Given the physical characteristics of flash memory, are SSDs an appropriate long-term storage medium for backups, etc.? Is their decay rate such that it is amenable to using them for rolling backups (thereby avoiding the wear issues)?
Asked
Active
Viewed 865 times
3 Answers
6
I wouldn't try it. The floating charges that are used to store the bits can degrade within a few years. The more the flash memory has been used, the more likely this will happen. (The over-voltage used to erase the cells can be hard on the components.)
Electrical storage media (these days) generally do not have as long a lifetime as their magnetic counterparts. Charge can seep away but magnetic spin is much more stable by comparison.
ParoX
- 838
- 6
- 11
1
Sorry to be negative but I can't think of a worse use for SSDs myself - just on price/performance alone, forget their retention capabilities. Again, sorry to be negative.
Chopper3
- 100,240
- 9
- 106
- 238
-
1To be fair, the question wasn't about price/performance, just about whether or not the data would stay were it was put :) – Jeremy Huiskamp May 07 '09 at 22:02
1
The technology is way too new to be used as a long-term storage medium of any kind. Every three months new, unexpected high-impact performance issues are being discovered. So clearly the technology isn't quite ready for prime time. If the data is valuable and needs to be saved, the solutions are:
- Disk-based archival systems (yours or someone else's)
- Tape
- Multiple permutations of the above.
duffbeer703
- 20,077
- 4
- 30
- 39
-
The question wasn't particuarly about performance; more about archival quality and degradation. Generally, archival media are less concerned with performance than most other bulk storage types. – Paul Sonier May 11 '09 at 16:31
-
The unexpected performance issues are a good way to demonstrate that SSD solutions aren't fully baked yet. If the people making these things haven't figured out how to keep performance consistent for more than a few months, do you really think that they've thought long and hard about archiving? Archiving is a discipline where being cautious and conservative is a really good idea. – duffbeer703 May 11 '09 at 18:51