, however, that a gunfight developed and Chandler was killed along with two law enforcement officers. One officer was injured as was Chandler's son, Claude Chandler, and the one remaining officer at the scene arrested Claude. Logan County Prosecutor A. I. Dinwiddie determined after a cursory investigation that there was sufficient evidence to charge Claude Chandler with homicide and try him in court. Dinwiddie determined to initiate a formal inquest and investigation in conjunction with Logan County officers. However, before Logan Country officers could transport him to the Logan County Jail, Cargill arrived on the scene with a group of heavily armed men and took custody of Chandler and crime scene evidence. Cargill indicated that he was taking Chandler to Oklahoma City in order that he be prosecuted in federal court, which he later admitted was a bluff. Dinwiddie's insistence that Logan County officials had jurisdiction, and that Oklahoma county and federal statute had no legal mechanism by which to prosecute Chandler (claims which were confirmed by the Federal District Attorney Herbert Peck), served only to anger Cargill, who would not be deterred.[9]

Cargill voiced concern that "a Logan County jury made up largely of Negroes would have turned [him] loose". Cargill ordered that Chandler be taken to the Oklahoma County Jail. There, jail personnel were substantially and anomalously weakened, although The Daily Oklahoman reported at the time that threats to lynch Claude Chandler "were legion".[8] In recounting his role in the episode, Cargill said, "The officers of Logan county were foolish to be bluffed by Oklahoma county officers. The government did not want Chandler and he could not be prosecuted in Oklahoma county. I went to the scene of the murder and found [deputy] Adrean and [agent] Weiss lying in bloody dirt while Logan county officers stood and talked about holding an inquest. I did not fool; I just took things in my own hands, ordered the bodies taken to Oklahoma City, the Chandler boy to be brought to our jail. I guess those Logan officers are still standing gaping at the road talking inquest."[10]

The following night, three men easily gained access to the jail, which was under the protection of one guard, and a mob abducted and brutally murdered Claude Chandler. In subsequent grand jury hearings, 13 inmates identified Deputy Luther Bishop as the leader of the mob, one a former deputy and another who had known Bishop for over a decade. Cargill previously hired Bishop to work in the D.A.'s office. The two were very close, Cargill's life having years before been saved by Bishop. Though Bishop refused to testify to the grand jury, a man named Ned Looney testified that he had seen Bishop at a filling station at the time of the abduction of Claude Chandler. Loony was appointed Deputy District Attorney by Cargill two days after the lynching. Jail logs indicate that three inmates, the only three who testified to the grand jury that it was not Bishop who had abducted Chandler, were released from jail by assistant D.A. Looney. A photo was taken of Claude Chandler, dead and hanging from a tree, while a man who appears to be Bishop rests his arm on one of Chandler's feet. The following caption is written on the photo: "I send you this beautiful photograph this is one who died by the unwritten law yesterday. -Ned"[8]

Later career and perjury conviction

Cargill practiced law for many years.[11] Late in his career, he became embroiled in a wide-ranging bribery scandal also involving several justices of the Oklahoma Supreme Court.[12] In 1965, he was convicted on three counts of perjury.[6] In 1967, the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit set aside two of the counts, but affirmed his conviction on the third.[13]

Family

He had four children: O.A. "Buck" Cargill Jr., Keet Cargill, Oklahoma Cargill Hood and Otha Cargill Westcott.[1] He was the grandfather of the country music star Henson Cargill,[3] O.A. "Little Buck" Cargill Jr., and Carol Cargill.

References

1. Oklahoma, a history of the state and its people (Lewis Historical Publishing Co., 1929), vol. 3, p. 29.
2. "O. A. Cargill." Oklahoma City Archives. Undated. Accessed February 6, 2018.
3. "O.A. "Buck' Cargill Jr., Noted Attorney, Dies", The Oklahoman, November 29, 1988.
4. Otto A. Cargill biography Archived 2016-01-19 at the Wayback Machine, City of Oklahoma City (accessed April 22, 2014).
5. O. A Cargill, My first 80 years (hardcover, 1965)
6. "Ex-Mayor Cargill is Guilty in Oklahoma Perjury Trial", Associated Press in The Spokesman-Review, June 17, 1965.
7. Owens, Ron (1995). Oklahoma Justice: The Oklahoma City Police, a Century of Gunfighters, Gangsters and Terrorists. Turner Publishing Company. p. 85. ISBN 1563112809.
8. Dobbs, Bobby (February 22, 2016). "1920 lynching of Claude Chandler: Shedding light on painful past". The Daily Oklahoman. Retrieved August 15, 2017.
9. "Moonshine Raid Cause of Three Killed". Oklahoma State Register. September 2, 1920. Retrieved August 15, 2017.
10. "Claud Chandler, Logan Negro, Hanged On El Reno Road By Mob". The Guthrie Daily Leader (Volume XLXIV, Number 154). August 30, 1920. Retrieved 15 August 2017.
11. David Randall Fisk, Legendary Locals of Edmond (Arcadia Publishing, 2014), ISBN 978-1467101233, p. 93. Excerpts available at Google Books.
12. William Aylor Berry & James Edwin Alexander, Justice for sale: the shocking scandal of the Oklahoma Supreme Court (Macedon Publishing Co., 1996). Snippet excerpts available at Google Books.
    - Linda Burket O'Hearn, "Supreme Court Scandal Examined", The Oklahoman, September 23, 1997.
13. Cargill v. United States, 381 F.2d 849 (10th Cir. 1967)