Jus trium liberorum

The ius trium liberorum, meaning "the right of three children" in Latin,[1] was a privilege rewarded to Roman citizens who had produced at least three children or freedmen of both sexes who had produced at least four children.[2] It was a direct result of the Lex Iulia and the Lex Papia Poppaea, laws introduced by Augustus in 18 BC and 9 AD, respectively.[3] These laws were intended to increase the dwindling population of the Roman upper classes.

Roman Statue of Augustus

The intent of the ius trium liberorum has led scholars to interpret it as eugenic legislation.[4] This interpretation is long outdated, however. Most current scholarship sees the law as a politically-motivated effort to increase birth rates among the senatorial class.[5] Men who had received the jus trium liberorum were excused from munera (compulsory services). Women with jus trium liberorum were no longer subject to tutela mulierum (guardianship by a male relative) and could receive inheritances which would otherwise descend to their children.[6]

The senatorial reaction to the jus trium liberorum was largely to find loopholes, however. The prospect of having a large family was still not appealing.[7] A person who caught a citizen in violation in this law was entitled to a portion of the inheritance involved, creating a lucrative business for professional spies.[8] The spies became so pervasive that the reward was reduced to a quarter of its previous size.[9] As time went on, the ius trium liberorum was granted by consuls to some citizens as rewards for general good deeds, holding important professions or as personal favors, not just prolific propagation.[10] Eventually the ius trium liberorum was repealed in 534 AD by Justinian.[11]

Background

During the Augustan period the upper classes, the senatorial and equestrian orders, were diminishing in number. These classes formed the backbone of the state, forming the empire's civil and military administration. The classes’ populations had been affected by the recent civil wars, proscription, and most importantly, low birth rates within the classes. The decrease in birth rate was even more dramatic than is typical for the increase in Rome's development.[12] The Lex Iulia and the Papia Poppaea had been able to increase marriage rates within the upper classes, but the birthrate had not increased enough through these bodies of legislation alone. For this reason the jus trium liberorum was enacted.[13]

Eugenic implications

It is important to note that Italy's population as a whole was not decreasing. In fact, it may have been increasing. The growth in population was largely due to the influx of slaves from outside of Italy, especially Eastern Europe. The jus trium liberorum, therefore, has been called a eugenic measure by scholars as it specifically worked toward increasing a specific population deemed desirable.[14] It is argued that the aspect of population growth in the jus trium liberorum was a secondary intention.[15] It is important that the jus trium liberorum is kept in the context of the Lex Iulia and the Papia Poppaea, which dealt with issues concerning racial purity within these classes, like appropriate marriage partners.[16] James A Field equated the jus trium liberorum to the Third Reich’s decree by which a Jew might become an honorary Aryan in his article "The Purpose of the Lex Iulia et Papia Poppaea."[17]

Legal specifics

The jus trium liberorum was a reward gained by compliance with the Lex Iulia and Papia Poppea. The privilege concerned both genders, but impacted women more than men. The specifics of the jus trium liberorum is defined as follows in Adolf Berger's Encyclopedia of Roman Law:

Fathers might claim exemption (excusatio) from public charges and from guardianship to which they were called by law (tutela legitima). The most important application of jus liberorum concerned women. A freeborn woman with three children and a freedwoman with four children (jus trium vel quattuor liberorum) were freed from guardianship to which women were subject (tutela mulierum) and had a right of succession to the inheritance of their children. The women’s jus liberorum was applied even when the children were no longer alive.[18]

In short this meant that a man could not be forced to take over the obligation of guardianship of a woman, legally a minor, that he would otherwise be obligated under the tutela mulierum.[19] Women who had the appropriate number of children no longer needed to have a guardian as they would under the tutela mulierum. This meant that when a woman was no longer subject to the power of her father (patria potestas) or her husband (manus) she could act independently.[20] She also gained the right to inheritance that would have otherwise been awarded to her children. Often this meant that she inherited and owned her husband's estate upon his death.[21] As stated above children did not need to be alive for them to count toward the jus liberorum. Legitimate children were counted for men and women. Children born to an unknown father (spurius) did count toward a woman's number of children under the jus trium liberorum.[22] A child considered to be a portentum (literally a monster or monstrous being[23]) was not considered to be a human but still counted toward the mother's number of children under the jus trium liberorum. Both parents could count a child deemed a portentum under the laws against childless parents in the Lex Iulia and Papia Poppaea, however.[24]

Impact

After being enacted this right was considered valuable, but it soon became a privilege unconnected with three or more births to a citizen. Many people did not want the burden of children, but still sought the jus trium liberorum. This enticed many people to exploit loopholes in the law, which was often accomplished through illegal means. A reward consisting of a percentage of the inheritance involved was offered for spies who caught others illegally benefitting from the jus trium liberorum. This reward created a large number of spies due to the lucrative rewards. To reduce the problem of spies the reward was then reduced to a quarter of its previous size.[25] The jus trium liberorum was also awarded to people in no connection with their number of offspring as a reward by the emperor. Often it was awarded in connection with a good deed, military service or as a personal favor.[26] Many famous Romans were awarded the jus trium liberorum including Suetonius through a personal favor from Trajan to Pliny the Younger,[27] Martial by Domitian in reward to Martial's flattery,[28] and to Livia in response of the death of Drusus in 9 BCE.[29] Owners of large ships were also granted the jus trium liberorum under the Empire.[30] The jus trium liberorum was eventually repealed by Justinian in 534 CE.[31]

Notes

1. Perseus Digital Library Project
2. Berger, pg. 530
3. Yue, pg. 685
4. Field, pg. 398-399
5. Kaius Tuori "Augustus, Legislative Power, and the Power of Appearances," in Fundaminia 20:2 2014, 942-3
6. Berger, pg. 530
7. Field, pg. 408
8. Yue, pg. 686
9. Field, pg. 412
10. Field, pg. 408
11. Field, pg. 398
12. Field, pg. 399
13. Field, pg. 402
14. Field, pg. 398 - 399
15. Field, pg. 414
16. Berger, pg. 553 - 554
17. pg. 408
18. Berger, pg. 530
19. Yue, pg. 683
20. Berger, pg. 748
21. Field, pg. 408
22. Berger, pg. 714
23. Perseus Digital Library Project
24. Berger, 636
25. Field, pg. 412 - 413
26. Field, pg. 408
27. Dunham, pg. 421 - 422
28. Clarke, pg. 47
29. Field, pg. 408
30. Berger, 592 - 593
31. Field, pg. 398

Bibliography

NOTE: Most of this scholarship is grossly outdated, serious revisions to both the entry and the scholarship used is recommended

• Berger, Adolf. "Encyclopedic Dictionary of Roman Law." Transactions of the American Philosophical Society. ns. 43.2 (1953)
• Clarke, M. L.. "Poets and Patrons at Rome." Greece & Rome. 2nd ser. 25.1 (1978): 46-54.
• Dunham, Fred S.. "The Younger Pliny, Gentleman and Citizen." The Classical Journal. 40.7 (1945): 417-426.
• Field, James A. Jr.. "The Purpose of the Lex Iulia et Papia Poppaea." The Classical Journal. 40.7 (1945)
• Tuori, Kaius. "Augustus, Legislative Power, and the Power of appearances." Fundamina 20.2 (2014): 938-945.
• Yue, Esther. "Mirror Reading and Guardians of Women in the Early Roman Empire." Journal of Theological Studies. 59.2 (2008)

Please note:

The jus trium liberorum is often called the ius liberorum.

Classical latin made no distinction between i and j so it may also be correctly named the ius trium liberorum or the ius liberorum.