Strathclyde RC v Wallace

Strathclyde RC v Wallace [1998] 1 WLR 259 is a UK labour law case concerning indirect discrimination and equal pay.

Strathclyde RC v Wallace
CourtHouse of Lords
Citation(s)[1998] 1 WLR 259, [1996] IRLR 670
Transcript(s)judgment
Keywords
Indirect discrimination, equal pay

Facts

Teachers wanted equal pay as head teachers when they had to ‘act up’ or fill in for the heads (even though they were not formally appointed). Most of the teachers who acted up were in fact men.

The Tribunal held the women did have a claim, even though none of the factors relied were discriminatory (acting up teachers also being men). The EAT overruled, and the women claimants were unsuccessful on appeal.

Judgment

The House of Lords refused the teachers' claim. Lord Browne-Wilkinson said ‘the purpose of the section 1 of the Equal Pay Act is to eliminate sex discrimination in pay not to achieve fair wages’.

The selection by the applicants in this case of male principal teachers as comparators was purely the result of a tactical selection by these appellants: there are male and female principal teachers employed by the respondents without discrimination. Therefore the objective sought by the appellants is to achieve equal pay for like work regardless of sex, not to eliminate any inequalities due to sex discrimination. There is no such discrimination in the present case.

gollark: I think cryptocurrency with proof of work is impressive in how it manages to make people burn vast amounts of resources on slightly reallocating mining reward, and scalpers are just people exploiting retailers' incorrect unwillingness to raise prices.
gollark: But incentives reduce it, in my IMO.
gollark: I don't consider scalping very bad in the first place.
gollark: If someone does something due to incentives pushing them to do so, I would blame them slightly less.
gollark: More seriously: I don't think the blame thing is entirely binary.

See also
  • UK labour law
  • UK employment equality law

Notes

    References
        This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.