1
I have a Mac PC and a Windows PC on the same network.
If I turn the firewall off on the Windows PC the Mac can ping it, if I turn it on, the Mac cannot.
I've checked every individual option in the firewall, but it still is not working. What rule do I need to apply to allow the Mac to connect? Or what am I doing wrong?
Using Windows 7 and OS X Snow Leopard.
Your firewall might be blocking ICMP packets not allowing it to be pinged. You might still be able to access it though if it is connected to the internet. – paradd0x – 2011-02-17T21:23:22.537
I tried to allow all ICMPv4 packets through, but still no luck. Crazy thing is, it used to work yesterday, and I never changed any firewall settings, anywhere. – v15 – 2011-02-17T21:29:15.293
What kind of firewall are you using? The Windows Firewall? Or a Third Party firewall? – paradd0x – 2011-02-17T21:32:11.670
Windows Firewall. UPDATE: so I allowed all connections for ICMPv4, domain, public and private. That worked, but it seemed a little unsafe. Is it ok to leave this open? Allow all connection from this? – v15 – 2011-02-17T21:36:11.560
2Unless you are worried about bad ping packets from some unknown source. No. It's nothing to worry about. And it's not really a connection, since most connections are done in TCP and UDP. ICMP is mostly for ping packets. So you should be fine by leaving it open. – paradd0x – 2011-02-17T21:38:00.230