Gordon Welchman

William Gordon Welchman (15 June 1906 – 8 October 1985) was a British-American mathematician. During World War II, he worked at Britain's secret codebreaking centre, "Station X" at Bletchley Park, where he was one of the most important contributors. After the war he moved to the US, and worked on the design of military communications systems.[1]

Gordon Welchman
Born	(1906-06-15)15 June 1906 Fishponds, Bristol, England
Died	8 October 1985(1985-10-08) (aged 79) Newburyport, Massachusetts, US
Occupation	Mathematician, codebreaker, author

Early life, education and career

Gordon Welchman was born, the youngest of three children, at Fishponds in Bristol, to William Welchman (1866–1954) and Elizabeth Marshall Griffith. William was a Church of England priest who had been a missionary overseas before returning to England as a country vicar, eventually becoming archdeacon of Bristol. Elizabeth was the daughter of another priest, the Revd Edward Moule Griffith.[2]

Welchman was educated at Marlborough College and then studied mathematics at Trinity College, Cambridge, from 1925 to 1928.[3] In 1929, he became a Research Fellow in Mathematics at Sidney Sussex College, Cambridge. He became a Fellow in 1932, and later Dean of the College.

Bletchley Park

Hut 6 at Bletchley Park in 2004

Just before World War II, Welchman was invited by Commander Alastair Denniston to join the Government Code and Cypher School in the event of war. GCCS established a centre ("Station X") for decryption and analysis of enemy (mostly German) encrypted messages at Bletchley Park (BP).

Welchman was one of four early recruits to BP, the others being Alan Turing, Hugh Alexander, and Stuart Milner-Barry. They all made significant contributions at BP and became known as "the wicked uncles". They were also the four signatories to a letter to Winston Churchill in October 1941, asking for more resources for the code-breaking work at BP. Churchill responded with one of his "Action This Day" written comments.

Much of Welchman's work at Bletchley was in "traffic analysis" of encrypted German communications. This was the collection and analysis of data about which enemy units sent and received messages, including where and when. Such metadata analysis can reveal a lot about enemy organization, movements, and activities, even when the content of the messages remains unknown. Welchman is credited with developing this technique.

However, Welchman's main contributions were to the process of breaking the German Enigma machine cipher. Welchman became head of Hut Six, the section at BP responsible for breaking German Army and Air Force Enigma ciphers.[4]

Polish cryptanalysts had developed the bomba, an electromechanical device for finding the Enigma settings used by German operators; Turing improved the Polish design. Welchman invented the "Diagonal Board", an addition which made the English Bombe immensely more powerful.

The Diagonal Board exploited the self-reciprocity of the plugboard element of the Enigma; that is, if on the plugboard, letter B is Steckered (plugged) to letter G, then G is also Steckered to B. If 26 rows of 26 way connectors are stacked up, then any connection point can be referenced by its row letter and column letter. A physical piece of wire can now connect (row B element G) to (row G element B.) Each such wire runs diagonally across the board; thus its name.

The Diagonal Board enabled the bombe to solve the Enigma plugboard setting separately from the wheel setting. This reduced the time required to find the complete setting from days to hours.

As head of Hut Six, Welchman was also closely involved in other work which yielded breaks into Enigma by taking advantage of German operational weaknesses and lapses. These were quite extensive, and Welchman's experience in this area informed his later work on making communications secure.[4]

Welchman left Hut Six in 1943, to become Assistant Director for Mechanization. His responsibilities in this post included the construction, deployment, and operation of additional bombes. By the end of the war, hundreds of bombes were in use at BP and satellite locations. Welchman had responsibility for cryptographic liaison with the US, which constructed and used additional bombes. He was responsible for making sure that the British and American bombes were not wastefully working on the same keys, and that all solutions by one group were reported to the other group.

His main interest at this time was the development of similar machines for attacking more advanced German ciphers, such as the Geheimschreiber.

Welchman was awarded the OBE in the 1944 King's Birthday Honours list. The London Gazette described him as William Gordon Welchman, Esq., Employed in a Department of the Foreign Office.

Postwar

After the end of the war Welchman took up Hugh Alexander's old post as director of research for the John Lewis Partnership.[5] In 1948, he moved to the United States. Welchman taught the first computer programming course at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in 1951, and Frank Heart was among his students.[6] He followed this by employment with Remington Rand and Ferranti.[4] Welchman became a naturalised US citizen in 1962. In that year, he joined the Mitre Corporation, working on secure communications systems for the US military. He retired in 1971, but was retained as a consultant.

In 1982 his book The Hut Six Story[4] was published, initially by McGraw-Hill in the US and by Allen Lane in Britain. The National Security Agency disapproved. The book was not banned, but as a result of it, Welchman lost his security clearance, and therefore his consultancy with Mitre, and was forbidden to discuss either the book or his wartime work.[7] The impact on Welchman of withdrawal of his security clearance, by the NSA, has been described as "devastating".[8]

Welchman died in 1985; his final conclusions and corrections to the story of wartime code breaking were published posthumously in 1986 in the paper "From Polish Bomba to British Bombe: the birth of Ultra" in Intelligence & National Security, Vol 1, No l. The paper was included in the revised edition of The Hut Six Story published in 1997 by M & M Baldwin.[4]

Personal life

In 1937 Welchman married Katharine Hodgson, a professional musician, the daughter of Francis Faith Hodgson, who was a captain in the Indian Army. The couple had a son and two daughters.[2]

In 1959 Welchman divorced Katharine and married the American Cubist painter Fannie Hillsmith. The marriage lasted until 1970.[9] Fannie was the daughter of Clarence Hillsmith, a consulting engineer from New Hampshire.[2]

In 1972 he married Elisabeth Huber, daughter of Anton Wilhelm Huber, a sawmill owner and carpentry contractor from Bavaria, and Myrtle Octavia Hussey, who was Welchman's second cousin.[2]

Legacy

Gordon Welchman was the subject of a BBC documentary in 2015.[8] The programme was entitled Bletchley Park: Code-breaking's Forgotten Genius[10] and as The Codebreaker Who Hacked Hitler when broadcast on the Smithsonian Channel in the US.[11] The documentary notes that traffic analysis is now known as "network analysis" and "metadata" analysis and gives as an example the location of Osama bin Laden by the use of network analysis.

On 26 September 2016, a blue plaque was unveiled by his daughter, Susanna Griffiths, at St Mary's Church, Fishponds, in Bristol. Speaking at the event, the Director of GCHQ Robert Hannigan acknowledged the harsh treatment of Welchman and paid tribute to his "immense contribution" as a "giant of his era".[12]

See also

• History of cryptography
• Peter Calvocoressi

References

Notes

1. Greenberg, Joel (2014). Gordon Welchman: Bletchley Park's Architect of Ultra Intelligence. Frontline Books. ISBN 978-1848327528.
2. University of St Andrews – Welchman
3. Denniston, Robin (2004). "Welchman, (William) Gordon (1906–1985)". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. Oxford University Press.
4. Welchman, Gordon (1984) [1982]. The Hut Six story: Breaking the Enigma codes. Harmondsworth, England: Penguin Books. ISBN 0-14-00-5305-0. An early publication containing several misapprehensions that are corrected in an addendum in the 1997 edition.
5. "Bletchley Park Roll of Honour – Gordon Welchman". Bletchley Park website. Retrieved 24 January 2016.
6. Hafner, Katie; Lyon, Matthew (1998) [1st pub. 1996]. Where Wizards Stay Up Late: The Origins of the Internet. New York: Simon & Schuster. p. 88. ISBN 0-684-87216-1.
7. West, pg. 26-28, and 310-319
8. BBC documentary
9. Smith, Roberta (4 August 2007). "Fannie Hillsmith, Distinctly American Cubist, Dies at 96". The New York Times. Retrieved 2 September 2015.
10. Narrator: Steven Mackintosh, Contributors: John Naughton, Cynthia Storer, Producer and Director: Russell England (7 September 2015). "Bletchley Park: Code-breaking's Forgotten Genius". Make It Digital Season. BBC Two.
11. "The Codebreaker Who Hacked Hitler" Smithsonian Channel website
12. "Gordon Welchman, no longer a forgotten hero". Downend Voice. 28 October 2016. Retrieved 9 May 2017.

Bibliography

• Russell-Jones, Mair (2014), My Secret Life in Hut Six: One Woman's Experiences at Bletchley Park, Lion Hudson, ISBN 978-0-745-95664-0
• Welchman, Gordon (1997). The Hut Six Story: Breaking the Enigma Codes (2nd Revised ed.). M.& M. Baldwin. ISBN 978-0947712341.
• West, Nigel (1986). The Sigint Secrets: The Signals Intelligence War, 1900 to Today–Including the Persecution of Gordon Welchman. New York: William Morrow and Company. ISBN 0-688-07652-1. LCCN 88-43153.