Kimberly Clark Saenz
Kimberly Clark Saenz[2] (born November 3, 1973)[3] also known as Kimberly Clark Fowler, is a former licensed practical nurse and a convicted serial killer.[4] She was tried and convicted for killing several patients at a Texas dialysis center by injecting bleach into their dialysis lines.
Kimberly Clark Saenz | |
|---|---|
 2012 Mugshot[1] | |
| Born | Kimberly Clark Fowler November 3, 1973 |
| Occupation | Former licensed practical nurse |
| Children | 2 |
| Criminal charge | Capital murder, aggravated assault |
| Penalty | Life plus 60 years |
| Details | |
| Victims | 10 (5 killed, 5 attempted) |
| Country | United States |
| State(s) | Texas |
Date apprehended | 2008 |
| Imprisoned at | Mountain View Unit of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice |
Background
Saenz was born in Fall River, Massachusetts. By 2007, she had made her way to Lufkin, Texas, where she was hired as a nurse at DaVita's dialysis clinic. She was hired despite a checkered employment history. At the time, she had been fired at least four times from health care jobs. One of those firings came when her bosses at Woodland Heights Hospital caught her stealing Demerol (which was found in her handbag) and cheating on a urine test.[5][6][7]
Saenz was married with two young children. She suffered from drug dependence and used stolen prescription medication.[6] She had been arrested for public intoxication and criminal trespass after a 2007 domestic disturbance with her husband, though the two later reconciled.[7][8]
Suspicion mounts
In the spring of 2008, DaVita's Lufkin clinic saw an unusual spike in patients falling seriously ill during their treatments. Paramedics were called to the clinic 30 times in April – double the number of calls in the past year.[7] For instance, one patient, Thelma Metcalf, had to go to the emergency room several times due to getting too much Heparin blood thinner. More seriously, patients were going into cardiac arrest. The spike in EMS calls was especially unusual since under normal conditions, dialysis patients almost never code.[9]
After two patients, Thelma Metcalf and Clara Strange, died of cardiac arrest on April 1, DaVita sent one of its clinical coordinators, Amy Clinton, to Lufkin to find out what was wrong. However, the problems continued, unnerving paramedics. They passed their concerns on to their superiors at the Lufkin fire department. A department official secretly wrote state health inspectors and asked them to have a look.[7][10]
Investigation
On April 28, 2008; with inspectors on site, two more patients, Marva Rhone and Carolyn Risinger, suffered severe drops in blood pressure. Patients Linda Hall and Lurlene Hamilton subsequently testified that they saw Saenz draw a bleach solution into two syringes, then inject the substance into Rhone and Risinger's dialysis lines. When Clinton confronted Saenz, Saenz said she was cleaning an unused dialysis machine, and used a syringe to get a precise measurement–a method that was contrary to DaVita corporate policy. The bucket Saenz was using, as well as the syringes, tested positive for bleach. Police were called in, and the clinic was shut down for two weeks. After several other syringes used by Saenz tested positive for bleach, she was fired the following day.[7][10] Her nursing license was subsequently suspended.[8] Saenz then applied to work as a receptionist in a Lufkin medical office, in violation of her bail.[8][6]
Research by an epidemiologist at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention revealed that Saenz had been present at every incident in April at which someone died. Almost as damning, a search of Saenz' hard drive revealed Google searches for information about whether bleach could kill. When questioned by police, Saenz mentioned her use of bleach to clean lines before detectives even mentioned bleach. She claimed that there were no measuring cups available, so she had to use a syringe to measure the bleach. She was subsequently arrested on charges of five counts of capital murder and five counts of aggravated assault with a deadly weapon.[9]
According to one of Saenz' co-workers, Candace Lackey, Saenz had expressed dislike for a number of patients, all of whom either died or coded.[7] Another coworker, Sharon Dearmon, recalled that Saenz went on a cigarette break after tending to a patient, Opal Few. Soon afterward, Few coded, but Saenz refused to rush over to tend to her.[9]
Despite the seemingly damning forensic evidence and eyewitness accounts, police and Angelina County prosecutors were at a loss to prove that the bleach had indeed gone from the patients' dialysis lines into their bloodstreams. At the time, almost no research had been done on how to detect bleach in blood. They got in touch with Mark Sochaski, an analytical chemist and bioterrorism expert. He was developing a test for measuring chlorine exposure by measuring the presence of chlorotyrosine, an amino acid formed from exposure to chlorinating agents like bleach. Sochaski tested several samples sent to him by investigators, and discovered chlorotyrosine peaks in nine samples – something that could only be explained by exposure to bleach. When the bleach entered the patients' bloodstream, it caused their red blood cells to explode, which in turn released iron. It was this process, called hemolysis, which caused them to go into cardiac arrest and die.[9]
Conviction
On March 31, 2012, an Angelina County jury convicted Saenz of murdering five patients and injuring five other patients.[11][12] Prosecutors sought the death penalty. However, on April 2, 2012, Saenz was sentenced to five concurrent terms of life imprisonment without the possibility of parole for the five murders, plus three consecutive 20-year sentences for aggravated assault.[4] The five murder victims were Clara Strange, Thelma Metcalf, Garlin Kelley, Cora Bryant and Opal Few.[13]
District attorney Clyde Herrington believed there were more victims than just the ten indicted cases, based on CDC research.[14] The CDC epidemiologist statistically connected Saenz to other adverse health events.[14] Lufkin Police detectives could only obtain medical waste from two weeks prior to April 28, 2008, so there was inadequate evidence to raise further indictments against Saenz in the other incidents.[14] At the victim impact statement portion of the trial, the daughter of victim Thelma Metcalf told Saenz, "You are nothing more than a psychopathic serial killer. I hope you burn in hell".[15]
Saenz's defense team appealed to Twelfth Court of Appeal of Texas.[16][17] However, the appeal was denied.[10]
Saenz; Texas Department of Criminal Justice #01775033 is serving her sentence at Mountain View Unit in Gatesville, Texas.
References
- Angelina County Jail
- Texas Department of Criminal Justice: Offender Details
- http://www.texastribune.org/library/data/texas-prisons/inmates/kimberly-saenz/345403%5B%5D
- KSLA: Jury hands down life sentence for Kim Saenz
- Lufkin Daily News: Jury sentences Saenz to life in prison for killing patients with bleach
- "Nurse's bleach injection deaths trial begins". KIMA-TV. The Associated Press. March 4, 2012.
- Benjamin H. Smith (July 15, 2019). "Texas Nurse Kills 5 Patients After Injecting Bleach Into Their Dialysis Tubes". Oxygen.
- The Age: US nurse sentenced to life in prison over bleach deaths
- License To Kill: Deadly Dialysis (Television Production). United States: Oxygen. 2019.
- Saenz v. State
- CNN: Woman convicted of killing patients with bleach awaits fate
- ABC: Ex-Nurse Convicted of Bleach Killings Awaits Fate
- Lufkin Daily News: Angelina County jury finds Saenz guilty of killing patients at DaVita by injecting dialysis lines with bleach
- Lufkin Daily News: The day Kimberly Saenz got caught
- Nurses Labs: Nurse sentenced to life for killing patients by injecting them with bleach
- KLTV: Jury hands down life sentence for Kim Saenz
- Lufkin Daily News: Serial killer Saenz appeals conviction