Louis Loyzeau de Grandmaison

Louis Loyzeau de Grandmaison (born 21 January 1861 - died 18 February 1915) was a French military theorist who in an atmosphere of revanchism, linked the shattering humiliation of the Franco-Prussian War to the French having ceased to use Napoleonic methods. De Grandmaison argued for rapid maneuver by large formations employing a high tempo attack and the school of thought he subscribed to dominated French army thinking by 1914, but in a degenerated form that melded into the contemporaneous philosophy of Élan vital. and proved no match for modern weapons. He was a member of Nichan Iftikhar (Order of Glory), a Tunisian honorary order.

Career and political background

Commissioned in 1883, de Grandmaison served in light, mountain, and Foreign Legion infantry units before--benefiting from meritocratic promotion--he he was admitted on a course to qualify as a staff officer. He was a favourite pupil of Ferdinand Foch, who characterised war as a battle of the will. Assigned to the General Staff in 1906, he began building on Foch's ideas with intensified emphasis on operational mobility and seizing the initiative.[1]

The French army rifle was the Lebel Model 1886 rifle with a 20 ½ inch bayonet. German heavy guns had been unveiled in 1900, but under the influence of Hippolyte Langlois France had concentrated on mobile shrapnel firing Canon de 75 modèle 1897 with a flat trajectory that left crews exposed instead of the high explosive lobbing howitzers. In 1911 French army chief Victor-Constant Michels proposed returning to the established pattern of French army plans for defensive strategy in a war with Germany. He proposed deploying a million-strong French army on a line Verdun-Namur-Antwerp to counter the anticipated German offensive. In order to field an army of this size French reserve units would need to be integrated with the active army immediately on mobilisation.[2]. Michels had presciently identified where the German attack was to come three later, but he ran afoul of the regular army contempt for reserve officers, and politicians who wanted to recover France's lost provinces.[3] The fortresses that were to bear the brunt of a German attack were garrisoned by low quality reservist units, because the High Command considered use of regular troops on non-offensive assignments as redundant.[4][5]

Using the controversy to discredit what he saw as conservative opposition to the new aggressive style of waging war, operations director Lt Col de Grandmaison published a book including two of his lectures to officers of the General Staff that could be read as advocating headstrong all out attack, although being to such senior officers the talks had clearly been about handling very large formations.[6] An earlier book of de Grandmaison about infantry tactics written when he was a major did seem to be dismissive of attacks not made with the bayonet.[7][2][8]

The reaction to de Grandmaison's intervention was entirely favourable and Michel, who had advocated economy of force holding action along the border with Alsace and Lorraine, was dismissed and replaced as French army commander by the offensive minded Joseph Joffre, who bought in new regulations mandating commanders to privilege the offensive.[2] He also charged Plan XVII to incorporate an immediate French invasion of Alsace-Lorraine.[9] Joffre was strongly supported by Raymond Poincaré as President of the Republic, his election in 1913, had been helped by two million francs in Russian bribes to the French press.[10] Poincaré anticipated war in two years and announced that his entire effort was to prepare for i.[11]

Explaining the 1870 defeat of France as the result of its drift towards a spirit of defence started to be presented as a way of winning back the lost provinces through overcoming modern long range rifle and artillery fire by will and elan.[12] Thus corrupted, his teachings were taken up with alacrity and had become received wisdom in the French army by late 1911, when de Grandmaison was rewarded with promotion to colonel and command of the crack 153rd regiment.[13] A hoax by Edmond Buat (who falsely claimed to have found the German war plan under his seat on a train) was widely accepted and the French line along the Belgian frontier was denuded by Joffre at the beginning of hostilities.[14]

First World War

In the fighting of August 1914 de Grandmaison was wounded three times in 24 hours.[15] The huge casualties for no gains during the early months of WW1 resulting from crude offensive à outrance attacks on Lorraine created a pessimistic climate of public opinion, while the death of so many of the army's best and most determined young officers had lasting deleterious effects.[16][17] Apologists for Joffre's botched dispositions in the first month of the war pointed to him lacking useful intelligence on the intentions of Germany toward Verdun, but Michels had been sacked for a proposal to defend Verdun that correctly anticipated the Schlieffen Plan[18][19]

While now often seen as having been a disastrous misstep in tactical doctrine, the pre war reforms de Grandmaison was at least spokesman for have been given credit for being instrumental in swift operational level movement of reserves to meet German offensives, and so the doctrine's effect may have been somewhat ambiguous. Another defence of de Grandmaison is his General Staff lectures were taken as applying to the company level which they could hardly have been to such senior officers, he was not of sufficient rank to implement those views, and him being dead made him a ideal scapegoat.[20] In Jan 1915 de Grandmaison's post 1911 meteoric ascent continued when he received promotion to Major General, being given command of Fifth Army Reserve group. He was killed in action the next month.[21][22][23]

References

1. Historical Perspectives of the Operational Art. Michael D. Krause, R. Cody Phillips, Center of Military History U S Army (2005)
2. Tuchman, Barbara (2014). The Guns of August. Penguin. p. 40. ISBN 9780241968215.
3. Historical Perspectives of the Operational Art. Michael D. Krause, R. Cody Phillips, Center of Military History U S Army (2005)
4. World War I: A Student Encyclopedia By Spencer Tucker
5. No Other Law: The French Army and the Doctrine of the Offensive Charles W. Saunders (1987)
6. Marshal Joffre: The Triumphs, Failures and Controversies, André Bourachot (2014)
7. Historical Perspectives of the Operational Art. Michael D. Krause, R. Cody Phillips, Center of Military History U S Army (2005)
8. No Other Law: The French Army and the Doctrine of the Offensive Charles W. Saunders (1987)
9. The Sleepwalkers: How Europe Went to War in 1914., Christopher Clark (2014)
10. McMeekin, Sean (2014). July 1914: Countdown to War. New York: Basic Books. ISBN 978-0465060740.p66
11. Zuber, Terence (2014). "France and the Cause of World War I". Global War Studies. 11 (3): 51–63. doi:10.5893/19498489.11.03.03. p53
12. Historical Perspectives of the Operational Art. Michael D. Krause, R. Cody Phillips, Center of Military History U S Army (2005)
13. World War I: The Definitive Encyclopedia and Document Collection.edited by Spencer C. Tucker (2006) p668
14. No Other Law: The French Army and the Doctrine of the Offensive Charles W. Saunders (1987)
15. Marshal Joffre: The Triumphs, Failures and Controversies, André Bourachot (2014)
16. Historical Perspectives of the Operational Art. Michael D. Krause, R. Cody Phillips, Center of Military History U S Army (2005)
17. World War I: A Student Encyclopedia By Spencer Tucker
18. Marshal Joffre: The Triumphs, Failures and Controversies, André Bourachot (2014)
19. Historical Perspectives of the Operational Art. Michael D. Krause, R. Cody Phillips, Center of Military History U S Army (2005)
20. Marshal Joffre: The Triumphs, Failures and Controversies, André Bourachot (2014)
21. Historical Perspectives of the Operational Art. Michael D. Krause, R. Cody Phillips, Center of Military History U S Army (2005)
22. World War I: A Student Encyclopedia By Spencer Tucker
23. No Other Law: The French Army and the Doctrine of the Offensive Charles W. Saunders (1987)

External links

• http://ww1blog.osborneink.com/?p=5796