Air Caribbean Flight 309
Air Caribbean flight 309 was a domestic, non-scheduled airline flight by Puerto Rican airline Air Caribbean, which on September 26, 1978, crashed as it was preparing to land at Luis Muñoz Marín International Airport in San Juan, after a flight from Ramey Air Force Base (what is now known as Rafael Hernandez Airport) in Aguadilla, killing all six occupants of the aircraft and injuring several customers of a Barrio Obrero bar over which the airplane fell.[1]
| Accident | |
|---|---|
| Date | 26 September 1978 |
| Summary | Crashed into a populated bar, caused by wake turbulence from an L-1011 jet |
| Site | Barrio Obrero in Santurce, San Juan, Puerto Rico |
| Aircraft | |
| Aircraft type | Beech 18 |
| Operator | Air Caribbean |
| Registration | N500L |
| Flight origin | Ramey Air Base, Aguadilla |
| Destination | Isla Verde International Airport, San Juan |
| Passengers | 5 |
| Crew | 1 |
| Fatalities | 6 |
| Survivors | 0 |
Flight
Air Caribbean flight 309 took off from Aguadilla airport and had an uneventful flight for about 25 minutes before it got to San Juan. The flight that day was being carried on a Beechcraft D185 which was owned by Puerto Rican businessman and pilot Francisco Cruz, who sometimes leased this airplane, registered as N-500L, to Air Caribbean. N-500L was a small propeller airplane with a capacity for 10 passengers; on the fateful day it was carrying five passengers and a crew member, pilot Jerry Cannon.
Happenings outside the Air Caribbean airplane
About the same time as Air Caribbean flight 309's take-off, Eastern Airlines flight 75, performed on this date by a Lockheed L-1011 "Tri-Star" jet, was approaching Puerto Rico to land at the Luis Munoz Marin International Airport, then known as Isla Verde International Airport instead.
Right about that time (18:00 local standard time, or 6:00 PM) patrons were arriving at a local bar in Barrio Obrero, a Santurce area near the international airport, to enjoy drinks and socialize during the rest of that afternoon and ensuing night.
Crash
The two airplanes almost collided over San Juan. Minutes before, Flight 309 announced that they were just past Dorado Airport, where they would have had to report because they were flying under visual flight rules, and were over Levittown instead. Pilot Cannon could not contact Dorado Airport because his airplane's approach frequency was inoperative; he phoned the local air controllers from his airplane instead.[2]
Eastern's flight 75's approach was begun over the Atlantic Ocean; the airliner was flying on instrument flight rules.
At 18:41, about 5 minutes before flight 309's crash, Cannon was advised as to the position of the Eastern L-1011, which San Juan controllers had observed go down to 3,000 feet and place itself directly behind flight 309, with about two minutes of distance separation between the two aircraft. Because of the speed at which the two airplanes were coming, there was now a danger that the two airliners would collide. Pilot Cannon acknowledged having the Eastern L-1011 in sight. He was heard saying "Yeah, I got him" to San Juan control tower, referring to the Eastern jet. At 18:42, the smaller aircraft was told by the controllers to head in a southeast direction at 130 degrees in order to let the Eastern airplane overpass the Air Caribbean one, at the same time the controllers warned the Air Caribbean plane about the possible effects of wake turbulence.[2]
A few seconds later, controllers turned their attention to the Eastern L-1011, telling them that Air Caribbean flight 309 would now be following them for final descent. The L-1011 had by now descended to 1,400 feet, its speed lowered from 220 knots to about 146 knots, while the Air Caribbean aircraft was at 110 knots, which caused the Eastern L-1011 to delay it's overtaking of the Puerto Rican airliner until now.
At 18:43, pilot Cannon told controllers that he had lost sight of the Eastern jet. The airplanes were so close, however, that an Eastern pilot who was riding jump-seat on the L-1011 later testified he could see the Beech's passengers' silhouettes from his vantage point.[2] This closeness between the two airplanes is considered to have caused hazardous wake turbulence that Air Caribbean flight 309 had then to overcome.
The wake turbulence led pilot Cannon to lose control of the Beech aircraft. That and the fact he was flying at under 1,000 feet at the time of the crash meant he had no time to recover and the airplane he was flying plummeted into the local bar near Residencial Las Casas, killing him and all five passengers aboard, and injuring several patrons at the bar, including a local mechanic identified by the press as Luciano Rivera.[3]
The Eastern Air Lines airplane landed safely at the airport, with no injuries reported among the crew and passengers on that aircraft.
Aftermath
Family members of those killed in the crash and some of the injured at the bar filed a class act lawsuit against Air Caribbean, Eastern Airlines, the Federal Aviation Administration, Francisco Cruz and Cornhill Insurance (which represented the Lloyd's of London firm in this case).
Ultimately, Eastern and the FAA admitted liability and settled with the claimants for an amount of $5,690,000.00 dollars.[2]
PSA 182
The accident occurred only one day after the accident of PSA Flight 182 in San Diego, California. Had Eastern flight 75 and Air Caribbean flight 309 collided, it would have been the second accident of its kind in similar circumstances in American territory on back to back days.[4]
References
- "IN RE N-500L CASES | 517 F.Supp. 825 (1981) | upp82511228 | Leagle.com". Leagle. Retrieved 2020-07-28.
- "IN RE N-500L CASES | 517 F.Supp. 825 (1981) | upp82511228 | Leagle.com". Leagle.
- Ranter, Harro. "Accident Beechcraft D18S N500L, 26 Sep 1978". aviation-safety.net.
- "PSA crash at 40: A page of San Diego history 'written in blood'". San Diego Union-Tribune. September 23, 2018.