John Keir

Sir John Lindesay Keir KCB (6 July 1856 – 3 May 1937) was a late 19th-early 20th Century British soldier and General. He fought in the Second Boer War, and commanded the 6th Division and the VI Corps of the British Army on the Western Front during World War 1.

John Lindesay Keir
Nickname(s)	Matador
Born	6 July 1856
Died	3 May 1937 Leamington
Service/branch	British Army
Years of service	1876–1918
Rank	Lieutenant General
Unit	Royal Artillery
Commands held	1st Battalion, Imperial Yeomanry South Midland Division 6th Division VI Corps
Battles/wars	Boer War First World War
Awards	Knight Commander of the Order of the Bath Mentioned in Despatches Médaille militaire Order of the Crown (Belgium)

Early career

After receiving his early formal education at Wimbledon College, Keir studied at the Royal Military Academy, Woolwich, from where he received a commission into the Royal Artillery in February 1876. He was posted to a battery in India, and after six years was awarded his "jacket" and transferred into the Royal Horse Artillery. In 1884, promoted to captain, he returned to the R.F.A. He had become a skilled rider in the artillery, and whilst he was too heavy to compete in traditional horse-racing, he participated in point-to-point racing and similar events. After attending the School of Gunnery he entered the Staff College in 1892, and passed out, newly promoted to major, to command a field battery in England.

Second Boer War

Keir later transferred back to the R.H.A., and was commanding a battery at the outbreak of the 2nd Boer War in October 1899.[1] His unit was not sent out with the Expeditionary Force, and he remained at home during the early stages of the war. However, in early 1901 he was promoted to lieutenant-colonel and offered command of the 1st Battalion of the newly formed Imperial Yeomanry, volunteer mounted infantry being raised for service in South Africa. He commanded the battalion for several months along the Orange River, and in December 1901 was assigned to command the Royal Artillery Mounted Rifles, a similar force drawn from regular artillerymen; he remained with this unit until shortly before the end of the war, and received the brevet rank of colonel in the South Africa Honours list published on 26 June 1902.[2][1] For his services in South Africa, he was mentioned in despatches (dated 8 April 1902[3]) as well as awarded the Queen's medal with five clasps.[4] Following the end of the war in June 1902, he returned to the United Kingdom in the ship S.S. Dunottar Castle, which arrived at Southampton in July 1902.[5]

1902-1914

He had transferred back to the R.H.A. as a Lieutenant-Colonel in April 1902,[6] and was posted to India, where he was formally promoted to Colonel and appointed an Assistant Adjutant-General. In 1907, he was given the command of a brigade at Allahabad, promoted to Major-General in 1909, and returned home in 1911. In July 1912 he was given command of the South Midland Division, part of the Territorial Force, and remained with them until July 1914, when he was transferred to take command of the 6th Division, a Regular Army formation at that time based in Ireland.[1]

First World War

Keir had hardly been in command of the 6th Division for a month when the World War 1 began, and it was mobilised as part of the British Expeditionary Force for service on the European Continent. However, the original plan of sending six divisions to France was altered due to fears of German landings in the United Kingdom, and the 6th Division spent the first month of the war in reserve in East Anglia. In September 1914 it landed in France, and immediately saw service at the Battle of the Aisne. Later in the year, he commanded it saw action at the Battle of Armentières. In mid-1915, Keir was appointed to take command of the newly formed VI Corps (United Kingdom),[7] which took part in the Battle of Loos in September 1915. In December 1915 VI Corps was attacked by the Imperial German Army with phosgene gas, the first time this form of chemical warfare was used.[1]

On 8 August 1916 Keir was relieved of command of VI Corps, whilst the official explanation for the move was given as being due to exhaustion or illness, the real cause was a personal dispute between Keir and Edmund Allenby, his commanding general at the head of Third Army. Allenby was notorious for his overbearing command manner with subordinates, and had gained the nickname "the Bull" for his aggression amongst them. Keir had previously protested to Douglas Haig, the Commander-in-Chief of the Expeditionary Force, and as a result had acquired the sobriquet in III Army of "the Matador" – i.e. the man who could handle "the Bull". However, Allenby later formally raised concerns with Haig about Keir's front-line dispositions of VI Corps in the line around Arras in August 1916, and Haig supported Allenby's assessment that Keir was an indifferent General (augmented by an inherent prejudice that Haig possessed towards older Generals, Keir having just turned 60),[8] and despite Keir's threats to Haig to appeal to higher authority against the decision in England if he was deprived of his command in the field and forcefully returned home, protesting that he had been wronged by Allenby's action, Haig removed him thence.[9]

On return to England Keir was sidelined and without a command, and spent the remainder of the war fulminating about the role of privileged "cavalry generals" (such as Haig and Allenby), whom he argued held a disproportionate number of senior posts in the British Expeditionary Force compared to infantrymen, gunners and engineers.[10]

Later life

Keir was formally retired from the British Army in July 1918, and wrote and published a book detailing his thoughts for the post-war future of the British Army, entitled A Soldier's-Eye View (1919).[4] In it he called for "a true National army", alongside reforms to create a "National church".[11] His suggested reforms included cutting the size of the peace-time regular forces, alongside significant reductions in cavalry forces, and reorganising the home and colonial forces for better efficiency. More unusually, he also anticipated strong government control of labour in all spheres – a "national plan of personal service to the state" – and the creation of an "Army Senate" to oversee the organisation and governance of the National Army.[12] The Senate would have both peacetime and wartime roles, and could serve as an advisory body akin to the War Cabinet during wartime.[13] In retirement, he served as a Deputy Lieutenant and Justice of the Peace for Warwickshire.[1]

Death

Keir died at Leamington Spa in the county of Warwickshire, on 3 May 1937, at the age of 80.

Awards

As well as his knighthood, which he had received with his promotion in 1915, he was awarded the Medaille Militare and appointed a Grand Officer of the Belgian Order of the Crown.[1]

Notes

1. Obituary, The Times
2. "No. 27448". The London Gazette (Supplement). 26 June 1902. pp. 4191–4193.
3. "No. 27443". The London Gazette. 17 June 1902. pp. 3967–3974.
4. Who Was Who
5. "The Army in South Africa - Troops returning home". The Times (36814). London. 8 July 1902. p. 11.
6. "No. 27427". The London Gazette. 22 April 1902. p. 2690.
7. His obituary gives May 1915, as does Marden (left command on 26 May); Who Was Who gives June. It may be that he left the division in the last week of May and began at VI Corps in early June.
8. 'Douglas Haig: War Diaries & Letters 1914-1918', by G. Sheffield & J. Bourne (Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 2005), entry regarding Keir's dismissal, 8 August 1916, P.217.
9. MacDonald, p. 506
10. Harvey, pp. 357–358
11. Keir, pp. 1-11
12. Keir, pp. 155-159
13. Keir, pp. 201-204

References

• "KEIR, Lt-Gen. Sir John Lindesay", in Who Was Who (Online ed.). London: A & C Black. 2007.
• Harvey, Arnold D. (1992). Collision of empires: Britain in three world wars, 1793-1945. ISBN 1-85285-078-7.
• Keir, Lieut-Gen. Sir John (1919). A "Soldier's-Eye View" of Our Armies. London: John Murray.
• MacDonald, Allan (2008). A Lack of Offensive Spirit? The 46th (North Midland) Division at Gommecourt, 1st July 1916. ISBN 0-9558119-0-2.
• Marden, Thomas Owen (1920). A Short History of the 6th Division: Aug. 1914-March 1919. London: Hugh Rees.
• Obituary in The Times, 4 May 1937, p. 18.

Military offices
Preceded by Alexander Thorneycroft	GOC South Midland Division 1912–1914	Succeeded by Edward Graham
Preceded by William Pulteney	GOC 6th Division 1914–1915	Succeeded by Walter Congreve
Preceded by New post	GOC VI Corps 1915–1916	Succeeded by Aylmer Haldane