Stovin v Wise

Stovin v Wise [1996] UKHL 15 is an English tort law case about a highway authority's liability in negligence. The majority speech of Lord Hoffmann contains important principles about omissions liability and the liability of public authorities.

Stovin v Wise
CourtHouse of Lords
Full case nameStovin v Wise (Norfolk County Council, third party)
Decided24 July 1996
Citation(s)
Case history
Appealed fromCourt of Appeal
Court membership
Judges sitting
  • Lord Goff
  • Lord Jauncey
  • Lord Slynn
  • Lord Nicholls
  • Lord Hoffmann
Keywords

Facts

Ms Wise was turning right at an acute intersection in Wymondham. Her view was obscured by an earthen bank which the Norfolk County Council's highway authority had earmarked for removal but since neglected. Ms Wise pulled into the road as Mr Stovin was approaching at speed on his motorbike. Unable to slow down in time, he crashed into Ms Wise's vehicle.

Judgment

Mr Stovin successfully sued Ms Wise in negligence. The High Court held her 70% to blame for the accident, and the Council 30%. The question on appeal was solely whether the Council could indeed be liable. The Court of Appeal of England and Wales held that it was.

House of Lords

The House of Lords upheld the Council's appeal, finding that no duty of care requiring them to remove the earthen bank existed. Lord Hoffmann wrote the majority opinion (with Lords Goff and Jauncey concurring). Lord Nicholls dissented (with Lord Slynn concurring).

Legacy

Stovin v Wise is a decision of major significance in the development of negligence liability in English law. It deals with both the liability of state defendants and liability for omissions; the case exemplifies, and helped to establish, English law's conservative attitude to both.


gollark: One cool idea I had was a semi-automated market using Plethora to move items around between chests, using computers.
gollark: If you want concrete to be cheaper, then according to economic theoryâ„¢ you should... buy less of it, or sell some?
gollark: Okay, wow, that's expensive, I'm not going *there* for it.
gollark: I suppose that may be an alternative to using some old Keansian surplus equipment which makes it.
gollark: Oh, is Lemmmy's shop up again?
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.