Internet Diplomacy

Internet Diplomacy refers to any of a number of online implementations of Diplomacy, a board game in which seven players, each controlling one of the major European powers of the early 20th century, fight for control over Europe.

This article is about online correspondence play of the board game Diplomacy. For a discussion of social norms governing the behavior and communication of Internet users, see Netiquette.

A map generated by the online Diplomacy game stabbeurfou

Instead of communicating face-to-face, as in the board games, or by mail, as in the play-by-mail games, communication and order submission is done over the internet. Typically orders are processed by software, but in the earlier systems a person called a GameMaster would process the orders manually.

Background

Internet Diplomacy is popular for many reasons, including avoiding inconveniences associated with playing the game face-to-face and the lack of availability of local players. Also, a face-to-face game needs up to seven players and can last several hours, which makes it difficult to find enough players with enough free time for a game.

Internet Diplomacy brings together players from anywhere in the world, with deadlines ranging between a few minutes to a few days, and allows players to play multiple games at the same time. The role of GameMaster, depending on the specific implementation, can be minimized to setup and resolution of rules questions/disputes, or even eliminated entirely.

This makes Internet Diplomacy the preferred choice for many, but it is not without its flaws. Plain text messages aren't as good as face-to-face conversation for back-and-forth discussion or watching for signs of deception. Also playing with relatively anonymous remote players may be less emotionally rewarding than playing with close friends.

Types

Play by email (PBEM)

Play-by-email internet Diplomacy followed from Play-by-mail games dating to 1970s fan zines. Similar to standard mail games, players originally sent press directly to one another through email, and sent their orders via email to a pre-designated human GameMaster.

Comparison of Play-by-email Diplomacy variants

Title	Year	Platforms	Parent	Turn deadline	Bots	Features
Diplomaticcorp	1999	Web site	None	3d - 7d	None	100% free human-run Diplomacy games and variants since 1999

Email judges

As email became more prevalent software Judges were developed, which would route emails addressed from one player to another, and route submitted orders and results to/from human GameMaster(s). As well as routing messages they provided more accountability and security, a place where all the info about the game could be stored and retrieved, and provided a way to keep scores of players from multiple games.

These software Judges were eventually extended to include adjudicators, which are pieces of software capable of resolving orders and producing results, thus replacing the human GameMaster with software. Those adjudicators often had many bugs and only after a few years they became reliable. The Diplomacy Adjudicator Test Cases were written to overcome this problem. With the use of these test cases new programs can be of high quality on first release. The DATC contains also recommendations for ambiguities in the rules.

Variants to the original map and rules were also added to judges. As it is sometimes difficult to find many people who are familiar with the same variant in a face-to-face environment, and the addition of software expanded the possibilities for variants, many variants are specific to Internet Diplomacy, where players can easily download a map and rule-set.

Ken Lowe Judge

The Ken Lowe Judge system was the first judge system to be created.[1] The Ken Lowe Judge system allows users to send press to one another and send orders to the processing server through a variety of text commands. Today, many online adjudication systems run in the same, or similar, fashion to the Ken Lowe Judges.

NJudge

Njudge was a rewrite of the Ken Lowe Judge system, with more support added for different variants. This version of the judge software was created by Nathan Wagner, then Judgekeeper (Administrator for a Judge Server) to clean up issues that arose over the years due to the multiple different programmers who had made adjustments to the original code. This software program continues to be used on a number of email servers.[2]

Web/email interfaces

In recent years as the web has become more dynamic Internet Diplomacy has shifted from email to the web. Due to the complexity of adjudicators and judges, the earliest web implementations primarily provided a web interface to the email based Judges.

One of the main advantages of web-based implementations over previous options is that they can display computer-generated graphical maps of the current board on the web-page, instead of requiring the user to update the positions of the game's units on a physical board based on text output.

The DPjudge

In 1995, Manus Hand created the DPjudge, among the first to use a web interface for an email judge. DPJudge allows players to view maps, game history, enter orders and write press to other players through a web interface, however some features, including signing up for a new game, or filling a vacancy in a game in progress, require email usage. The DPjudge is also able to handle numerous variant maps and rules, in addition to the standard map and rules as published by Hasbro.

Web based

The most recent Diplomacy via web implementations were created for the web from scratch. This gives the advantage of allowing more complex features to be added (e.g. rule variants), but requires that complex adjudicator code be rewritten.

Comparison of Web-based Diplomacy variants

Title	Year	Platforms	Parent	Turn deadline	Bots	Features
Backstabbr	2011	Web based	PlayDiplomacyOnline	15m - 7d	None	English Sandbox
BOUNCED	1999	?	?	?	?
Diplicity[3]	2020	Web (desktop, pad, mobile), Android	Diplicity	1m - 30d	None	100% free, push or email notifications, modern interface, reliability rating, Tribute scoring[4], TrueSkill rating
webDiplomacy	2004	Web based	None	5m - 10d	6 bots	English Variants Free
vDiplomacy	2010	Web based	webDiplomacy	5m - 10d	None	100+ Variants
Stabbeurfou	2005	?	?	?	?	English & French
playdiplomacy	2007	Web based	webDiplomacy	12h - 7d (live games only for premium members)	None
Conquest of Nations	2008	?	?	?	?
Diplomacy by deNes	2003	?	?	?	?
DipGame.org	?	?	?	?	6 bots

DipGame

DipGame provides a web-interface to an AI server that allows a web-based single-player game against 6 bots (i.e. computer players). It is also possible to save games and to resume later. The website is a beta version and has some known bugs, including a critical one that makes the game stop and impossible to log in again until the webmaster restarts the system and your game is lost (June 2012).

The website was initiated for a PhD research project to provide a Multiagent Systems' testbed developed at the http://www.iiia.csic.es/ IIIA-CSIC in Barcelona. They plan to develop negotiating capabilities for the bots,[5] however these are not available in the web-interface yet (June 2012). It is also possible to download an off-line version to develop your own bots.[6]

Smartphone apps

Resolution Phase (Conspiracy Android App)

There are also several implementations for smartphones, like Droidippy, Diplicity (Android)[7] and Conspiracy[8], all of them free. Realpolitik for Android[9] also has a hot-seat mode for local play. While Subterfuge provides a modern adaptation.

Online service based

The GEnie online service offered fully automated versions of Diplomacy and variants to subscribers.[10]

Intellectual property

The Diplomacy game is in copyright in most of the world, and in addition, Hasbro holds a trademark in the name. All the Avalon Hill intellectual property did not go to Avalon Hill allowing Valley games to reprint under the Avalon Hill title.[11] None of the implementations in this article hold a license from Hasbro.

References

1. "What is njudge?" Archived 2012-07-31 at Archive.today by Millis Miller, The Diplomatic Pouch, S2002R, retrieved October 4, 2006
2. "DP:Judge current openings list". Archived from the original on 2012-07-24. Retrieved 2006-09-19.
3. Diplicity
4. Tribute scoring
5. Fabregues & Sierra, 'DipGame: a challenging negotiation testbed'. Scientific journal article in prep. at EAAI
6. Fabregues & Sierra, 'DipGame: a challenging negotiation testbed'. Scientific journal article in prep. at EAAI
7. Diplicity (Android)
8. Conspiracy
9. Realpolitik
10. "A Survey of On-Line Games". Computer Gaming World. May 1993. p. 84. Retrieved 7 July 2014.
11. Avalon Hill History