Expansion microscopy

Expansion microscopy (ExM) is a sample preparation tool for biological samples that allows investigators to identify small structures by expanding them using a polymer system.[1] The premise is to introduce a polymer network into cellular or tissue samples, and then physically expand that polymer network using chemical reactions to increase the size of the biological structures. Among other benefits, ExM allows those small structures to be imaged with a wider range of microscopy techniques. It was first proposed in a 2015 article by Fei Chen, Paul W. Tillberg, and Edward Boyden.[2] Current research allows for the expansion of samples up to 16x larger than their initial size.[3] This technique has been found useful in various laboratory settings, such as analyzing biological molecules. ExM allows researchers to use standard equipment in identifying small structures, but requires following of procedures in order to ensure clear results.

Principles

Purpose

4-step process of ExM

Traditional light microscopy has limits of resolution that prevent it from reliably distinguishing small structures that are important to biological function, and must instead be imaged by a higher-resolution technique, such as electron microscopy. For example, synaptic vesicles are 40-50 nanometers in diameter, which is below the commonly quoted resolution limit of 200 nanometers for light microscopy.[4] Expansion microscopy solves this problem by expanding the underlying tissue sample. One key advantage of samples prepared using expansion microscopy and light microscopy over conventional electron microscopy is that it also allows investigators to stain for and visualize particular molecules in the sample, such as specific proteins or RNA to identify their density and distribution in relation to the biological structures of interest. The most beneficial principle of expansion microscopy is that it requires no specialized equipment;[5] the materials for expansion are worth little to nothing compared to the price of a microscope that could get the same resolution.

Stages

Expansion microscopy is a multistep process that, depending on the protocol, has different requirements for gelation and expansion. The sequence of steps are stain, link, digest, and expand[5] The staining process can take many different forms, and only requires that the fluorophores used can attach to the polymer in the next step. Linking is the process of adding a polymer gel to the cells, which permeabilize through the cell. The linking step also includes, as the name suggests, the process of linking the fluorophores to the gel. The digestion step involves adding a solution that digests the cell, removing the structure from the cell. If this step fails, the gel will not expand uniformly because the cell will try to stay together. Failure of this step can also cause cracking or fractures in the cell.[6] Lastly, expansion causes the gel to be physically expanded in all directions, which causes the fluorophores that are attached to the gel to expand as well.

History

In 2015, Chen, Tillberg, and Boyden, all of MIT first described expansion microscopy as a method to enhance microscopy resolution by swelling a sample rather than using stronger microscopy equipment.[2] Since then, the use of ExM has continued to grow. Due to the recency of development, there is limited information on applications. However, the most common modern use is in biological samples. In 2016, several papers were published detailing workarounds for ExM's traditional limitation of labeling probes. These changes proposed a way to use ExM with conventional microscopy probes, allowing it to be used more widely. In 2016, these new labeling methods were applied to allow fluorescence microscopy of RNA molecules. ExM is a rapidly growing field, and there is hope that many biological mysteries will be elucidated using ExM techniques within coming years.[7]

Theory

Expansion microscopy is achieved by synthesizing a polymer system within a specimen. By then swelling this polymer network, the sample is expanded to be examined under conventional microscopic analysis tools without degrading the integrity of the sample. This allows a sample to be analyzed with a less powerful microscope than would be needed without expansion, and makes analysis of microscopic biological samples more accessible to labs that would otherwise have not been available to afford or obtain necessary powerful microscopy technology.[4]

Applications

Use

Expansion microscopy is a method which improves the final image resolution during regular microscopy by physically enlarging the organism or molecule itself. After the enlargement of the organism or molecule, more standard microscopes can achieve higher resolution imaging. The primary fields this method is used in are those involved in analyzing biological samples. However, this technique has since been adopted into many different fields of research and continues to grow and be applied in more and more laboratory settings.

Disease and diagnoses

Before the discovery of expansion microscopy, examination of cellular structures and biomolecules were done using diffraction-limited microscopy. They were mainly used to diagnose or investigate the pathogenesis of a wide variety of predisease and disease states. However, biomolecules are nanoscale in dimension and are located with nanoscale precision throughout cells and tissues. Several techniques such as super-resolution microscopy were used, but these required complex hardware and were difficult to apply to human tissues. Thus, expansion microscopy was developed. This method physically magnified the tissue samples rather than optically, and as a result was able to produce images with high resolution. These high quality images of tissues served as a turning point in diagnostic and medical expansion microscopy.[8]

Like many other techniques, expansion microscopy also possesses many potentials in the medical and diagnostic fields. Expansion microscopy improves the resolution of light microscopy by physically expanding the specimens. When this technique is applied to the clinical tissue samples nanoscale imaging of human tissue specimens. First, expansion pathology is used to convert clinical samples into a compatible state for the expansion microscopy. This process can be used for optical diagnosis of kidney minimal-change disease, early breast neoplastic lesions and to spot the difference of normal human tissue specimens to cancer tissue specimens, enabling a routine use of clinical research.[9] The use of pathogenic expansion microscopy enabled clear images of tissue. Applying expansion microscopy on microarrays containing specimens from various organs, such as breast, prostate, lung, colon, pancreas, kidney, liver, and ovary, including normal and cancer-containing tissues, enabled the diagnostic and the examination of cellular network of diseased state tissues. This imaging reveals sub-diffraction limit sized features of the intermediate filaments keratin and vimentin, critical in the epithelial mesenchymal transition, cancer progression and initiation of metastasis.[8]

In the future, after further development of this technique, observation of nanoscale morphology of biomolecules and samples from wide range of human organs is anticipated to be provided.

Neuroscience

Many of the questions surrounding neuroscience attempt to answer and understand molecules and wiring in neural circuits. However, mapping these structures across the large scales of neural circuits is difficult. In these cases, ExM magnifies biological specimens such as brain circuits and allows them to be more easily mapped. Biomolecules, such as proteins and nucleic acids, are anchored to the polymer, which is then swelled in order to expand the biomolecules. Due to the increased distance between the biomolecules, ordinary microscopes can then perform nanoscale resolution imaging. Through the use of ExM technique, neuroscientists can more easily map images of synapses, cells, and neural circuits.[10]

Subsets

With the development of expansion microscopy, scientists have begun to create subsets of the technique, including scanning Joule expansion microscopy, or SJEM. SJEM utilizes a thermal imaging technique which measures the thermal expansion of Joule-heated elements. One of the largest advantages of SJEM over older submicron thermal imaging techniques is that SJEM does not require the nanofabrication of specialized probes. Rather, SJEM only requires a standard atomic force microscope and simple electronics.[11]

Advantages

One of the most significant advantages of expansion microscopy versus other forms of microscopy is that it prevents the requirement of purchasing stronger equipment. Because ExM is performed within a sample to enlarge the sample, it prevents researchers from needing to purchase expensive super-resolution microscopy equipment, such as electron microscopes. By making a sample larger, it becomes more easily examinable as the larger structures can then be examined using traditional microscopy techniques, such as light microscopy.

Limitations

Each of the four preparation steps of ExM must fully complete, or the cell will not yield a bright and clear stain. Failure to complete these steps can result in the breaking of the cell or uneven expansion, distorting the image beyond use. ExM struggles in those procedures that use fluorophore markers, as the polymerization process can bleach these fluorophores, rendering them unusable. There are some, such as Alexa 488 and Atto 565 that are still effective after polymerization, however their efficacy is greatly decreased to about 50%. The conjugation of DNA with another antibody is often very costly and difficult. These two issues are the primary limitations to using ExM in biological samples.[12] It is important to note that while rebinding new antibodies can be costly and time consuming, it is sometimes made possible, post expansion, in cases where the antibody struggles to bind in dense tissue. After expansion, the tissue is far less dense and often allows for better reception of fluorescent antibodies.

References

1. Markoff J (2015-01-19). "Expansion Microscopy Stretches Limits of Conventional Microscopes". New York Times. Retrieved 21 October 2015.
2. Chen F, Tillberg PW, Boyden ES (January 2015). "Optical imaging. Expansion microscopy". Science. 347 (6221): 543–8. Bibcode:2015Sci...347..543C. doi:10.1126/science.1260088. PMC 4312537. PMID 25592419.
3. "Larger than Life: Monique Copeland and Paul Tillberg Explain Expansion Microscopy | Janelia Research Campus". www.janelia.org. Retrieved 2019-05-01.
4. Fagan T. "Kiss and Tell—STED Microscopy Resolves Vesicle Recycling Question". AlzForum. Retrieved 21 October 2015.
5. Chozinski TJ, Halpern AR, Okawa H, Kim HJ, Tremel GJ, Wong RO, Vaughan JC (June 2016). "Expansion microscopy with conventional antibodies and fluorescent proteins". Nature Methods. 13 (6): 485–8. doi:10.1038/nmeth.3833. PMC 4929147. PMID 27064647.
6. Wassie AT, Zhao Y, Boyden ES (January 2019). "Expansion microscopy: principles and uses in biological research". Nature Methods. 16 (1): 33–41. doi:10.1038/s41592-018-0219-4. PMC 6373868. PMID 30573813.
7. Strack, Rita (2016-12-29). "Expansion microscopy". Nature Methods. 14: 32. doi:10.1038/nmeth.4113. ISSN 1548-7105.
8. Zhao Y, Bucur O, Irshad H, Chen F, Weins A, Stancu AL, Oh EY, DiStasio M, Torous V, Glass B, Stillman IE, Schnitt SJ, Beck AH, Boyden ES (August 2017). "Nanoscale imaging of clinical specimens using pathology-optimized expansion microscopy". Nature Biotechnology. 35 (8): 757–764. doi:10.1038/nbt.3892. PMC 5548617. PMID 28714966.
9. "Synthetic Neurobiology Group: Ed Boyden, Principal Investigator". syntheticneurobiology.org. Retrieved 2019-05-03.
10. Karagiannis ED, Boyden ES (June 2018). "Expansion microscopy: development and neuroscience applications". Current Opinion in Neurobiology. 50: 56–63. doi:10.1016/j.conb.2017.12.012. PMC 5984670. PMID 29316506.
11. Majumdar A, Varesi J (1998). "Nanoscale Temperature Distributions Measured by Scanning Joule Expansion Microscopy". Journal of Heat Transfer. 120 (2): 297. doi:10.1115/1.2824245.
12. Cho, I.; Seo, J. Y.; Chang, J. (2018). "Expansion microscopy". Journal of Microscopy. 271 (2): 123–128. doi:10.1111/jmi.12712. ISSN 1365-2818. PMID 29782656.