Frankfurt's Way or Labour's Way
"Frankfurt's Way or Labour's Way" (sometimes repeated as "Labour's Way or Frankfurt's Way")[1][2][3][4] was a campaign slogan used by the then Irish Labour Party leader Eamon Gilmore in advance of the country's 2011 general election. The phrase has become an archetypal example of a broken election promise in Irish politics. Described as "a desperate attempt to get votes",[5] Gilmore claimed on 3 February 2011 that the Labour Party (if put into power) would renegotiate the recent EU-IMF deal brought in under the Fianna Fáil-Green Party coalition. The promise was made as Gilmore launched Labour's economic plan. Frankfurt (in Germany) is home to the headquarters of the European Central Bank (ECB).[6] The party made a very strong showing, almost doubling its share of the vote to become the second-largest party in the Dáil, its best showing ever.[7][8][9] They then formed their own coalition with Fine Gael, but did not renegotiate the deal.
In 2012, after a decline of 25 per cent in their vote previous year's election evaporated, the Irish Independent said the Labour Party was "haunted" by the promise.[5] The following month, the European Fiscal Compact was enshrined in the Constitution, thereby ensuring the very fiscal compliance Labour had vowed to oppose.[10] Gilmore's promise was also referenced following the rush through the Oireachtas of legislation to liquidate IBRC in 2013.[11] Even Labour stalwart Fergus Finlay admitted in 2015 that it was "a phrase he [Gilmore] had difficulty living down".[12] However, Alan Kelly claimed "A lot of Labour's way was achieved" when quizzed on Gilmore's promise in 2015.[13]
In Labour's centenary year, state television (RTÉ) produced a two-part documentary on the history of party. They titled it Labour's Way.[14]
References
- 'Labour's Way Or Frankfurt's Way' Latest
- Labour's way, Frankfurt's way - or back to the old ways
- A Dark day for Labour
- Broken promises in a broken system
- Labour haunted by old slogans
- Gilmore vows to renegotiate 'bad deal' on EU-IMF bailout package irishtimes
- "Irish election: Enda Kenny claims opposition victory". BBC News. 26 February 2011. Retrieved 7 November 2018.
- Doyle, Kilian (27 February 2011). "Fine Gael poised to lead next government as FF collapses". The Irish Times. Retrieved 7 November 2018.
- McDonald, Henry (27 February 2011). "Fianna Fáil trounced as Fine Gael and Labour set to form coalition". The Guardian. London. Retrieved 7 November 2018.
- Tonight with #vinb: We now know Labour's way is Frankfurt's way
- Frankfurt's Way
- FERGUS FINLAY: Dáil could lose its way without politicians of vision and principle irishexaminer
- Saying Labour hasn't delivered is just 'lazy media spin' – Alan Kelly
- Labour's Way