Finding duplicate balls in a basket?

4

1

Question

A basket is full n colored balls . Except one ball all the other colors are repeating. Find the one color that does not repeat,in O(n) space complexity.

What if each ball is repeated exactly twice?

you can consider it to be an array or a list or any container with a capacity of 100

samairtimer

Posted 2012-07-09T18:12:44.890

Reputation: 151

6Unless you specify some kind of input and output format (or the flexibility of what you allow) people are going to make vastly different assumptions. – Peter Taylor – 2012-07-09T18:24:38.717

2This question isn't suited for CodeGolf. You need to specify a winning criteria. Otherwise, try StackOverflow.com if you are needing help. – MrZander – 2012-07-09T21:15:37.547

Do you want us to find the duplicate balls as the title suggests? – Prince John Wesley – 2012-07-10T15:00:58.787

@PrinceJohnWesley Yes thats the whole idea!! – samairtimer – 2012-07-10T15:36:05.800

-1 no input format specified, no output format specified... How you output the repeated ball? Index? Is it one indexed or zero indexed? – Rohan Jhunjhunwala – 2016-07-08T22:31:32.787

Answers

10

Python - 17 chars

Solely as an expression:

min(B,key=B.count)

Full, standalone program with input and output, 34 chars:

B=input()
print min(B,key=B.count)

edit: What gnibbler said.

daniero

Posted 2012-07-09T18:12:44.890

Reputation: 17 193

1Python3 would be a little shorter - use input instead of raw_input and () around the print. Since the input format isn't specified, why not assign single letter codes to each colour? eg "rrgbb", then you can drop the split(). And use min instead of sorted FTW – gnibbler – 2012-07-11T23:23:24.603

Thanks! Yeah, I guess a string is within the bounds of 'any container' :D The question doesn't even mention input, so I think it's legit with 2.x's input() and have the user wrap quotes around it too. – daniero – 2012-07-11T23:51:33.217

6

K, 17 15

&1=#:'=" "\:0:0

Takes input from stdin as a space separated list

k)&1=#:'=" "\:0:0
red red green blue blue
"green"

tmartin

Posted 2012-07-09T18:12:44.890

Reputation: 3 917

I think you've got me beat this time - it takes me 15 characters just to get the separate strings. – Gareth – 2012-07-11T21:36:52.063

...or maybe not - I've got the input down to 8 which at least gives me a fighting chance... :-) – Gareth – 2012-07-11T21:43:38.717

Given the way you successively golfed the last one I wouldn't be surprised to see you beat me again. My solution can't get any shorter, I think. – tmartin – 2012-07-11T21:57:56.780

No, I think 20 is my limit here. – Gareth – 2012-07-11T22:15:25.523

No need to wrap this in a function, &1=#:'=" "\:0:0 runs fine for 15. – skeevey – 2012-07-12T16:32:10.860

5

J, 31 24 20 characters

{.(~./:#/.~);:1!:1[1

A lot prettier than the previous attempt. Takes input from keyboard.

Makes an assumption that wasn't necessary in the previous version - that there is exactly one colour with one ball. If there are 2 colours with one ball you'll get the first that appears in the list, if there are no colours with only one ball you'll get the colour with the least balls.

Example:

   {.(~./:#/.~);:1!:1[1
green green red blue blue
┌───┐
│red│
└───┘

Gareth

Posted 2012-07-09T18:12:44.890

Reputation: 11 678

3

SQL - 44

Find Unique Color

SELECT C FROM B GROUP BY C HAVING COUNT(C)=1

Find Duplicate Colors

SELECT C FROM B GROUP BY C HAVING COUNT(C)>1

Tester101

Posted 2012-07-09T18:12:44.890

Reputation: 141

The right tool for the job! – Rohan Jhunjhunwala – 2016-07-08T22:32:03.693

2

Python 2.7, 44 chars

Using the same sort of format as Keith Randall's answer of a function that takes an array and returns the element/colour that only occurs once.

R=lambda B:[a for a in B if B.count(a)<2][0]

Alternatively, if I need to read in colours from the command line and output the colour that is unique (which takes 60 chars):

B=raw_input().split();print[a for a in B if B.count(a)<2][0]

JPvdMerwe

Posted 2012-07-09T18:12:44.890

Reputation: 2 565

This is O(1) space complexity - which is usually better than O(n), but technically isn't what the question asks for :) – gnibbler – 2012-07-10T23:32:01.493

2I think you could use <2 rather than ==1 to save a char. – grc – 2012-07-11T01:24:03.513

@gnibbler: O(1) is a subset of O(n). – Keith Randall – 2012-07-11T03:00:30.383

@grc: Thanks, amended the solution. – JPvdMerwe – 2012-07-11T09:22:25.440

2

Clojure - 44

#(some(fn[[c n]](if(= n 1)c))(frequencies%))

That's a lambda function. Example:

(#(some(fn[[c n]](if(= n 1)c))(frequencies%))
  [:red :red :red :blue :green :blue :yellow :yellow])
=> :green

Álvaro Cuesta

Posted 2012-07-09T18:12:44.890

Reputation: 311

1

GolfScript, 23

After a tremendous amount of help from w0lf, here's the source code.

' '/:x.&{x{1$=},,1=\;},

DEMO


28 characters with the error checking

? is displayed if there is not one unique color. For the sake of keeping the number of characters down to a minimum, the question mark was used (this of course can be changed to something more meaningful).
' '/:x.&{x{1$=},,1=\;},'?'or

DEMO


Commentary

' '/:x        # split up each element and assign it to 'x'
.&            # copy the last element in the stack and do a "setwise and"
{x            # start filtration process and invoke 'x'
{1$=}         # checks for an equality comparison
,,            # find the count of each unique character
1=            # compare value to '1'
\;            # leave only value that has count of '1' on the stack
},            # close filtration process and print element on stack
'?'or         # OPTIONAL: is printed if no element with a count of '1' is found

Rob

Posted 2012-07-09T18:12:44.890

Reputation: 1 277

1

Mathematica 23

n contains the list.

Cases[Tally@n,{x_,1}:>x]

DavidC

Posted 2012-07-09T18:12:44.890

Reputation: 24 524

0

Python 2.7, 67 chars

from collections import*
R=lambda B:Counter(B).most_common()[-1][0]

Keith Randall

Posted 2012-07-09T18:12:44.890

Reputation: 19 865

0

R - 18 chars

which(table(x)==1)

flodel

Posted 2012-07-09T18:12:44.890

Reputation: 2 345

0

APL (14)

B/⍨1=+/B∘.≡B←⎕

Takes input from the keyboard in the form of an APL list, so you need to put quotes around the colors 'like' 'this'. (Or use numbers.)

      B/⍨1=+/B∘.≡B←⎕
⎕:
      'green' 'green' 'red' 'blue' 'blue'
 red 

As a function (that takes a list, also 14 characters):

{⍵/⍨1=+/⍵∘.≡⍵}

marinus

Posted 2012-07-09T18:12:44.890

Reputation: 30 224

0

Groovy - 22 chars

it.min{a->it.count(a)}

Attribution and test case:

lone={it.min{a->it.count(a)}}

l = ['red','green', 'red', 'blue', 'green']

assert lone(l) == 'blue'
assert lone(l) != 'red'

Will Lp

Posted 2012-07-09T18:12:44.890

Reputation: 797