Moses-Saunders Power Dam

The Moses-Saunders Power Dam, short for Robert Moses-Robert H. Saunders Power Dam, is a dam on the Saint Lawrence River straddling the border between the United States and Canada. It is located between Massena in New York and Cornwall in Ontario. The dam supplies water to two adjacent hydroelectric power generating stations, the United States' 912 MW St. Lawrence-Franklin D. Roosevelt Power Project and Canada's 1,045 MW R.H. Saunders Generating Station. Constructed between 1954 and 1958, the dam created Lake St. Lawrence and is part of a larger project called the Saint Lawrence Seaway. Aside from providing significant amounts of renewable power, the dam regulates the St. Lawrence River and affords passage for the navigation of large vessels. Despite the enormous economic advantages to the dam, it required the relocation of 6,500 people and caused harm to the surrounding environment. Positive efforts have been made over the years to improve shoreline and fish habitats.

Moses-Saunders Power Dam
The dam's R.H. Saunders Generating Station
Location of Moses-Saunders Power Dam in New York
Official name	Robert Moses-Robert H. Saunders Power Dam
Country	United States/Canada
Location	Massena, New York Cornwall, Ontario
Coordinates	45°00′23″N 74°47′42″W
Status	Operational
Construction began	1954
Opening date	1958
Owner(s)	New York Power Authority Ontario Power Generation
Dam and spillways
Impounds	Saint Lawrence River
Height	195.5 ft (60 m)[1]
Length	3,216 ft (980 m)
Spillways	Long Sault Dam
Reservoir
Creates	Lake St. Lawrence
Surface area	100 sq mi (259 km^2)[2]
Maximum length	30 mi (48 km)
Power Station
Commission date	R.H. Saunders: July 8, 1958-December 18, 1959[3]
Hydraulic head	81 ft (25 m)[4]
Turbines	R.H. Saunders: 16 x 65.3 MW fixed-pitch Kaplan-type St. Lawrence/FDR: 16 x 57 MW fixed pitch Kaplan-type[5]
Installed capacity	R.H. Saunders: 1,045 MW St. Lawrence/FDR: 912 MW Total: 1,957 MW

Background

Panorama of the dam from the U.S. side

Development of the St. Lawrence River which serves as a border between Canada and the United States was in its early stages in 1871 when the Treaty of Washington was signed, which in part demarcated the St. Lawrence River as a boundary and offered Americans greater use of the Canadian side of the river for shipping. In 1895 the Deep Waterways Commission was established to explore expanded use of the river for navigation. International shipping on the river would have a positive impact on trade between the two countries. The early St. Lawrence Seaway was proposed but railway companies in the United States stopped its construction because they felt it would reduce their profits. The Boundary Waters Treaty of 1909 further solidified cooperation between the U.S. and Canada on the river, allowing "free and open" navigation and establishing the International Joint Commission (IJC) to resolve disputes. In 1931, New York's Governor Franklin D. Roosevelt signed the Power Authority Act which allowed the development of the St. Lawrence River for power use. A primary site was just below the Long Sault Rapids. Despite the cooperation, the U.S. Federal Government was unable to open up the river for increased navigation and development due to political issues. Upset with this, Canada unilaterally passed two acts in 1951 which allowed projects on the St. Lawrence for power and navigation purposes. As Daniel Macfarlane's book Negotiating a River shows, Canada attempted to build the Seaway alone, with Ontario and New York constructing the power dam; however, the United States considered this a security threat and forced Canada to accept a shared Seaway. The next year a proposal for a hydroelectric dam and navigation lock was submitted to the IJC for approval. In October 1952 the project was approved.[6]

Because of political stalemate and the railway companies, construction did not begin until August 19, 1954 when the entire seaway project began with a ground breaking ceremony at the dam site. Construction was expected to last seven years and much of which was supervised by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.[7] Chairman of the New York Power Authority, Robert Moses, oversaw the U.S. portion and Robert Hood Saunders, chairman of Ontario Hydro, oversaw the Canadian side of the project. The project included the main dam, the Long Sault Dam, the Eisenhower\Snell Locks, the Massena Intake, and 10.9 mi (18 km) of dikes. Robert Hood Saunders had already been elected mayor of Toronto four times when he joined Ontario Hydro. Saunders would not live to see his name on the station. He died on January 16, 1955 from injuries and shock from the previous evening when his ice-covered aircraft crashed near an airstrip in London, Ontario. He and four others were returning to Toronto from Windsor; Saunders had reportedly just delivered a speech in Detroit on the St. Lawrence Power Project. He was only 51 and at the peak of his career.

On July 1, 1958, Dr. Otto Holden, chief engineer of Hydro-electric Power Commission of Ontario, and J. Burch McMorran, Chief Engineer of The New York Power Authority, detonated 27 metric tonnes of explosives to demolish the cofferdam that had diverted St. Lawrence River water away from the powerhouse construction site. It took four days for the plant to become fully operational. The last generators were commissioned in 1959.[8] Previously, in 1956, the IJC established the International St. Lawrence River Board of Control as a mechanism to regulate the river above and below the dam. Competing interests for power and navigation had to be controlled in order to maintain good function of the dam. Those interested in power and flood control desired moderate water levels and the shipping industry and power station operators wanted levels to be higher.[6]

Negative impacts

To construct the dam 6,500 people in Eastern Ontario were dislocated, some farmers but predominantly the residents of six villages and three hamlets, known as The Lost Villages, before the land was flooded. The residents were given market value for their land, though there are claims it was unfair because the land prices were believed to have already been depressed due to the anticipated submergence; some residents were forcibly removed. Most were relocated to homes in new communities called South Stormont (Long Sault) or Ingleside and Iroquois.[9][10] In 2008, Ontario Hydro made an official apology.[3]

The construction and operation of the dam impacted the traditional territory used by the Native American Mohawks of Akwesasne. Over 1,200 acres of reserve lands and 15,000 acres of traditional lands were flooded. The group was not consulted or compensated in any way for the flooding of ten islands belonging to Akwesasne for the creation of the head pond. In 2008, a 15 year effort to address the past wrongs resulted in a proposed settlement between Ontario Power Generation and The Mohawk Council of Akwesasne. The settlement included monetary compensation, a transfer of islands originally owned by Akwesasne, and environmental stewardship.[11]

Power produced by the dam was the primary reason that General Motors, Reynolds Metals and the Aluminum Company of America opened factories in the area. These factories generated severe pollution on the river and are now Superfund clean-up sites.[12]

Environmental Impacts

Flooding and pollution have affected fish populations on the river and in Lake St. Lawrence. Northern Pike, Walleye, Muskellunge, Lake Sturgeon and American eel have been affected. The loss of spawning grounds is also believed to have contributed to drops in their populations. Recent efforts have stabilized or increased much of the populations.[13] R.H. Saunders Generating Station has a ladder made in a decommissioned ice sluce designed for juvenile American Eels to head upriver, across the generating station. At 521 ft (159 m) long and 95 ft (29 m) high, it was the only one in North America and the tallest in the world at the time. In recent years, it has been upgraded and extended 984 ft (300 m) in length.[14] OPG maintains a trap and transport program with local commercial fisherman for downstream migration. From 2006 to 2011, approximately four million young eels crossed into the upper St. Lawrence River and Lake Ontario.[15]

Both New York and Ontario have instituted programs to improve the local environment around the reservoir and its water quality.[3] The U.S. programs were mainly instituted after the power station was re-licensed for 50 years on October 23, 2003.[4][16][17]

R.H. Saunders Generating Station works to control their environmental initiative by conducting studies, improving habitats, and coordinating electricity production during spawning seasons. In the summer of 2016, Bird Studies Canada installed a MOTUS tracking system at R.H. Saunders Generating Station that tracks the migration of 85 species of birds, bats, and large insects.[18]

Rehabilitation and upgrades

After investigations in 1990 and 1991, it was determined that generator and structural problems within the dam were due to Alkali–aggregate reaction. The power station's concrete was cracking and deteriorating while the generator stators and throat ring linings were deformed. From 1993 to 2001 extensive repairs were carried out to fix damaged concrete and mitigate concrete expansion.[19] From 1987 to 2007 upgrades to R.H. Saunders Generating Station have increased efficiency by 16 percent.[3] In 1998, the New York Power Authority began a $254 million refurbishment of the turbine-generators at the St. Lawrence/FDR. The project is expected to be complete in 2013.[20]

Design and operation

R.H. Saunders control room.

The 195.5 ft (60 m) tall and 3,212 ft (979 m) long dam is situated in between the Canadian shore at Cornwall and New York's Barnhart Island. To create the reservoir, the Long Sault Dam was constructed 3.5 mi (6 km) upstream in between Barnhart Island and one of the Long Sault Islands. In between the Long Sault Island the New York shore is the Eisenhower and Snell Locks. Located 7.5 mi (12 km) upstream is the Massena Intake. Further securing the reservoir is 10.9 mi (18 km) of dikes. The Long Sault Dam, completely in the U.S., is 2,960 ft (902 m) long and 109 ft (33 m) high. It serves as a spillway to pass flood waters on the river. The Massena Intake is 721 ft (220 m) long and 108 ft (33 m) high. It provides water for industry and local civil consumption.[4] The power station at the Moses-Saunders Dam contains 32 turbine generators. Ontario Power Generation operates units 1-16 and the New York Power Authority operates 17-32. The Canadian side of the power station, R.H. Saunders Generating Station, contains 16 x 65.3 MW fixed-pitch Kaplan turbine-generators and the U.S. power station, St. Lawrence-FDR contains 16 x 57 MW vertical fixed-pitch Kaplan turbine-generators. The dam affords the turbines 81 ft (25 m) of hydraulic head.[4] The Eisenhower and Snell Locks can pass ships up to 730 ft (223 m) in length and 76 ft (23 m) wide a height of 38 ft (12 m) (Eisenhower) and 43 ft (13 m) (Snell).[21]

Further Reading Macfarlane, Daniel (2014) Negotiating a River: Canada, the US, and the Creation of the St. Lawrence Seaway. Vancouver: UBC Press.

See also

• Saint Lawrence Seaway
• The Lost Villages
• List of power stations in New York
• List of electrical generating stations in Ontario
• List of largest power stations in Canada

References

1. Parham, Claire Puccia (2009). The St. Lawrence Seaway and Power Project : an oral history of the greatest construction show on earth (1st ed.). Syracuse, N.Y.: Syracuse University Press. pp. xxiii. ISBN 0-8156-0913-2.
2. "St. Lawrence River (International Section)". U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. Retrieved 5 March 2012.
3. "R.H. Saunders Station". Ontario Power Generation Inc. Retrieved 5 March 2012.
4. "Order Approving Settlement Agreements, Dismissing Complaint and Issuing New License" (PDF). Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. 23 October 2003. Retrieved 5 March 2012.
5. "The HydroX System" (PDF). Orbit. 2004. Retrieved 5 March 2012.
6. Macfarlane, Daniel (2014). Negotiating a River: Canada, the US, and the Creation of the St. Lawrence Seaway. Vancouver: UBC Press.
7. Levasseur, Phillip G.; Dane McKinney (22 April 2010). "The Great Lakes-The St. Lawrence River: Under Climate Change" (PDF). Transboundary Water Resources. University of Texas at Austin. Retrieved 5 March 2012.
8. Little, Gordie (2009). "St. Lawrence-FDR Power Project & NYPA". Absolutely Business. Retrieved 5 March 2012.
9. Gorrie, Peter (29 June 2008). "Our own Three Gorges". Toronto Star. Retrieved 5 March 2012.
10. "The Lost Villages". Postmedia Network Inc. 28 June 2008. Archived from the original on 4 November 2012. Retrieved 5 March 2012.
11. Time, Indian. "Mohawk Council of Akwesasne Announces Ontario Power Generation proposed settlement terms". Indian Time. Retrieved 2016-11-09.
12. Hofrichter, edited by Richard (2000). Reclaiming the environmental debate : the politics of health in a toxic culture. London: MIT. pp. 96–97. ISBN 0-262-58182-5.CS1 maint: extra text: authors list (link)
13. "FISH HABITAT CHANGES - Thousand Islands, Middle Corridor, and Lake St. Lawrence" (PDF). RE Grant & Associates. Retrieved 5 March 2012.
14. Johnson, Brian (1 August 2009). "The eels weren't forgotten". Lake Ontario Waterkeeper. Archived from the original on 14 July 2011. Retrieved 5 March 2012.
15. "Power News 2015 Q3" (PDF). opg.com. Ontario Power Generation. Retrieved November 9, 2016.
16. "Land Management Plan - St. Lawrence River". New York Power Authority. Retrieved 5 March 2012.
17. "Future Habitat Improvement Projects Fund". New York Power Authority. Retrieved 5 March 2012.
18. "Bird Monitoring" (PDF). Retrieved November 9, 2016 – via opg.com.
19. "R.H. Saunders Generating Station Structural Rehabilitation". AWARD OF EXCELLENCE: Water Structures Category. International Concrete Repair Institute. Retrieved 5 March 2012.
20. "St. Lawrence-FDR Power". New York Power Authority. Retrieved 5 March 2012.
21. "Erie Canal and Eisenhower Locks" (PDF). Learning on the Great Lakes Seaway Trail. Seaway Trail. Retrieved 5 March 2012.