St. Paul's Anglican Church, Vancouver

St. Paul's Anglican Church serves the south-west downtown peninsula of Vancouver, British Columbia, (the West End and Yaletown neighbourhoods) alongside Christ Church Cathedral (established 1888) serving the north-east (Downtown and Coal Harbour neighbourhoods). Both parishes separated from St. James (established 1881), the first Anglican Church in Granville, as Vancouver was then known.[1]

St Paul's Anglican Church
St Paul's church with the parish hall (right) and the Pendrellis apartment building (left), 2015
Location	Vancouver, British Columbia
Country	Canada
Denomination	Anglican Church of Canada
Administration
Deanery	Kingsway
Archdeaconry	Burrard
Diocese	New Westminster
Province	Ecclesiastical Province of British Columbia and the Yukon
Clergy
Archbishop	The Most Rev'd Melissa Skelton, Archbishop of New Westminster
Rector	The Rev'd Philip Cochrane

Early history

Church buildings

The Anglican Parish of St Paul was established at a time when the population of Vancouver was rapidly expanding. In response to a demand from a small group of St James' parishioners, a vacant lot was purchased and a daughter church was built in 1889. The parish was established in 1891.[2] The church was located at the centre of the geographically-defined parish, but in 1898 it was placed on skids and moved north-west, away from railway yards in Yaletown and closer to where most parishioners lived in the West End.[3] In 1905, it was replaced by a larger church, and the old church became the parish hall.

The new church on the site of the old church with the old church re-located alongside to become the parish hall, 1905

The new church was built in Gothic revival style with pointed-arch windows and doors, following the traditional lines of an English parish church, something that would have been familiar to most of the parishioners at the time, or to their parents.

The church had eighteen windows (not including clerestory windows), all except three glazed with leaded lights. Stained glass was fitted in windows in the east wall (portraying St Paul preaching in Athens), the west wall (St Peter with Dorcas doing good works), and the north transept (Faith, Hope and Charity). Between 1952 and 1964, nine more windows were fitted with stained glass, all in some way portraying Christ. Until 1952, the only portrayal of Christ in the church had been a print showing Jesus as a small boy.[4]

The church pipe organ, Opus 264 by Casavant Frères of Québec, is said to be the first to be constructed west of the Rockies.[5]

The old church was replaced by a new parish hall and a rectory in 1911. In 1929, the rectory was re-located to allow the hall to be extended. By then, the site at the corner of Jervis Street and Pendrell Street had assumed its present configuration, except for a wheelchair ramp added in 2002.[6]

Mortgage costs associated with extending the parish hall were exacerbated by the mid-thirties depression. Optimism, and finances, revived after the Second World War and the mortgage was ceremoniously burned in 1945.

Godfrey Gower (centre) and parish officials burn the mortgage on the parish hall, 1945

During the 1960s a plan to build a car park was frustrated by the City of Vancouver. Instead, the parish built, and in 1973 opened, a high-rise apartment building for accommodating seniors at subsidised rents.[7]

Parish clergy

The first rector, Ernest Flewelling (1891 - 1894), was followed by Thomas Outerbridge and Henry Bowers, both briefly, and then by Harold Underhill (1896 - 1908) during whose incumbency the new church was built. He was followed by Adam de Pencier (1908 – 1910), who resigned to become Bishop of New Westminster, then Frederick Chadwick (1910 - 1913) and then the seventh and lonest-serving rector, Harold King (1914 - 1944). As the Second World War ended Godfrey Gower (1944 – 1951) became rector, resigning to become Bishop of New Westminster, and he was succeeded by Patrick Ellis (1951 - 1960) and then Joe Ellis (1960 - 1973).

Parish activities

From its founding, the parish thrived by serving a large and relatively prosperous middle-class membership. The parish followed a traditional Anglican Sunday liturgical pattern of Holy Communion, Morning Prayer and Evensong, and sponsored well-supported educational and social activities like Sunday Schools, Ladies’ and Men’s Guilds, scouts and guides and youth groups.

Liturgical practice tended to be conservative. The introduction of a processional cross in 1931 was contentious,[8] and even more so was the introduction of women into the choir in 1933.[9]

Post-1980 changes

As the centennial of the parish approached the eleventh rector, Harold McSherry (1973 - 1984), retired. In the search for his successor, a profile was prepared describing how the character of the West End of Vancouver[10] had changed significantly since the parish had been established.[11] The situation was summarised thus:

"In the 1950s, developers began pulling down the old family houses of the West End to make room for apartment buildings. The composition of the population changed with the changes in residential housing and the population density increased to become one of the highest in Canada. Old-style families were replaced by single-parent families, who were joined by previously unknown (or, at least, unrecognized) residents like gays and lesbians and unmarried couples living together. For most of these persons St Paul’s was perceived as irrelevant, if not invisible, and to some as passively or actively hostile." [12]

In 1985, David Crawley (1985–1990) was appointed rector, setting in process significant reforms of pastoral ministries (particularly the services offered by St Paul's to those who did not count themselves as its members) and liturgical practices (the rituals it used in its forms of worship).

New ministries

Foremost of all, Crawley initiated a ministry to members of the LGBT community,[13] many of whom were at that time facing the challenges of the AIDS crisis. He and his assistant priest, Neil Gray who became Crawley' successor (1991 - 2003), opened up the parish to the wider community and co-operated with other agencies like St Paul's Hospital[14] and AIDS Vancouver.[15] In reflecting upon this experience, Crawley later wrote: "St Paul's had not so much found a mission as it had regained its soul"[16]

As the AIDS crisis receded, Gray set about consolidating the positive response received from the LGBT community by advocating at the 1998 synod of the Diocese of New Westminster for permission to bless covenanted same-sex relationships. The initiative achieved the immediate success of a favourable vote, but it was not sufficiently favourable to win the consent of Bishop Michael Ingham. Permission was sought again in 2001, with an even more favourable outcome, leading in 2002 to episcopal consent.

The result had repercussions throughout the international Anglican Communion, meriting among other responses a rebuke from the then Archbishop of Canterbury, George Carey. Ingham expressed his own position thus:

"In many places around the world homosexual people are still treated as criminals and even worse, and in some instances with the support of the church. We regret this [. . . ] and express our sadness and disquiet at their suffering, and hope that our actions in this part of the world may bring comfort and relief to those millions of people who look to the church for safety and support instead of judgement and condemnation."[17]

In 2004, the then assistant priest, Dale Yardy, officiated at the first Blessing of a Covenanted Union of a same-sex couple in St Paul's.[18]

In 1995, St Paul's Advocacy Office was established to provide support and information for people facing problems associated with government benefits, tenancy disputes, immigration, and the like. From its inception, the program has been operated by a salaried director and volunteer associates (most of whom are not members of the parish), conducting as many as four thousand interviews in a year with clients from a wide area.[19]

St Paul's played a major role in the re-introduction of labyrinth-walking as a meditative technique.

General view of the replica of the Chartres labyrinth painted on the floor of the parish hall

In 1997, under the direction of the then assistant priest, April Stanley, a 13-metre, full-scale replica of the medieval labyrinth found at Chartres Cathedral in France was painted on the floor of the parish hall to become the first permanent indoor labyrinth in Canada. Very soon, the number of individual visits to the labyrinth exceeded four thousand a year, mostly by persons who were not members of St Paul's.[20]

Liturgical developments

Significant changes to liturgical practices began in 1981 when a contemporary-language Eucharistic rite was used at St Paul's for the first time. In 1986, a Eucharistic celebration additional to the traditional early-morning celebration (using the Book of Common Prayer) was introduced using the Book of Alternative Services. At the same time the Eucharist gradually displaced Morning Prayer at the principal Sunday morning service, Morning Prayer being used for the last time in 1995.[21]

A survey of the parishes of the Diocese of New Westminster completed in 2015 suggested that these trends were common throughout the diocese.[22]

Gray's successor, Markus Dünzkofer (2004 – 2012), made decreasing use of the Book of Common Prayer at the principal Sunday morning service, cutting back to three times a year by 2013.[23] In 2014, when Dünzkofer's successor, Jessica Schaap (2013 – 2017), discontinued the early-morning Eucharistic celebration for lack of attendance, regular use of the Book of Common Prayer ceased completely.

In 1986, Crawley moved the high altar away from the east wall so that the celebrant could face the people.

Yazeed Said celebrates Eucharist with the congregation gathered around the altar standing in the chancel

He also introduced a portable altar which could be placed in the chancel or the nave, and he and his successors made increasing use of it for celebrating Eucharist in a more intimate manner.[24]

During this period, icons and votive candles were introduced into the church, and an aumbry was installed allowing for reservation of the consecrated Bread and Wine for use in administering Communion to sick parishioners. Practices like Exchanging the Peace were introduced, together with ceremonies like Washing of Feet on Maundy Thursday, all of which increased the level of participation in the Eucharistic celebration by members of the congregation.[25]

Of all the developments, the most significant was the changing role of women. In 1976, the then Bishop of New Westminster, David Somerville, ordained women as priests for the first time in the diocese. In 1982, Eucharist was celebrated at St Paul's for the first time by a woman priest, Barbara Blakely. In 1990 a woman, Helen Patterson, was first appointed to the clerical staff, and she was succeeded as assistant priest by several other women. In 2013, Jessica Schaap became the first woman to be appointed rector.[26]

Membership

The church was built at a time when church attendance was normal practice, and attendance increased as the population increased. In 1914, for example, the number of Easter communicants (the customary criterion for Anglican membership) reached almost one thousand.[27] The second church had been built to accommodate growing membership, and as late as 1928 the need for more seating remained a topic for debate.[28] The next year, a proposal for a third, larger, church was prepared, but never implemented.[29]

The membership was largely (if not completely) of British origin. Until 1955, St Paul’s was part of the Church of England in Canada, a body referred to in a brochure published in 1929 as “the Mother Church of the English-speaking race”.[30]

Since 1955, St Paul’s has been part of the then renamed Anglican Church of Canada/l'Eglise anglicane du Canada.

As the 1960s passed, membership fell (in step with those of all mainline churches in Canada) but became more diverse in terms of ethnic origin, maternal language, sexual orientation, gender identity, confessional upbringing, and social class.

References

1. Leslie Buck (2019), Peace be to the whole community: The story of St Paul's Anglican Church in the West End of Vancouver, Vancouver: Second City Print Solutions, ISBN 978-1-77136-761-5.
2. Buck, op.cit., page 5.
3. Buck, op.cit., page 7
4. Buck, op.cit., page 16.
5. Buck, op.cit., page 15.
6. Buck, op.cit., chapter 4.
7. Buck, op.cit, page 31.
8. Parish Archives, Folder D22/1.6, Minutes dated 20 April 1931.
9. Buck, op.cit., page 42.
10. At the time few people lived in the Yaletown neighbourhood.
11. Parish Archives, Folder D11/2.1.
12. Buck, op.cit., page 50.
13. David Crawley, A Parish Transformed. In Charles Hefling (Ed), Our Selves, Our Souls and Bodies. Cambridge, Mass: Cowley Publications.
14. The sharing of the name is quite coincidental.
15. Buck, op.cit., page 73.
16. Crawley, op.cit., page 207.
17. Minutes of the 101st Diocesan Synod, 2003. Synod Journal, 2004.
18. Buck, op.cit., page 84.
19. Buck, op.cit., chapter 12.
20. Buck, op.cit., chapter 14.
21. Buck, op.cit., chapter 7.
22. Buck, Leslie, "What's in a name?" Topic (Diocesan newspaper), March 2015
23. Buck, op.cit., page 56.
24. Buck, op.cit., page 52.
25. Buck, op.cit., chapter 7,
26. Buck, op.cit., page 45.
27. Buck, op.cit., page 65
28. Buck, op.cit., page 17
29. Parish Archive, Folder D71/1.5.
30. St Paul’s Church Forward Movement 1929

External links

• St. Paul's Anglican Church
• Diocese of New Westminster