Joseph Barnard Davis

Joseph Barnard Davis (1801 – 19 May 1881) was an English medical doctor now remembered as a collector and craniologist.

Joseph Barnard Davis

Life

In the summer of 1820, while still a student, he went as a surgeon in a whaling ship to the Arctic seas. Obtaining the Apothecaries' Hall qualification in 1823, it was not till twenty years later that he became a member of the College of Surgeons. In 1862 he graduated M.D. at the University of St Andrews. He early settled at Albion Street Shelton, Staffordshire (now Hanley), and was a medical practitioner till his death on 19th May 1881. He was elected a Fellow of the Royal Society in 1868.[1]

He was active in local life and was an important member of the Athenaeum, Stoke-upon-Trent. As such he played a part in establishing the first Museum of the Natural History, Pottery and Antiquities.

Collection and works

In 1836 he published a Popular Manual of the Art of Preserving Health.[1]

Davis collected a museum of skulls and skeletons of various races, nearly all with histories;[1] it was larger than all the collections in British public museums put together, numbering 1474 in 1867.[2] His personal collection began with two skulls bought from Matthew Moorhouse in 1848.[3] He purchased from the collection of James De Ville (Deville), a phrenologist.[4] He corresponded with travellers, collectors, and residents in foreign countries. In 1856 he began with John Thurnam, the publication of Crania Britannica: delineations and descriptions of the skulls of the aboriginal and early inhabitants of the British islands, with text, plates and an accompanying atlas. The work was completed in 1865.

In 1867 he published a catalogue of the collection called Thesaurus Craniorum, describing and figuring many specimens, and giving 25,000 measurements. In 1875 a supplement to the Thesaurus was published. In 1879 or 1880 the Royal College of Surgeons purchased the collection, then numbering 1800 crania and some skeletons.[1][5]

As well as his collection of human remains, Davis was an avid collector of books, photographs, prints, drawings and artefacts relating to many cultural groups. Amongst his collection were works of art and artefacts collected originally by George Augustus Robinson from Tasmania and from the state of Victoria, Australia. The Australian works were mainly purchased by Davis after Robinson’s death from Robinson’s widow.[6] Davis also bought art works relating to Tasmanian Aborigines directly from the artist John Skinner Prout.[7]

He was also interested in the most ancient history of his local north Staffordshire, having a collection of the rare carved runic calendar sticks from the north part of the county. He published a detailed article on these, “Some Account of Runic Calendars and Staffordshire Clogg Almanacs”, Archaologia, Vol. XLI, Part II, 1867, pages 453-478.

For some years from 1870 he was one of the editors of the Journal of Anthropology, and of Anthropologia.[1]

Davis’s collection was dispersed after his death through a series of auctions in London at Sotheby’s in 1883. Many works relating to Oceania, Asia, the Americas and Africa were purchased by A W Franks and given to the British Museum in the late 1880s and 1890s.[8][9]

Findings

Davis was a critic of the idea of human speciation. He believed that comparative anatomy would demonstrate that racial differences were immutable.[10] He supported anti-evolutionary views, and presented a paper to the British Association for the Advancement of Science in 1868, on brain weight,[11] publishing Contributions towards Determining the Weight of the Brain in Different Races of Man (Philosophical Transactions, 1868, clviii. 505–28). In an 1869 paper On the Weight of the Brain in the Negro he argued that brain weight was a racial characteristic.[12]

A polygenist, he drew conclusions on the intellectual capacities of the Australian Aborigines, in particular, from his collection.[13] A motivation for his collecting was his belief that the morphology of the Australian remains provided indications of a separate origin.[14]

References

1. "Davis, Joseph Barnard" . Dictionary of National Biography. London: Smith, Elder & Co. 1885–1900.
2. Helen Patricia MacDonald, Human Remains: dissection and its histories (2006), p. 96; Google Books.
3. Marguerita Stephens, White Without Soap: Philanthropy, Caste and Exclusion in Colonial Victoria 1835–1888, A Political Economy of Race (2010), p. 143; Google Books.
4. Cressida Fforde, English Collections of Human Remains: An Introduction (PDF) Archived 11 May 2012 at the Wayback Machine, p. 1.
5. Christine Quigley, Skulls and Skeletons: human bone collections and accumulations (2001), p. 141; Google Books.
6. Numbloote (aka Jenny). British Museum.
7. Hohepa Teumuroa (Hohepa Te Umuroa), New Zealand. British Museum.
8. G. Sculthorpe The Ethnographic Collection of George Augustus Robinson. Memoirs of the Museum of Victoria. Anthropology and History. 1(1):1-96 (1990).
9. British Museum Collection Online.
10. Bronwen Douglas, Chris Ballard (editors), Foreign Bodies: Oceania and the science of race 1750–1940 (2008), p. 206; Google Books.
11. Helen MacDonald, Possessing the Dead: The Artful Science of Anatomy (2011), p. 112; Google Books.
12. Burt Green Wilder, Richard M. Reid, Practicing Medicine in a Black Regiment: the Civil War diary of Burt G. Wilder, 55th Massachusetts (2010), p. 14 note 57; Google Books.
13. Cressida Fforde, Jane Hubert, Paul Turnbull, The Dead and their Possessions: repatriation in principle, policy and practice (2004), p. 41; Google Books.
14. Paul Turnbull, Michael Pickering, The Long Way Home: the meanings and values of repatriation (2010), p. 127; Google Books.

Attribution

 This article incorporates text from a publication now in the public domain: "Davis, Joseph Barnard". Dictionary of National Biography. London: Smith, Elder & Co. 1885–1900.