The Separate Problem

The Separate Problem is a 1979 book by Judy Jolley Mohraz. It is a collection of case studies of Black education in the Northern United States from 1900-1930.

The Separate Problem
AuthorJudy Jolley Mohraz
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
GenreNonfiction
Published1979
PublisherGreenwood Press
Media typePrint
Pages165
ISBN9780313204111
OCLC4056844

Reception

The book received mixed reviews by critics in academic journals. Leonard L. Hayes III, the director of the Desegregation Policy Studies Unit of the Institute for Services to Education remarked that “The Separate Problem is an excellent source for those persons in search of additional documentation of the efforts put forth by the North to deny blacks access to educational opportunities during the early part of the twentieth century." Hayes III added that "the author’s effective use of the case study methodology is laudable….although she did not make sufficient use of the rich vein of oral historical tools…” He found the writing style to be “lucid” and well organized except for interchangeably using the terms “Negro,” “black,” and “Black."[1]

Diane Ravitch wrote that the book is flawed due to the author's ideological framework and suggests that the problems in the book may have been "mitigated" through the use of interviews with members of the African-American community.[2]

Ronald D. Cohen of the Indiana Magazine of History wrote that the book "heavily influenced by recent revisionist interpretations." He added that the book is helpful but lacks detail. Cohen finds that the book relies on newspapers and public documents in such a way that the details of segregation are generalized. He concludes his review, stating that despite its flaws, the book is "important."[3]

Robert G. Sherer from The American Historical Review finds that “both her [Mohraz] end and her means present theoretical and organizational problems.”[4]

gollark: NONE are safe.
gollark: Interesting! I'm vaguely aware of that! It seems like one of the better ☭s. Although arguably not a ☭.
gollark: Nonsense, there is a shared HTech-GTech™ ([HG]Tech™) cactus farm in a [REDACTED] location.
gollark: I am not aware of "GG policy".
gollark: Containment efforts of the █████ spectre are ongoing.

References
  1. Haynes, Leonard L. (1979). "Review of The Separate Problem: Case Studies of Black Education in the North, 1900- 1930". The Journal of Negro Education. 48 (4): 548–549. doi:10.2307/2295147. JSTOR 2295147.
  2. Ravitch, Diane (1981). "Review of Deep like the Rivers: Education in the Slave Quarter Community, 1831-1865, ; The Separate Problem: Case Studies of Black Education in the North, 1900-1930, ; Schooled to Order: A Social History of Public Schooling in America". The Journal of Interdisciplinary History. 11 (3): 558–561. doi:10.2307/203654. JSTOR 203654.
  3. Cohen, Ronald D. (1980). "Review of Schooled to Order: A Social History of Public Schooling in the United States, ; The Separate Problem: Case Studies of Black Education in the North, 1900-1930". Indiana Magazine of History. 76 (2): 150–152. JSTOR 27790447.
  4. Sherer, Robert G. (1979). "Review of The Separate Problem: Case Studies of Black Education in the North, 1900-1930". The American Historical Review. 84 (5): 1487–1487. doi:10.2307/1861687. JSTOR 1861687.
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.