Guerrillas and Generals

Guerrillas and Generals[1] is a book written by American Paul H. Lewis.[2] Its subject is the history of Argentina from the 1970s to some years ago. It talks about the Dirty War in Argentina and the trials of Jorge Rafael Videla and other military rulers of Argentina.

Reception

Donald C. Hodges of Florida State University, reviewing the book in Political Science Quarterly, claims that Lewis holds a bias against the guerrillas. He notes, however, that except for the omission of Abraham Guillén the book is a "well documented study".[2]

Ruth Stanley of the Free University of Berlin, in a review of the book for the Journal of Third World Studies, claims that Lewis "appears to believe that guerrilleros who were tortured and disappeared got what they deserved". The review concludes by opining that

[T]his is a work based on published materials that provides no new insights, fails to engage with theoretical debates and offers no analysis of the underlying causes of repression. The author's reliance on anecdote and questionable sources make it unsuitable as an introductory work.[3]

gollark: ...
gollark: … is this where you go on about something something love?
gollark: No, then. I'm not sure how you'd merge with stars. They're quite far away.
gollark: What do you mean "being of enlightenment"?
gollark: That's a bad definition.

References
  1. Lewis, Paul H (2002). Guerrillas and generals : the "Dirty War" in Argentina. Praeger. ISBN 978-0-275-97360-5.
  2. Hodges, Donald C. (Winter 2002–3). "Guerrillas and Generals: The "Dirty War" in Argentina. (Book Reviews)". Political Science Quarterly. 117 (4): 713–4. doi:10.2307/798171. Check date values in: |date= (help)
  3. Stanley, Ruth (2004). ""The Dirty War" in Argentina". Journal of Third World Studies. 21 (2): 263–4.


This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.