How to safely remove eSATA drive when it's not in the Safely Remove Hardware dialog - XP

2

1

How can I safely remove my external eSATA disk on Windows XP? I want to avoid any workarounds that involve reinstalling, rebooting, and/or reconfiguring the drive.

I found a similar question here but I'm using Windows XP instead of Windows 7. The answer provided there makes no sense to me, as I want nothing but to safely remove the hard disk. I don't want to change the options in any way - I especially don't think that disabling caching will be useful to anyone (as I'm not expecting a power outage any time soon!).

Note that unlike my C: drive, the drive I want to switch off does not appear in the "Safely remove..." menu.

maaartinus

Posted 2011-09-17T21:27:51.177

Reputation: 3 054

Answers

3

Go into either Device Manager or Computer Management-Disk Storage.

From there, you can disable the drive or under Disk Storage you can make the drive offline.

edit

The only other option to make your drive appear on the Safely remove IS a reconfiguration, which is to set the drive as removeable under Device Manager.

As said below, disabling a drive under Device Manager does not remove the drive from the list. It just puts a gray arrow on it. Switching it offline is under Computer Management, which I stated above.

edit

To batch this, you use the diskpart remove drive_letter command to dismount the drive.

surfasb

Posted 2011-09-17T21:27:51.177

Reputation: 21 453

Disabling the disk falls into the category "reconfiguring" and is even worse than simple disabling the caching (the device disappears from the list, which makes re-enabling harder). I haven't found any possibility to switch it off-line. – maaartinus – 2011-09-18T09:29:20.753

Disabling a device doesn't remove the device from Device Manager. Even if it did, rescanning your system for hardware changes (which device manager also does) will redetect it. – surfasb – 2011-09-18T13:44:53.417

Agreed, it doesn't get removed from the from Device Manager, but it gets removed from Computer Management/Disk Storage (which is what I meant). I hate Windows forcing me to make permanent changes for something as trivial as stopping a device. – maaartinus – 2011-09-18T13:53:42.970

If the Drive has a dynamic volume, it doesn't disappear. It's something you can batchfile also. I have two eSata docks myself and I use an autohotkey script to eject them from the system. – surfasb – 2011-09-18T14:07:28.090

It's not dynamic. I'd like to create a batch script using diskpart, however remove f: says The arguments you specified for this command are not valid. which is (as usually) of no help. It looks like it should be remove letter=f, but this complains again... Finally it works... unless the volume number changes! How could anybody invent something as user-hostile as this? – maaartinus – 2011-09-18T16:00:05.107

Windows has the optimize for removal option. But per your specifications, that option isn't a solution you are looking for. So thus, any other solution isn't going to be a point+click affair. – surfasb – 2011-09-18T16:08:31.057

It's getting better and better: "DiskPart successfully removed the drive letter, but your computer needs to be rebooted before the changes take effect." :D:D:D – maaartinus – 2011-09-18T16:08:53.083

Ignore the reboot message. I never reboot either. – surfasb – 2011-09-18T16:10:58.963

Actually, I am a command line fan. However, using such a strange CLI and giving such perfectly non-informative messages drives me crazy. But forget it, I've accepted your answer and I'm gonna struggle with diskpart myself or maybe ask another question. – maaartinus – 2011-09-18T16:15:43.260

If you are a command line fan, then this should be a piece of cake. – surfasb – 2011-09-18T16:20:26.237

2

http://mt-naka.com/hotswap/index_enu.htm

It is free and works great for disconnecting eSata drives.

rbeede

Posted 2011-09-17T21:27:51.177

Reputation: 157

Asked: 2011-09-17T21:27:51.177

Viewed: 3 292 times

Active: 2012-11-07T03:03:23.780