Melbourne University Law Review
The Melbourne University Law Review is a triannual law journal published by a student group at Melbourne Law School covering all areas of law. It is one of two student-run law journals at the University of Melbourne, the other being the Melbourne Journal of International Law. Students who have completed at least one semester of law are eligible to apply for membership of the editorial board. Applicants are assessed on the basis of their performance in a practical exercise, academic aptitude, proofreading skills, editing skills and enthusiasm. The 2020 editors-in-chief are Priyanka Banerjee, Nicholas Felstead and Daniel Lopez.[1]
| Discipline | Law |
|---|---|
| Language | English |
| Edited by | Priyanka Banerjee, Nicholas Felstead and Daniel Lopez |
| Publication details | |
Former name(s) | The Summons; Res Judicatae |
| History | 1957–present |
| Publisher | Melbourne University Law Review Association (Australia) |
| Frequency | Triannually |
| Standard abbreviations | |
| Bluebook | Melb. U. L. Rev. |
| ISO 4 | Melb. Univ. Law Rev. |
| Indexing | |
| ISSN | 0025-8938 |
| LCCN | sf84007069 |
| OCLC no. | 60630207 |
| Links | |
Occasionally, the review produces a symposium issue devoted to a particular aspect of law. Past symposium issues have focused on the centenary of the federation of Australia, contemporary human rights in Australia, and tort law. The Review's alumni include two High Court Justices, three Solicitors-General, five Federal Court judges and at least six Supreme Court judges.
Rankings
The journal has been awarded an A* ranking by the Australian Business Law Deans Council.[2]
History
The Summons
The first periodical published at the Melbourne Law School was The Summons. It appeared with the subtitle A Magazine of Legal and General Literature and was published by the Articled Law Clerks' Society of Victoria between 1891 and 1903. It was a yellow-covered sixteen-page journal depicting an angel with a trumpet on its cover and served as more of a current affairs magazine than an academic journal, publishing reports of moots and discussing topical issues, which at the time included the fusion of the two branches of the Victorian legal profession and the admission of women.
Res Judicatae
In 1935, the students of the Faculty of Law established Res Judicatae — roughly translated as "things that have been judicially adjudicated on" — which was intended to provide a forum for discussion and debate among students of the law. Published by the Law Students' Society of Victoria, it focused on legal journalism.
Notable publications include C S Lewis on 'The Humanitarian Theory of Punishment',[3] Owen Dixon on 'De Facto Officers',[4] H V Evatt on 'Amending the Constitution',[5] John Latham on 'The Law Student',[6] and the re-printing of Frank Gavan Duffy's poem, 'A Dream of Fair Judges' (originally published in The Summons).[7]
Melbourne University Law Review
In 1957, Zelman Cowen (then dean of the faculty and later governor-general of Australia) re-established the journal along the model of the Harvard Law Review and renamed it the Melbourne University Law Review. In line with prevailing American practice, top ranking law students were invited to become members of the editorial board. In 1998, the number of issues published each year was increased from two to three.
Alumni
Notable alumni of the Melbourne University Law Review include:[8]
- Kenneth Hayne, former Justice of the High Court of Australia, editor 1966
- Keith Aickin, former Justice of the High Court of Australia, editor 1939 (Res Judicatae)
Federal Court
- Susan Kenny, Justice of the Federal Court of Australia, editor 1976
- Mark Moshinsky, Justice of the Federal Court of Australia, editor 1987
- John Middleton, Justice of the Federal Court of Australia, assistant editor 1974
- Alan Goldberg AO, former Justice of the Federal Court of Australia, editor 1961
- Ronald Sackville, former Justice of the Federal Court of Australia, editor 1962
Supreme Court
- Stephen McLeish, Justice of the Supreme Court of Victoria, editor 1984
- Emilios Kyrou, Justice of the Supreme Court of Victoria, assistant editor 1981
- Philip Mandie, former Justice of the Supreme Court of Victoria, editor 1964
- William Ormiston, former Justice of the Supreme Court of Victoria, business manager 1957
- Frank Callaway, former Justice of the Supreme Court of Victoria, editor 1967
- John Winneke, former Justice of the Supreme Court of Victoria, President of the Court of Appeal, member 1958–60
- John Phillips, former Justice of the Supreme Court of Victoria, editor 1957
Solicitors-General
- Stephen Donaghue, Solicitor-General of Australia, editor 1995
- Gavan Griffith, Solicitor-General of Australia, editor 1962
- Stephen McLeish, Solicitor-General of Victoria, editor 1984
Barristers
- Allan Myers, Queen's Counsel, editor 1969
- Alan Archibald, Queen's Counsel, case note editor 1967
- Neil Young, Queen's Counsel, assistant editor 1973
- Robert Richter, Queen's Counsel, editor 1966
- Jason Pizer, Queen's Counsel, editor 1992
- Kristen Walker, Queen's Counsel, editor 1991
Politicians
- Gareth Evans, former Commonwealth Minister for Foreign Affairs, member 1965–6
- Lindsay Tanner, former Minister for Finance and Deregulation, member 1979–81
- Robert Clark, former Victorian Attorney-General, member 1981
Academics
- Arie Freiberg, Dean of Monash University Faculty of Law, member
- Hilary Charlesworth, law professor at University of Melbourne, editor 1979
- Simon Chesterman, Dean of National University of Singapore Faculty of Law
- Allan Myers, Chancellor of the University of Melbourne, editor 1969
- Anne Twomey, Professor of Constitutional Law at University of Sydney, editor 1988
- Kim Rubenstein, Professor of Constitutional and Administrative Law at Australian National University, editor 1987
- Dr Jim Minifie, economist at the Grattan Institute, editor 1989
Writers
- Anna Funder, author of Stasiland, editor 1991
Australian Guide to Legal Citation
In collaboration with the Melbourne Journal of International Law, the journal publishes the Australian Guide to Legal Citation.
References
- Melbourne Law School, the University of Melbourne. "MLS Honour Board". Melbourne Law School. Retrieved 12 February 2020.
- Australian Business Deans Council, (ABDC). "Journal Quality List". Australian Business Deans Council. Retrieved 12 February 2020.
- Lewis, CS. "The Humanitarian Theory of Punishment". (1954) 6 Res Judicatae 224.
- Dixon, Owen. "De Facto Officers". (1938) 1 Res Judicatae 285.
- Evatt, H V. "Amending the Constitution". (1938) 1 Res Judicatae 264.
- Latham, John. "The Law Student". (1938) 1 Res Judicatae 253.
- Gavan Duffy, Frank. "A Dream of Fair Judges". (1938) 1 Res Judicatae 183.
- "Past editors". Melbourne University Law Review.